magic the gathering

Carbiens

there's prolly one around here somewhere, but if there isn't any chance of a magic forum?

im sure there'll be loads of support (thats why im guessing there already is one)

amp

There was a thread a week or so requesting such a forum. Didn't get much support.

Gordon

amp - the murderer of new board suggestions

regi

I think they already have some forums linked off http://www.ccgireland.com

Raphael

Yes but this will be one on boards, and enable us to boost our post count!

I mean...

It would be better, as it willdraw users, and i wont have to register a new account else where (i'm lazy, so sue me)

Vader

This gets my vote. I would be very interested

sionnach

even though it failed last time i wanna add my support again.

sionnach

Originally posted by Regi
I think they already have some forums linked off http://www.ccgireland.com

ive been checking out that site for a while and the only working, active forums it leads to are, believe it or not, boards.ie, which doesnt have a magic the gathering forum. Perhaps we could make it a private board and people could request access?

Raphael

Posted by ecksor before closing the last request thread
Nein! Pix'n'Mix is the spiritual (and holiday) home of MTG.

Eh ecks, Pix'n'Mix is a photoshopping forum with 1 thread about BTG cards. nothing to do with MTG at all

Art_Wolf

Id like to see one

Funky

yes please!

Brian Houlihan

Hey,
Gets my vote, how long till this idea is shot down?

amp

Originally posted by Gordon
amp - the murderer of new board suggestions

Moi? Just merely stating facts...

/me strolls off whistling innocently

sionnach

Originally posted by amp
There was a thread a week or so requesting such a forum. Didn't get much support.

isnt the frequency of requests an indicator of support?

amp

No, it just means that two people had the same idea.

DeVore

I know wookie (one of the Gods of Irish Magic) from Gaelcon. I'll ask him (he's on Boards already) and see what he thinks. If there is a community there already, then its the community I'll support...

DeV.

Raphael

Anything happenning on this DeV?

imp

Most interesting... I'd definitely be in favour.

I hope to hear an update soon

}:>

DeVore

just back from hol, I'll talk to wookie in the next while and see what he thinks...

DeV.
ps: till then I'll stickie it to remind myself.

Exit

First, you'll have to remind yourself to stickie it

mr_angry

It'd be very interesting. What kind of rules would be imposed on such a forum though?

Raphael

Obviously the usual no trolling, no flaming stuff

Might be a good idea to stop people posting up just to brag about their cool cards ie

"HA! i have akroma angel of wrath, ph33r my superiority, you all suck!"

Hmmm, not sure if offering trades should be allowed, but cash deals would probly be a bad idea....


(is over-thinking this, sorry)

americanCat

YAY!!! a Magic the Gathering forum!!!! i think that'd be pretty kewl...we could compare tactics and cards and stuff! and we could talk about which types of packs we like better and maybe even argue over variations in the rules..hehe..and my fav. card that i possess is a phantom nishoba..anybody wanna play sometime???
~cat~

Carbiens

wrath o' god....................BANG!

Gordon

Originally posted by Raphael
Obviously the usual no trolling, no flaming stuff

Might be a good idea to stop people posting up just to brag about their cool cards

It would most likely need to be heavily moderated. Maybe even 5 mods would be needed.

Raphael

maybe more along the lines of 1 IMHO, or was that sarcasm, i only just got up so im not sure


I dont think it would need very heavy moderation, except for the first while when people would come in and spam it for the laugh, after its been around a while, it should slow down

Ivan

Sounds good, sign me up!

nosmo

But the question is how much use would the board get?
I play Magic myself, but I'm curious as to what the hell you could talk about that would warrant a forum.

regi

Well, we could always suck it and see. We usually give most forums a few weeks to get on their feet.

DeVore

Aye, I havent been able to talk to Wookie recently but I think we should just go and do this and see how it works out. Regi, can you look after this for mods and what not.... you know more about the community these days then I do.

DeV.

sionnach

excellent /me thinks of organising a boards.ie magic tourney........more info on the forum....whenever its up

btw raph, i have an akroma too, and yes she does ROCK