Best band lineup

isthisit

What are peoples best band lineups taking people from any band?

Mine would be

Liam Gallagher - Vocals
Jimmy Page - Guitar
Nick Valensi - Guitar
Flea - Bass
Larry Mullen Jnr - Drums

isthisit

Giblet

Liam Gallagher vocals?, ah I see your joking, I get it, I get it.

zAbbo

Vocally Liam Gallagher is certainly distinc, borrowing on both Johnny Rotten and John Lennon, where he sits somewhere in the middle. And as such is a great Vocalist, least said about the Lyrics, Check out Def Maybe for his vocals.

Id prefare either Lennon or Lydon to Gallagher

superconor

Vocals - Ozzy Osbourne

Guitar 1 - Slash

Guitar 2 - Adrian Smith

Bass - Flea

Drums - Alex Van Halen

Robbo

The original Clash lineup. And by that I mean with Topper Headon on drums, not Terry Chimes who was the drummer for the recording of the first album.

everythinglive

I agree with flea from rhcp on bass. but i would have joe strummer from the clash on lead vocals, john fuisciante from rchp on lead guitar, john bonham from led zeppelin on drums and ed o'brien from radiohead on rhythm guitar.:ninja:

Kingp35

This would be the best band by far.

Rob Thomas(matchbox twenty) - lead Vocals,Piano
John Frusciante(Red Hot Chilli Peppers) - Lead Guitar/Rythm Guitar/Acoustic Guitar
Mike McCreedy(Pearl Jam) - Lead Guitar/Rythm guitar/Acoustic Guitar
Flea(Red Hot Chilli Peppers) - Bass
Dave Grohl(Nirvana/Foo Fighters) - Drums/Lead Vocals/Backing vocals/guitars

With those members you have quality on all instruments and a number of them can play different instruments and sing.

eclectichoney

thom yorke - vocals
jonny greenwood - guitar
colin green wood- bass
ed o brien - guitar
phil selway - drums...

....oh wait, that band exists already

40crush41

One Crazy Jam Band

dave matthews-vocals, rythm guitar
timmy reynolds on the guitar
victor wooten (flecktones) on the bass guitar
boyd tinsley (dmb) on the violin
lerio moore (dmb) on the saxophone
jeff coffin also on the saxophone (flecktones)
bela fleck on the banjo
carter beauford (dmb) on the drums
roy bittan (springsteen) on the piano

and whoever else that wants to come along and jam
~batch

feylya

Bruce Dickinson - Vocals
Steve Vai - Guitar And Vocals
Joe Satriani - Guitar
John Petrucci - Guitar
Billy Sheehan - Bass
Mike Portnoy - Drums

Not sure about Bruce Dickinson but I can't think of anyone else really.

IrishMike

eddie vedder - vocals
slash - guitar
ritchie blackmore - guitar
lemmy - bass
danny carey - drums

Töpher

Cynic, Tool, and Liquid Tension Experiment already have the "best of" line ups.

Doctor J

Originally posted by Einstürzende
Cynic, Tool, and Liquid Tension Experiment already have the "best of" line ups.

Don't forget Atheist & Watchtower

Weather Report during the late 70's

no complaints with any of them

Töpher

You're never happy are you?!

Ro: maaan!

Originally posted by Robbo
The original Clash lineup. And by that I mean with Topper Headon on drums, not Terry Chimes who was the drummer for the recording of the first album.

Beat me to it...