Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi all! We have been experiencing an issue on site where threads have been missing the latest postings. The platform host Vanilla are working on this issue. A workaround that has been used by some is to navigate back from 1 to 10+ pages to re-sync the thread and this will then show the latest posts. Thanks, Mike.
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest
Clare GAA discussion thread
Comments
-
^ another point on the sidelines, it was frustrating to see players standing up waiting for Duggan to have a go at slotting it over, nobody looking for space or a quick 1-2 for a much easier score.0
-
As a neutral watching the game I feel that the reason ye lost this game was a lack of leaders on the field, SOD excepted. Management are also too slow to react, don’t think ye would have lost this game had Davy Fitz been on the line.0
-
Join Date:Posts: 23225
As a neutral watching the game I feel that the reason ye lost this game was a lack of leaders on the field, SOD excepted. Management are also too slow to react, don’t think ye would have lost this game had Davy Fitz been on the line.
We wouldn't have gotten to a All Ireland semi final with Davys tactics0 -
^ another point on the sidelines, it was frustrating to see players standing up waiting for Duggan to have a go at slotting it over, nobody looking for space or a quick 1-2 for a much easier score.
Indeed. That's how Galway got their first point I think. Clare lads standing around waiting for Canning to have a go this time.0 -
As a neutral watching the game I feel that the reason ye lost this game was a lack of leaders on the field, SOD excepted. Management are also too slow to react, don’t think ye would have lost this game had Davy Fitz been on the line.
If Davy Fitz was on the line we would have been out of the Championship in May. He is toxic in Clare at this stage.0 -
As a neutral watching the game I feel that the reason ye lost this game was a lack of leaders on the field, SOD excepted. Management are also too slow to react, don’t think ye would have lost this game had Davy Fitz been on the line.
Watcching ther first half yesterday with a sweeper was a throw back to the horror days of davys era. Awfull hurling to watch. The clare fans prefer the hurling under new management, direct and physical.0 -
Usually before I make my comments on here, I watch the recording back. I think this was the first time I switched it off before half time. Honestly, I remember leaving Croke Park after the AI semi final in 2005 against Cork thinking I never experience such a heart breaking defeat. Daly said after the match that day the game will set back Clare hurling for years. At least with the loss yesterday, John Conlon is the only outfield player over 26 years old. I think we will be back next year. But for sure, we are going to have alot of regrets about yesterday, like we did in 2005. Yesterday was heart breaking.
Look, I'm reading back through the pages and I'm seeing alot of people pointing fingers at players, bemoaning missed chances, etc. Like people need to understand, hurling is an incredible emotional, fast-paced intense sport. We have to remember the conditions of the game yesterday, after the extra time played a few days ago and the heat yesterday, it was an incredibly difficult environment, with both teams making alot of mistakes. It was always going to be like this, players don't deliberately hit balls wide. I think they deserve some leeway in this regard.
The main reason we are not going to Dublin in a fortnight though is we don't have a proper balance across the park of players that can physically take on a team like Galway. When you only have one puckout option down the field, when you don't have enough players that can win their own ball, when you don't have enough players that can take and give a physical challenge, you leave yourself open to being starved of possession and quite litterly runover. And that's what Galway did in the opening 20 minutes of both games. Yesterday it was too much. I said it before the game we had to survive the opening half before the game loosened up and we didn't. I think we are probably short a midfielder and a half back to be honest, like if we want to single out players, Mannion and Canning were the only two players out of both team's 5-12 that hurled consistently well throughout the 160 odd minutes we played. Those two players were the difference between the sides imo.
I just want to finish up with two things.
First off, I know it's a tough loss to take, but we cannot forget the massive improvements and positives the team made throughout this season. From Touhy's rock solid year in goals to Conlon's amazing season there are loads of positives. Even just take Hayes coming on there. Lads no joke honestly, that poor kid must have spent well over an hour throughout the year, standing on the line with his helmet on ready to come in for his debut, only not to! And then for his first proper appearance (Wexford aside) he is tasked to man mark one of the best forwards in the game in an tight AI semi final. The kid did brilliantly. At the end of the day, we still have a young squad, but it's hugely important that we build on what has been a great year and learn from our mistakes. That's vitally important. Because this team can achieve something special.
Finally, I'm just very thankful for all the players and management efforts throughout the year. It was an amazing year really, Jamie Wall's tweet summed it up saying we were the width of a post between being knocked out by Tipp but also denied an AI final place. That's just the way this crazy game goes, but one thing I would never question is the team's honesty and heart. They died in their boots there yesterday. I think what makes me proud also, everyone is always talking about Clare's weak support, but yesterday there was a brilliant Clare support. I think this year we all saw and appreciated the work and commitment the players were bringing, I think there is a strong connection back between the players, management and supporters which is really important.
Very proud of everyone's effort. It hurts now but we will be back!
Up The Banner.0 -
Usually before I make my comments on here, I watch the recording back. I think this was the first time I switched it off before half time. Honestly, I remember leaving Croke Park after the AI semi final in 2005 against Cork thinking I never experience such a heart breaking defeat. Daly said after the match that day the game will set back Clare hurling for years. At least with the loss yesterday, John Conlon is the only outfield player over 26 years old. I think we will be back next year. But for sure, we are going to have alot of regrets about yesterday, like we did in 2005. Yesterday was heart breaking.
Look, I'm reading back through the pages and I'm seeing alot of people pointing fingers at players, bemoaning missed chances, etc. Like people need to understand, hurling is an incredible emotional, fast-paced intense sport. We have to remember the conditions of the game yesterday, after the extra time played a few days ago and the heat yesterday, it was an incredibly difficult environment, with both teams making alot of mistakes. It was always going to be like this, players don't deliberately hit balls wide. I think they deserve some leeway in this regard.
The main reason we are not going to Dublin in a fortnight though is we don't have a proper balance across the park of players that can physically take on a team like Galway. When you only have one puckout option down the field, when you don't have enough players that can win their own ball, when you don't have enough players that can take and give a physical challenge, you leave yourself open to being starved of possession and quite litterly runover. And that's what Galway did in the opening 20 minutes of both games. Yesterday it was too much. I said it before the game we had to survive the opening half before the game loosened up and we didn't. I think we are probably short a midfielder and a half back to be honest, like if we want to single out players, Mannion and Canning were the only two players out of both team's 5-12 that hurled consistently well throughout the 160 odd minutes we played. Those two players were the difference between the sides imo.
I just want to finish up with two things.
First off, I know it's a tough loss to take, but we cannot forget the massive improvements and positives the team made throughout this season. From Touhy's rock solid year in goals to Conlon's amazing season there are loads of positives. Even just take Hayes coming on there. Lads no joke honestly, that poor kid must have spent well over an hour throughout the year, standing on the line with his helmet on ready to come in for his debut, only not to! And then for his first proper appearance (Wexford aside) he is tasked to man mark one of the best forwards in the game in an tight AI semi final. The kid did brilliantly. At the end of the day, we still have a young squad, but it's hugely important that we build on what has been a great year and learn from our mistakes. That's vitally important. Because this team can achieve something special.
Finally, I'm just very thankful for all the players and management efforts throughout the year. It was an amazing year really, Jamie Wall's tweet summed it up saying we were the width of a post between being knocked out by Tipp but also denied an AI final place. That's just the way this crazy game goes, but one thing I would never question is the team's honesty and heart. They died in their boots there yesterday. I think what makes me proud also, everyone is always talking about Clare's weak support, but yesterday there was a brilliant Clare support. I think this year we all saw and appreciated the work and commitment the players were bringing, I think there is a strong connection back between the players, management and supporters which is really important.
Very proud of everyone's effort. It hurts now but we will be back!
Up The Banner.
Surely an all-Ireland a mere 5 years ago makes a loss like yesterday somewhat tolerable. Ye have hardly evolved a KK mind set just yet...?
Imagine the pain defeats like yesterday has for the Limericks and Waterford of this world...?0 -
Great post Letowski.
'If I ventured in the slipstream, Between the viaducts of your dream'
0 -
Advertisement
-
Imagine the pain defeats like yesterday has for the Limericks and Waterford of this world...?[/quote]
Throw Galway into that prior to last year. Galway had chances to put Kilkenny away in previous years and couldn't/didn't.
I think the future is bright.
Hon da Banner!0 -
windy shepard henderson wrote: »i think some of the supporters from galway were very naive in there planning for traveling south today , i met several that came in at half time or before it , you need a plan B when traveling to big games
if you are stuck heading into templemore you will see 2 or 3 signs for clonmore take one of them and they will bing you into templemore , when you get to templemore take a left for loughmore (noel and john mcgrath country) and when you arrive in loughmore village go left and take the next right and it will lead you into thurles at the munster hotel side , go right and it will bring you back on the main road just outside thurles about 4 or 5 miles away ,
thurles is full of small roads leading into the town have a look on google maps before you plan your next journey but beware they are a minefield if you dont know the areas
In all my years travelling to Thurles, yesterday's traffic was by far the worst in my experience. I had alway managed to get into The CBS car park previously. Alternately I could turn around and park on the Templemore rd. Yesterday the Gardai were redirecting traffic up a right-hand road to a big field where I got parked, thankfully for €5:D.
Gutted with the result, though.0 -
-
Join Date:Posts: 23225
Usually before I make my comments on here, I watch the recording back. I think this was the first time I switched it off before half time. Honestly, I remember leaving Croke Park after the AI semi final in 2005 against Cork thinking I never experience such a heart breaking defeat. Daly said after the match that day the game will set back Clare hurling for years. At least with the loss yesterday, John Conlon is the only outfield player over 26 years old. I think we will be back next year. But for sure, we are going to have alot of regrets about yesterday, like we did in 2005. Yesterday was heart breaking.
2005's team had Davy, the Lohan's, Seanie, Lynch, Markham and Gilligan, all winners with Clare merging with Griffin, D. McMahon, Nugent, Carmody. 2005 wasn't about potential, it was about the team that had won 2 All Irelands, 3 Munsters and lost another All Ireland merging with the next generation. Leaving Croke Park in 2005 we knew that half the team was gone and those coming through weren't going to do anything, it was the case of we're gone.Look, I'm reading back through the pages and I'm seeing alot of people pointing fingers at players, bemoaning missed chances, etc. Like people need to understand, hurling is an incredible emotional, fast-paced intense sport. We have to remember the conditions of the game yesterday, after the extra time played a few days ago and the heat yesterday, it was an incredibly difficult environment, with both teams making alot of mistakes. It was always going to be like this, players don't deliberately hit balls wide. I think they deserve some leeway in this regard.
We are taling about 170 minutes of hurling after 7 matches that came down to 1 point of a difference between 2 teams, leeway is implied.
Again, we played them for 170 minutes and lost by a point, yesterday we scored twice as much from frees than they did, that suggests we are physically better than them. These aren't small underage players, these are grown men.The main reason we are not going to Dublin in a fortnight though is we don't have a proper balance across the park of players that can physically take on a team like Galway.When you only have one puckout option down the field, when you don't have enough players that can win their own ball, when you don't have enough players that can take and give a physical challenge, you leave yourself open to being starved of possession and quite litterly runover.
Clare's puck out stradegy was amazing, didn't they win 24 out of 27 of their own, our options are quick to corner/wing backs or low driven ball to Podge or Reidy or high ball to Kelly or Duggan. The 1 thing that Calre was brilliant at was our puck outs.
The first day Galway beat us for the first 15 minutes by crowding the middle third and exposing our weak half forward line, we adjusted by dropping a player back and bringing our full forward line back as well. The second day we started how we counteracted the first day, this meant that Galway's weakness in the backs was actually a strength, it wasn't helped by out backs hitting balls straight to the Galway half backsAnd that's what Galway did in the opening 20 minutes of both games. Yesterday it was too much. I said it before the game we had to survive the opening half before the game loosened up and we didn't. I think we are probably short a midfielder and a half back to be honest,like if we want to single out players, Mannion and Canning were the only two players out of both team's 5-12 that hurled consistently well throughout the 160 odd minutes we played. Those two players were the difference between the sides imo.
Tony Kelly and Peter Duggan both scored once from play each yesterday, they were our only half forwards/midfielders to score from playFirst off, I know it's a tough loss to take, but we cannot forget the massive improvements and positives the team made throughout this season.
At the end of the day they finished 2 places better in the league and lost a semi final instead of a quarter final, I don't think that'd be considered massive improvements.From Touhy's rock solid year in goals
Agreed, I thought Touhy was brilliant all year, he's unlucky that Quaid had that save for Limerick, he'd be All Star Goalie otherwise
Stand up John Conlon, 2019's captain, the amount of strapping the man had on yesterday meant he must have been in pain, he did it when it counted all year.to Conlon's amazing season there are loads of positives.Even just take Hayes coming on there. Lads no joke honestly, that poor kid must have spent well over an hour throughout the year, standing on the line with his helmet on ready to come in for his debut, only not to! And then for his first proper appearance (Wexford aside) he is tasked to man mark one of the best forwards in the game in an tight AI semi final. The kid did brilliantly. At the end of the day, we still have a young squad, but it's hugely important that we build on what has been a great year and learn from our mistakes. That's vitally important. Because this team can achieve something special.
Hayes was briliant yesterday, serious speed merchant, why wasn't he playing earlier in the year? Sorry Pat but you might have lost your place.
I agree 100%, they amount of effort it takes for any player/manager/selector/analyst/physio is amazing, thank you to everyone involved, I know I'm being a **** calling out the issues.Finally, I'm just very thankful for all the players and management efforts throughout the year.
Clare support will always come out to support a team that gives their all, there are a lot of reasons there was a small Clare crowd at the Wexford game but twice we should have won only to not win and to roll over, to be let down by certain players. We were lucky to beat Tipp, we could have beaten Cork and Gawlay, we beat Limerick and WaterfordIt was an amazing year really, Jamie Wall's tweet summed it up saying we were the width of a post between being knocked out by Tipp but also denied an AI final place. That's just the way this crazy game goes, but one thing I would never question is the team's honesty and heart. They died in their boots there yesterday. I think what makes me proud also, everyone is always talking about Clare's weak support, but yesterday there was a brilliant Clare support. I think this year we all saw and appreciated the work and commitment the players were bringing, I think there is a strong connection back between the players, management and supporters which is really important.0 -
Right, today's performance sums up EVERYTHING that's wrong with this set of Clare hurlers, this isn't a set of players with potential, this is a set of players who won an All Ireland 5 years ago. Not only could they have won today, they SHOULD have won, they held the All Ireland champions to 10 scores in the first half and still went in the break down by double scores, our half forwards were non existent. For the whole first half stupid ball was being sent into a 2 man forward line who just broke the ball down to Galway defenders, they couldn't do anything else, they were out manned, our half forwards were completely missing.
David McInerney's distribution was terrible, he seemed more intent to pick out a Galway player than do anything else with the ball, his striking was extremely poor. I thought Cleary was excellent, he played very well.
Now, for the 2 reasons we lost the match, Tony Kelly and Peter Duggan. Kelly just went missing anytime he was needed, he seemed more intent to live on the fringes than getting stuck in, at the end of the match where was our start forward/midfielder? He was BEHIND his full backline hiding from play, he seemed shocked when he got the ball, but when he did get it you'd think he'd do something with it, but no, he did the most idiotic thing possible and hit a high ball into the forwards, it was clear that any low driven ball into the forwards would have resulted in at worst a free. Peter Duggan, first terrible thing was the sideline at the end of the first half, he might as well as driven the ball out himself for Galway, he free taking was of poor standard today and his sidelines were worse, he missed 2 frees that should have been scored and put 3 sidelines wide.
Re Duggan and that sideline at the end of the 1st half, I wouldn't put the entire blame on him.
He didn't want to shoot due to the angle, was looking for options & runners but we were entirely static, as we were up front all half bar O Donnell.
Eventually Duggan had no other choice, that said he should have reset his feet to have a proper cut at the posts0 -
Join Date:Posts: 23225
Re Duggan and that sideline at the end of the 1st half, I wouldn't put the entire blame on him.
He didn't want to shoot due to the angle, was looking for options & runners but we were entirely static, as we were up front all half bar O Donnell.
Eventually Duggan had no other choice, that said he should have reset his feet to have a proper cut at the posts
Agreed that no-one was making a run, in fact Reidy turned his back and walked the other way, but what he did with the ball was shocking.0 -
Advertisement
-
The game was lost because of management. They have been found out tactically and are slow to respond to make changes to what is happening on the pitch. I couldn't believe the tactics in the first half of playing a sweeper where Tuohy passed to the either corner back who would run 10 yards and hit long high balls into our two man full forward line against three Galway backs and sweeper. It happened time and time again in that first half. The reason we came back into the first match in Croke Park was by running at Galway with short offloading passes through the lines and hitting low balls into our forwards, similar to how we reverted in the second half and got back into the game. Galway were vulnerable to being run at. Not once did Conlon get a low ball in front of him, frustrating. Fair play for the underage success but I like to see the two lads gone now, their term is up now too. Would like to see Brian Lohan take charge, his done a very good job in UL.
Can't fault the players they gave everything asked of them and tried there best. Didn't work out for Duggan, was man marked throughout. Kelly was poor and hasn't really done anything since 2013, goes missing in big games a lot and doesn't get stuck in, similar to the Munster final performance. Don't think center forward is where he should be played, I'd put him in corner next year and let him roam between the forward lines, his kind of game.
It was great to see the size of support from Clare, we outnumbered them 2:1 I'd say. great to see the yellow jerseys being worn again. Also I've noticed this year Clare have brought the flags back, which have kind of disappeared from county games these last few years. They are a great sight to be seen, especially during the parade.
Overall was a good year, all hurling teams are fairly even now, anyone can beat anyone. Make few changes and we will go again in 2019.0 -
There's are only a few positives to gain from 2018. Going deep into the championship is one and not losing in Ennis is the other. There's way more question marks now then there was a the start of the year. I 'll list a few.
1. Is Tony Kelly only a 'bit' player ?
2. Have we a viable midfield partner for Galvin?
3. Is David McInerney really a fullback?
4. Is Peter Duggan a 'clutch' free taker or just a taker of great frees?
5. Is Podge a sub and sub only?
6. Can Pat O Connor remain on the team?
7. Are our management worth another 2 or 3 years?
8. Will we keep making average decisions on the ball and will our wide tally remain an unmitigated disaster? (Brushed off by Moloney)0 -
Join Date:Posts: 23225
I can't understand starting with the sweeper, not only is it a complete change but Galway would have been expecting it. With Galway starting a new centre back surely we should have pushed up. In my opinion our half forward line was the weakest line all year and ended up costing us.0 -
I can't understand starting with the sweeper, not only is it a complete change but Galway would have been expecting it. With Galway starting a new centre back surely we should have pushed up. In my opinion our half forward line was the weakest line all year and ended up costing us.
Yes, our half forward is the weakest link, Kelly and Reidy aren't half forwards. Reidy is a midfielder so move him there and put Kelly into Podge corner spot next year. We missed the opportunity in the league this year to experiment new players but management kept same team throughout. Ian Galvin deserves a shot at wing forward0 -
In the first half, we had numbers along our HB line/midfield and instead of running at Galway and using the spare man as a runner/option, we continually pumped aimless ball into an outnumbered FF line. The most frustrating thing watching it was the strikers had time to see what they were doing, it wasn't like the simply had to get rid of it due to pressure applied.
For next year's league we have to try and use more players in the league. This ye we went to Waterford having already qualified for the knockout stages. A great opportunity to use the panel, instead we went out with an almost full strength team0 -
Advertisement
-
very good article on today's Independent by Eamonn Sweeney, sums it up perfectly
https://www.independent.ie/sport/gaelic-games/hurling/eamonn-sweeney-semifinal-meltdown-will-haunt-clare-for-a-long-time-as-they-let-galway-off-the-hook-37187395.html
Clare are a real jekyll and hyde team, sublime to the ridiculous is ingrained in their DNA now, eradicating this must be foremost in their pre season preparation, lack of composure and good decision making is literally killing them, despite all their flaws [and there are many] they were only [a sliotar 1 inch to the left] away from getting to an all Ireland final
they've play 8 high intensity championship games with ZERO to show for it, the big question is, can they use the devastating hurt of being so near and yet so far away to really drive on and don't accept anything else only being top of the pile by August 20190 -
Yes, our half forward is the weakest link, Kelly and Reidy aren't half forwards. Reidy is a midfielder so move him there and put Kelly into Podge corner spot next year. We missed the opportunity in the league this year to experiment new players but management kept same team throughout. Ian Galvin deserves a shot at wing forward
Ian Galvin is well worth a start going forward. He's been coming on and getting important scores all year. He scored a great point on Sunday from out by the sideline - the kind Kelly, Colm Galvin and Reidy all missed and the kind the likes of Conlon or Canning or Shefflin would nail more often than not.
Not sure about Reidy in midfield though, I think we need a bit more size and physicality in there. Even though we pushed Galway close twice, we badly struggled with their physicality at times. A few more duggans and conlons in the side are badly needed.0 -
supernova5 wrote: »very good article on today's Independent by Eamonn Sweeney, sums it up perfectly
https://www.independent.ie/sport/gaelic-games/hurling/eamonn-sweeney-semifinal-meltdown-will-haunt-clare-for-a-long-time-as-they-let-galway-off-the-hook-37187395.html
Clare are a real jekyll and hyde team, sublime to the ridiculous is ingrained in their DNA now, eradicating this must be foremost in their pre season preparation, lack of composure and good decision making is literally killing them, despite all their flaws [and there are many] they were only [a sliotar 1 inch to the left] away from getting to an all Ireland final
they've play 8 high intensity championship games with ZERO to show for it, the big question is, can they use the devastating hurt of being so near and yet so far away to really drive on and don't accept anything else only being top of the pile by August 2019
That article sums up Clare. They have oodles of hurling, running ,skill but are the worst decision makers of all the top 5 hurling teams.0 -
Join Date:Posts: 23225
At the start of the year we wanted to stay in the top division of the league and get to Croke Park, we should be happy with that but the problem is we are so much better than that.0 -
Join Date:Posts: 23225
Was talking to a friend about Duggan's frees and he pointed out that Duggan doesn't have a set routine for frees at all, if you watch any top class free taker in any sport they all go through a set routine and hit the ball the same every time, Duggan changes his feed and striking style for different frees, his most comfortable free is the low driven 1 but that's been blocked down twice this year but he will revert to it if he's in doubt.0 -
Join Date:Posts: 23225
BloodyBill wrote: »There's are only a few positives to gain from 2018. Going deep into the championship is one and not losing in Ennis is the other. There's way more question marks now then there was a the start of the year. I 'll list a few.
1. Is Tony Kelly only a 'bit' player ?
I don't know what Tony Kelly is to be honest, he seems to want to be able to play a roaming role picking up lose ball but at inter-county level he's being found out.
2. Have we a viable midfield partner for Galvin?
Malone has gone up in my expectation no end, if he could add some finishing to he arsenal he'd be a HOTY candidate.
3. Is David McInerney really a fullback?
Nope
4. Is Peter Duggan a 'clutch' free taker or just a taker of great frees?
Nope, he has missed some terrible frees this year, except for the first day against Galway I don't think he scored every scorable free, to be blocked down twice in 1 year is a disgrace
5. Is Podge a sub and sub only?
I think he's a corner forward. I don't think there's a sub better than him at the moment over the full 70 minutes
6. Can Pat O Connor remain on the team?
Nope, Hayes is the future.
7. Are our management worth another 2 or 3 years?
They have to be, who else would you get? Maybe Anthony Daly.
8. Will we keep making average decisions on the ball and will our wide tally remain an unmitigated disaster? (Brushed off by Moloney)
Our lack of half forward line means that we will continue to struggle for both of the above0 -
Im not sure about management. Why did they not bring on Shanagher earlier or even start him. He got a run in the drawn match and was buzzing. Big, fast and strong, ideal for playing a big Galway team. This was their biggest mistake. Other things may not have worked out but what was the thinking behind this? Was he fully fit?
We only have a few years left with this team and maybe Daly with his All Ireland medals might just give them that little bit more confidence. Management have been around this group of players for along time now and maybe players need a new voice. Donal and Gerry have been great for Clare but Daly was good too and might tweak things a little. We are not far away
We lack the killer extent for a number of years now, never far away but cant get the job done all the same. We were lucky against Tipp and could have been out along time ago.
Saying that, fair play to all involved including management, they did us very proud0 -
Again, we played them for 170 minutes and lost by a point, yesterday we scored twice as much from frees than they did, that suggests we are physically better than them. These aren't small underage players, these are grown men.
Clare's puck out stradegy was amazing, didn't they win 24 out of 27 of their own, our options are quick to corner/wing backs or low driven ball to Podge or Reidy or high ball to Kelly or Duggan. The 1 thing that Calre was brilliant at was our puck outs.
At the end of the day they finished 2 places better in the league and lost a semi final instead of a quarter final, I don't think that'd be considered massive improvements.
I agree with all your other points, these three I wouldn't be on the same page.
With regards to points one and two, like I agree the puckout strategy in Corke Park after 16 minutes was excellent, but abysmal the first 16. On Sunday, as I said, the losing of the game for me was our inability to take on Galway in physical matchups/contests across the field in the first half. Like I don't know could I go up to Michael Donoghue and tell him we were brilliant on our puckouts in the first half. Most went to Jack Browne close to the corner flag, and for me it would be naive to think this was part of a cunning plan to get a lad open. Another went stright back over the crossbar. Donoghue had his homework done, and while 6 forwards can't mark 7 players, he gave leeway to Jack Browne knowing he isn't a noted sticksman that can make pin point deliveries into the forward line.
Looking back on the game, the 5 lads that were playing around the 40 were Duggan, Reidy, Kelly, I. Galvin and Podge, not one player, not one, either caught a high ball, won a 50-50 ball, turned a Galway back over. The only score we got in the first half where a player won a contest was SOD, who passed it off to Kelly for a point. By comparison Galway scored 1-4 from either winning a high ball, 50-50 or turning over a Clare player. Your example of frees won/lost is skewed because the 3 frees we won the first were just careless Galway discipline (high arm on Reidy, tug on Fitz, Burke tripping on Conlon). At the end of the day, the start of any game of hurling always features tighter man marking, less space, more structured, high tactical input, meaning the team that is physically stronger, better in the air and winning contests usually gets on top. Everyone knew we were going to be in survival mode against Galway in the first half, because under these terms, we don't have the proper balance of players throughout the team to cope. The team is purely designed to take teams on in loose open games of hurling where our excellent skill and movement can be prominent, but for me it's not enough, and it wasn't enough to sink Galway.
Here is Donal Moloney himself saying as much after the game:
"I thought it was a case of Galway just hanging in there when we came with the storm in the second half. I wouldn't agree that we played particularly poorly in the first half. We've got to recognise Galway and the way they start. Both Kilkenny and ourselves have experienced that over the last few weeks. They've a big capability when they come with that early surge. Our focus was that this (early surge) was going to come. Let's weather it and we'll take them in the final straight."
With regards to your last point, we didn't improve much, I think your forgetting the base we are coming from. Our performances in the championship last year were very medicore, like probably our best performance last year was as good as our worst performance this year. The additions of Touhy and Duggan were massive upgrades just that alone. But also looking at the teamsheet, along with Touhy and Duggan, Browne, Morey, Malone, Conlon, O'Donnell, Podge, Ian Galvin had significantly better years. Other intangibles like discipline (especially) and work-rate cannot be over looked. I think this year we have elevated ourselves to being proper AI contenders, showing an ability to go toe to toe against some of the best teams in the country. If we can re-look at our lineup between 5-12 and find say 2 players, along with the likes of Hayes, Shanagher, Cunningham, O'Brien pushing for places we will be there abouts again next year for sure. There wasn't a single stage, from 2014 to 2017, did we put in even just one performance in the championship that was remotely close to our best.0 -
1. Is Tony Kelly only a 'bit' player ?
I don't know what Tony Kelly is to be honest, he seems to want to be able to play a roaming role picking up lose ball but at inter-county level he's being found out.
2. Have we a viable midfield partner for Galvin?
Malone has gone up in my expectation no end, if he could add some finishing to he arsenal he'd be a HOTY candidate.
3. Is David McInerney really a fullback?
Nope
4. Is Peter Duggan a 'clutch' free taker or just a taker of great frees?
Nope, he has missed some terrible frees this year, except for the first day against Galway I don't think he scored every scorable free, to be blocked down twice in 1 year is a disgrace
5. Is Podge a sub and sub only?
I think he's a corner forward. I don't think there's a sub better than him at the moment over the full 70 minutes
6. Can Pat O Connor remain on the team?
Nope, Hayes is the future.
7. Are our management worth another 2 or 3 years?
They have to be, who else would you get? Maybe Anthony Daly.
8. Will we keep making average decisions on the ball and will our wide tally remain an unmitigated disaster? (Brushed off by Moloney)
Our lack of half forward line means that we will continue to struggle for both of the above
I'd agree with some of what you said. I don't think Cathal Malone is a good enough hurler to hold his place. Effort, attitude etc is first class, but he doesn't have the skill set required to beat teams.Malone fouled the ball twice against Wexford if I recall correctly. He isn't a 'natural' hurler, but he is a valuable workhorse, Fergal Hegarty was similar but a far superior hurling brain.
Podge is exceptional, but in the current game, wing forwards or roving corner forwards are expendable,, the should be burnt out after 50 minutes and hand over to fresh legs. To me that was the mistake Clare made this, a little too slow to bring in the subs.. Limerick are the same, they left it until nearly too late to bring on Dowling.
McInerney is doing fine at full back. He is the best option we have. I'd like to see Cleary bursting up the field a bit more and turning the oppositions half back line with smart ball in .
Pat O'Connor is a leader, he may lack a little pace, but he is a lovely stick hurler and a calm head. I had hoped he would move to centre back but that won't happen.
The criticism of Duggans free taking is justified. Brilliant against Galway the first day. But did you notice for the blocked down free in the replay, Galway put two men in front of him, they knew they had a chance to block him down with the style he has.
Management has to stay, but it has to get a little more ruthless on match day.
No team has won an all-ireland with a sweeper, and if we haven't men who win their own battle with opposition we are going to struggle. Having the sweeper,, (or two at times), means that for close in line balls there were 3 Galway players free,, meaning Duggan had little other option that to shoot for a score..
There are positives,. but we were the width of a post from being beaten by Tipp so in reality, we are still in the chasing pack rather than top 3.0 -
I had this idea for next year with regards to our forward line in order to try to maximise our talents. In key periods this year, the second half versus Cork and the first halves versus Galway, our two best forwards, Tony Kelly and John Conlon were out of the game. There is a multitude of reasons, but the main reasons are that Kelly isn't good at winning his own ball and we didn't get good supply into Conlon during those period.
So I have this way of working around the problem.
With Shanagher fit next year, we can use him as another focal point of the team. If were in a situation where once again Kelly is out of the play and Conlon is getting no ball, we could bring him out to try get us back in the game, while taking Kelly out of the 'warzone' if you like where he is redundant, and have him roaming inbetween good ball winners like Conlon, Shanagher and Duggan. Making runs onto passes and shooting is his game as we know. While Conlon, although not ideal away from goal, at least he would be still in the game. He shot 5 points from play against Cork in the first round of the championship from center forward.
Duggan - Conlon - I. Galvin
Kelly
Shanagher - SOD
When the game opens up later on, and were able to get good ball inside, we can return to default with both Shanagher and Conlon inside. Kelly back to center forward getting on loose ball. Having a forward line and where players have to adapt and change positions can be hard to get right but it's something that we can work on next spring.
Duggan - Kelly - I. Galvin
SOD
Conlon - Shanagher
Finally, heading into the last 15/20 minutes you can inject some serious speed into the forward line.
Duggan - Kelly - Reidy
Podge
Cunningham - Conlon
Just this idea I had that could help keep our best forwards in the game more and cope with different patterns of play.0 -
Advertisement
-
I had this idea for next year with regards to our forward line in order to try to maximise our talents. In key periods this year, the second half versus Cork and the first halves versus Galway, our two best forwards, Tony Kelly and John Conlon were out of the game. There is a multitude of reasons, but the main reasons are that Kelly isn't good at winning his own ball and we didn't get good supply into Conlon during those period.
So I have this way of working around the problem.
With Shanagher fit next year, we can use him as another focal point of the team. If were in a situation where once again Kelly is out of the play and Conlon is getting no ball, we could bring him out to try get us back in the game, while taking Kelly out of the 'warzone' if you like where he is redundant, and have him roaming inbetween good ball winners like Conlon, Shanagher and Duggan. Making runs onto passes and shooting is his game as we know. While Conlon, although not ideal away from goal, at least he would be still in the game. He shot 5 points from play against Cork in the first round of the championship from center forward.
Duggan - Conlon - I. Galvin
Kelly
Shanagher - SOD
When the game opens up later on, and were able to get good ball inside, we can return to default with both Shanagher and Conlon inside. Kelly back to center forward getting on loose ball. Having a forward line and where players have to adapt and change positions can be hard to get right but it's something that we can work on next spring.
Duggan - Kelly - I. Galvin
SOD
Conlon - Shanagher
Finally, heading into the last 15/20 minutes you can inject some serious speed into the forward line.
Duggan - Kelly - Reidy
Podge
Cunningham - Conlon
Just this idea I had that could help keep our best forwards in the game more and cope with different patterns of play.
Would love to see Conor McGrath come back to his own high standard.0 -
Would love to see Conor McGrath come back to his own high standard.
Me too. I'm not sure is it a pace issue most people seem to think, he is only 26, granted after some injuries, but he was never a speed merchant, he always relied on his quick feet. I think he has lost alot of composure and decisiveness when he gets the ball. Also I think he needs to be put in a position where he is just 1v1 closer to goal, he is not great in crowded areas. I'm not ruling him out, the talent is there. I hope he goes back to Cratloe, gets back enjoying his hurling. Then throw away the hurley for the winter and come back next year eager with no shackles and play his own game. Greame Mulcahy's form this year is a good example of a player playing great in his late 20's.
Our inside forward line is stacked.0 -
What are the views on Pat O'Connor lads? I thought he was fairly well regarded but the last few pages has me wondering if I'm 100% right.0
-
Figerty the top 1 is the only thing that matters in any given year. No reason why ye can't be that next year at this stage, time will tell.0
-
Is O'Donnell not away next year or something like that?I had this idea for next year with regards to our forward line in order to try to maximise our talents. In key periods this year, the second half versus Cork and the first halves versus Galway, our two best forwards, Tony Kelly and John Conlon were out of the game. There is a multitude of reasons, but the main reasons are that Kelly isn't good at winning his own ball and we didn't get good supply into Conlon during those period.
So I have this way of working around the problem.
With Shanagher fit next year, we can use him as another focal point of the team. If were in a situation where once again Kelly is out of the play and Conlon is getting no ball, we could bring him out to try get us back in the game, while taking Kelly out of the 'warzone' if you like where he is redundant, and have him roaming inbetween good ball winners like Conlon, Shanagher and Duggan. Making runs onto passes and shooting is his game as we know. While Conlon, although not ideal away from goal, at least he would be still in the game. He shot 5 points from play against Cork in the first round of the championship from center forward.
Duggan - Conlon - I. Galvin
Kelly
Shanagher - SOD
When the game opens up later on, and were able to get good ball inside, we can return to default with both Shanagher and Conlon inside. Kelly back to center forward getting on loose ball. Having a forward line and where players have to adapt and change positions can be hard to get right but it's something that we can work on next spring.
Duggan - Kelly - I. Galvin
SOD
Conlon - Shanagher
Finally, heading into the last 15/20 minutes you can inject some serious speed into the forward line.
Duggan - Kelly - Reidy
Podge
Cunningham - Conlon
Just this idea I had that could help keep our best forwards in the game more and cope with different patterns of play.0 -
-
-
Join Date:Posts: 23225
One of the big problems I see for next year is what to do with Tony Kelly. It's clear that he's not a marker so there's not point in playing him in the backs. It's clear that he doesn't like winning his own or dirty ball so there's no point in playing him in midfield. I don't think he likes to be marked closely, in a few games where teams have manned marked him (even at club level) he disappears a bit.
He has to be played in the forwards I'm still not sure where to play him. As he won't win dirty ball there's no point in playing him wing or corner back so he's down to 2 positions, his current position 11 or 14. At 11 he goes missing too much, missing might be the wrong word, but he goes looking to make himself available on the fringes of the play, this leaves a big hole in the middle of the field which means we'll always struggle to get scores. At 14, he won't win his own ball or like to be marked so it's hard to play him there.
I don't think he can keep playing in his current role, he just goes missing too much and I don't think he's enough of a leader, a prime example of this for me was the end of the game on Sunday, when we needed a score at the end of the game he went back behind the full back line, not in the middle of the pitch but hiding behind the play, when he got the ball he just put the head down and ran, he didn't look up to pick out a pass and at the end he did the worst thing possible, it's not as if Clare haven't experience of being in that position.0 -
Would love to see Conor McGrath come back to his own high standard.
Likewise, but I'm fearful that injuries have robbed him of the short burst of acceleration he used to get by defenders.
He simply wasn't able to shake them off this summer & got blocked down regularly.
I hope I'm wrong but I wouldn't be shocked if he left inter-parliamentary hurling altogether0 -
Advertisement
-
Join Date:Posts: 23225
We're a huge bunch of players who are all around 25/26 with Under 21 and Senior All Ireland medals already won, the games against Galway should definitely show them they aren't wasting their time like they were under Davy. Next year is going to be able bringing new players through the league and having different systems available if needed. In a way I'm delighted SoD is going off until next May, it wouldn't do a few of the other "senior" players to take a break for the winter and for them to realise that there are other players there.0 -
Clareman wrote:We're a huge bunch of players who are all around 25/26 with Under 21 and Senior All Ireland medals already won, the games against Galway should definitely show them they aren't wasting their time like they were under Davy. Next year is going to be able bringing new players through the league and having different systems available if needed. In a way I'm delighted SoD is going off until next May, it wouldn't do a few of the other "senior" players to take a break for the winter and for them to realise that there are other players there.
This.
I would prefer next year we use our panel much more in the league than we did this year. Looking back, almost everyone on the starting team have been on the go since last January, playing a huge amount of games. The lads need a long and proper break, and the management should be looking at exposing and developing a couple of new players. And like, there is no need of playing someone like John Conlon and have him slog it out on the heavy fields in January. We need to keep our players fresh for the longer championship.0 -
Join Date:Posts: 23225
This.
I would prefer next year we use our panel much more in the league than we did this year. Looking back, almost everyone on the starting team have been on the go since last January, playing a huge amount of games. The lads need a long and proper break, and the management should be looking at exposing and developing a couple of new players. And like, there is no need of playing someone like John Conlon and have him slog it out on the heavy fields in January. We need to keep our players fresh for the longer championship.
Can anyone remember the last game that SoD or Tony Kelly didn't play in?0 -
Look there has been a lot of comments posted following Clare's exit from this years championship that id like to address with my opinions.
1. Firstly id like to say the comments by some users that Davy is toxic in Clare is untrue and unwarranted and disgraceful. Davy won 2 senior All Irelands with Clare as a player and a senior All Ireland Club title for the 1996 Clare County Hurling Champions Sixmilebridge who also wear the Clare colours (Davy was simply a born Clare winner!).Davy won 3 Senior Munster titles as a player in 1995, 1997, 1998. Davy won 1 Munstee Minor title as a player in 1989 too. Davy also won the Poc Fada All Ireland Championship on at least one or more occasions. So Davys pedigree as a player was not toxic but rather a victorious sports ambassador for Clare!
The above was some of Davys achievements as a player. With respect to Davys management achievements he achieved great credentials! He first took over a Waterford team in 2008 after Justin McCarthy had resigned and led that Waterford Team to the All Ireland Final for the first time in decades and decades albeit they lost badly to one of the greatest Kilkenny Teams of all times. Davy followed up that final apperance with managing Waterford to a Munster title over Cork in the following years.
Davy then managed Clare to an all ireland title in 2013 the first in 16years and to a league title in 2016 the first in nearly 40 years!
When Davy managed Clare he knew the limitations of the Clare backline and despite at times especially post 2013 the sweeper system didnt always work the winning result nevertheless it worked as a strategy intermittently with careful planning to ultimately win the all ireland for Clare in 2013 and thats all that counts! Davys management also worked to capture the league title in 2016 just two years ago! How we would treasure any silverware now
with the so called 'popular managers 2 of them!'
who have failed naively in the last two years to win a title or really recruit any new players ( with the exception of Duggan who lets be frank was almost established last year!)
Anyway to continue with the nasty comments on Davy let me say his style while always not the one we all liked did reap the awards! Within 2 years Clare were all ireland champions and not once was he suspended in them two years from the sideline unlike the current managers! which proves he managed for good results as hard as he could!
Were it not for Davy the wait for Liam McCarthy to revisit Clare would be 21years and the wait for the league title would be about 40 years!
So I am at a loss how some jealous bad minded so called people could say Davy is toxic in Clare.
Davy is far from toxic in Clare and I am a clare fan and codone them bullying comments! I bet them same so called clare fans all the same enjoyed the 2013 all ireland win or sadly maybe they actually didnt!
The current managements two years are now up they have delivered no title despite taking over an all ireland winning team of just 5 yrs ago.
These sad anti Davy fans would be better off debating that and stop dragging Davy into it!
Il conclude if Davy was in charge last Sunday or the previous Saturday Clare when they got on top would have seeing out the victory because players would have been brought in sooner, scores would have to be scored not missed (19 wides!) and lastly Davy would have played his tactics close to his chest and would not have let the Clare team be so predictable as in playing the sweeper system again when Gearoid Mc Inerney was out! Indeed the current management were so naive that they went with Davys sweeper system because they had no plan of their own to save themselves but acourse it backfired at the start it had to!
So to conclude get a grip Davys critcs and instead stick to the current debate the current management have 2 years got and last weeks loss was the most lost opportunity since 1955 or probably ever! Its time for them to step down.
They should get credit for the 3 in a row u21 titles and minor munster titles which was helped by the pool they luckily had but only for Davy Clare would not have won Liam in 2013 and the league in 2016 thats proven now beyond doubt.
Davy left in 2017 in my opinion because this current crop of leaders were not prepared to put in the hard work and sacrifices and do what he wanted to in order to land a second title! The team in my opinion were relieved to finish ties with Davy but imo Davy had enough of that.
Thats why two years later since Davy left Clare hurling is more toxic and the toxicity starts with the goalie Tuohy who pucked out balls that went straight back from Galway over his bar! He pucked balls over the line to his corner backs!
The corner backs when the received shakily some passes from the goalie fumbled them over the sideline UNMARKED! Ask any reasonably hurling fan and will tell you your heart was in your mouth every time with the Clare backlines!
The backlines have not beem addressed at all in 2 years by this management! No new or strong backs brought in! Everyone of the existing defence was there in Davy's era! Tony Kelly was woeful bad and has shown even less leadership in a consistent basis since Davy left and management wont drop him!
ODonnell played well last Sunday but upto then and with the last 5 years has not!
This team were not beaten once or twice (by Cork! Davy would not tolerate that in same year)but 3 times in the championship! How could you win an all ireland with that statistic!
Its time for some clare fans to stop saying tuohy was good, that clare progressed this year when instead they collapsed on the big days but lulled Clare fans into thinking they had improved! Finally any team that demands support from the captain and mnagement before they win anything or prove themselves are usually lacking something. This team is currently lacking something and in particular management!
Slan!0 -
Keeping well Davy?
0 -
Bring back Davy Fiz.0
-
Advertisement
-
Yes look Davy got Liam back after 2 years.
The current setup are already 2 yrs in charge and there seems to be an element of fans who cant see no faults at all just wait and be patient etc Its pure defeatist talk and backwards imo the clare team are gone. While last year was not as exciting as last yr still lost to Cork again (twice one year) who have been Clares bogey team since post 2013! Kept a winded Galway team out on their feet in it to win aided by 19 wides not bri nging on subs on time like Shanaher, allowed to Tuohy for the 2nd week in a row and the backline to hand Galway a 9 point lead! Talk about Christmas coming early! Then dusting ovet after Moloney saying Galway hung in! Galway were rattled beyond doubt but Clare just were so silly in the basics of hurling evebthough can be very fancy at other times! In the name of God we need Ryan back for frees for the pressure ones at the end because it was so immature and a farce the way Clare lost this game! Daly or Davy or Lohan or someone needs to now be appointed as the new manager because if we dont 2019 is going to be another fruitless year it really will be!0 -
Naming Davy 31 times in one post is fair going, hats off to you man.
(And yes, taking the time to count the number of occurences is equally sad!!)0 -
I still think we had an All Ireland team that we mis-managed and cost us dearly, very lucky in a few of those games to come back, if shows tremendous heart from the players and I'd hate to be in any of there boots.
But people here and out there say some players didn't do this or that or underperformed, my question is if so why leave them on, why start them why not use the bench we have to the fullest, there are some great hurlers on the bench who barely or didn't get any game time, and would have been better than some fellas out there coasting on there name alone.
I'm not trying to diminish what the lads accomplished it was a good year and from talking to the few I know they are hurting but on 2 occasions it took us almost 20 minutes to react to Galways tactics, that's too slow in senior, in 21's maybe it cuts it but not in senior, they lads if they are staying on need to drop there favouritism towards some players and drop the lads that are coasting, and work on there own reactions to opponents0 -
Look there has been a lot of comments posted following Clare's exit from this years championship that id like to address with my opinions.
1. Firstly id like to say the comments by some users that Davy is toxic in Clare is untrue and unwarranted and disgraceful. Davy won 2 senior All Irelands with Clare as a player and a senior All Ireland Club title for the 1996 Clare County Hurling Champions Sixmilebridge who also wear the Clare colours (Davy was simply a born Clare winner!).Davy won 3 Senior Munster titles as a player in 1995, 1997, 1998. Davy won 1 Munstee Minor title as a player in 1989 too. Davy also won the Poc Fada All Ireland Championship on at least one or more occasions. So Davys pedigree as a player was not toxic but rather a victorious sports ambassador for Clare!
The above was some of Davys achievements as a player. With respect to Davys management achievements he achieved great credentials! He first took over a Waterford team in 2008 after Justin McCarthy had resigned and led that Waterford Team to the All Ireland Final for the first time in decades and decades albeit they lost badly to one of the greatest Kilkenny Teams of all times. Davy followed up that final apperance with managing Waterford to a Munster title over Cork in the following years.
Davy then managed Clare to an all ireland title in 2013 the first in 16years and to a league title in 2016 the first in nearly 40 years!
When Davy managed Clare he knew the limitations of the Clare backline and despite at times especially post 2013 the sweeper system didnt always work the winning result nevertheless it worked as a strategy intermittently with careful planning to ultimately win the all ireland for Clare in 2013 and thats all that counts! Davys management also worked to capture the league title in 2016 just two years ago! How we would treasure any silverware now
with the so called 'popular managers 2 of them!'
who have failed naively in the last two years to win a title or really recruit any new players ( with the exception of Duggan who lets be frank was almost established last year!)
Anyway to continue with the nasty comments on Davy let me say his style while always not the one we all liked did reap the awards! Within 2 years Clare were all ireland champions and not once was he suspended in them two years from the sideline unlike the current managers! which proves he managed for good results as hard as he could!
Were it not for Davy the wait for Liam McCarthy to revisit Clare would be 21years and the wait for the league title would be about 40 years!
So I am at a loss how some jealous bad minded so called people could say Davy is toxic in Clare.
Davy is far from toxic in Clare and I am a clare fan and codone them bullying comments! I bet them same so called clare fans all the same enjoyed the 2013 all ireland win or sadly maybe they actually didnt!
The current managements two years are now up they have delivered no title despite taking over an all ireland winning team of just 5 yrs ago.
These sad anti Davy fans would be better off debating that and stop dragging Davy into it!
Il conclude if Davy was in charge last Sunday or the previous Saturday Clare when they got on top would have seeing out the victory because players would have been brought in sooner, scores would have to be scored not missed (19 wides!) and lastly Davy would have played his tactics close to his chest and would not have let the Clare team be so predictable as in playing the sweeper system again when Gearoid Mc Inerney was out! Indeed the current management were so naive that they went with Davys sweeper system because they had no plan of their own to save themselves but acourse it backfired at the start it had to!
So to conclude get a grip Davys critcs and instead stick to the current debate the current management have 2 years got and last weeks loss was the most lost opportunity since 1955 or probably ever! Its time for them to step down.
They should get credit for the 3 in a row u21 titles and minor munster titles which was helped by the pool they luckily had but only for Davy Clare would not have won Liam in 2013 and the league in 2016 thats proven now beyond doubt.
Davy left in 2017 in my opinion because this current crop of leaders were not prepared to put in the hard work and sacrifices and do what he wanted to in order to land a second title! The team in my opinion were relieved to finish ties with Davy but imo Davy had enough of that.
Thats why two years later since Davy left Clare hurling is more toxic and the toxicity starts with the goalie Tuohy who pucked out balls that went straight back from Galway over his bar! He pucked balls over the line to his corner backs!
The corner backs when the received shakily some passes from the goalie fumbled them over the sideline UNMARKED! Ask any reasonably hurling fan and will tell you your heart was in your mouth every time with the Clare backlines!
The backlines have not beem addressed at all in 2 years by this management! No new or strong backs brought in! Everyone of the existing defence was there in Davy's era! Tony Kelly was woeful bad and has shown even less leadership in a consistent basis since Davy left and management wont drop him!
ODonnell played well last Sunday but upto then and with the last 5 years has not!
This team were not beaten once or twice (by Cork! Davy would not tolerate that in same year)but 3 times in the championship! How could you win an all ireland with that statistic!
Its time for some clare fans to stop saying tuohy was good, that clare progressed this year when instead they collapsed on the big days but lulled Clare fans into thinking they had improved! Finally any team that demands support from the captain and mnagement before they win anything or prove themselves are usually lacking something. This team is currently lacking something and in particular management!
Slan!
As a neutral I was the one who suggested that Clare would be better off with Davy on the line and was taken aback by the level of negativity towards him. He delivered two national titles albeit with a precocious under 21 squad at his disposal. Since he left I think Clare have regressed in their decision making under pressure and no longer carry the same aura they had when he was in charge. Last Sunday was a match Clare should have won and imo it was lost on the line similar to Cork the previous Sunday. I do not see Clare winning an All Ireland under the current management and better use should be made of the current crop of players as there doesn’t seem to be much coming through at minor and u21.0 -
Join Date:Posts: 23225
Anyone who doesn't think we have progressed would really need to have their heads examined, ok we should be better than we and we should be challenging for All Ireland's every year but looking at the cold hard facts.
In 2015 we played 3 championship games where we lost to Limerick and Cork but beat Offaly. Knocked out before quarter finals.
In 2016 we played 4 championship games where we lost to Galway and Waterford but beat Laois and Limerick. Knocked out before quarter finals.
In 2017 we played 3 games, lost to Cork and Limerick but beat Limerick. Got to All Ireland quarter final and a Munster final
In 2018 we played 8 games, lost to Cork and Galway but beat Limerick, Tipperary, Waterford and Wexford. Got to All Ireland Semi Final and Munster final.
Give the lads another year I say.0 -
Advertisement
This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement