Montana

Sugar_Ray · 13-09-2006 7:23pm #1

Was Joe cool the greatest quarterback on any given day???

joe_elway · 13-09-2006 7:34pm

Hard to tell given how the game has changed over the years. Guys like Bart Starr and YA Tittle all have to be given their props. But seeing as Joe Cool was they guy that got me hooked on the sport I'll definitely say he's the best to have played in the last 30 years. Only Tom Brady comes close in my eyes.

Forget Manning... he gets rattled in big games.

Manny7 · 14-09-2006 3:51pm

Brady is approaching that level already, and he could have another 10 years in the game. Of course, it'll be tough this year for him without any receivers so we'll see.

spooiirt!! · 15-09-2006 6:49pm

He has Deion Branch ( Super Bowl MVP) and Ben Watson who many say could have a breakout year. Although you have a point- Branch and Watson aint Holt, Bruce and Curtis or Harrison, Wayne and Stokely. Id like to see what Tom Brady would do with Wr corps like the Colts or Rams.

RuggieBear · 15-09-2006 7:13pm

hasn't branch gone to seatle

FlutterinBantam · 15-09-2006 10:21pm

There's no one else I would depend on more to drive from yer own 10 to the house with a buck 40 left.... Just no one.... Joe's the man.

Did he do that against the Cleveland Browns yonks ago after the famous Ernest Byner fumble???

Anyone???

Padwick · 16-09-2006 2:17am

Elway any day for me.

FlutterinBantam · 16-09-2006 6:26pm

FlutterinBantam wrote:

There's no one else I would depend on more to drive from yer own 10 to the house with a buck 40 left.... Just no one.... Joe's the man.

Did he do that against the Cleveland Browns yonks ago after the famous Ernest Byner fumble???

Anyone???

No he didn't ... that was an AFC Championship game..... checked it out.

tallaghtoutlaws · 17-09-2006 4:47pm

spooiirt!! wrote:

He has Deion Branch ( Super Bowl MVP) and Ben Watson who many say could have a breakout year. Although you have a point- Branch and Watson aint Holt, Bruce and Curtis or Harrison, Wayne and Stokely. Id like to see what Tom Brady would do with Wr corps like the Colts or Rams.

Branch is a Seahawk.

On a different note Brady in my opinion will walk into the hall of fame he has alot of seasons left in him and has done a fantatsic job with average receivers over these past 5 years. Give Brady a receiver like Holt or Harrison etc. and you are looking at the Best QB in the NFL easily ahead of Manning.

spooiirt!! · 18-09-2006 1:26pm

tallaghtoutlaws wrote:

Branch is a Seahawk.

Damn...Fingers crossed they do well without him.

spud06 · 11-10-2006 10:49pm

Dan Marino was the best without doubt

Devrozex · 26-10-2006 4:30pm

Marino holds all the meaningful quarterback records, but Montana was surely the best 'clutch' quarterback in NFL history, although Brady is pushing him close for that honour these days.

spud06 · 28-10-2006 8:07pm

I agree Brady is pushing alright but what do u think of Peyton Manning i think he has all the right things to become a legend

geoff_nfl · 28-10-2006 10:27pm

i prefer tom brady as a player than manning but manning has the stats to show he is a top QB! dan marino is my all time QB!

spud06 · 29-10-2006 8:38am

geoff_nfl wrote:

i prefer tom brady as a player than manning but manning has the stats to show he is a top QB! dan marino is my all time QB!

At least somebody else on this forum knows what thhey are talking about Dan Marino is the greatest of all time.

Manny7 · 29-10-2006 5:49pm

Manning has what it takes to be next Marino, he's going to finish his career with the same amount of Superbowl rings anyway!! Montana is still No 1 but should Brady win another Superbowl it'd be a very close call.

Montana

Comments