Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Seriously - Will The Irish Public Please cop The Hell On!

1356

Comments

  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 34,567 ✭✭✭✭Biggins


    Tellox wrote: »
    If the NAMA is passed, I'll be the first one chained up outside the Dail, starving away. If anyone would like to join me or bring me some water...

    Seriously, if your willing to do that, let me know. I will join you.
    I mean it.
    I can't starve myself (due to a non-curable sick child) but protest along with you I will, in chains or not!

    At my own cost, I'll hand out the self created leaflets of why the action is taking place.
    Won't be the first time I've done similar.

    As it is, I'm currently constructing video and related information for a youtube channel set-up.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 267 ✭✭waitinforatrain


    NOthing short of a national strike will get them to call a general election.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,680 ✭✭✭Tellox


    Biggins wrote: »
    Seriously, if your willing to do that, let me know. I will join you.
    I mean it.
    I can't starve myself (due to a non-curable sick child) but protest along with you I will, in chains or not!

    At my own cost, I'll hand out the self created leaflets of why the action is taking place.
    Won't be the first time I've done similar.

    As it is, I'm currently constructing video and related information for a youtube channel set-up.

    I'm deadly serious. Im in my early 20's, and in good health. I also have the constitutional right to protest - so thankfully, my job can't be taken from me, which would be my only major concern (most of my family are now redundant - which is my only commitment).

    I'm sorry to hear about your child - but even if I'm the only one starving, a few people around to keep an eye on me and even to encourage others would get me through it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 806 ✭✭✭bonzos


    As a matter of interest, who are the TD's that agreed to the pay cut? I will assume Brian's Cowen and Lenihan are two of them. I think Enda Kenny is another. Anyone know the rest?
    Gilmore didnt take a cut as far as i know he "didnt get around to it yet"did you ever hear such BS....maybe JOD took a cut:rolleyes:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,558 ✭✭✭netwhizkid


    The Taoiseach will be in Killarney from 11 to 1 on Saturday if any boardsie want to meet him. I will be meeting him myself.


  • Moderators, Music Moderators Posts: 35,945 Mod ✭✭✭✭dr.bollocko


    skelliser wrote: »
    i opened a new thread highlighting saturdays no to nama march
    Rojomcdojo wrote: »
    Wow that was closed fast. God forbid if you'd want to advertise a protest against the biggest robbery of the Irish State to date, it would warrant being posted on the busiest forum on boards.... :rolleyes:
    skelliser wrote: »
    if its put in the politics forum a lesser audience will see it plus the vast majority of posters there would be well aware of the protest anyway, so id just be wasting my time.
    AH is the best place for it. more will see it and go off and investigate a learn about nama and then make there minds up.

    This is the most important decision this country has ever faced.

    I think that THE little issue of irelands image and future economic solvency warrants a disscusion in AH

    1. The thread was briefly locked while discussing what to do with it.
    2. The thread is now open on the politics forum
    http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=2055678416
    with an active redirect from AH which I bumped to take it to the top of AH before the move.
    3. It is best placed in the politics forum.
    4. If it's kept here or stickied it shows a mod bias the yes to NAMA people wouldn't be too happy about.
    5. If you have a problem with my moderation here then use helpdesk from now on. I have tried to PM everyone and anyone involved to explain the process and opened a discussion with all the mods on this. The thread is open on the politics forum. I just linked to it right there. Posting in AH just to reach a larger audience is contra-indicated. Please pm me for any clarification on this as I will not be entertaining any further discussion on that thread or it's fate on here.


    OK. That's the mod bit over.

    I'm not a goddamned economist and I don't know what's best for this country. I've heard "It's our only hope." I've heard "It'll sink the country forever."
    Every time somebody explains it to me I just think of all of those ads on TV asking you to "consolidate all your existing debts into one easy to pay loan".
    But what do I know. I'm an AH mod. I like puns and hating bono.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,477 ✭✭✭Riddle101


    Unfortuantely the only alternative we have to to stage a huge protest that will shake the goverment. But that won't work because the goverment have proven in the past the protests are meaningless. Unless of course you stage a coup, but then we'll have to find a leader worthy to put in charge of the country.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3 TAKAWAKA


    IF THE GREEN,S HAVE THERE WAY WE WILL BE PAYING 20 EURO FOR A ****ING LITRE OF PETROL .FAGS WILL BE ILLEGAL AND WE WILL ALL GET THE JAIL FOR STEAM COMMING OFF OF OUR PISS.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 110 ✭✭shaca


    Such a shower of money grabbing s**t talkers the lot of them. Trying to convince people they know what they are doing and to trust them. Look at their "centre of excellence" hospitals - my aunt started radium treatment this week, has to travel 2 hours to get there for 10 minute treatment. Can't take the bus there and doesn't drive so has to try and organise lifts 5 days a week for 7 weeks. (definately can't afford €600 for a taxi) Told today not to bother coming tomorrow cos the macine is broke. They are playing with our lifes here. How would they feel if it was a member of their family. I'm all for us getting us out on the streets in every major town and city in the country.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,378 ✭✭✭Borneo Fnctn


    netwhizkid wrote: »
    The Taoiseach will be in Killarney from 11 to 1 on Saturday if any boardsie want to meet him. I will be meeting him myself.

    I can't make it but do me a favour yeah? Tie a good tight knot around his neck. I'll explain another time.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,355 ✭✭✭dyl10


    This thread has me riled up.
    Anyone know of any no-confidence marches coming up?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 37 REAL LIFE HOOD


    Nothing will be changed because the first thing the Irish do is look to emmigration. Other nations have more pride in their country and wouldn't tolerate this ****!!!!!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11,221 ✭✭✭✭m5ex9oqjawdg2i


    What exactly are we to do biggins? We could have a protest... yet I bet it would do absolutely nothing... I am all for change, getting these pr1cks out of power and putting somebody/party in power that is not interested in running the country into the ground to benifit himself and his horsey friends, or his mate that's ceo of a major bank, etc etc. The government will more than likely ignore the 1-2 thousand people who would march on the dail. They would basically laugh, then make up some legislation that would make it illegal.

    France does a great job of making themselves heard... riot. A mass riot in dublin city, ransack the dail and make a hames of the place. I would like to see that ;)

    So what exactly can we do? I would love to run in the elections, but how the hell would you do that? I would go in with great intensions... but it just wouldn't work. Too many corrupt officials would oppose me. Too many powerful people would be against it. In their eyes, we do not matter... you see we do not invest heavily in what ever it is they own. We don't give them power. We are just pawns. It should be the other way around. They should be our bastard pawns.

    So, I would also like to see some sort of body to keep the government in check. Oh but there would be some legislation installed to keep government officials and TD's from investigation etc etc.

    Guys, our government don't care if we eat or not, they don't care about your sick children, they don't care about our tomorrows, they don't care about any one of us. We are not important to them, not in the slightest. So what exactly do we do? How do we remove them? How do we put somebody in power that will fight for us?

    There are no political party that I would like to see in power. We get to pick from a bunch of scum, money grabbing, back stabbing corrupt bastards. Who's the best? Any one of them parties will do the same thing, maybe more stealthily than our current government, but they are only there for themselves, their family and their super rich friends.

    Why is there an obese whore running our medical department? The overweight b1tch can't even look after her own health let alone 4.5 million people.

    Who lets somebody that says "I will run this country as I see fit" on national television, actually run our country? Who put this fat turd in power? Oh yea, that other greedy bastard.

    So what exactly are we going to do about it???

    What is this about NAMA, it is an offence to lobby against it? How does that work? Who does this law protect?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,745 ✭✭✭laugh


    If Fine Gael get into government they will have to, completely ignore what their base of farmers, nurses, teachers etc want, in order to get the country back to making money from outside.

    Does Enda Kenny have the balls to do that, **** no.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 168 ✭✭super_metroid


    i voted against fianna fail the last 3 elections

    fat lot of good that did


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,704 ✭✭✭squod


    Nolanger wrote: »
    We need a political party devoted to people instead of the environment.


    This is the quote of the century! Yesterday I heard Green TD, John Sh1thead, talking about Irelands' number one problem. Fukkin' climate change.

    A great insight into what's top of voters agenda!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,985 ✭✭✭skelliser


    well Tellox wants to go on a hunger strike outside the dail.

    I think for a mass protest say 150,000 people you will need to sit down and start with a plan and set a date, some saturday, the 26th of september or 3oct are the days imo
    like it or not your goin to need the unions on board. To get massive numbers you will need them.

    if anyone is thinking of organising something pm me im definitly willinging to get involved.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,985 ✭✭✭skelliser


    dyl10 wrote: »
    This thread has me riled up.
    Anyone know of any no-confidence marches coming up?

    the only marches coming up are the nama ones, there is three i believe, this saturday, wednesday and next saturday


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 206 ✭✭itsnotmyname


    perhaps the socialists among us need to think of the greater good ???
    we're in a sh**H**E..........and harsh decisions are needed !
    Robbin Hood cant get ANYONE out of this 1 !!!!.........


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,190 ✭✭✭✭IvySlayer


    Protesting isn't magically going to get answers/solutions. It'll take persistance.

    Remember 120, 000 people marching in Dublin on Feb 21st? Result?

    Wow, great jobs, one march.

    The only way the government will start taking us seriously is if we arrange weekly marches, walk out of work etc etc until the government is forced to call a general election.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,985 ✭✭✭skelliser


    well it worked with the pensioner medical card debacle, they made a sharpish u-turn on that!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,190 ✭✭✭✭IvySlayer


    skelliser wrote: »
    well it worked with the pensioner medical card debacle, they made a sharpish u-turn on that!

    Back benchers had a lot to do with that, it did work. But I think there's a major difference between the medical card and telling the government to quit.

    Imagine a few thousand people standing/sleeping/living outside the Dail until they called a general election. I bet most people would support them. Maybe a couple more thousand will join.

    International media would then come in, advertising more support.

    Maybe the government would cave.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,119 ✭✭✭Wagon


    Biggins wrote: »
    It was nothing. ONLY 5 now have volunteered to take a 10% cut.
    The rest have declined quietly. Thats 140+ TD's that are currently stll milking the gravy train while telling everyone else in the state to tighten their own belts!

    Ireland - WAKE THE FCUK UP!!!
    Well suggest something rather than shouting out of your fúcking monitor will you!!? i hate this government and the corruption as much as the next petrson but i dont have any bloody idea how to go about getting these things changed!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 914 ✭✭✭tommyboy2222


    When the fcuk will the bony arsed, lazy, dumb sheep of this country start to see the morally corrupt shower that is running/ruining this country and when are we going to finally get rid of them!

    When they call a general election.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,045 ✭✭✭Húrin


    Biggins wrote: »
    Well if you also including me in that section, you can count me out!
    I got up off my arse and is trying to waken the public!
    Whats more, as a protest action, I WILL be running in the next election as a protest INDEPENDENT canidate.

    Unitedpeople.ie IS my site and "no" to the government - I won't shut the fcuk up!

    Greetings fellow activist. I looked at your website. Are you a political party, NGO or pressure group?

    What are your plans for action? Would you be up for civil disobedience to get the gov's attention at this point?
    Dean09 wrote: »
    The thing that really pisses me off is everyone moans and groans in this country but does nothing about it (me included).

    Some of us do things about it. This summer I and a dozen others organised Climate Camp to expose and stop the the government's inaction in the face of climate change. Their bog-cutting policy in the Midlands may have been a good idea back in the 60s but now it is not in our interests at all.

    How on earth can it cost €10 million to build a 7km bike path?
    Nolanger wrote: »
    We need a political party devoted to people instead of the environment.

    Bicycle lanes are for people. Who knows what kind of sub-humans are getting the unjustifiable cost of building it though?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,985 ✭✭✭skelliser


    na man the sight of 20,000 pensioner outside the dail was the major factor, this is by and large seasoned ff voting country demographic.
    A big no no group to piss off, what ever about of other demographics pensioners/old people are consistantly the highest demograph that vote. Annoy them and its political suicide.

    If 150,000 people showed up at the dail thats serious pressure, the greens would walk


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 206 ✭✭itsnotmyname


    omg .........this thread make's me think that FF at least has a legit plan .......


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,019 ✭✭✭carlmango11


    Just looking at these forums shows how many people want change. I for one would be 100% prepared for any protests people would organize. Just tell me the date and I'll drag my whole family who have been complaining about the Government every day for the last 6 months :D

    Just throwing that out there :pac:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,985 ✭✭✭skelliser


    well ive been in contact with 2 people so far via pm here about starting something, also a few over in p.ie

    need loads more to organise a protest, like reps in every single town and city etc.
    a mass movement like


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,145 ✭✭✭DonkeyStyle \o/


    Biggins wrote: »
    The government TD's refuse so much to take ANY form of pay cuts AT ALL or enact anything that will effect their UN-vouched, gravy train expenses scandal.
    One of the many "tough decisions" they're making I'm sure.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,440 ✭✭✭✭Piste


    Biggins wrote: »
    The point of my speaking up here is when or what does it take for the public to get their backsides finally into gear and motivated enough to get themselves out to the streets in protest!

    Again seriously, what will it take? What will be for most the breaking point because by god, if I knew what it was, I'd wish it would come soon!

    When enough people are affected. Really the best thing for this country would be if the government announced ridiculous schemes all at once, like full college fees (the same value that non-EU students pay- 45K a year or so) + slashed dole + no medical cards + taxes on kittens or whatever you're having yourself. There'd be immediate uproar and hopefully we'd have kicked the government out before any of the schemes could be implemented.

    Bam, sorted.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,619 ✭✭✭Bob_Harris


    Húrin wrote: »
    Some of us do things about it. This summer I and a dozen others organised Climate Camp to expose and stop the the government's inaction in the face of climate change. Their bog-cutting policy in the Midlands may have been a good idea back in the 60s but now it is not in our interests at all.

    You do realise there is no concrete evidence of man made climate change, and this current shift in temperatures is a natural fluctuation of an ever changing climate?

    But hey, I bet you feel all important and profound setting up your climate camp, with this great battle you have against the pure evil of climate.

    I'd like to personally thank you, and people like you, for the carbon tax which we will see shortly. A tax which will effectively increase the price of all products and services. Cheers.

    Lets say for a second that carbon dioxide (a minor greenhouse gas) is indeed the cause of climate change (or is it Global Warming? - whatever happened the hole in the o-zone layer btw?) do you think anything you do here in Ireland will have any positive effect on the world when other nations are pumping out uncountable multiples of what we are?

    Is it just that your life is empty and you feel the need to partake in this "great battle" against climate change?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,985 ✭✭✭skelliser


    regardless of climate change, the burning of peat is the most ineffiecient waste of time ever.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 16,391 ✭✭✭✭mikom


    skelliser wrote: »
    ineffiecient waste of time

    Does not compute.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 97 ✭✭OnTheBalls


    I will be at the front of the nama protest tomorrow hopefully! To be honest this country needs some civil unrest to get people off there holes. I hate the way the Irish have opinions on everything and act on nothing. The nation is a laughing stock and full of sheep.

    I cannot for the life of me stomach bailing out property developers for gambling. It's insane that most of the people in this country don't care. If this happens I am emigrating. I am 21 years old and wondering who the **** the government are going to sell these houses to when they recover in value. Do they actually think property will ever be what it was again? I definately hope my peers are not sheep coting for the people their parents vote for. The Irish obsession with houses. I'm renting for the rest of my life. Probably will be living in Germany by then anyway. I am not leaving to college to get a job bailing out scum bag property investors who are thick as ****. **** that.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,943 ✭✭✭abouttobebanned


    Great post OP.

    A fine, collective example of this Ireland you are talking about could be found in an Irish studio last Friday night. The audience clapped when Tubridy grilled cowen, but then they clapped at a lot of Cowen's answers...I was perplexed as to how a group of people could change their minds so often in the space of such a short period of time. The answers of course is that the Irish public is as easily led as a jack russell with his eye on a sausage. They were easily led on voting no to lisbon, and now they're going to be easily led on voting yes. It's not hard for a government to pull the wool over these kind of eyes.

    People complain about those who don't vote - oh you have to use your vote, that's what our great grandparents died for etc...Nonsense. More people, in my opinion, should stay the fcuk away from polling booths, because they haven't got a clue what they are voting for and are making a mockery of our country.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 909 ✭✭✭Captain Furball


    Mrmoe wrote: »
    The only way legally and morally that we can bring about change in this country is through the ballot box. We are better off keeping our heads down and waiting in the long grasses, ready to strike the next opportunity we get to vote. For some the next chance will be a general election for others it will be the Lisbon referendum. The most important thing each and every person can do is vote. So the next time there is an election and we vote in the next shower of b@stards with a 50% turnout I won't be placing the blame at the politicians or the people who voted for them, but the remaining 50% of people who did not even bother to get off their asses to vote. If you want change vote for it and if it doesn't happen then suck it up because thats democracy. Protests are all well and good but that energy should be used to get people out to vote on polling day because that is when it really counts.

    Every sh!thead up there is the same you vote for the same sh!theads with the same sh!ty policies.The system is the problem.
    Greedy fkcss


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 909 ✭✭✭Captain Furball


    OnTheBalls wrote: »
    I will be at the front of the nama protest tomorrow hopefully! To be honest this country needs some civil unrest to get people off there holes. I hate the way the Irish have opinions on everything and act on nothing. The nation is a laughing stock and full of sheep.

    I cannot for the life of me stomach bailing out property developers for gambling. It's insane that most of the people in this country don't care. If this happens I am emigrating. I am 21 years old and wondering who the **** the government are going to sell these houses to when they recover in value. Do they actually think property will ever be what it was again? I definately hope my peers are not sheep coting for the people their parents vote for. The Irish obsession with houses. I'm renting for the rest of my life. Probably will be living in Germany by then anyway. I am not leaving to college to get a job bailing out scum bag property investors who are thick as ****. **** that.

    Your better off. Your kids will be paying for it anyway, so why bother getting them to pay for the houses?
    People are like cows the more the better more tax etc etc it's all one big farm..........


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    People complain about those who don't vote - oh you have to use your vote, that's what our great grandparents died for etc...Nonsense. More people, in my opinion, should stay the fcuk away from polling booths, because they haven't got a clue what they are voting for and are making a mockery of our country.

    They should literally have this written above the door when you go into vote. Well f'ing said!


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 34,567 ✭✭✭✭Biggins


    Originally Posted by Biggins
    Well if you also including me in that section, you can count me out!
    I got up off my arse and is trying to waken the public!
    Whats more, as a protest action, I WILL be running in the next election as a protest INDEPENDENT canidate.

    Unitedpeople.ie IS my site and "no" to the government - I won't shut the fcuk up!
    Húrin wrote: »
    Greetings fellow activist. I looked at your website. Are you a political party, NGO or pressure group?

    For the record.
    I am a married husband with 4 children.
    I have no political affiliations with ANY party, NGO or political motivated movement.
    I do help a few concerned parents to further fund and publicise the need for more support/equipment for the nurses and ground doctors for Crumlin Hospital in their specialist Cancer/Scoliosis/Leukaemia sections.
    I am a pissed off person seeing what is (I think) wrong and although I am 100% willing to accept some of the pain to my bank account to get things back right in this country, I (and my wife) is not willing to sit idly by and let the rest of the nation suffer, be degraded, made a fool of, treated like dumb sheep, to be laughed at by money grabbing, intimidating thugs elected to the Dail!

    Unitedpeople.ie is not about trying to score points directly against FF.
    As can be read, many of the items apply to all TD's that are so out of touch on all sides and morally corrupt that if we tried to make this stuff up and stick it in a novel, a critic reviewing it would claim that it was too unreal!

    I, myself hope to be running (independent protest) in the next election - ONLY to remind the buggers that we, the people will not "go quietly into the night" and just accept any old crap they dish out (but unwilling to accept themselves of).
    - If by some crazy miracle (I'm realistic about my chances), I was to even get somewhere with votes - I've said this before and I will say it again - 40% to 50% of my wages from such an elected position would/will be donated to 2 places.
    1. The Dublin nationally used Rape Crises Centre
    2. Crumlin Childrens Hospital.

    No if's, no buts.
    My daily agenda (listed by the hour) would be totally open to the public to show EXACTLY what the hell I was up to in my daily role of public service.
    Complete transparency would be not a problem for me.

    ...and thats me in a nutshell. Like everyone else that is working away or unemployed, paying their taxes, with/without kids, etc.
    I'm a pissed off person that sees what I feel inside is wrong and so fcuking angry at what others are blatantly getting away with that I won't shut the hell up about it and go away quietly!

    This country needs a new direction, a new moral compass to re-direct itself on a straighter, decent, honest and open path, a new group of people that should without question see running a state, as a vocation and a national honour - not a money grabbing exercise and not just a job position to pass down like from father to son!

    We should have political parties and individual persons with enough balls, that are willing to say:
    - If you as an individual, accept "donations" from businesses, private individuals etc and don't disclose such payments - YOUR OUT!
    - If your unwilling to accept the same measures as the rest of the country is being asked to accept - YOUR OUT!
    - If your unwilling to give up the 5 star hotels, the limo lifts, the junkets, the unvouched expenses, etc - YOUR OUT!

    NO IF'S - No BUT'S

    What we have at the moment in the Dail is a sick joke - and because of them, the rest of Ireland, YOUR nation, is dying on its landbed!
    * Dying in their hospital bed (if they are luck to get one)
    * Dying in their home beds because the money that is out there is being mis-directed to bike roads! (again, on average 78 lives a year could be saved by funding the inoculations. Thats 78 families that shouldn't have to be devastated a year with the loss of a loved one!)
    * Dying in streets due to lack of homes, available affordable drugs, and warmth (no money for the heat bills).
    * Dying victims of crime who get less proper treatment by the courts than the criminals, who's more rights they are concerned about!
    Its goes on and on... Its sickening!

    Enough is fcuking enough! No more!

    Wake up Ireland, wake the fcuk up!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,850 ✭✭✭Cianos


    While I completely understand the frustration, I don't think improving bike lanes is a waste of money at all. Dublin infrastructure needs to be greatly improved. A better infrastructure means a much more efficient economy which means more money for health care in the long run.

    Throwing money at things does not change anything in the long run. It's usually a short sighted solution..."there's a problem in X"..."give it more money and the problem will be solved". No, the problem won't be solved. Unless the system is working correctly, the problem will just raise it's head again.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 34,567 ✭✭✭✭Biggins


    Cianos wrote: »
    ...Dublin infrastructure needs to be greatly improved. A better infrastructure means a much more efficient economy which means more money for health care in the long run...

    I do 100% agree with you there on that point.

    So it would have been better to presently spend 10 million on roads if they had to, that carry produced goods, the public in their cars/vans, firepersons, Garda and ambulance services to where they need to go in order to help keep alive the economy and the people of this country.
    But for a 7km bike track costing 10 million Euro, (and here is the hypocrisy) which they say they cannot find(!) right now for clearly more vital services - when as they are claiming, money is short in the country - is amazing and also an insult to our intelligence!
    To simplfy:
    At the present time if you only have "X" amount of money in your pocket and you either need new drugs to save lives for a whole generation or need a bike track (which doesn't lead to the loss of average 78 lives a year), which would you buy for your family and nation?

    Which should you buy first and get to the rest later when possible?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 588 ✭✭✭Hauk


    Biggins, I must say, I commend your enthusiasm and focus.

    I agree with everything you say, and good luck! :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 13,615 ✭✭✭✭ArmaniJeanss


    Biggins wrote: »
    I do 100% agree with you there on that point.

    So it would have been better to presently spend 10 million on roads if they had to, that carry produced goods, the public in their cars/vans, firepersons, Garda and ambulance services to where they need to go in order to help keep alive the economy and the people of this country.
    But for a 7km bike track costing 10 million Euro, (and here is the hypocrisy) which they say they cannot find(!) right now for clearly more vital services - when as they are claiming, money is short in the country - is amazing and also an insult to our intelligence!
    To simplfy:
    At the present time if you only have "X" amount of money in your pocket and you either need new drugs to save lives for a whole generation or need a bike track (which doesn't lead to the loss of average 78 lives a year), which would you buy for your family and nation?

    Which should you buy first and get to the rest later when possible?

    The €10 million for the cycle lane is over ~8 years. Whereas the €10 million for the vaccine is every year. So its not a case of the latter could pay for the former.
    So you are every bit as guilty as the politicians you despise when it comes to manipulation of figures.

    A certain percentage of the cost of the cycle lane will be recouped every year as it encourages more people to cycle. This amount is not easily quantifiable in advance, but hopefully it will pay for itself eventually.

    Finally your logic that because bicycle lanes havn't been built before, that if we had to spend €10m on transport that it should be spent on better roads for gardai, ambulance drivers, cars and vans is a really bizarre bit of logic.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,850 ✭✭✭Cianos


    Biggins wrote: »
    I do 100% agree with you there on that point.

    So it would have been better to presently spend 10 million on roads if they had to, that carry produced goods, the public in their cars/vans, firepersons, Garda and ambulance services to where they need to go in order to help keep alive the economy and the people of this country.

    A greatly improved system of cycle lanes would encourage a lot more people to cycle. More bikes on the road means less cars on the road. Less cars means less traffic, meaning police cars and ambulances can get through the city a lot faster. 10 million going towards "road maintenance" would just disappear down the void along with all the other millions that have been thrown at it. Hence my point, that throwing money at things to solve problems is usually just a waste...money is not a problem solver, it is a tool. It is ideas and innovation that solve problems, not money.
    At the present time if you only have "X" amount of money in your pocket and you either need new drugs to save lives for a whole generation or need a bike track (which doesn't lead to the loss of average 78 lives a year), which would you buy for your family and nation?

    Which should you buy first and get to the rest later when possible?

    I'm not disagreeing with you that money is mismanaged. It's not like that €10m is the last €10m the government has. If it was the last €10m left in the country then your question would be worth answering. Because while you think the €10m that is going on the bike lane should go to hospitals, everyone else has their idea on what it should go to. Again, I'm not disagreeing with you that money is mismanaged. What I'm saying is that we need to get away from the simplified opinion that money solves problems.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 649 ✭✭✭Catenaccio!


    We need an AH sort of character to get things back on track, and I ain't talking about After Hours.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11,221 ✭✭✭✭m5ex9oqjawdg2i


    skelliser wrote: »
    well Tellox wants to go on a hunger strike outside the dail.

    I think for a mass protest say 150,000 people you will need to sit down and start with a plan and set a date, some saturday, the 26th of september or 3oct are the days imo
    like it or not your goin to need the unions on board. To get massive numbers you will need them.

    if anyone is thinking of organising something pm me im definitly willinging to get involved.

    Don't need the unions, not exactly. We don't need their permission to protest. The unions are very much like the bankers imo.
    Piste wrote: »
    When enough people are affected. Really the best thing for this country would be if the government announced ridiculous schemes all at once, like full college fees (the same value that non-EU students pay- 45K a year or so) + slashed dole + no medical cards + taxes on kittens or whatever you're having yourself. There'd be immediate uproar and hopefully we'd have kicked the government out before any of the schemes could be implemented.

    Bam, sorted.

    Where do you get the 45K from? This must be at the very very top end of the scale and is very very misleading. The average is only a fraction of that for non-EU students.
    Great post OP.

    A fine, collective example of this Ireland you are talking about could be found in an Irish studio last Friday night. The audience clapped when Tubridy grilled cowen, but then they clapped at a lot of Cowen's answers...I was perplexed as to how a group of people could change their minds so often in the space of such a short period of time. The answers of course is that the Irish public is as easily led as a jack russell with his eye on a sausage. They were easily led on voting no to lisbon, and now they're going to be easily led on voting yes. It's not hard for a government to pull the wool over these kind of eyes.

    People complain about those who don't vote - oh you have to use your vote, that's what our great grandparents died for etc...Nonsense. More people, in my opinion, should stay the fcuk away from polling booths, because they haven't got a clue what they are voting for and are making a mockery of our country.

    Did you see the same people clapping? My wild guess would be that the audience had anti cowens as well as pro cowens. ;)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,943 ✭✭✭abouttobebanned


    Don't need the unions, not exactly. We don't need their permission to protest. The unions are very much like the bankers imo.



    Where do you get the 45K from? This must be at the very very top end of the scale and is very very misleading. The average is only a fraction of that for non-EU students.



    Did you see the same people clapping? My wild guess would be that the audience had anti cowens as well as pro cowens. ;)

    I made a point of watching closely....it was the same people ;)


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 34,567 ✭✭✭✭Biggins


    The €10 million for the cycle lane is over ~8 years. Whereas the €10 million for the vaccine is every year. So its not a case of the latter could pay for the former.
    So you are every bit as guilty as the politicians you despise when it comes to manipulation of figures.

    A certain percentage of the cost of the cycle lane will be recouped every year as it encourages more people to cycle. This amount is not easily quantifiable in advance, but hopefully it will pay for itself eventually.

    Finally your logic that because bicycle lanes haven't been built before, that if we had to spend €10m on transport that it should be spent on better roads for gardai, ambulance drivers, cars and vans is a really bizarre bit of logic.

    Again, try to look at it this way. 10 million over eight years is 1.25 million a year.
    Now you have hundreds per year (that were not inoculated) that is going to get cervical cancer so for the rest of their time living in the state and assuming that some actual survive for lenghty periods - each one of those is going to need further on going continuous medical health care (per year). That means doctors, nurses, use of equipment, operations(?), drugs (not cheap!) and everything else that is going to be needed to try and keep them alive for their loved ones. What does all that cost the state per year, for not clearly taking a cheaper option in the long run for all concerned?

    Now which works out the cheapest in the long run? Inoculate now and for this year alone and for possibly for subsequent years till the rest of their normal lives, save the state millions in each case for each person from the above subsequent medical costs!

    You make your point and its a good one.
    Its hypocritical and insulting by FF however to claim on every piece of the media that "we cannot find 10 million Euro" for emergency/specialised services/etc then a short while later say "O' well we do now have 10 million Euro for a 7km bike track instead"!
    Thats just plain disgusting in any language.

    Cianos wrote: »
    ...What I'm saying is that we need to get away from the simplified opinion that money solves problems.

    Long story short, I agree with you
    - but what little money we do have, should be now spent in the right direction to stop further what WILL be increasing costs later on put on the state and thus the tax payer - you - as the subsequent medical costs of those not treated early enough, will progressively get larger and thus pull the state into further national debt.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,692 ✭✭✭Dublin_Gunner


    First off, great post Biggins :)

    Secondly, would people please stop and think first, before they start criticising the set up of NAMA and the bank bail outs?? Seriously, where are people going to get their car loans, house loans etc if the countries banking system failed. The Credit Union? :rolleyes:

    Anyway, thats about the only thing I'm going to state against the general consensus of this thread.

    We NEED to take action. We NEED to rally. We NEED to march. We NEED to enact change.

    We're all too comfortable sitting here in front of our computers typing about how passionate we are about this sort of thing, when what we need to do, is march, with as much of the population as possible to the doors of the Dail, break down the effing doors, and pull these muppets out by the scruff of their necks.

    I for one think we SHOULD organise a march, a country wide march, on the day of the Lisbon vote.

    If anything is going to get attention, is would be disrupting the vote they are using to sway our attention away from what really matters, Ireland, US.

    Sure, we need Europe, we all bloody know that. But we need Europe whilst having a competent government in place.

    The main problem I see with this would be - who do we put in power??

    How about - an accountant as head of finance, a doctor as head of health & children, a general as head of defence etc etc ya know, people who are actually relevant to the positions they hold.

    Our government / country NEEDS to be run as a business. People who are harsh, willing to make tough calls, and willing to put procedure and policy in place that is beneficial to the country in the long run, NOT to the government themselves in the short run, in order to keep their ridiculously inflated wages.

    Grr.


Advertisement