Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Body Image

Options
1356

Comments

  • Moderators, Music Moderators Posts: 8,490 Mod ✭✭✭✭Fluorescence


    Yeah 10 would be average for that age. I'm a size 12/14 at age 17 and would definitely be above average :P


  • Registered Users Posts: 9,029 ✭✭✭Lockstep


    Do these general clothes sizes take into account difference in upper body/lower body ratios?

    I'm surprised that 10 is the average, The women I've sold size 10 clothes to look slim to my mind. Would've thought 12-14 was more average.


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 30,657 Mod ✭✭✭✭Faith



    The real question in my mind is how does this happen? What sparks the worry that ends with obsession? How can it change? Mostly I wonder how anyone can feel lessened because their thighs are less than perfect. What you look like isn't who you are, and to be imperfect is to be human.

    For me, it was largely due to my parents tbh. I remember being about 7 years old and my dad telling me I was fat. I was always a bit pudgy, but my parents were obsessed with my weight, regularly telling me that I was fat from as early as I can remember. My dad because he's extraordinarily critical, and my mum because of her preoccupation with her own weight. My mum still tells me that if I lost weight my boyfriend would love me more. That sounds shocking, but she does mean well. She just doesn't realise how much damage saying things like that does, she thinks she's just helping. Her obsession with being thin has now become mine - but I've also inherited her emotional eating habits.

    But well done you for being happy with yourself, that's something most women will strive their whole lives for! :)
    I'd say a size 10 would be average in that age range?

    Really? When I look around, I'd be surprised if the average was actually below a 12 at least.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,488 ✭✭✭pikachucheeks


    I'd say a size 10 would be average in that age range?

    Really?

    I'd say the average size is about a 12 - all my friends seem to take that size!

    I was flicking through a paper in work the other day, one of the tabloids, and they had this 2-page spread about this new survey revealing men's ideal size for a woman is a 14!


  • Posts: 50,630 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    in the 18-22 yo age range I would have said a size 10 average yeh, there are definitely alot of bigger girls out there - especially from less privileged backgrounds. I'm 27 and it definitely goes up by the time you get to my age - I'm a 12 which I would say is probably average although I was away with a group of girls a few weeks ago and most of them would be a 10 or less - all hitting or above 30 years of age.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,440 ✭✭✭GirlInterrupted


    Faith wrote: »
    For me, it was largely due to my parents tbh. I remember being about 7 years old and my dad telling me I was fat. I was always a bit pudgy, but my parents were obsessed with my weight, regularly telling me that I was fat from as early as I can remember. My dad because he's extraordinarily critical, and my mum because of her preoccupation with her own weight. My mum still tells me that if I lost weight my boyfriend would love me more. That sounds shocking, but she does mean well. She just doesn't realise how much damage saying things like that does, she thinks she's just helping. Her obsession with being thin has now become mine - but I've also inherited her emotional eating habits.

    Thats really quite upsetting to read.

    The responsibilty of being a parent is huge in so many ways. A few thoughtlessly chosen words can be the catalyst of a lifetime of poor self-image or self-loathing.

    I just feel so sad that its so common to feel so bad about oneself, and I truly never realised how lucky I was to feel - at worst - indifference to my body.


  • Registered Users Posts: 6,691 ✭✭✭Lia_lia


    I seriously doubt a 10 is the average size for that age group. I'm 20 and most of my friends are a size 12.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,129 ✭✭✭Nightwish


    Some of the replies, particularly Faith's are quite sad to read. I cant imagine what it must be like to have someone remark on your weight like that, even if there's no malice involved. I have never had an issue with my weight. I was a size 8 up to my 20's when I went on the pill and now I'm a size 10. I've never felt fat or anything like that. The only time I felt a bit big was when I tried on a pair of Victoria Beckham skinny jeans in NYC and they barely came up to my thighs and I asked the sales assistant for them in a bigger size and she said "Oh no, they dont come any bigger than that". The moment passed very quickly and I laugh at it now.

    I suppose the only aspect of my body I'd change is my muscle tone, but thats because I'm too lazy to excercise every day.


  • Registered Users Posts: 6,383 ✭✭✭Aoibheann


    I'm better than I used to be, but I'm still not totally happy. However there'll always be something that's not perfect, no matter how much weight I lose, how toned I become. I would always find a problem with something - the most stupid thing, of course. And I think most people are the same. It's impossible (nearly, anyway) to be 100% confident about your body 100% of the time. :) Eating better and taking up a martial art (the second one more so) have been the best things that have happened to me. I probably don't weigh a whole lot less than I did a couple of years ago - back then I weighed myself on a regular basis, now if you asked me, I genuinely wouldn't have a clue - but I'm much happier with my body shape, tone.. everything. Yes, there are days that I feel horribly fat, weeks even. I'm far more confident about myself now though than I was a few years back and those days are getting fewer. :) It's taken a lot of effort to bring myself around to seeing myself in a better light, but it's happening slowly but surely! Still can't accept a compliment though about my body though.. that's my main thing. I always failed with compliments anyway! :P

    /end rambling


  • Registered Users Posts: 14,983 ✭✭✭✭Hermione*


    Aoibheann wrote: »
    Eating better and taking up a martial art (the second one more so) have been the best things that have happened to me.
    Qft.

    I really think the best way to start being happy with yourself is to start looking after yourself, and in particular, to do something active. If you use your body for something productive, you realise that your body can actually do some amazing things. Your body becomes something which can make you happy.
    Plus, you spend less time staring at a mirror, critiquing yourself!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 18,150 ✭✭✭✭Malari


    I posted a reply on the first page of this thread, but I deleted it when I saw the other replies. I was afraid I'd appear conceited.

    I'm happy with myself, grateful I'm put together the way I am. I've a couple of scars on my back, but other than that there's nothing I'd change. Actually, I wouldn't even bother changing those.

    I was going to post too, but was afraid of the same thing! I am shocked that most people who post don't like their bodies. I had to go and check the original question to see if it was "DO you like your body" and not "what is wrong with your body"

    I like the way I look. I am very happy with my face, my weight, my body shape. I wouldn't change anything. I am "me" exactly the way I am.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,428 ✭✭✭sunnyside


    I have what a lot of people consider a perfect figure. Hourglass shape, size 10, flat stomach but I can honestly say I'm never happy with how I look.

    My weight moves between 9-10 stone but I rarely weigh myself. The weight is the one thing I don't obsess about.
    shellyboo wrote: »
    he did used to tell me I was gorgeous, but I remember when he used to say it I'd just feel uncomfortable and angry and genuinely thought he was lying. I couldn't see what he saw.

    I never believe it when someone tells me I'm beautiful. My idea of beauty revolves around images in glossy magazines and other people's pictures on bebo. I know the magazine pictures are airbrushed but it doesn't help.

    I obsess about ageing, I hate how I look in photos. I hate my teeth and want to get some cosmetic work done on them. Only reason I haven't is because I can't afford it yet.

    I spend a fortune on hairdresser and waxing. I won't take my clothes off unless perfectly waxed. I find it harder to look good as I get older (30). I work really hard at it.

    Women are so judgemental, I admit to judging other women on how they look and I know they do it to me all the time too. I feel good when I look better than a woman who is younger than me because I am a lot thinner than her. I wouldn't admit how much effort I make though, I pretend it's fairly effortless.

    I was in Dublin at the weekend and I got asked if I had a student card twice when I paid for things. This totally made my weekend because as I said I hate getting older so these people must have thought I looked younger. Of course it might have been because I looked scruffy, but I hope not:)


  • Moderators, Arts Moderators Posts: 17,231 Mod ✭✭✭✭Das Kitty


    sunnyside wrote: »
    Women are so judgemental, I admit to judging other women on how they look and I know they do it to me all the time too.


    You only think that because you do it. I know I don't judge other women on their looks / bodies and I never suspect any other women of doing it to me unless it's obvious and she says something. You're projecting how you feel about yourself onto how they feel about you.

    Faith's post made me so sad. My Mum still has the odd jibe about the size of my gut, but it's really her reflecting her insecurities about her own one on me. I'm OK with mine, she's really not with hers.

    My grandmother as well always has something to say about my size, I found out recently that she's been bulimic, I don't know how long for but definitely since going into the nursing home and I suspect her whole life judging from her lack of teeth at the age of 40 and her tiny breakable body. It's kind of disturbing thinking of someone in their 90s doing these things to stay thin. She's lucky she had no daughters to pass on that level of ****ed-uppedness to .


  • Registered Users Posts: 1,121 ✭✭✭Censorsh!t


    For my height, I'm slightly underweight, but I'm not very fit at all.
    Some days, like most people here, I get fat days, when I look in the mirror and my tummy is sticking out like I'm pregnant and my ass seems way too fat for my body. These days, I wont wear tight tops, and will suck in my tummy as much as possible.
    Then somedays I'm rather happy, and shocked at how much thinner I look.
    I think the main problem is periods and bloating :( I also plan on getting fit (I say that every day).
    Also, my nose is horrible from a side view i think, it's not like those perfect little button noses, it's more straight and unfeminine. Yet I don't mind my face from the front.


  • Registered Users Posts: 2,280 ✭✭✭paperclip2


    Hated my physical self for years and did really, really stupid things like vomiting and starving myself. I've been every size between 10 and 20 and mostly miserable for all of that time. I measured my worth in terms of poundage. :( I was eternally at war with myself, my weight was on my mind constantly and lots of the time it did stop me from doing the things I would have liked to have done.

    I try not to live like that anymore, I do have days where I think the mirror is out to get me :D but I'm not letting myself get wrapped up in the negative thoughts the way I used to. Thats the hardest part actually, trying to rewire my thinking and look at my body issues differently rather than using them as an excuse to self-flagellate.

    It can be bloody hard work though. :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 95 ✭✭madra-rua


    I'm happy with my body, I'm a size 14 at the minute and would describe myself as curvy. In my teens I was a size 10-12 but I can honestly say I've always been happy enough with my body, even as I got older and it started to change. Of course I have my bad days but I think we should be thankful for what we've got - on the bad days I sometimes think how lucky I am to be healthy and alive and then any body issues seem silly. I think a lot of it depends on the clothes you wear - you've got to accentuate your best bits and dress properly - and when you feel confident on the inside it shows on the outside :D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 443 ✭✭valery


    I posted a reply on the first page of this thread, but I deleted it when I saw the other replies. I was afraid I'd appear conceited.

    I'm happy with myself, grateful I'm put together the way I am. I've a couple of scars on my back, but other than that there's nothing I'd change. Actually, I wouldn't even bother changing those.

    Reading about the self-loathing that goes on with so many has left me feeling really sad. I can't imagine an existence where weighing yourself several times a day feels normal. I know how much I weigh when my doctor mentions it.

    The real question in my mind is how does this happen? What sparks the worry that ends with obsession? How can it change? Mostly I wonder how anyone can feel lessened because their thighs are less than perfect. What you look like isn't who you are, and to be imperfect is to be human.



    Honestly not getting at you here Girlinterrupted. To find the answer to that question you would have to walk in the shoes of those people.
    :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 844 ✭✭✭allabouteve


    valery wrote: »
    Honestly not getting at you here Girlinterrupted. To find the answer to that question you would have to walk in the shoes of those people.
    :)

    Thats why she's asking, not assuming she knows.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 443 ✭✭valery


    Thats why she's asking, not assuming she knows.





    oh, sorry. :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 13,252 ✭✭✭✭Madame Razz


    I've never had any issue with food, but I can safely say I have a pretty negative body image, an image which has disimproved with age.

    I feel, quite frankly, disappointed everytime I look in the mirror; despite having a healthy BMI.

    I'll never be tiny, as I don't have a small frame and am quite tall. But I definately feel that theres room for serious improvement.

    Improvement gets harder and harder to achieve as I get older tho:rolleyes:


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 443 ✭✭valery


    I've never had any issue with food, but I can safely say I have a pretty negative body image, an image which has disimproved with age.

    I feel, quite frankly, disappointed everytime I look in the mirror; despite having a healthy BMI.

    I'll never be tiny, as I don't have a small frame and am quite tall. But I definately feel that theres room for serious improvement.

    Improvement gets harder and harder to achieve as I get older tho:rolleyes:



    I turned 40 a while back and can relate to what your saying. For me watching what i eat a little more than i used to is important, also 4 trips to the gym per week for aerobics has really worked wonders for me, and i never let food "settle" , out for a good walk half an hour after dinner .
    I would say the above has improved my mental self/outlook on life. we all grow old but theres no need to" live" old , not bloody yet. :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 13,252 ✭✭✭✭Madame Razz


    valery wrote: »
    I turned 40 a while back and can relate to what your saying. For me watching what i eat a little more than i used to is important, also 4 trips to the gym per week for aerobics has really worked wonders for me, and i never let food "settle" , out for a good walk half an hour after dinner .
    I would say the above has improved my mental self/outlook on life. we all grow old but theres no need to" live" old , not bloody yet. :)


    Oh I agree. I just resent the fact that my body doesnt react as well or as quickly to such healthy habits anymore:rolleyes:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 443 ✭✭valery


    Oh I agree. I just resent the fact that my body doesnt react as well or as quickly to such healthy habits anymore:rolleyes:



    Things do slow down alright. For me though, Im running to 50, and if the legs will comply , then its on to 60. yep, crazy bitch but i dont care, feeling fit and healthy is fab. :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 117 ✭✭winking weber


    I dont stress out too much about my body but I wouldnt say I've a great self image either.

    Was out with friends at the weekend and when they were chatted up, I presumed it was because I was less attractive. When I was chatted up, I presumed it was because I was less attractive. Ok it may have been true in both instances but I need to cop myself on and stop thinking like that in the first place.

    I was feeling really bleugh today and a friend/colleague emailed me to say I looked lovely which was really nice though :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 443 ✭✭valery


    I dont stress out too much about my body but I wouldnt say I've a great self image either.

    Was out with friends at the weekend and when they were chatted up, I presumed it was because I was less attractive. When I was chatted up, I presumed it was because I was less attractive. Ok it may have been true in both instances but I need to cop myself on and stop thinking like that in the first place.

    I was feeling really bleugh today and a friend/colleague emailed me to say I looked lovely which was really nice though :)


    Sometimes we can be too self critical when it comes to how we "look" .
    I would build on what your friend said about you . Think back to those negative thoughts you had at the weekend and laugh them away. There is a book you can buy called " The Little Book Of Confidence" in Easons .
    I found it inexpensive and invaluable. :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,811 ✭✭✭*Page*


    ok well i know that i am overweight and i want to fit it for health reasons rather than to be skinny... I was 15+stone and was happy.

    I used to have a big problem with weight when i was younger which ment i couldnt put on any weight and was at 1 point under 7 stone but i was really unhappy with being skinny. I always wanted to be bigger.

    So to be healthy I have to loose 2 stone i am currently 12 and a half stone. my doctor wants me to be 8-9 stone but now way am i going back to skin and bones....


    So i guess we all have issues either too skinny too fat ect....


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 443 ✭✭valery


    *Page* wrote: »
    ok well i know that i am overweight and i want to fit it for health reasons rather than to be skinny... I was 15+stone and was happy.

    I used to have a big problem with weight when i was younger which ment i couldnt put on any weight and was at 1 point under 7 stone but i was really unhappy with being skinny. I always wanted to be bigger.

    So to be healthy I have to loose 2 stone i am currently 12 and a half stone. my doctor wants me to be 8-9 stone but now way am i going back to skin and bones....


    So i guess we all have issues either too skinny too fat ect....



    If your into it i would go for aerobic fitness . an hours walk a day after your main meal will start to burn off calories and you dont have to go to "skin and bones" . How about meeting the doc half way and lose one stone .
    Ask one of your friends to join you on the walks and you can get in a good natter as well. :)


  • Registered Users Posts: 170 ✭✭LauraLoo


    Here is a theory ive been thinking about for some time:

    Man are naturally square shaped- flat chested and straight down with no curve to the hips. Heterosexual women are instinctively attracted to the square shape of the male species.
    Women are naturally round shaped- round chested, round hips, round bottom. Heterosexual men are instinctively attracted to the round shape of the female species.

    Alot of the women on here are saying that they are continiously comparing themselves to other women. It seems a womans body image issues could stem from judgement recieved from other women/women targeted media/womens magazines etc

    Although we have a coherence that separates us from the rest of the animal kingdom- we are essentially animals.

    In the wild- the female will try to mate with a man thats as high up in the pack as possibel (i.e the best provider). Men will try to mate with the most fertile female to re-produce. (the most "attractive"- this is where "child bearing hips" comes from as apparently the wider the hips, the more fertile one is)

    In the wild, women have to compete for the alpha male. It is within our nature to be competitive with each other. But society has changed where technically we no longer have to compete because we no longer run in a pack. But our nature cannot change over night, so women are still competing. (similar to how men front each other and act like the tough guy)

    Do you think the obsession with being "skinny" is women trying to be attractive to other women, in the sense that we are worrying what other women are thinking about us? Has our nature to compete for a male become a bit twisted because we no longer have to compete for a male but still continue to have the instinct of competition?

    Look at the size zero fiasco. These women are on the cover of womens magazines- men are not buying these magazines; women are. Are these size zero's shrinking to be as male-like in their figure so that all the women in the world will think they're attractive?

    For example, now that our brains are cognitive and humans are essentially more attracted to personality for a mate than the size of their hips or chest- are women now confused about what they should look like now that what makes us attractive has changed?

    Hmmmm... i wonder...:confused::confused::confused:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 443 ✭✭valery


    LauraLoo wrote: »
    Here is a theory ive been thinking about for some time:

    Man are naturally square shaped- flat chested and straight down with no curve to the hips. Heterosexual women are instinctively attracted to the square shape of the male species.
    Women are naturally round shaped- round chested, round hips, round bottom. Heterosexual men are instinctively attracted to the round shape of the female species.

    Alot of the women on here are saying that they are continiously comparing themselves to other women. It seems a womans body image issues could stem from judgement recieved from other women/women targeted media/womens magazines etc

    Although we have a coherence that separates us from the rest of the animal kingdom- we are essentially animals.

    In the wild- the female will try to mate with a man thats as high up in the pack as possibel (i.e the best provider). Men will try to mate with the most fertile female to re-produce. (the most "attractive"- this is where "child bearing hips" comes from as apparently the wider the hips, the more fertile one is)

    In the wild, women have to compete for the alpha male. It is within our nature to be competitive with each other. But society has changed where technically we no longer have to compete because we no longer run in a pack. But our nature cannot change over night, so women are still competing. (similar to how men front each other and act like the tough guy)

    Do you think the obsession with being "skinny" is women trying to be attractive to other women, in the sense that we are worrying what other women are thinking about us? Has our nature to compete for a male become a bit twisted because we no longer have to compete for a male but still continue to have the instinct of competition?

    Look at the size zero fiasco. These women are on the cover of womens magazines- men are not buying these magazines; women are. Are these size zero's shrinking to be as male-like in their figure so that all the women in the world will think they're attractive?

    For example, now that our brains are cognitive and humans are essentially more attracted to personality for a mate than the size of their hips or chest- are women now confused about what they should look like now that what makes us attractive has changed?

    Hmmmm... i wonder...:confused::confused::confused:



    laura Loo, what your saying there is fantastic and so true. I could not agree with you more. I would go as far as saying there is an abuse of women today on that theme. competing with one another for a guy is one thing but when fashion trends are used almost as a weapon and a large number of women are terribly effected by same it annoys me /sorry, ENRAGES me !!!!. I am reading off the same page as you but could never share same as eloquently and as informatively as you. please keep opining re. same as life is about enjoy, not wall to wall competition. fair play to you and i hope you dont think Im a nutter , I just feel so strongly re. what you said. :)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 18,150 ✭✭✭✭Malari


    LauraLoo wrote: »
    In the wild- the female will try to mate with a man thats as high up in the pack as possibel (i.e the best provider). Men will try to mate with the most fertile female to re-produce. (the most "attractive"- this is where "child bearing hips" comes from as apparently the wider the hips, the more fertile one is)

    In the wild, women have to compete for the alpha male. It is within our nature to be competitive with each other. But society has changed where technically we no longer have to compete because we no longer run in a pack. But our nature cannot change over night, so women are still competing. (similar to how men front each other and act like the tough guy)

    Unfortunately, it's not that simple for humans though! There is pair-bonding with occasional polygamy so there's still competition but also great potential for cheating by men and cuckoldry by women.
    LauraLoo wrote: »
    Do you think the obsession with being "skinny" is women trying to be attractive to other women, in the sense that we are worrying what other women are thinking about us? Has our nature to compete for a male become a bit twisted because we no longer have to compete for a male but still continue to have the instinct of competition?

    I think it probably is a symbol of status. If you are thin in a world full of plenty of food then maybe it is an indicator that you are healthy. Or manage your lifestyle. Then, as long as it is found attractive by the majority, sexual selection will continue the trend. Over-simplified, but in a nutshell.
    LauraLoo wrote: »
    Look at the size zero fiasco. These women are on the cover of womens magazines- men are not buying these magazines; women are. Are these size zero's shrinking to be as male-like in their figure so that all the women in the world will think they're attractive?

    For example, now that our brains are cognitive and humans are essentially more attracted to personality for a mate than the size of their hips or chest- are women now confused about what they should look like now that what makes us attractive has changed?

    Hmmmm... i wonder...:confused::confused::confused:

    I don't think so, because it's not something that's conscious and also for natural selection to work, it doesn't really matter what other women think. Size zero is probably best explained by out-of-control sexual selection in one direction. I don't know, but there are LOTS of theories out there. It's an interesting topic.


Advertisement