The 'You Have To Pick One' thread

Hofftastic

As much as i hate to say it JBL. I don't like JBL as a wrestler but he is the better of the 2.


Jake the snake or Superstar billy graham

Vince135792003

Thats a tough one becasue both are better remebered for their great promo ability than their ring work. I'll go with Billy Graham if only for the fact he was hugely over in his era and he was duplicated by alot of guys that followed.

The Boogeyman or Popa Shongo?

ff101

the boogeyman purely coz he beat JBL. JBL sucks and cant sell and f#$%s people over all the time.

Road Warriors
or
Steiner Brothers

Cactus Col

Steiner Brothers - because they had some singles success.

Scotty Too Hotty
or
Grand Master Sexay?

Dragan

Grand Master Sexy - because his finisher never made me want to smash his face in! and he is instantly cool for being the King's kid

Rock Bottom or the Bookend ???

Hofftastic

Rock bottom. Not because of the move itself as much as the crowd reaction to it.

Ravishing rick rude or Val venus

Mr.Nice Guy

Ravishing Rick. Probably the only guy to ever make that kind of narcissistic character work.

I'll use the one you people ignored above - Batista or Randy Orton?

ff101

Batista, he's not half the wrestler a headliner should be, but is insanely over( Hulk Hogan mark 2??). if more wrestlers knew how to work the crowd like him all wrestling would be better{ ru listening John Cena} he does minimal work, although well i might add, but gets a reaction like few others.

what should be the last match at wm this year

cena vs hhh
or
angle vs orton vs rey

Cactus Col

Angle vs Orton vs Rey ..... With Cena being booed, and triple H a bit stale, I reckon the triple threat has got to be the match to watch.

Big Boss Man
or
One Man Gang?

ff101

big boss man--- he had cool entrance music, was a great worker and really over as was the nightstick. i need to stop playing this game it is so addictive, i am neglecting my studies for my finals. it is such a simple game, yet works the mind over time. curse the thread starter, i'm going to fail my exams

armageddon hell in a cell
or
elimination chamber

Cactus Col

Elimination Chamber, the armageddon hell in a cell was a bit too much all over the place, with too much going on in and out of the cell, Elimination Chamber keeps everyone inside all the action limited to inside the cell.

Devon Dudley
or
Farooq

Dragan

Farooq , he just had a better singles career and for my money was a member of the more appealing tag team in the end. Also, him leaving was the worst thing to ever happen Bradshaw in my mind, even if he has been on constant push pretty much since then.

Shane O Mac 60 foot elbow drop or Shane O Mac getting belly to bellied through the glass?

rebelsbells2005

Shane O Mac 60 foot elbow drop it had a real shock value to it and you didnt really know if he was really injured or not a real shockin moment

the rockers or the hardy boyz?

TOPDAWG

^^^^^^
Jaysus i was actually gonna sat that one earlier in the thread. Shane o mac thro the glass because of the bumps he took on the failed attempts and it was the better match too and one of those ones that makes you jump up off your seat.

Chris jericho
or
Christian

HUP! rebelsbell2005 beat me to it
so il answer his
The rockers cos they were the innovaters of highflying tagteams and also gave birth to shawn michaels in the wwe.

so Jericho or christian?

Mr.Nice Guy

Chris Jericho. He's the first ever undisputed champion and he's had more great matches in the WWE than Christian.

Brother Love or Paul Bearer?

J.R.HARTLEY

bearer, he just had a way longer career life than brother love, although i think it was love who originally managed undertaker.

Mathilda the british bulldog or Damian Jakes Snake

Cactus Col

Damian because at least Earthquake squashed him (it was Damian right?)

Typhoon
or
Earthquake

J.R.HARTLEY

yeah it was damian, which then brought about his brother lucifer seeking revenge

TOPDAWG

Earthquake cos he actually had a main event feud (vs hogan) and a good run as a heel whereas typhoon was just a quick cash-in by being turned from tugboat to typhoon to create the natural disasters..... (oh the irony)


Ankle lock
or
Crippler cross face?

Mr.Nice Guy

Crippler Cross face. It's more impressive and I'm pretty sure Benoit broke Mark Henry's shoulder with it.

Babyface Rock or Heel Rock?

Zombienosh

Heel rock definetly, far more interesting to watch and always got into some good feuds.

Badass taker or Deadman taker

TOPDAWG

Deadman taker. Waaay more memorable moments, i.e. hell in a cell, his crucifixions of people,his ministry to name a few.

a ROCK Concert
or
an Austin Beer Bash?

Vince135792003

A rock concert. His one with Bill Goldberg I just loved even if it did bury Goldberg.


Mick Foley or Tery Funk?

Dragan

Foley , it only because he made it to the big time and cannow make someone more respectable with just one match. Orton anyone????

Come on, how much were you loving him for the RKO into the thumbtacks???

Dean Malenko

or

Perry Saturn?

Cactus Col

Perry Saturn, because I liked what I saw of the eliminators. And dean malenko bored me a bit in wwe.


Akeem, the african dream

or

One man gang?

Dragan

One Man Gang , just think after the rename and the Twin Towers thing he stopped getting the same level of push.

WWF

or

WWE

Mr.Nice Guy

WWF for the history associated with it.

Scott Hall or Kevin Nash?

Vince135792003

Scott Hall, He could wrestle when sobre.

The torch or the wrestling observer newsletter ?

Cactus Col

Don't read either .... so .... .the wrestling observer .. cause I've seen more people quoting it.

Kaientai

or

The Bushwackers

dlofnep

Cactus Col wrote:

Don't read either .... so .... .the wrestling observer .. cause I've seen more people quoting it.

Kaientai

or

The Bushwackers

The Bushwackers. I loved those two guys. Kaientai didn't accomplish much and were just a part of the large group era that WWE exploited to it's fullest.

5starpool

dlofnep wrote:

The Bushwackers. I loved those two guys. Kaientai didn't accomplish much and were just a part of the large group era that WWE exploited to it's fullest.

You didn't put in any options so I will intrude....

Tables, Ladders and Chairs or Battle Royale?

Dragan

TLC's

Because i have much better memories of being on the edge of my seat during those matches!!!!!!!!!

Thats the Bottom Line........ or It Doesn't Matter..........

Mr.Nice Guy

'That's the bottom line' as the people can join in with it.

Razor Ramon or nWo Scott Hall?

J.R.HARTLEY

scott hall, razor had a slightly contrived feel to it, at least hall was open about things when he was allowed to play himself
cripler crossface or sharpshooter

Brow

Crippler for me as it can sometimes come from nowhere. Sharpshooter is good but crippler can have the element of suprise.

Masked Kane or Unmasked Kane?

Mr.Nice Guy

Masked Kane.

I thought it was a good idea to remove the mask but the character has gone stale without it. Kane was more intimidating with the mask I feel.

Stone Cold or Hulk Hogan?

Stalfos

Stone Cold for reasons i gave before. Not Hogan cause he won't go away.

Matt Hardy or Jeff Hardy

Winning Hand

Stone Cold because he made the WWE what it was at its best without turning it into the Sone Cold show.

The opposite can be said for Hogan.

Macho Man Randy Savage or the Macho King?

Mr.Nice Guy

I'll do both questions.

Matt over Jeff as he seems to have more passion for wrestling and can put on better matches.

Macho King for me as it reminds me of my favourite match of Savage's against the Ultimate Warrior and his reunion with Ms Elizabeth at the end.

Samoa Joe or AJ Styles?

Fozzy

Samoa Joe. He's got a better psychology, AJ often forgets to sell certain things. Every Joe match is excellent, even though I'm not a huge fan of his. Great wrestler all the same

Brian Danielson or Paul London?

Devon

Fozzy wrote:

Samoa Joe. He's got a better psychology, AJ often forgets to sell certain things. Every Joe match is excellent, even though I'm not a huge fan of his. Great wrestler all the same

Brian Danielson or Paul London?

Paul London because he's impressive to look at and seems to have better mat skills.

Hercules Hernandez or Ultimate Warrior?

Mr.Nice Guy

Ultimate Warrior. He had more intensity and presence than Hercules.

Andre the Giant or Big Show?

Brow

I'll pick Show purely cause he has more skills in the ring doing dropkicks and what not.

Tommy Dreamer Or Raven?

Vince135792003

Raven, I always thought if the WWE taped into him and his character better they could have had somthing really different in 2000/01 with him. Great on the mic and at his peak a good brawler too. I'm not sure this has n't been asked yet but anyway:

Shawn Michaels or Bret Hart?

Cactus Col

Shawn Michaels, because I always found Bret Hart to be quite boring.

Test or Lance Hoyt?

ONI

have to choose it would be hoyt only cause i cant stand test but both are crap

80s wwf (old school) or 90s wwf (attitude) or 00s wwe (muscles)

Mr.Nice Guy

90s wwf attitude

It was the era where they had strong competititon and that's what's missing.

Muhammad Hassan or Daivari?

Dragan

Mr.Nice Guy wrote:

Muhammad Hassan or Daivari?

Muhammed Hassan because the guy could really wrestle.

Perry Saturns "Elbow Drop from the Scafolding" or The Dudley Boys "Flaming Tables Powerbomb"?

J.R.HARTLEY

the dudleys, cause i'm a sucker for a table drop.

TnA or MnM (yes it includes trish and melina)

Cactus Col

TnA, because the tag scene was in much better shape back then, and they had better opponents.

Spirit Squad

or

Mean Street Posse?