Kerry GAA Discussion Thread Mod Warning Post #4167

D'Agger

TheBomber14 wrote: »

Donncha walsh is simply not upto it imo, hes a better hurler anyway, seen him loadsa times playing the game and im led to believe that brendan cummins has contacted him about joining up with the hurlers , they could use someone with his stick work around the middle of the pitch imo

Who does he play hurling with? Kenmare isn't it?

Kerrydude1981

Kerry Minor Team v Clare

1 Shane Ryan (Rathmore)
2 Jack Morgan (Austin Stacks)
3 Brian Begley (An Ghaeltacht)
4 Tom O’Sullivan (Dingle)
5 Jason Foley (Ballydonoghue)
6 Andrew Barry (Na Gaeil)
7 Brian Sugrue (Renard)
8 Barry O’Sullivan (Dingle)
9 Mark O’Connor (Dingle)
10 Matthew Flaherty (Dingle)
11 Brian Rayle (Lispole)
12 Micheál Burns (Dr Crokes)
13 Jordan Kiely (Dr Crokes)
14 Killian Spillane (Templenoe)
15 Cathal Bambury (Dingle)

Fir Ionaid
16 Eoin O’Connell (St Senans)
17 Liam Kearney (Spa)
18 Stephen O Sullivan (Templenoe)
19 Cormac Coffey (Kerins O'Rahillys)
20 Shane Cronin (Spa)
21 Dan O Donoghue (Spa)
22 Ivan Parker (Churchill)
23 David Roche (Milltown C'maine)
24 Tomas Ó Sé (An Ghaeltacht)

What are people's thoughts on the minor team this year?

TheBomber14

he has scored 2-07 in 17 championship games for kerry. Is that good enough?

TheBomber14

Kerrydude1981 wrote: »

Kerry Minor Team v Clare

1 Shane Ryan (Rathmore)
2 Jack Morgan (Austin Stacks)
3 Brian Begley (An Ghaeltacht)
4 Tom O’Sullivan (Dingle)
5 Jason Foley (Ballydonoghue)
6 Andrew Barry (Na Gaeil)
7 Brian Sugrue (Renard)
8 Barry O’Sullivan (Dingle)
9 Mark O’Connor (Dingle)
10 Matthew Flaherty (Dingle)
11 Brian Rayle (Lispole)
12 Micheál Burns (Dr Crokes)
13 Jordan Kiely (Dr Crokes)
14 Killian Spillane (Templenoe)
15 Cathal Bambury (Dingle)

Fir Ionaid
16 Eoin O’Connell (St Senans)
17 Liam Kearney (Spa)
18 Stephen O Sullivan (Templenoe)
19 Cormac Coffey (Kerins O'Rahillys)
20 Shane Cronin (Spa)
21 Dan O Donoghue (Spa)
22 Ivan Parker (Churchill)
23 David Roche (Milltown C'maine)
24 Tomas Ó Sé (An Ghaeltacht)

What are people's thoughts on the minor team this year?

Struggle to get out of munster defo

duchalla

TheBomber14 wrote: »

if ye think walsh is up there with the likes of moynihan, scanlon,gooch, fitzgerald, then ye wud want to go away and have yer heads tested

As good as Seamus Scanlon was, he was a long way behind the other 3 players you mentioned. Nobody is claiming Walsh is as good as Seamus Moyinhan, the Gooch or Maurice Fitz. Stop reading stuff that isnt there....:rolleyes:

TheBomber14

Kerrydude1981 wrote: »

Kerry Minor Team v Clare

1 Shane Ryan (Rathmore)
2 Jack Morgan (Austin Stacks)
3 Brian Begley (An Ghaeltacht)
4 Tom O’Sullivan (Dingle)
5 Jason Foley (Ballydonoghue)
6 Andrew Barry (Na Gaeil)
7 Brian Sugrue (Renard)
8 Barry O’Sullivan (Dingle)
9 Mark O’Connor (Dingle)
10 Matthew Flaherty (Dingle)
11 Brian Rayle (Lispole)
12 Micheál Burns (Dr Crokes)
13 Jordan Kiely (Dr Crokes)
14 Killian Spillane (Templenoe)
15 Cathal Bambury (Dingle)

Fir Ionaid
16 Eoin O’Connell (St Senans)
17 Liam Kearney (Spa)
18 Stephen O Sullivan (Templenoe)
19 Cormac Coffey (Kerins O'Rahillys)
20 Shane Cronin (Spa)
21 Dan O Donoghue (Spa)
22 Ivan Parker (Churchill)
23 David Roche (Milltown C'maine)
24 Tomas Ó Sé (An Ghaeltacht)

What are people's thoughts on the minor team this year?

Easy to see that politics within kerry gaa circles is alive and rife, just looking at this team selection! 5 guys from dingle starting, management team have obviously left their tinted sunglasses on anyway when they sat down to pick this team, disgraceful behaviour and im ashamed to call myself a kerry man if this kind of behaviour is still going on throughout the county. CIARRAI ABU

Kerrydude1981

Every thread needs a troll I think we have found one

TheBomber14

this is a public forum kerrydude im entitled to my opinions surley?

keane2097

TheBomber14 wrote: »

this is a public forum kerrydude im entitled to my opinions surley?

Very quick to assume you were the troll there weren't you? Have a bit more self-confidence bomber.

TheBomber14

keane2097 wrote: »

Very quick to assume you were the troll there weren't you? Have a bit more self-confidence bomber.

surley to god a man can voice his opinion a PUBLIC forum without being lambasted by his fellow county men. Were all in this together lads, i admit some of my views are radical to say the least but i have the best intentions of kerry gaa firmly close to my heart. KINGDOM ABU

keane2097

TheBomber14 wrote: »

surley to god a man can voice his opinion a PUBLIC forum without being lambasted by his fellow county men. Were all in this together lads, i admit some of my views are radical to say the least but i have the best intentions of kerry gaa firmly close to my heart. KINGDOM ABU

Well that's the beauty of PUBLIC fora isn't it? Everyone is entitled to opinions, but people who hold ones which are idiotic are exposing them to the world to be critiqued as such. Not saying that applies to you, I personally think the idea of the small, nippy Seamus Scanlon as a wing forward for the hurlers is the sign of a rare intellect.

Also appreciate your concern as to whether I have a drug addiction, it's nice for people to take an interest.

TheBomber14

keane2097 wrote: »

Well that's the beauty of PUBLIC fora isn't it? Everyone is entitled to opinions, but people who hold ones which are idiotic are exposing them to the world to be critiqued as such. Not saying that applies to you, I personally think the idea of the small, nippy Seamus Scanlon as a wing forward for the hurlers is the sign of a rare intellect.

Also appreciate your concern as to whether I have a drug addiction, it's nice for people to take an interest.

appreaciate the kind words man, thanks! Defo agree with you re Scanlon and the hurlers, himself and donnacha walsh in the same half forward line would be a lethal combination.


As regards the minor team dont see them being upto much this year, hope im wrong but too many west kerry heads on that team for my liking.

premierstone

TheBomber14 wrote: »

If you think im going to back down and lick ur ass just cause your a mod , think again!. this is a public forum and im free to say what i want , its not a dictatorship!! Donncha walsh is simply not upto it imo, hes a better hurler anyway, seen him loadsa times playing the game and im led to believe that brendan cummins has contacted him about joining up with the hurlers , they could use someone with his stick work around the middle of the pitch imo

Why would Brendan Cummins be contacting anyone about joining the hurlers? Is he a goalkeeper, because Brendans entire role with Kerry amounts to part time goalkeeping coach, Eamon Kelly is the manager and Brian Horgan hte trainer.

keane2097

TheBomber14 wrote: »

appreaciate the kind words man, thanks! Defo agree with you re Scanlon and the hurlers, himself and donnacha walsh in the same half forward line would be a lethal combination.


As regards the minor team dont see them being upto much this year, hope im wrong but too many west kerry heads on that team for my liking.

I actually think people from West Kerry should be banned from playing. Except Dingle's Scanlon obviously.

TheBomber14

premierstone wrote: »

Why would Brendan Cummins be contacting anyone about joining the hurlers? Is he a goalkeeper, because Brendans entire role with Kerry amounts to part time goalkeeping coach, Eamon Kelly is the manager and Brian Horgan hte trainer.

Cummins doubles up his role as goalkeeping coach with human relations duties from time to time

TheBomber14

keane2097 wrote: »

I actually think people from West Kerry should be banned from playing. Except Dingle's Scanlon obviously.

Bit drastic, ur lucky theres not many on here from west kerry, theyd be irate.

Kerrydude1981

TheBomber14 wrote: »

appreaciate the kind words man, thanks! Defo agree with you re Scanlon and the hurlers, himself and donnacha walsh in the same half forward line would be a lethal combination.


As regards the minor team dont see them being upto much this year, hope im wrong but too many west kerry heads on that team for my liking.

Back boned by All Ireland Champions no harm in that surely??

Past few years the team was back boned by The Sem players,it all depends who is on top in the schools game.

premierstone

TheBomber14 wrote: »

Cummins doubles up his role as goalkeeping coach with human relations duties from time to time

No he does not, I know the manager personally and that is complete lies.

keane2097

Lads, seriously. Come on.

TheBomber14

Kerrydude1981 wrote: »

Back boned by All Ireland Champions no harm in that surely??

Past few years the team was back boned by The Sem players,it all depends who is on top in the schools game.

Schools success should have no bearing on an inter county minor panel imo. Schools football predominantly played in the winter, = slow ball, playing in ****.. shuits big strong players.... inter co minor= fast ball, faster pitches, should be more skillful guys on the team

TheBomber14

premierstone wrote: »

No he does not, I know the manager personally and that is complete lies.

are you good friends with eamonn fitzmaurice so ?. obviously not that close if you dont know that

TheBomber14

3 points a piece in the minor, 18 mins played

TheBomber14

5- 3 to kerry now

TheBomber14

7-3 after 28min

TheBomber14

half time 8-3

windy shepard henderson

that sounded like a fairly deacent kerry team , the expectation in the county was that we would run ye close tonight but it sounded like anything but that,

the reason for the optimism was based on the fact many of these lads had good senior club championship campaines last autumn/ winter and had no problem making the step up, also the impact of two or 3 players of last years minor team to the clare inter county team this year made all the difference when getting promoted

i would hope we lost to a very good kerry side tonight rather then to find this group of players we have are not as good as first taught , i am sure the tipperary game will be a better indicator for ye in a few weeks time

Boom__Boom

windy shepard henderson wrote: »

that sounded like a fairly deacent kerry team , the expectation in the county was that we would run ye close tonight but it sounded like anything but that,

the reason for the optimism was based on the fact many of these lads had good senior club championship campaines last autumn/ winter and had no problem making the step up, also the impact of two or 3 players of last years minor team to the clare inter county team this year made all the difference when getting promoted

i would hope we lost to a very good kerry side tonight rather then to find this group of players we have are not as good as first taught , i am sure the tipperary game will be a better indicator for ye in a few weeks time

Would be regarded as a pretty decent minor team here in Kerry - fair few PCD players in there who would probably still be a high after winning the Hogan Cup. Michael Burns was a sub on the Crokes team and Spillane at full-forward is Tom's son so he didnt exactly lick it off the stones.

QF 1 Waterford Tipperary 16/4
QF 2 Kerry Clare 16/4
QF 3 Cork Limerick 16/4
Play-Off 1 4 Loser of 2 Loser of 3 23/4
Play-Off 2 5 Loser of 1 Winner of 4 30/4
SF 6 Winner of 1 Winner of 2 14/5
SF 7 Winner of 3 Winner of 5 14/5
Final 6/7

Sounds like Limerick aren't up to much after the result in the Cork game [Cork 6-15 Limerick 1-7]

Tipp 2-11 Waterford 2-8 - wonder how strong Tipp are if they are only beating Waterford by 3

Clare v Limerick play this night week then winner of Clare/Limerick v Waterford => winner plays Cork in one semi with the other semi Tipp v Kerry

Kerrydude1981

windy shepard henderson wrote: »

that sounded like a fairly deacent kerry team , the expectation in the county was that we would run ye close tonight but it sounded like anything but that,

the reason for the optimism was based on the fact many of these lads had good senior club championship campaines last autumn/ winter and had no problem making the step up, also the impact of two or 3 players of last years minor team to the clare inter county team this year made all the difference when getting promoted

i would hope we lost to a very good kerry side tonight rather then to find this group of players we have are not as good as first taught , i am sure the tipperary game will be a better indicator for ye in a few weeks time

Did I hear right before the game that Clare played in a Leinster League during the winter? How did they fare out in that?

stuba

TheBomber14 wrote: »

Easy to see that politics within kerry gaa circles is alive and rife, just looking at this team selection! 5 guys from dingle starting, management team have obviously left their tinted sunglasses on anyway when they sat down to pick this team, disgraceful behaviour and im ashamed to call myself a kerry man if this kind of behaviour is still going on throughout the county. CIARRAI ABU

Which of these 5 players shouldn't be starting? Please inform me.

Radio5

Well done to the Minor team. When is the Tipp game?