Nasri or Babel/Nani?

Dolph Starbeam

Mr Alan wrote: »

start your own ****ing Nasri thread! :mad:

Who would you take?

All three of them are 21 iirc, you all seem to know the other two players stats from the other thread.

Nasri has 124 club games scoring 12, 3 and 1 for Arsenal. 13 caps for France with 2 goals.

Technically like a lot of Arsenal players he is brilliant. In my opinion a good bit better than Babel and Nasri who although have great potential they will not match what this kid has.

Xavi6

Robinho


/goes off to start a 'Titus Bramble or Paul McShane' thread

monkey9

MOG7 wrote: »

Who would you take?

All three of them are 21 iirc, you all seem to know the other two players stats from the other thread.

Nasri has 124 club games scoring 12, 3 and 1 for Arsenal. 13 caps for France with 2 goals.

Technically like a lot of Arsenal players he is brilliant. In my opinion a good bit better than Babel and Nasri who although have great potential they will not match what this kid has.

For fvck sake. You'll take Nasri cos you follow Arsenal, i'll take Babel and we'll say....Boggles can take Nani. Sorted. See ya!!

Dolph Starbeam

Robinho? He's what, 24...

Xavi6

MOG7 wrote: »

Robinho? He's what, 24...

23

aidan24326

Xavi6 wrote: »

Robinho

Good player but overpriced at the money City paid for him.

Personally I wasn't too sure about Nani at first but I think he took some time to settle and adapt to English football, which is fair enough. He has impressed me a couple of times I've seen him for Portugal and I reckon he could yet turn out to be a good signing.

goes off to start a 'Titus Bramble or Paul McShane' thread

Imagine those two playing together. At least McShane is a good honest trier though, even if he isn't up to prem league standard he would probably do ok at championship level. Bramble is just a waste of space.

Pepe LeFrits

Denilson, Anderson or Lucas?

Fabianski, Kuzsszcsczczak or Cavalieri?

Tom Cruise, David Gray or Steve Irwin? (:D)

Red jersey, red jersey or red jersey?

Daddy or chips?

Xavi6

Xavi6 wrote: »

/goes off to start a 'Titus Bramble or Paul McShane' thread

lol

That's given me an idea!

CHD

Sure throw Robinho and Kalou and the likes in aswell.

While your at it maybe Vela and the othe new young lad at Arsenal aswell.

Lets go mad!

Xavi6

Pepe LeFrits wrote: »

Red jersey, red jersey or red jersey?

Blue please

Xavi6

Deleted User wrote: »

lol

That's given me an idea!

It better include Sun Jihai! Gave away another peno last night AND got sent off!

Dolph Starbeam

monkey9 wrote: »

For fvck sake. You'll take Nasri cos you follow Arsenal, i'll take Babel and we'll say....Boggles can take Nani. Sorted. See ya!!

Right a typical boards reply:rolleyes: Thanks for that...


Where do i say i support Arsenal, i don't! I don't support any EPL team!

leninbenjamin

well based on what little we've seen this season, Nasri is head and shoulders above the others. but considering the other two have been reduced to cameos i don't think it's a fair comparison.

Nasri's natural position would be further down the pitch anyway, he's really more of a playmaker midfielder so i don't think it's really comparing like for like either.

Sherifu

Daddy or chips...

Dolph Starbeam

leninbenjamin wrote: »

well based on what little we've seen this season, Nasri is head and shoulders above the others. but considering the other two have been reduced to cameos i don't think it's a fair comparison.

Nasri's natural position would be further down the pitch anyway, he's really more of a playmaker midfielder so i don't think it's really comparing like for like either.

Ye good point, though Babel and Nani don't exactly play the same role as each other either..

leninbenjamin

MOG7 wrote: »

Ye good point, though Babel and Nani don't exactly play the same role as each other either..

well I've been arguing that for a good while although some people here would have you believe they are both widemen.

Nalz

Killian Brennan anyone?

herbieflowers

Nani had a good season last season, 14 assists and 4 goals ain't bad for a player who wasn't even first choice.

leninbenjamin

herbieflowers wrote: »

Nani had a good season last season, 14 assists and 4 goals ain't bad for a player who wasn't even first choice.

shut up Herbie, your facts are not relevant here. :mad:

Dolph Starbeam

herbieflowers wrote: »

Nani had a good season last season, 14 assists and 4 goals ain't bad for a player who wasn't even first choice.

14 assists? Really? Source? I'm not saying i don't believe you but it sounds like a lot more than i remember.

Nalz

MOG7 wrote: »

14 assists? Really? Source? I'm not saying i don't believe you but it sounds like a lot more than i remember.

When I watched Uniteds season review I was shocked to see Nani was involved in an awful lot of the goals (some screamers in there too).

Karmafaerie

Lads it doesn't matter.
Kieran Richardson is obviously better than all of them combined!!!

Nalz

MOG7 wrote: »

14 assists? Really? Source?

Its only 12 not 14, but he was involved in a lot of other goals. I was shocked!

http://soccernet.espn.go.com/players/stats?id=67716&cc=3888

Karmafaerie

herbieflowers wrote: »

Nani had a good season last season, 14 assists and 4 goals ain't bad for a player who wasn't even first choice.

As with Babel. 10 goals and 6 assists, again not first choice.

What it comes down to is that All three players are different.
Who wouldn't like this for the future of their team?!


---Other

---

Other

---

Other

---

Nani---

---

Nasri

---

---

Babel

---

Karmafaerie

Trilla wrote: »

Its only 12 not 14, but he was involved in a lot of other goals. I was shocked!

http://soccernet.espn.go.com/players/stats?id=67716&cc=3888

Ahhhh, that says 11 not 12.;)

Karmafaerie

So...

Babel.

Starts______Subs______Goals______Assists
27_________20________10_________6

Nani

Starts______Subs______Goals______Assists
25_________14________4__________11

Nasri

N/A

Bramble

No Hope!!!:p

Nalz

Sorry according to that its 11. I didnt think Babel featured that often in the Liverpool

Karmafaerie

Trilla wrote: »

Sorry according to that its 11. I didnt think Babel featured that often in the Liverpool

2 more starts.
6 more from the bench.
(Than Nani obviously)

Dolph Starbeam

Ye it does sound alot, i didn't hink he had that many starts but he must of.


Btw Nasi started 37 and 1 extra as a sub.

Karmafaerie

MOG7 wrote: »

Ye it does sound alot, i didn't hink he had that many starts but he must of.


Btw Nasi started 37 and 1 extra as a sub.

All those stats are for all competitions by the way.

Prem/Fa/CL for both players.

Nani started 16 and was subbed on for 10 in the Prem.
Babel started 15 and was subbed on for 15.

That's where Nasri has an advantage too.
He's been a regular starter for a full season now.
Babel and Nani are still bit players.

DSB

From what I've seen of him I'd probably go with Nasri but obviously its impossible to judge until hes been here at least a season.