Which Album is the pinnacle of Thrash?

brain damaged

Which is the best thrash album?

i know theres more but i thought i'd pick theese!

Pugsley

Not a fan of thrash at all, only real thrash Ill listen to is Mastery, their Lethal Legacy album is superb, purely instrumental thrash, great stuff.

cournioni

I would have said Peace Sells by Megadeth. Purely for Devils Island. Reign in Blood is my pick out of those though.

buck65

Actually I think Beneath the Remains is far ahead of Arise, I would vote for that. Again Bonded by Blood is no match for Peace sells.. or Among the living IMO

deftdony

You forgot to put Rust in Peace up their!

Alucard II

you cant ask people to choose which album was the pinnacle of a genre and then say "you can only choose from these 4"
lose the poll and let it be an open thread

Mental Mickey

I voted for Master Of Puppets, cos I think every single track on the album is brilliant. There's not a single bad one on it. That, and the "Black" album, are Metallica's two best recordings.

Gonzo

agreed on Beneath The Remains being far superior to Arise... I voted for Master Of Puppets

John

Trivium is the biggest load of trash I've ever heard. Wait, what did you say? Oh, thrash!

brain damaged

John wrote:

Trivium is the biggest load of trash I've ever heard. Wait, what did you say? Oh, thrash!

haha luverly
nicely said

Léan

Confining poll.
I went for Bonded By Blood. That album influenced loads of bands afterwards. One of my favourite thrash albums ever methinks. Class.

Kreator and Testament should be in the poll though :P

Alucard II

^amen to that. think i may go listen to The Legacy, its been a while...

GhostInTheRuins

yeah, why no Testament?

funky_buddah

I wouldnt say Master is a thrash album. Id say either Reign In Blood or Beneath the Remains.

xanthor

I've no problem with Master, but I'd say Reign by a long stretch.

Catari Jaguar

Wiki:

thrash metal's most famous and successful band, Metallica.

Well that settles it then.. Must be M of P. Wiki knows all and sees all...

I would call Kill 'Em All more thrash than M of P, but that's just my opinion....

Sepultura have 2 albums there! Bias! Some megadeth perhaps.. Or an option of one of these??

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_thrash_metal_bands

brain damaged

Lil Kitten wrote:

Wiki:

..

Sepultura have 2 albums there! Bias! Some megadeth perhaps.. Or an option of one of these??

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_thrash_metal_bands

Theres one sepalura album there..

Catari Jaguar

Ah... Slayer. My mistake. I do apologise...

CyberWaste

Peace Sells by Megadeth or Beneath The remains, Not Arise. Bonded by blood is meh.. Id pick master of puppets as its amazing.

PlatonicDisease

I've long been a big believer in and one of thrash metal's biggest fans. When I saw the title of this thread I was hesitating to venture in, cos I probably can never honestly say which single album is the 'pinnacle of thrash', that's a real stretch of a statement to make about a single thrash record. Ok, so it's a very short poll. How I wish there were album mentions of Dark Angel, Testament, Kreator, Megadeth, Anthrax, Overkill and some more of the heavy-hitters of Thrash.

Anyway, I picked Exodus's 'Bonded by Blood'. Supreme template for classic, authentic thrash for all time. Gary, Rick, Paul, Tom and Rob were at their fieriest best showing us how thrash oughta be done. But it was tough for me to edge out Slayer's 'Reign in Blood', an almost equal-favourite of mine. I was never much of a Metallica fan, but MoP is one of only two albums by them that I really like. But MoP would actually come dead last for me on this specific poll, with Sepultura's excellent 'Arise' being a definite bronze medallist for me in this four-way contest.

dimerocks

Beneath the Remains all the way!

empirix

I do believe the question states "pinnacle of thrash" in which case its Reign in Blood, Beneaththe remains is nowhere near it although its probably a better album

Master of puppets is brilliant, but is definitely not thrash

Beekay

empirix wrote:

Master of puppets is brilliant, but is definitely not thrash

Definately not thrash?i know it isn't full on thrash such as K.E.A. or R.I.B., but its still thrash with different elements brought in.


i'd prob pick K.E.A. or Beneath the Remains, Was never a fan of R.I.B.

Mystic Fibrosis

ONE vote (me) for Sepultura. You all suck.

buck65

:eek: No man you picked the wrong Sepultura album. At least 3 people have said if Beneath the Remains was nominated it would be their choice.

Tazz T

Ask me 15 years ago and I would've said Reign In Blood. Ask me now and I'd say Bonded By Blood. Infinitely more innvoative - even the production has stood the test of time. I'd put it up against anything released today and it's 20 years old.

bozzie

reign in blood

dont consider master thrash

buck65

did you vote bozzie?

Morf

darkness descends - dark angel

Mental Mickey

I think M.O.P is a Thrash Metal album. There are some mellower passages in some of the songs(Battery's intro, mid section of MOP,Sanitarium & Orion), but the rest of it is pretty much Thrash Metal all the way....especially The Thing That Should Not Be!!! I went absolutely ape**** when they played that at the last gig in Dublin. My favourite song by Metallica.

Dr. Feelgood

Kill em all definatly. Can't believe MOP is on the list instead of that.