Rate the PL managers

whatawaster

basically, if your club's manager resigned tomorrow, which of the current crop would you like to see take over (hatred of Mr Ferguson put to one side of course Liverpool fans.)

1. Alex Ferguson
2. Arsene Wenger
3. Rafa Benitez
4. Martin O'Neill
5. David Moyes
6. Steve Bruce
7. Roy Hodgson
8. Luis Scolari
9. Sam Allardyce
10. Harry Redknapp
11. Phil Brown
12. Joe Kinnear
13. Mark Hughes
14. Tony Pulis
15. Tony Mowbray
16. Gary Megson
17. Gareth Southgate
18. Gianfranco Zola
19. Tony Adams
20. Ricky Spragia

Bounty Hunter

personally I dont think anyone would be as suited to the Villa job atm as Martin O'Neil but if i had to pick one from that list i guess it would be David Moyes cos i could see him suiting the job as it is currently the most however he wouldent be the one id rate the highest but of course Wenger, Fergie etc wouldent be heading to Villa Park now.

Wengers next job is probably the French national job whenever he decides to leave Arsenal (unless things go completley tits up for him) and Fergie is in his last job now imo.

ShoulderChip

My first vote is for this season's management and second for overall

1. Alex Ferguson 5/10.... 8/10
2. Arsene Wenger 6/10 .... 9/10
3. Rafa Benitez 8.25/10 .... 7.6/10
4. Martin O'Neill 8.4/10 .... 8.2/10
5. David Moyes 6.8/10 .... 7.825/10
6. Steve Bruce 5/10 .... 6.5/10
7. Roy Hodgson 8/10 .... 7.3/10
8. Luis Scolari 5.5/10 .... 8/10
9. Sam Allardyce n/a .... 7.35/10
10. Harry Redknapp 8.34/10 .... 7.5/10
11. Phil Brown 7.92/10 ... n/a
12. Joe Kinnear 6.85/10 ... n/a
13. Mark Hughes 4.5/10 ... 6/10
14. Tony Pulis n/a .... n/a
15. Tony Mowbray n/a ... n/a
16. Gary Megson 5.5/10 ... 5.5/10
17. Gareth Southgate 5.75/10 ... 6/10
18. Gianfranco Zola 4.85/10 ... n/a
19. Tony Adams 4.75/10 ... n/a
20. Ricky Spragia n/a ... n/a

DSB

How does Alex Ferguson get rated below Wenger there? Insane.

Supermanscat

Do you honestly think Wenger is better than Fergie?

whatawaster

ShoulderChip wrote: »

My first vote is for this season's management and second for overall

1. Alex Ferguson 5/10.... 8/10
2. Arsene Wenger 6/10 .... 9/10
3. Rafa Benitez 8.25/10 .... 7.6/10
4. Martin O'Neill 8.4/10 .... 8.2/10
5. David Moyes 6.8/10 .... 7.825/10
6. Steve Bruce 5/10 .... 6.5/10
7. Roy Hodgson 8/10 .... 7.3/10
8. Luis Scolari 5.5/10 .... 8/10
9. Sam Allardyce n/a .... 7.35/10
10. Harry Redknapp 8.34/10 .... 7.5/10
11. Phil Brown 7.92/10 ... n/a
12. Joe Kinnear 6.85/10 ... n/a
13. Mark Hughes 4.5/10 ... 6/10
14. Tony Pulis n/a .... n/a
15. Tony Mowbray n/a ... n/a
16. Gary Megson 5.5/10 ... 5.5/10
17. Gareth Southgate 5.75/10 ... 6/10
18. Gianfranco Zola 4.85/10 ... n/a
19. Tony Adams 4.75/10 ... n/a
20. Ricky Spragia n/a ... n/a

how did you come up with the exact ratings?

eZe^

ShoulderChip wrote: »

My first vote is for this season's management and second for overall

1. Alex Ferguson 5/10.... 8/10
2. Arsene Wenger 6/10 .... 9/10
3. Rafa Benitez 8.25/10 .... 7.6/10
4. Martin O'Neill 8.4/10 .... 8.2/10
5. David Moyes 6.8/10 .... 7.825/10
6. Steve Bruce 5/10 .... 6.5/10
7. Roy Hodgson 8/10 .... 7.3/10
8. Luis Scolari 5.5/10 .... 8/10
9. Sam Allardyce n/a .... 7.35/10
10. Harry Redknapp 8.34/10 .... 7.5/10
11. Phil Brown 7.92/10 ... n/a
12. Joe Kinnear 6.85/10 ... n/a
13. Mark Hughes 4.5/10 ... 6/10
14. Tony Pulis n/a .... n/a
15. Tony Mowbray n/a ... n/a
16. Gary Megson 5.5/10 ... 5.5/10
17. Gareth Southgate 5.75/10 ... 6/10
18. Gianfranco Zola 4.85/10 ... n/a
19. Tony Adams 4.75/10 ... n/a
20. Ricky Spragia n/a ... n/a

7.825, 7.92, how the fcuk did you work out that kinda precision when rating managers objectively, I'll be very interested to see that calculation system. :pac:

ShoulderChip

DSB wrote: »

How does Alex Ferguson get rated below Wenger there? Insane.

Supermanscat wrote: »

Do you honestly think Wenger is better than Fergie?

I guess I just have more respect for Wenger considering the money he has spent, I also hate Ferguson, maybe I left too much bias creep in, its late at night.

whatawaster wrote: »

how did you come up with the exact ratings?

eZe^ wrote: »

7.825, 7.92, how the fcuk did you work out that kinda precision when rating managers objectively, I'll be very interested to see that calculation system. :pac:

I didn't use a calculation system its just how I work, If it bothers you just round up or down yourself.

whatawaster

ShoulderChip wrote: »

I didn't use a calculation system its just how I work, If it bothers you just round up or down yourself.

how come Mowbray or Pulis have no ratings for this season?

eZe^

ShoulderChip wrote: »

I didn't use a calculation system its just how I work, If it bothers you just round up or down yourself.

Thus your calculations are flawed and therefore invalid. :pac: I'm just messing around btw. I would happily rate those managers, but I've never ever heard of Phil Brown or Ricky Sbragia (notice how I spelled his name correctly, because I googled it :P)

ShoulderChip

whatawaster wrote: »

how come Mowbray or Pulis have no ratings for this season?

ah i do not know enough about the conditions at those clubs to be rating their managers,

I would end up just reciting their reputation in the media.

redout

I would take Martin O'Neil. He is destined for one of the big four clubs sooner or later and knows how to get the best out of lesser players.

jank

Well if wenger left I dont know who I would like to take over.

Maybe the special one, with tony adans as No2.

Bounty Hunter

thought id rate em too to give you guys another persons ratings to comment on and like shoulderchips my first vote is for this season's management and second for overall/ I didnt give anyone less than 5 though

1. Alex Ferguson 7.4/10..........9.2/10
2. Arsene Wenger 6/10............9/10
3. Rafa Benitez 8.5/10..........7.9/10
4. Martin O'Neill 8.5/10....... 8.5/10
5. David Moyes 6.9/10...... 7.8/10
6. Steve Bruce 7/10..........6.7/10
7. Roy Hodgson 8/10..........7.4/10
8. Luis Scolari 6.5/10..........8/10
9. Sam Allardyce n/a............7/10
10. Harry Redknapp 7.7/10..... 7.7/10
11. Phil Brown 8/10 ........... n/a
12. Joe Kinnear 6.9/10......... n/a
13. Mark Hughes 5/10 ...........7/10
14. Tony Pulis 5.3/10 ...........n/a
15. Tony Mowbray 5/10 ..........n/a
16. Gary Megson 5.5/10 ........5.5/10
17. Gareth Southgate 6.5/10...6/10
18. Gianfranco Zola 5/10.........n/a
19. Tony Adams 5/10............n/a
20. Ricky Sbragia n/a...............n/a

Hank Scorpio

roy hodgen i salute you

Jazzy

hodgsen has surprised me, thought he was worse then he is.

adams is terrible. has little idea how to manage a football club

eZe^

Bounty Hunter is the first person here to spell Sbragia correctly, thus he deserves thanks.

mike65

Can I cheat? - Jose

spockety

Without letting emotion get involved, and assuming it's an open choice with no barriers, as a Liverpool fan I would take Alex Ferguson. Most successful manager of the last 15 years, more league titles than anyone else, two european cups.. it's a no brainer.

kingshankly

spockety wrote: »

Without letting emotion get involved, and assuming it's an open choice with no barriers, as a Liverpool fan I would take Alex Ferguson. Most successful manager of the last 15 years, more league titles than anyone else, two european cups.. it's a no brainer.

tut tut tut sacrilege spockety have you been drinking how can you say such a thing(in public) go and take a long hard look at yourself;););)

eirebhoy

Jazzy wrote: »

hodgsen has surprised me, thought he was worse then he is.

adams is terrible. has little idea how to manage a football club

I was going to stick about 200 quid on Fulham on the handicap at 17/1 at the start of the season. I'm so regretting not doing that now. Really underrated by the bookies. Hodgson's a brilliant manager.

http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=56824438&postcount=5

I'd put them as favourites to win it. Had Portsmouth last season and they should have walked away with it. 1 win from any of their last 3 games would have won me €1,700. Even a draw and I'd have halved it with Everton.

kingshankly

eirebhoy wrote: »

I was going to stick about 200 quid on Fulham on the handicap at 17/1 at the start of the season. I'm so regretting not doing that now. Really underrated by the bookies. Hodgson's a brilliant manager.

http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=56824438&postcount=5

I'd put them as favourites to win it. Had Portsmouth last season and they should have walked away with it. 1 win from any of their last 3 games would have won me €1,700. Even a draw and I'd have halved it with Everton.

what start were they recieving was utd off scratch or chelsea

PHB

Depends on the amount of money you spend between Fergie and Wenger. If you've got literally no money, Wenger is better (although Fergie can pick a bargain). If you've got lots of money, Fergie is better (although Wenger can spend big and get it right at times)

Personally, I think Fergie is much better when he's got less money. He works harder, and gets good signings like Vidic, Evra and VDS on the cheap. 3 world class defenders/goalies for 10 million. Still though, Wenger can build a team from just youth which is amazing

eirebhoy

kingshankly wrote: »

what start were they recieving was utd off scratch or chelsea

I posted link.

mayordenis

PHB wrote: »

Depends on the amount of money you spend between Fergie and Wenger. If you've got literally no money, Wenger is better (although Fergie can pick a bargain). If you've got lots of money, Fergie is better (although Wenger can spend big and get it right at times)

Personally, I think Fergie is much better when he's got less money. He works harder, and gets good signings like Vidic, Evra and VDS on the cheap. 3 world class defenders/goalies for 10 million. Still though, Wenger can build a team from just youth which is amazing

beckham, neville, neville, scholes, giggs, butt, sharpe etc. etc.
Be fair to Fergie he's the forgotten man when it comes to blooding youth.

Highsider

With all bias put aside i'd take Fergie if he was 10 years younger in a heartbeat as a Liverpool supporter. But considering his age i'd say O'Neill out of that bunch as he has potential to be one of the great managers.