Local elections

ciaran76

Alot of new people putting their name into the hat this time around.

Wonder how the results will go in the local election in D.15 this time around.
Anyone predicting big shocks ?

athtrasna

Mulhuddart is an interesting LEA. However I'm stuck in Castleknock which has to be the most boring LEA in Dublin!! No exciting candidates at all unless you factor in the heavily improved posters of a certain former PD :eek:

Powerhouse

I have often met the said former PD and I think the posters are a decent likeness. Maybe it is the quality of the cardboard you mean.

It is the phenomenally gleaming white teeth of a former (and indeed current also) Labour candidate that struck me as odd on the posters.

Expect the Greens to take a seat in Castleknock and FF to quite possibly get no seat in either ward. The latter would not be the massive shock some people will say it is because FF got only the last seat in either of the Dublin 15 wards ward last time.

Considering that starting point and the likely national swing against them they will stuggle in both wards, though the extra seat in Mulhuddart changes things a bit, so they might do something there. Socialists might take a seat in both wards.

Mulhuddart is guaranteed while Higgins's profile will make him strong in Castleknock which is the kind of place where profile is probably more important than work on the ground and you are bound to have a lot of very well-heeled 'socialists'.

Demographics guarantees FG one in Castleknock but the same thing make it unlikely in Mulhuddart.

athtrasna

Powerhouse wrote: »

I have often met the said former PD and I think the posters are a decent likeness. Maybe it is the quality of the cardboard you mean.

You are kidding me right? They look at least 20 years younger!! Google the 2007 and 2004 posters and there's little resemblance!

The Higgins issue that might stop him being elected in Castleknock is that he's running for Europe too, regardless of his chances, he's not being true to the electorate of Castleknock by not being dedicated to his council run.

Re Mulhuddart, the new Irish vote is going to be an interesting one. Don't rule out a FG seat there just yet. It would be helped though if Waterville was in Mulhuddart rather than Castleknock. It's a weird situation where one side of the Snugborough Road is one ward and the other another.

Powerhouse

athtrasna wrote: »

You are kidding me right? They look at least 20 years younger!! Google the 2007 and 2004 posters and there's little resemblance!

I met the woman last Tuesday night. I don't need to google any posters.

Every poster is touched up, and of the many I have seen that would not be one that I'd consider overdone. One of the FG candidates who I see regularly has had 20 years taken off them I would think.

Gaspode

Agreed, they're heavily touched up. Met Mags in Coolmine today and had to stop myself making a comment on her poster picture!

Pineapple stu

How come Mountview is in the Castleknock ward now??????D

Higgins for Europe, he'd give them eurocrats some stick with his speeches:).

These posters on every lampost is getting out of hand these days. Has anyone voted for someone just because they saw them on a poster? My vote woud go to the candidate who didnt put up any posters.
Would it make the elections more fun and give those that dont usually vote a reason to do so if we had some silly parties like those in the UK like the monster raving looney's or some other made up parties.?

Jip

Powerhouse wrote: »

Socialists might take a seat in both wards.

Mulhuddart is guaranteed while Higgins's profile will make him strong in Castleknock which is the kind of place where profile is probably more important than work on the ground and you are bound to have a lot of very well-heeled 'socialists'.

Please god no, I'd even vote FF ahead of a socialist representative. They've misled alot of people on some issues, most noticably the management fees for one, Castlecurragh is still not in great shape compared to what it was before the socialists came in and told everyone they're not obliged to pay it.

They were against Snowtopia, complained about the delay in Tyrrelstown of the schools yet don't want the school built on land donated by the developer, afaik they objected to Tyrrelstown as a whole but you can bet they'll be in there looking for votes. Another irony is that they complain about the state of public transport in the area but yet the guy who brought the city to it knees with the unofficial bus strike a few weeks ago is running as a socialist party representative, the guy from the bus drivers action group.

Is there another party as full of hypocrisy, bar FF of course.

Powerhouse

cymro wrote: »

Has anyone voted for someone just because they saw them on a poster? My vote woud go to the candidate who didnt put up any posters.

You can be assured that people have voted for someone because they saw them on a poster. Why on earth do you think political parties spend money on these things? While the candidate that chose not to put any up might get your vote (which in fairness seems no less illogical than voting for someone because they have a poster up) because of the lack of recognition factor your ballot paper would become very lonely in its own little pile.

Leo Varadkar spent an absolute fortune in the last election. He had posters up at the bus shelters for weeks on end which cost him thousands upon thousands. He spent far more than either of the other two elected candidates elected on posters. This was a lesson he learned the hard way. In the local election in 1999 Varadkar polled 380 votes. Five years later his vote increased by 1,200% when he polled the highest vote in the country and followed it up with nearly 7,000 votes in the General Election. He certainly saw the value in posters. Don't be codding yourself that this stuff doesn't matter.

Powerhouse

Jip wrote: »

afaik they objected to Tyrrelstown as a whole but you can bet they'll be in there looking for votes.

They objected to Tyrrelstown being built without proper facilites and public transport. It is of course a novel concept to provide ancillary facilities for such places but that was the core of their objections. The FG/Labour governed council naturally just saw the great juicy building levies and didn't bother worrying about such trivialities as facilities. I would say it is the latter who are more brass-necked to be looking for votes in the place.

ciaran76

I don't like the posters on every lampost from Ongar to Littlepace it is unreal.

They really are an eyesore (IMO).

Funny thing is you dont see half of these guys till there is an election then suddenly their face is everywhere. I have been living in my house for near 4 years now and not once has a politican ever knocked on my door (maybe when I was out)

Yet I go to my Mam's house (Hartstown)and everytime I am there during election times there are always politicans knocking around.

I didn't know Higgins was running in Castleknock ! Is there alist anywhere of who is running in each area?

Powerhouse

ciaran76 wrote: »

Funny thing is you dont see half of these guys till there is an election then suddenly their face is everywhere. I have been living in my house for near 4 years now and not once has a politican ever knocked on my door (maybe when I was out)

Yet I go to my Mam's house (Hartstown)and everytime I am there during election times there are always politicans knocking around.

In fairness, this is just populist rheroric. All councillor's phone numbers are on the Fingal county council website and they are contactable for anyone who needs them. The idea that they should spend their time going from door to door every day on the off chance that someone might might specifically need them is laughable.

If you read Community Voice there are plenty of opportunities to see what these politicians think and get up to.

joolsveer

I have noticed a number of the posters in my area blown down but something different seems to have happened to this one.

joolsveer

On a more serious note has anyone come across racist comments being written across posters? I think I saw a defaced poster near the hospital in Clonsilla when I was driving by yesterday.

Rosita

joolsveer wrote: »

I have noticed a number of the posters in my area blown down but something different seems to have happened to this one.

Some people have waay too much time on their hands.

ciaran76

Powerhouse wrote: »

In fairness, this is just populist rheroric. All councillor's phone numbers are on the Fingal county council website and they are contactable for anyone who needs them. The idea that they should spend their time going from door to door every day on the off chance that someone might might specifically need them is laughable.

If you read Community Voice there are plenty of opportunities to see what these politicians think and get up to.

Yeah I do read that newspaper so do see what they are getting up to. I am in contact with some of the councillors by e-mail or post on occassions so I have no worries there.

I dont think they should spend their time going from door to door everyday thats your statement not mine. I was just talking about election times.

They seem to be able to get to my parents house plenty of times during the elections and what about the people who have never been voted in before how are we supposed to decided on them if their phone numbers are not on the Fingal website.

Powerhouse

ciaran76 wrote: »

1) I dont think they should spend their time going from door to door everyday thats your statement not mine. I was just talking about election times.

2) They seem to be able to get to my parents house plenty of times during the elections and what about the people who have never been voted in before how are we supposed to decided on them if their phone numbers are not on the Fingal website.

1) So why write this then: "Funny thing is you dont see half of these guys till there is an election then suddenly their face is everywhere. I have been living in my house for near 4 years now and not once has a politican ever knocked on my door (maybe when I was out)".

That could be interpreted as meaning you think they should be visiting houses all the time and not just during the election. Maybe you could clarify what you meant?


2) Well, I mentioned Community Voice. All the candidates have been profiled in that paper over the last six or eight weeks and it has been carrying election campaign information. Many if not all the candidates have advertised public meetings to discuss issues and are pushing leaflets through letter-boxes explaining their positions. Short of spoon-feeding people it's hard to know what they can do, but the information is out there about them.

confused-dazed

Powerhouse wrote: »

1) So why write this then: "Funny thing is you dont see half of these guys till there is an election then suddenly their face is everywhere. I have been living in my house for near 4 years now and not once has a politican ever knocked on my door (maybe when I was out)".

That could be interpreted as meaning you think they should be visiting houses all the time and not just during the election. Maybe you could clarify what you meant?


2) Well, I mentioned Community Voice. All the candidates have been profiled in that paper over the last six or eight weeks and it has been carrying election campaign information. Many if not all the candidates have advertised public meetings to discuss issues and are pushing leaflets through letter-boxes explaining their positions. Short of spoon-feeding people it's hard to know what they can do, but the information is out there about them.

these people when elected by you will be there to represent your voice in that area. now whats the point in voting for someone if all they're going to do is sit in a office or wherever and not be seem by joe public. i once asked a T.D.who came canvasing who he was as i never seem him before in the area.
(i knew damn well who he was), but my point was the only time you ever saw these guys was when they wanted something from us.
i want to know who i'm voting for, i want to ask questions face to face. i basically want to interview these guys to see if they're worth getting my vote.

ciaran76

Powerhouse wrote: »

1) So why write this then: "Funny thing is you dont see half of these guys till there is an election then suddenly their face is everywhere. I have been living in my house for near 4 years now and not once has a politican ever knocked on my door (maybe when I was out)".

That could be interpreted as meaning you think they should be visiting houses all the time and not just during the election. Maybe you could clarify what you meant?

Dont forget the 2 sentances I wrote before you decided to pull my quotes out.
It was in realation to the posters aswell!

"I don't like the posters on every lampost from Ongar to Littlepace it is unreal.

They really are an eyesore (IMO). I]

Powerhouse

ciaran76 wrote: »

Dont forget the 2 sentances I wrote before you decided to pull my quotes out.
It was in realation to the posters aswell!

"I don't like the posters on every lampost from Ongar to Littlepace it is unreal.

They really are an eyesore (IMO). I]

I don't see anything in this to change the nature of my question. What posters on lampposts has to do with you expecting to see your local politicians regularly on your doorstep is not clear.

Powerhouse

confused-dazed wrote: »

i want to know who i'm voting for, i want to ask questions face to face. i basically want to interview these guys to see if they're worth getting my vote.

Interview them?! Why not get a psychological profiler in while you're at it.
It's hard to believe reading this that your vote is worth only the same as mine!

ciaran76

Powerhouse wrote: »

I don't see anything in this to change the nature of my question. What posters on lampposts has to do with you expecting to see your local politicians regularly on your doorstep is not clear.

So the people looking to be elected for the 1st time who I have never seen before or heard of suddenly have an article in the local paper and a 1000's of posters on the lamposts around D.15 want me to vote for them.

So what if they set up some local meeting or clinic a few months before an election. The years and months before I have never seen these people and suddenly they want my vote.

I can't remember if it was last time or the time before but I had seen names on the voting slip of people I had never heard of or mentioned in the paper.

Nevyn

Powerhouse wrote: »

Interview them?! Why not get a psychological profiler in while you're at it.
It's hard to believe reading this that your vote is worth only the same as mine!

Clearly he values his vote and thinks that he is entitled to find out as much about the candidates and the issues they are running on as possible

ciaran76 wrote: »

Yeah I do read that newspaper so do see what they are getting up to. I am in contact with some of the councillors by e-mail or post on occassions so I have no worries there.

I dont think they should spend their time going from door to door everyday thats your statement not mine. I was just talking about election times.

They seem to be able to get to my parents house plenty of times during the elections and what about the people who have never been voted in before how are we supposed to decided on them if their phone numbers are not on the Fingal website.

Well one of the things I learned last night on my tour of the Dáil and being shown around the offices of Cairán Cuffe (green party whip) that if an estate has a high % of people who actually turn out an vote then they will canvas in those areas and target them more, which will be more mature areas.

New estates with a younger demographic just do not get canvased in the same way, or older estates which are seen to have a less educated, politically active residents will not have the politicians working the doorsteps for votes in the same way.

Tbh if you have their email and they are replying to you then by all means make use of it.

Actually how about we compile a list of questions and then email the candidates and post up how long it took them to answer and what their answers are?

The D15 forum doorstep.

What questions and what issue do you want to ask of the candidates?

Powerhouse

Thaedydal wrote: »

Clearly he values his vote and thinks that he is entitled to find out as much about the candidates and the issues they are running on as possible

Christ, pass me the sick-bucket. I have read what these politicians are saying. I have attended public meetings they have held on a variety of issues. I attended a public questions and answers session at the civic offices with the candidates last week - and you are implying that this other guy values his vote more than me? (And yes, yes, you didn't say it but that is the clear implication of what you said)

If he values his vote then he could get off his arse and inform himself instead of expecting election candidates to turn up at the doors of an electorate of 50,000 and be personally interviewed by them all.

Nobody is questioning anyone's entitlement to find out about candidates. What I have an issue with is lazy people who expect to be spoon-fed. He doesn't remotely value his vote. If he did he'd inform himself.

Powerhouse

ciaran76 wrote: »

So the people looking to be elected for the 1st time who I have never seen before or heard of suddenly have an article in the local paper and a 1000's of posters on the lamposts around D.15 want me to vote for them.

Apparently that's the idea of an election. Even the ones you have heard of might want you to vote for them. There's nowt so queer as folk.

Suzannem

Mags Murray's racenight is on at The Bell tonight at 9pm - Its going to better then the usual race nights.....come and find out!!

Gaspode

Right folks, some posts here are very close to attacking the person making the post, rather than attacking the content of the post.
So far things havent crossed the line too much, and the debate is interesting enough so I'll let it continue for the moment, but please remember the spirit of the forum charter.

Gaspode

cymro wrote: »

These posters on every lampost is getting out of hand these days.

I agree, what a pointless waste of money & time, and what an eyesore.

cymro wrote: »

Has anyone voted for someone just because they saw them on a poster?
.

Not I. Or at least I dont think so. Sometimes I give lower choice votes to nobodys just to make sure someone I dont want in doesnt get my vote. Maybe those 'nobodys' were subconsciously imprinted in my brain from posters? Who knows.

cymro wrote: »

My vote woud go to the candidate who didnt put up any posters.

Maybe they put up posters but you didnt see them, or like me you just stop noticing them after a couple of days.

Powerhouse wrote: »

You can be assured that people have voted for someone because they saw them on a poster.

Assured by whom?

Powerhouse wrote: »

Why on earth do you think political parties spend money on these things?

Who knows, maybe because they've always done it?

Powerhouse wrote: »

Leo Varadkar spent an absolute fortune in the last election. He had posters up at the bus shelters for weeks on end which cost him thousands upon thousands. He spent far more than either of the other two elected candidates elected on posters. This was a lesson he learned the hard way. In the local election in 1999 Varadkar polled 380 votes. Five years later his vote increased by 1,200% when he polled the highest vote in the country and followed it up with nearly 7,000 votes in the General Election. He certainly saw the value in posters. Don't be codding yourself that this stuff doesn't matter.

But surely Leo was elected because of all the great work he was doing for the local community, and not because he spent a fortune on publicity. You're making a tenuous link there between an effect and a single cause. Perhaps you 100% right and his poster campaing had an effect, but I'd like to think politicians get elected for something more useful than a good profile. Otherwise we could just have Simon Cowell and his cronies set up some popularity gameshow to elect politicians!

ciaran76 wrote: »

I don't like the posters on every lampost from Ongar to Littlepace it is unreal.

They really are an eyesore (IMO).

Agreed.

Powerhouse wrote: »

It's hard to believe reading this that your vote is worth only the same as mine!

Yeah weird isnt it? I believe its called democracy.

Nevyn

Powerhouse wrote: »

Christ, pass me the sick-bucket. I have read what these politicians are saying. I have attended public meetings they have held on a variety of issues. I attended a public questions and answers session at the civic offices with the candidates last week - and you are implying that this other guy values his vote more than me? (And yes, yes, you didn't say it but that is the clear implication of what you said)

Thats nice how did you find out about them?
And how great is that you have the time to attend such things, clearly you have an avid interest not everyone does.

Powerhouse wrote: »

If he values his vote then he could get off his arse and inform himself instead of expecting election candidates to turn up at the doors of an electorate of 50,000 and be personally interviewed by them all.

I see him asking why they haven't been on his doorstep as the start of him questioning and seeking out such info and I for am not going to knock a person who is starting to seek out engagement to inform themselves and he is so right about the disparity in estates visited and most people expect
politicians to door step them esp if that is what they have clearly grown up with.

Powerhouse wrote: »

Nobody is questioning anyone's entitlement to find out about candidates. What I have an issue with is lazy people who expect to be spoon-fed. He doesn't remotely value his vote. If he did he'd inform himself.

Some times I really wish I could away with a mega snarky reply.

Personally I will not look down my nose at someone who is looking to start that process, and I am sure if you were to list the up coming meetings he would be grateful, also any links you have to the agendas and profiles of the candidates, as I know more then you do stuff is petty and not helpful
and the better informed people are the better choices they make and includes
in using their vote.

Nevyn

oh and if you are not sure if you are on the register here is how to check quickly.

http://www.fingalcoco.ie/ereg/

and if you are missing you have until the 18th of May to fix that.

Gaspode

cymro wrote: »

How come Mountview is in the Castleknock ward now??????D

Dont remind me, at the last election we found out we'd been moved to whatever constituency is Finglas in when the polling cards arrived just before polling day! Not amused, dont know any of the politicians there.