This is a stupid thread

ibh

JimiTime wrote: »

^^IBH and Monkey9: So you think its perfectly fine to go out to intentionally hurt a fellow player? As long as its disguised as a tackle?

Give it up will you.. He didn't go out with a fcuking sniper rifle.

Yea i think its fine to clatter into someone in training in a 50-50.

If an opponent laughs at Carra before a game i hope he gets lifted out of it in the first 50-50 tackle.

JimiTime

podge018 wrote: »

ha ha, Jimi just keeps saying that Carragher set out to intentionally hurt him. He just made that up himself and now thinks it's fact. I bet he hasn't read the excerpt since yesterday morning.

:rolleyes: Ok smart @rse. Yes, I think he did. However, I haven't been arguing that point. I have quite categorically asked all those who are defending his behaviour. 'Is it ok to intentionally hurt a player?'. I'm not an idiot, It was clear yesterday that certain people just stand by 'their' club. I'm hardly going to delve into that idiocy. So maybe you could answer the question above now.
Nothing to do with Carra, so don't worry, you wont be betraying your club.
Is it ok to set out to intentionally hurt a fellow player?

irishpartyboy

Scratching my balls is more interesting than this thread.

JimiTime

ibh wrote: »

Give it up will you.. He didn't go out with a fcuking sniper rifle.

Yea i think its fine to clatter into someone in training in a 50-50.

If an opponent laughs at Carra before a game i hope he gets lifted out of it in the first 50-50 tackle.

Fup Carragher! Just answer the question. 'Is it ok to intentionally hurt a fellow player?'

monkey9

irishpartyboy wrote: »

Scratching my balls is more interesting than this thread.

It's all Des' fault

irishpartyboy

monkey9 wrote: »

It's all Des' fault

It's Carraghers' fault, the wuss.

Dave!

It's Mr Alan's fault for starting the thread in the first place!


*snigger*

ibh

JimiTime wrote: »

Fup Carragher! Just answer the question. 'Is it ok to intentionally hurt a fellow player?'

Please catch a grip of yourself. This thread is about Carraghers book and especially the Song incident.

If you want to develop it even further i.e. flog an already dead horse, make a new thread.

I have answered your question in relation to this incident. I couldn't answer your question in general, because it depends on the level of hurt inflicted.

missingtime

You see her:


She doesn't give a **** about this.

DeadSkin

Best. Thread. Ever.
I can't stop laughin', I is gettin' queer looks from folk in work.

Where would we be without t'internet eh? Where would we be???

elshambo

if there is a finer sport than womens pole vault, I havent seen it!

JimiTime

ibh wrote: »

Please catch a grip of yourself.

:rolleyes:

I have answered your question in relation to this incident. I couldn't answer your question in general, because it depends on the level of hurt inflicted.

Ok, so thats a yes. As I've been talking about INTENT. NOT the tackle. Thank you. Its a shame people think that way IMO. Football would be better without such things.

podge018

'Is it ok to intentionally hurt a fellow player?'


No.

JimiTime

DeadSkin wrote: »

Best. Thread. Ever.
I can't stop laughin', I is gettin' queer looks from folk in work.

Where would we be without t'internet eh? Where would we be???

Its certainly helped pass another slow day at the office anyhoo:)

elshambo

JimiTime wrote: »

Its certainly helped pass another slow day at the office anyhoo:)

Jimi you might be having that slow day at the office because that 2 inch wide vein trobbing on the side of you head is scaring people away from actually asking you to do anything:D

irishpartyboy

JimiTime wrote: »

Its certainly helped pass another slow day at the office anyhoo:)

I feel for the employers.... productivity downhill

JimiTime

podge018 wrote: »

'Is it ok to intentionally hurt a fellow player?'


No.

Great! Good to see.

ibh

JimiTime wrote: »

:rolleyes:


Ok, so thats a yes. As I've been talking about INTENT. NOT the tackle. Thank you. Its a shame people think that way IMO. Football would be better without such things.

It's not a yes, i told you that i can't give you a sweeping answer that covers every incident where an opponent gets hurt.

I don't care to argue back and forth with you abou intent. I answered the question in relation to this incident. Next time a player gets injured by a fellow professional, get back to me and i'll let you know if i condone it.

:rolleyes:

JimiTime

elshambo wrote: »

Jimi you might be having that slow day at the office because that 2 inch wide vein trobbing on the side of you head is scaring people away from actually asking you to do anything:D

LOL. You might be right.

JimiTime

ibh wrote: »

I don't care to argue back and forth with you abou intent.

LOL. You do realise that thats what this whole thing has been about? Intent. I mean, how could we assess the challenge? No-one seen it. The only thing that has been up for discussion is 'Intent'. You know, intention, with the intending, and some of that intent.

:rolleyes:

I know how ye feel.

MrPillowTalk

Any pool fans left under the illusion that Carra isnt a scumbag following the latest excerpt?

If so rose tinted glasses is no longer the apropriate term its more akin to being part of some religous cult, personally hope his next piece encourages mass suicide tbh prob best way out

copacetic

MrPillowTalk wrote: »

Any pool fans left under the illusion that Carra isnt a scumbag following the latest excerpt?

If so rose tinted glasses is no longer the apropriate term its more akin to being part of some religous cult, personally hope his next piece encourages mass suicide tbh prob best way out

working class lad from deprived area in 'not an angel' shocker. Wayne Rooney expresses his shock and surprise..

monkey9

MrPillowTalk wrote: »

Any pool fans left under the illusion that Carra isnt a scumbag following the latest excerpt?

If so rose tinted glasses is no longer the apropriate term its more akin to being part of some religous cult, personally hope his next piece encourages mass suicide tbh prob best way out

Kop on, will you.

PHB

Just a side note, can everyone see if people get infractions for posts yet? It should be a little yellow or red card in the bottom right of posts?

Wreck

PHB wrote: »

Just a side note, can everyone see if people get infractions for posts yet? It should be a little yellow or red card in the bottom right of posts?

Yeah I can see it.

DSB

PHB wrote: »

Just a side note, can everyone see if people get infractions for posts yet? It should be a little yellow or red card in the bottom right of posts?

Ooh thats an excellent little feature.

Mr Alan

PHB wrote: »

Just a side note, can everyone see if people get infractions for posts yet? It should be a little yellow or red card in the bottom right of posts?

yea i can see it also.

on another side note, how come i was able to amend the thread title on this?

The Rooster

Mr Alan wrote: »

yea i can see it also.

on another side note, how come i was able to amend the thread title on this?

Can you delete it?

missingtime

The Rooster wrote: »

Can you delete it?

+1

Mr Alan

wish i could

KevIRL

Mr Alan wrote: »

on another side note, how come i was able to amend the thread title on this?

You must have been made soccer mod at some stage but not told about it. Try to ban a few people there...

Mr Alan

KevIRL wrote: »

You must have been made soccer mod at some stage but not told about it. Try to ban a few people there...

hmmmmm......where can i find PHB,Helix and Redspider???? :pac::p

MrPillowTalk

copacetic wrote: »

working class lad from deprived area in 'not an angel' shocker. Wayne Rooney expresses his shock and surprise..

Im sure plenty Utd players fall into the same bracket Keane for one, my point however was re some of the guys on here beleiving otherwise.

I think its ridiculous that you cant talk about someone who talks about getting a gang of mates to beat someone up negatively on this forum.

Guy:Incognito

missingtime wrote: »

You see her:


She doesn't give a **** about this.

Quoted to get the pic on the next page.

Players kick other players all the time, it's football. Lets just drop the whole thing.
If anyone fancies a game in the park at the weekend I'll happily demonstrate the diffence between softenign someone a bit in a 50-50 and breaking someone up.

MrPillowTalk wrote: »

I think its ridiculous that you cant talk about someone who talks about getting a gang of mates to beat someone up negatively on this forum.

Just saw this. I notice it didnt take long to drop a few vital words to make it look like he sent a mob out to roam the streets looking for Lucas Neill.

DeadSkin

missingtime wrote: »

You see her:


She doesn't give a **** about this.

Quoted so we can have two of them :pac: Phwoooaaaarrrr!!!

Helix

copacetic wrote: »

working class lad from deprived area in 'not an angel' shocker. Wayne Rooney expresses his shock and surprise..

people seem to have no bother ignoring the working class background and deprived area thing for joey barton

i dont think carragher is any better from the way hes making himself out in the book, but its very likely that its being played that way to sell some more copies. or that he was convinced to have things twisted ever so slightly by the ghost writer to make a better read

as it comes across tho, he certainly does seem like quite the undesirable

Dave!

DeadSkin wrote: »

Quoted so we can have two of them :pac: Phwoooaaaarrrr!!!

she's delicious......

copacetic

Helix wrote: »

people seem to have no bother ignoring the working class background and deprived area thing for joey barton

i dont think carragher is any better from the way hes making himself out in the book, but its very likely that its being played that way to sell some more copies. or that he was convinced to have things twisted ever so slightly by the ghost writer to make a better read

as it comes across tho, he certainly does seem like quite the undesirable

I'm not sure it's comparable is it? Barton seriously assaults a team-mate, stubs a cigar out in someones eye and attacks someone in the street, caught red handed in all case.

Helix

copacetic wrote: »

I'm not sure it's comparable is it? Barton seriously assaults a team-mate, stubs a cigar out in someones eye and attacks someone in the street, caught red handed in all case.

whereas carragher deliberatly sets out to injure a team mate in a tackle and considers having his mates knock lumps out of lucas neil

theyre not a million miles apart

im not saying theyre the same thing, im just saying that neither bloke is a bloke id want to be around

Guy:Incognito

Helix wrote: »

im not saying theyre the same thing, im just saying that neither bloke is a bloke id want to be around

As already said. All footballers do what Carragher did to Song. You might want to stay away from everyone.

mike65

Mike.

Helix

Stekelly wrote: »

As already said. All footballers do what Carragher did to Song. You might want to stay away from everyone.

that on its own i was willing to accept as a one off yeh, but every single paragraph that comes out is as bad as it. hes very much coming across like hes not a particularly nice bloke. i honestly dont see how anyone could disagree with that

copacetic

Helix wrote: »

that on its own i was willing to accept as a one off yeh, but every single paragraph that comes out is as bad as it. hes very much coming across like hes not a particularly nice bloke. i honestly dont see how anyone could disagree with that

I'd say the same about all your paragraphs Helix. I'm sure you are sound in real life though?

Helix

why, do i come across as a bit of a thug?

invincibleirish

missingtime wrote: »

You see her:


She doesn't give a **** about this.

I did not expect this when i ventured into a Jamie Carragher thread but its improved it immeasurably.

Helix is a gentlemen with the occasional cutting comment (calling Savman Villa's Mr Alan was a classic:D:pac:).

~Rebel~

comparing carra and barton is just ridiculous. Carra is coming across as a bit of a scumbag, but barton is nigh on evil!

herbieflowers

I'm surprised it's taken 24 pages for it to have cropped up tbh

ROCKMAN

Stekelly wrote: »

Quoted to get the pic on the next page.

Players kick other players all the time, it's football. Lets just drop the whole thing.
If anyone fancies a game in the park at the weekend I'll happily demonstrate the diffence between softenign someone a bit in a 50-50 and breaking someone up.

WOW another internet HARDMAN ,jesus you don't see that every day.

RasTa

Has this part being posted yet?

'When my leg was broken in an horrific tackle by Lucas Neill in September 2003, my mates were ready to hunt him down if I gave the go-ahead.

'A few weeks later I received a phone call. "You won't believe this, Jay. We're in the Trafford Centre and Lucas Neill is walking straight towards us. What do you reckon?"

'Did I really want Neill to take a crack? "There's only one problem," added the voice. "Little Davey Thommo is with him."

'That was that. I could hardly let one of my best mates, David Thompson, now a Blackburn player, become a witness to an assault. Besides he'd have recognised the attackers. The impromptu mission was aborted and I sent a text to Thommo telling him Neill should give him a hug of thanks.

'As word got back to Blackburn about the near miss, or should that be hit, their coach Terry Darracott, a Scouser, appealed to one of my friends to call the boys off. I agreed.'

Seems like a lovely chap alright. Mr Alan...?

copacetic

yes it was posted already, thanks for resurrecting the thread again though.