Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Norway and the EU

Options
  • 29-09-2009 12:23am
    #1
    Registered Users Posts: 23,641 ✭✭✭✭


    Just thought it would be interesting to read a different perspective on Europe

    Party | Pos. | Main argument as stated on party websites
    Socialist Left Party| no | Lack of democracy; too much focus on liberal trade.
    Norwegian Labour Party| yes| Cooperation; influence in EU decisions.
    Centre Party | no| EU does not reduce economic differences, and does not strengthen democracy
    Christian People's Party| no| EEA is good enough, independence
    Liberal Party of Norway| Split | Party divided; EEA works; wants further coop. respects a referendum; not democratic enough yet
    Conservative Party| yes| Peace; stability; solidarity; influence
    Progress Party| Split | Will stay neutral; pledges to respect any referendum result


    Of course Norway and Ireland have different needs, and it isn't like we are voting to leave the EU and just be part of the EEA.

    Disclaimer: Table taken from Wiki so other source required but interesting to see different perspectives.


Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,484 ✭✭✭JIZZLORD


    Norway have enough oil money to keep themselves going in case of an emergency, and i believe fishing rights is another big issue for them. They're sufficiently cushioned from needing what we needed when we joined.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭ei.sdraob


    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norway_and_the_European_Union

    * As of 2005, Norway pays an annual fee of €240 million to the EU budget but it receives no EU expenditure

    not only do they have to pay for the privilege of trading with EU

    they have to implement all the laws while having NO say in them

    :eek:


    just some facts in case any NO supporters here decide to compare Ireland to Norway (again! while ignoring that Norway have a wealth of natural resources such as oil)

    /


  • Registered Users Posts: 23,641 ✭✭✭✭Elmo


    JIZZLORD wrote: »
    Norway have enough oil money to keep themselves going in case of an emergency, and i believe fishing rights is another big issue for them. They're sufficiently cushioned from needing what we needed when we joined.

    And fishing rights isn't a big issue for an Island nation :confused:. But as I said I do understand that Norway has Oil $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$


  • Registered Users Posts: 23,641 ✭✭✭✭Elmo


    ei.sdraob wrote: »
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norway_and_the_European_Union

    * As of 2005, Norway pays an annual fee of €240 million to the EU budget but it receives no EU expenditure

    not only do they have to pay for the privilege of trading with EU

    they have to implement all the laws while having NO say in them

    :eek:


    just some facts in case any NO supporters here decide to compare Ireland to Norway (again! while ignoring that Norway have a wealth of natural resources such as oil)

    /

    I was just point out some of the issues that Norway has with the EU. The Democracy thing stands out for me but then they are members of the EDA :eek:

    Not with comparing Ireland to Norway. As I said in my OP.

    Oh and you forgot to mention Fish as a natural resource, not that I am compare or anything. :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭ei.sdraob


    Elmo wrote: »
    And fishing rights isn't a big issue for an Island nation :confused:. But as I said I do understand that Norway has Oil

    ah yes i eagerly await for someone to quote 200-400 billion figure in lost fishing

    :D


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭ei.sdraob


    Elmo wrote: »
    I was just point out some of the issues that Norway has with the EU. The Democracy thing stands out for me but then they are members of the EDA :eek:

    Not with comparing Ireland to Norway. As I said in my OP.

    Oh and you forgot to mention Fish as a natural resource, not that I am compare or anything. :)

    Ireland is a member of EDA too

    we are spending 700,000 euro (yes thats the price of average Dublin home) over 3 years

    on a single research project into bulletproof technology for our soldiers in the field

    /


  • Registered Users Posts: 23,641 ✭✭✭✭Elmo


    ei.sdraob wrote: »
    Ireland is a member of EDA too

    we are spending 700,000 euro (yes thats the price of average Dublin home) over 3 years

    on a single research project into bulletproof technology for our soldiers in the field

    /

    Now put it in context that is the price the Ministers can use to get about the world on. :) When they need to save the would and now the want to waste a small amount of money on arms that we will prob never use.

    I would be great if that research was used help rescue workers and the RNLI etc. Hopeful some of that 700,000 will go their way.

    Price of an average house in Dublin 3 years ago you mean surely.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 301 ✭✭crocro


    Norway has €280bn saved in its sovereign fund. 3rd largest oil exporter in the world. 3rd largest gas exporter in the world. Massive coal reserves. Fish.

    Same population as Ireland.

    Despite all this, like Switzerland, they choose to comply with nearly all EU laws in order to trade freely with Europe - yet they have no vote in the formulation of those laws.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭ei.sdraob


    Elmo wrote: »
    Now put it in context that is the price the Ministers can use to get about the world on. :) When they need to save the would and now the want to waste a small amount of money on arms that we will prob never use.

    I would be great if that research was used help rescue workers and the RNLI etc. Hopeful some of that 700,000 will go their way.

    Price of an average house in Dublin 3 years ago you mean surely.

    if it saves the lives of our boys in Chad or whatever godforsaken part of the world they are in now

    then its money well spend



    i cant believe your arguing over 700k when the likes of FAS chief walk away with millions in ransom and the likes of Ganley spend as much on a campaign of misinformation and dont have to show where a cent came from


    and if you think Ireland is anything like Norway then you really need to get back down to the real world

    /


  • Registered Users Posts: 23,641 ✭✭✭✭Elmo


    ei.sdraob wrote: »
    if it saves the lives of our boys in Chad or whatever godforsaken part of the world they are in now

    then its money well spend



    i cant believe your arguing over 700k when the likes of FAS chief walk away with millions in ransom and the likes of Ganley spend as much on a campaign of misinformation and dont have to show where a cent came from


    and if you think Ireland is anything like Norway then you really need to get back down to the real world

    /


    John O'Donaghue and Roddy Molly and the rest of them thats is what I was talking about.

    You seem obsessed by Chad and yet you seem to have no interest in search and rescue and developments in such activities. I wonder if the EU are as good at use the savings to send the defense commissioner on junkets and 5 star hotels, they could care less about our lads in Chad or what ever other country they are in. Perhaps Mary Harney should be more involved in the EHA (European Health Agency) that could provide a quality Health services to all Europeans. I am sure the EU strives to provide quality Health and Research, and I support them in their efforts for that.

    Oh and again if you read my original post you would have seen that I was not comparing Ireland and Norway I was looking at their view on the EU.

    Again when Ireland has the guts to vote NO on Friday we will still be in the EU.

    EDA research and technology can be used by other European countries who plan wars with other nations.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭ei.sdraob


    Elmo wrote: »
    John O'Donaghue and Roddy Molly and the rest of them thats is what I was talking about.

    You seem obsessed by Chad and yet you seem to have no interest in search and rescue and developments in such activities. I wonder if the EU are as good at use the savings to send the defense commissioner on junkets and 5 star hotels, they could care less about our lads in Chad or what ever other country they are in.

    I dont know anything about search and rescue, they get plenty of money too from the government, btw RNLI are a charity, in case you didnt know the Irish government is still giving away a portion of our GDP to charities and aid

    so far im the one providing figures and facts and references here

    while you put more rubbish out and see if it sticks

    btw here is more facts and figures What's Europe Ever Done For Us?

    :(


  • Registered Users Posts: 23,641 ✭✭✭✭Elmo


    ei.sdraob wrote: »
    I dont know anything about search and rescue, they get plenty of money too from the government, btw RNLI are a charity, in case you didnt know the Irish government is still giving away a portion of our GDP to charities and aid

    so far im the one providing figures and facts and references here

    while you put more rubbish out and see if it sticks

    :(

    You should then be able to advice me if Search and Rescue and Health as important than the EDA. Personnel they are far more important.

    The first major problem I have is that the RNLI is a charity why isn't the government running it or giving it as much funding as the Army if not more, I suppose it saves them money for curtains and other sundries.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭ei.sdraob


    Elmo wrote: »
    You should then be able to advice me if Search and Rescue and Health as important than the EDA. Personnel they are far more important.

    The first major problem I have is that the RNLI is a charity why isn't the government running it or giving it as much funding as the Army if not more, I suppose it saves them money for curtains and other sundries.

    EDA research (700k) is part of our military spending

    that wouldn't even buy a tank btw

    do you have a problem with our defence forces?

    do you want our peace keepers to go into the field and do the jobs we ask them to do with substandard equipment that could cost their lives?

    why dont you pop into this forum and suggest what you did above, see how quickly they eat you for dinner

    btw why dont you go and readup on EDA, membership is not mandatory and countries can pull out, our Defence minister taught it be a good idea to spend 700,000 on bulletproof vests for our soldiers

    well i ****ing tell you thats a better use for my tax money that 54,000,000,000 that the Finance minister is giving to NAMA


    here straight from the horses mouth Jimmy Deenihan (Kerry North, Fine Gael) asking Willie O'Dea (Minister, Department of Defence; Limerick East, Fianna Fail) about Irelands involvement in the EDA

    :(
    :mad:


  • Registered Users Posts: 23,641 ✭✭✭✭Elmo


    ei.sdraob wrote: »
    EDA research (700k) is part of our military spending

    that wouldn't even buy a tank btw

    do you have a problem with our defence forces?

    do you want our peace keepers to go into the field and do the jobs we ask them to do with substandard equipment that could cost their lives?

    why dont you pop into this forum and suggest what you did above, see how quickly they eat you for dinner

    btw why dont you go and readup on EDA, membership is not mandatory and countries can pull out, our Defence minister taught it be a good idea to spend 700,000 on bulletproof vests for our soldiers

    well i ****ing tell you thats a better use for my tax money that 54,000,000,000 that the Finance minister is giving to NAMA


    here straight from the horses mouth Jimmy Deenihan (Kerry North, Fine Gael) asking Willie O'Dea (Minister, Department of Defence; Limerick East, Fianna Fail) about Irelands involvement in the EDA

    :(
    :mad:

    I have nothing against our peace keeping force or the UNs or the EU however I have a problem with the US and the UK going to war in Iraq for no real reason other than blind revenge. If these types of military actions take place with the use of the EDA then I have a problem, no problem with saving people lives and when I say saving peoples lives I mean the citizens of war torn countries, not the people sent out the save them (obivously they are important but their mission is the protection of innocent civilians and that can only be help with more spending in health, search and rescue research not in armaments). I think that is a fairly substantial view of what I think of the EDA in its current form I do not believe that it should be part of the treaty and it is part of the treaty. I know we are members but I even go as far as to say I disagree with that. Regardless of the cost, life is far more important than money or savings.

    Imagine how much Minister O'Dea could have spent on the Army and on search and rescue had those same ministers not mishandled our economy and our money on many many expensive sundries. You know I don't think much of FF or Willie O'Dea.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭ei.sdraob


    Elmo wrote: »
    I have nothing against our peace keeping force or the UNs or the EU however I have a problem with the US and the UK going to war in Iraq for no real reason other than blind revenge

    so do I

    and btw you might be shocked to find out that

    General. Richard Myers - one of the masterminds of the Iraq invasion, ex bush's chief of staff is a director in Declan Ganley's company along with other top brass and ex Bush buddies

    Yes the same guy who wants a United States of Europe

    and is the leading figurehead for the NO campaign

    whats say you now? keep that in mind if you decide to vote NO and dislike the Iraq war and the whole War of Terror business



    Elmo wrote: »
    If these types of military actions take place with the use of the EDA then I have a problem, no problem with saving people lives and when I say saving peoples lives I mean the citizens of war torn countries, not the people sent out the save them (obivously they are important but their mission is the protection of innocent civilians and that can only be help with more spending in health, search and rescue research not in armaments).

    why dont you go and please readup on what EDA is about, it is not NATO but an research institution


    Elmo wrote: »
    . I think that is a fairly substantial view of what I think of the EDA in its current form I do not believe that it should be part of the treaty and it is part of the treaty. I know we are members but I even go as far as to say I disagree with that. Regardless of the cost, life is far more important than money or savings.

    Ireland and any country can pull out of EDA at any time with or without Lisbon


    you have gone way of on a tangent because of complete lack of understanding about the subject your talking about

    please educate yourself, there are previous threads on EDA and Ireland here in this forum

    /


  • Registered Users Posts: 23,641 ✭✭✭✭Elmo


    ei.sdraob wrote: »
    so do I

    and btw you might be shocked to find out that

    General. Richard Myers - one of the masterminds of the Iraq invasion, ex bush's chief of staff is a director in Declan Ganley's company along with other top brass and ex Bush buddies

    Yes the same guy who wants a United States of Europe

    and is the leading figurehead for the NO campaign

    whats say you now? keep that in mind if you decide to vote NO and dislike the Iraw war







    why dont you go and please readup on what EDA is about, it is not NATO but an research institution





    Ireland and any country can pull out of EDA at any time with or without Lisbon


    you have gone way of on a tangent because of complete lack of understanding about the subject your talking about

    please educate yourself, there are previous threads on EDA and Ireland here in this forum

    /

    You might be surprised to hear that I don't listen to DG.

    Did I say anything about NATO??? NO keep on topic your putting words into my mouth.

    Ireland will never pull out of the EDA, our govs just don't do things like that.

    I have read up on the EDA which is a research institution into armaments, and is their to provide a e-tendering to European nations for armaments. I think it would be better to be a research institute into search and rescue and the an e-tendering platform for EU nations looking for equipment for such things.

    You will be surprised to find that the NO and YES have a wide range of people for and against the Lisbon Treaty. I am sure that FF and FG have a good relationship with the American Republican Party. (FF/FG are not that wide :( )


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭ei.sdraob


    Elmo wrote: »
    You might be surprised to hear that I don't listen to DG.

    good unfortunately many others do, and I will keep reminding people what a hypocrite he is (i hope hes no a member here :D ive collected enough infractions today :) )

    Elmo wrote: »
    Did I say anything about NATO??? NO keep on topic your putting words into my mouth.

    what you described earlier is fear of an organisation like NATO, something that EDA is not and never will be

    Elmo wrote: »
    Ireland will never pull out of the EDA, our govs just don't do things like that.

    then when the next election comes make sure to make fuss about it :)


    whether you vote YES or NO,

    EDA and Ireland's research project with it, will still be there


    EDA was founded under NICE from what I remember?


    /


  • Registered Users Posts: 23,641 ✭✭✭✭Elmo


    ei.sdraob wrote: »
    good unfortunately many others do, and I will keep reminding people what a hypocrite he is (i hope hes no a member here :D ive collected enough infractions today :) )

    what you described earlier is fear of an organisation like NATO, something that EDA is not and never will be

    then when the next election comes make sure to make fuss about it :)

    whether you vote YES or NO,

    EDA and Ireland's research project with it, will still be there

    EDA was founded under NICE from what I remember?

    Seriously most politican's are hypocrites, look ye have Mr. Ryanair on your side of the table :rolleyes:

    No I didn't I said that the UK could use armaments procured from the EDA in war, is this not the case as much as we can use them on peacekeeping missions.

    The next election won't change Ireland's position on the EDA since those parties who might be against will just go along with the ruling party. i.e. FG or FF.

    And if the EDA was formed under nice then guess what I voted NO.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭ei.sdraob


    Elmo wrote: »
    Seriously most politican's are hypocrites, look ye have Mr. Ryanair on your side of the table :rolleyes:

    MOL a politician :D hehehehe

    i think hes ashamed to call himself that

    and unlike Ganley he will step down as promised and keep his word

    /


  • Registered Users Posts: 23,641 ✭✭✭✭Elmo


    ei.sdraob wrote: »
    MOL a politician :D hehehehe

    i think hes ashamed to call himself that

    and unlike Ganley he will step down as promised and keep his word

    You know while I disagree with DG and am suspicious of him, he is allowed to speak out on these issue should he so wish. MOL is a complete asshole I have even less respect for him. His attitude of "Oh! you just want to be Dana" sorry MOL but guess what she actually was an MEP for this country.

    Anyway TBH its late and the Yes side will win on Friday and think it is brilliant. Perhaps this is why politicians don't listen.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,376 ✭✭✭ei.sdraob


    Elmo wrote: »
    You know while I disagree with DG and am suspicious of him, he is allowed to speak out on these issue should he so wish. MOL is a complete asshole I have even less respect for him. His attitude of "Oh! you just want to be Dana" sorry MOL but guess what she actually was an MEP for this country.

    Anyway TBH its late and the Yes side will win on Friday and think it is brilliant. Perhaps this is why politicians don't listen.

    <take a deep breath!>

    you know I agree with you :)

    i was disappointed by MOL performance

    a waste of space that was

    <yes this is one of them rare moments theres consensus in this forum>

    /


Advertisement