Tony Mowbray leaves Celtic?

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:03pm #1

Just heard on the headlines that Tony Mowbray is no longer with Celtic

no details as such, just "sources" saying he is gone, that the players have been told, supposedly happened about 15-20 minutes ago

Dolph Starbeam · 25-03-2010 4:12pm

Sad i think, i know its been a terrible year but he needed to rebuild the whole squad, that takes time.

Aidric · 25-03-2010 4:13pm

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/football/teams/c/celtic/8586352.stm

Beanmachine · 25-03-2010 4:16pm

Poor decision in my opinion,should have been given time

Vanbis · 25-03-2010 4:16pm

MOG7 wrote: »

Sad i think, i know its been a terrible year but he needed to rebuild the whole squad, that takes time.

Totally agree. I think he needed at least another season after bringing in so many new players. Whoever takes over next will probably have a smaller budget to work with and also be told that he has to work with the current squad.

Maybe the Celtic was to big for Mowbray and if thats the case then Neil lennon won't get a look in.

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:17pm

yeah i think its pointless sacking him at this stage tbh, may aswell have just let it run till the end of the season and had a look around then if needs be, there isnt anything whoever comes in can do in the league now

time was needed imo, i know it was terrible the last while but you can hardly expect so many changes of personnel and success?

Joyce Country · 25-03-2010 4:19pm

Beanmachine wrote: »

Poor decision in my opinion,should have been given time

:pac:

have ya watched the state of us this season?

he had to go. losing 4-0 to st.mirren will never ever be acceptable to celtic.

Who are we thinking we should get in? Lennon till the end of the season I reckon but I think we should go for a foreign manager at this stage.

Guss Hiddink is available? I'd imagine dermot desmond would be willing to put a bit of money into having a proper manager in there next season.

Brewster · 25-03-2010 4:19pm

Walter Smith sees another Celtic manager off the premises..... You have to hand it to the man...

PauloMN · 25-03-2010 4:21pm

kryogen wrote: »

there isnt anything whoever comes in can do in the league now

There is. Build for next season, in advance of next season. We were hearing week after week about taking defeats on the chin, against the dross of the bottom end of the SPL.

This had to happen, I was convinced it would last night after that game. Much as I'm sure he was a nice bloke, he had to go, and now is definitely the right time.

Joyce Country · 25-03-2010 4:21pm

Brewster wrote: »

Walter Smith sees another Celtic manager off the premises..... You have to hand it to the man...

good old uncle walter certainly knows what it takes in scotland

Vanbis · 25-03-2010 4:24pm

Joyce Country wrote: »

Guss Hiddink is available? I'd imagine dermot desmond would be willing to put a bit of money into having a proper manager in there next season.

Celtic fans will put pressure on Desmond and the board about the next manager. He can't really afford another mess or season the the current one.

The_Kew_Tour · 25-03-2010 4:24pm

Am surprised at how bad he did at celtic. Im Hibs fan and he really saved our club from going bust. Got in some great players, his devlopement of Youth players was excellent and we came third in his first season also beat Rangers 3-0 twice the next season away in Ibrox.

He better manager then that hope he comes back he good guy just did not work out this move.

Keano · 25-03-2010 4:26pm

Total knee jerk reaction. The leagues over and yes results were bad but wait till the end of the season. Pointless at this stage.

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:27pm

PauloMN wrote: »

There is. Build for next season, in advance of next season. We were hearing week after week about taking defeats on the chin, against the dross of the bottom end of the SPL.

This had to happen, I was convinced it would last night after that game. Much as I'm sure he was a nice bloke, he had to go, and now is definitely the right time.

how? how can someone build for next season now? they cant get rid of, or bring in any players, in the summer they will more then likely want to clear a few out and get a few in, but they will have less money then TM had to do it!

The league is lost, there is nothing anyone can do about that now

you dont think the players have to take any blame for their performances? the goalkeeper last night, had an absolute mare, should have saved all of them imo

Players left, some with Mowbrays blessing and some he didnt want to go, he wasnt able to get in the quality of players to replace them unfortunatly, but such is the way in Scottish football these days, players would rather play in the Championship easily nowadays over Scotland

I stand by the comment that he should have been given time, no point in letting him bring in all those new faces and then sacking him after a few months, likely most of those players he signed will be shown the door and the new manager will make his signings, they will need time to bed in, learn to play togeter etc.

Joyce Country · 25-03-2010 4:28pm

Keano A Legend wrote: »

Total knee jerk reaction. The leagues over and yes results were bad but wait till the end of the season. Pointless at this stage.

you obviously know nothing about the celtic football club.

Losing 4-0 to st. f**in Mirren is an automatic sackable offence.

every celtic fan across the world knew last night he would be gone this morning.

there was never any doubt.

Joyce Country · 25-03-2010 4:30pm

kryogen wrote: »

how? how can someone build for next season now? they cant get rid of, or bring in any players, in the summer they will more then likely want to clear a few out and get a few in, but they will have less money then TM had to do it!

simply - might as well give neil lennon the experience for the future.

league is gone, nothing to play for.

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:32pm

why? what do you think gives you a divine right to steam roll teams like St. Mirren?

the players werent at it and were well beaten on the day

you would swear it was Real Madrid the expectations some have

United were beaten by Burnley and Leeds this season, did you hear a bunch of United fans shouting for Alex to get the chop?? silly comparison i know but the point im making is that you will have bad patches, you will have bad days, you will have more then in the past now because the quality of players attracted to the club are poorer then before so the league will be a little bit closer and if the weaker teams are willing to bust a gut they will have every chance of getting results, Rangers were beat last night too

daithijjj · 25-03-2010 4:33pm

Brewster wrote: »

Walter Smith sees another Celtic manager off the premises..... You have to hand it to the man...

Managing one of the old firm is the easiest job in football, you only have to beat one team. Its hardly genius. The scotsman at birmingham is doing a far tougher job than walter smith is imo. This celtic squad is rank awful to be honest.

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:34pm

The Rangers squad isnt much better!

I wouldnt take away from Walter Smith in what he is and has done in Scottish football, and for his time at Manchester United

bit of a bogey · 25-03-2010 4:34pm

kryogen wrote: »

United were beaten by Burnley and Leeds this season, did you hear a bunch of United fans shouting for Alex to get the chop?? silly comparison i know but the point im making is that you will have bad patches, you will have bad days, you will have more then in the past now because the quality of players attracted to the club are poorer then before so the league will be a little bit closer and if the weaker teams are willing to bust a gut they will have every chance of getting results, Rangers were beat last night too

Its not as if this is celtic's only woeful result this year!

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:36pm

bit of a bogey wrote: »

Its not as if this is celtic's only woeful result this year!

i know, but cant you see that with the amount of players in and out the odds were firmly stacked against this being a banner year for the club?

Keano · 25-03-2010 4:36pm

I may not know much about the club but how can sacking a manager when the league is over and after a freak result be a good thing for any club?

Fuhrer · 25-03-2010 4:37pm

Brewster wrote: »

Walter Smith sees another Celtic manager off the premises..... You have to hand it to the man...

Aye, he couldnt cut it internationally or in a better league so hes just going to stick it out at Rangers till he dies.

Boggles · 25-03-2010 4:37pm

Should have never hounded out the Ginger One.

Xavi6 · 25-03-2010 4:38pm

Keano A Legend wrote: »

Total knee jerk reaction. The leagues over and yes results were bad but wait till the end of the season. Pointless at this stage.

It's the best time to do it. New man comes in, sees all the dead wood, gets rid early without wasting the summer transfer window.

Spot on by the board.

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:39pm

i bet there is still a large contingent of Celtic fans who are still happy Strachan is gone tbh

Joyce Country · 25-03-2010 4:39pm

kryogen wrote: »

why? what do you think gives you a divine right to steam roll teams like St. Mirren?

the players werent at it and were well beaten on the day

you would swear it was Real Madrid the expectations some have

United were beaten by Burnley and Leeds this season, did you hear a bunch of United fans shouting for Alex to get the chop?? silly comparison i know but the point im making is that you will have bad patches, you will have bad days, you will have more then in the past now because the quality of players attracted to the club are poorer then before so the league will be a little bit closer and if the weaker teams are willing to bust a gut they will have every chance of getting results, Rangers were beat last night too

it was an accumulation of factors built up over the season that got him sacked. obviously if we were neck and neck with rangers, playing good football he might have got away with it.

but losing 4-0 to a club like st.mirren .... no-one in their squad would get near our reserves probably. it's the managers fault. he has to motivate the players and get them playing. its the spl ffs.

Joyce Country · 25-03-2010 4:40pm

kryogen wrote: »

i bet there is still a large contingent of Celtic fans who are still happy Strachan is gone tbh

absolutely. i wish the guy never managed us. smarmy little ginger ..... let's stay on topic though

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:41pm

Xavi6 wrote: »

It's the best time to do it. New man comes in, sees all the dead wood, gets rid early without wasting the summer transfer window.

Spot on by the board.

he isnt in the job one year yet, he was forced/decided to get rid of loads of players, had to bring in loads of new ones, and at that, players of a lesser calibre then the ones sold

how is he expected to deliver in his first season with so many new players?

id have given him another year, if there hasnt been an improvement coming to christmas maybe, then you obviously have to look at his position, but instant success cannot be the water mark for whether you keep your job or not

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:42pm

Joyce Country wrote: »

it was an accumulation of factors built up over the season that got him sacked. obviously if we were neck and neck with rangers, playing good football he might have got away with it.

but losing 4-0 to a club like st.mirren .... no-one in their squad would get near our reserves probably. it's the managers fault. he has to motivate the players and get them playing. its the spl ffs.

fair enough, i respect your opinion, i just think would have kept the faith with him till next year

Beanmachine · 25-03-2010 4:42pm

Joyce Country wrote: »

obviously if we were neck and neck with rangers, playing good football he might have got away with it.

Might have got away with it? Surely that would have been a good achivement no?

Keano · 25-03-2010 4:44pm

So who realistically is going to be a contender?

Vanbis · 25-03-2010 4:45pm

Keano A Legend wrote: »

So who realistically is going to be a contender?

Paul Lambert, Roy Keane, David O Leary for a start.

bit of a bogey · 25-03-2010 4:46pm

Vanbis wrote: »

Paul Lambert, Roy Keane, David O Leary for a start.

I would never go to a celtic match again if roy keane got the job!

Keano · 25-03-2010 4:47pm

Vanbis wrote: »

Paul Lambert, Roy Keane, David O Leary for a start.

Maybe the other 2.

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:48pm

Lambert is a possibility, Keane wouldnt touch it imo, have my doubts O Leary would either, someone mentioned Guus Hiddink, sure he might be interested *cough* *cough*

If Lennon does take the caretaker job and aquits himself well i wouldnt mind him having a go

bit of a bogey · 25-03-2010 4:50pm

I dont think keane would go near it either (thank god)!

I bet he'll have something to say about it tho!

Joyce Country · 25-03-2010 4:51pm

Beanmachine wrote: »

Might have got away with it? Surely that would have been a good achivement no?

losing 4-0 to st.mirren will always be a disgrace for anyone involved with a celtic side

Xavi6 · 25-03-2010 4:51pm

Oh man, if Royston gets that one....

Chardee MacDennis · 25-03-2010 4:52pm

Joyce Country wrote: »

:pac:

have ya watched the state of us this season?

he had to go. losing 4-0 to st.mirren will never ever be acceptable to celtic.

Who are we thinking we should get in? Lennon till the end of the season I reckon but I think we should go for a foreign manager at this stage.

Guss Hiddink is available? I'd imagine dermot desmond would be willing to put a bit of money into having a proper manager in there next season.

this is the problem with football fans today. completely unrealistic expectations - agh my team is losing sack the manager and get in guus hiddink. you do realise celtics and the spls stock has taken a dive in the last 3 years and i would be surprised if you even managed to get anyone in that had half the rep Mowbray had before Celtic...

Vanbis · 25-03-2010 4:53pm

kryogen wrote: »

Lambert is a possibility, Keane wouldnt touch it imo, have my doubts O Leary would either, someone mentioned Guus Hiddink, sure he might be interested *cough* *cough*

If Lennon does take the caretaker job and aquits himself well i wouldnt mind him having a go

If any Celtic fan thinks they have a chance of getting Guus Hiddink then they need their head examined. I think David O Leary would be a good shout but i'd i have my doubts if he would want the job.

Also don't think Keane would fancy it either, he didnt as a player and that was a mistake so can't seeing him going back.

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:53pm

i agree with a lot of ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ what Bastard Prince said tbh
sad but true

keane2097 · 25-03-2010 4:56pm

Don't see the point in keeping him till the end of the season.

The results have been appalling so he was never going to be in charge next season.

Celtic have nothing left to play for this year so sacking him now versus then has no real negatives if he was going to be gone anyway, which he certainly was.

Get a new man in, let him have a few no pressure competitive games to appraise the squad before they go off on their holidays rather than him having to decide what areas need strengthening blindly in the summer time.

Brewster · 25-03-2010 4:56pm

Fuhrer wrote: »

Aye, he couldnt cut it internationally or in a better league so hes just going to stick it out at Rangers till he dies.

What planet are you on man? He took over a shambles from the Vogts here and made the Scotland team respectable again.

He took a bankrupt Rangers team to a Uefa cup final.

He took a bankrupt Everton side to upper echolons of premiership, and John Giles nominated him for manager of the year for his achievement. He has seen about 5 Celtic managers off the premises in two spells as Rangers manager.

Smith is one of the best British managers of his generation. Ask Sir Alex, the best around, for his views on Walter.

Beanmachine · 25-03-2010 4:56pm

Joyce Country wrote: »

losing 4-0 to st.mirren will always be a disgrace for anyone involved with a celtic side

I'm not disagreeing with you, and i understand its not the only bad result Celtic have had all season but i still think it was the wrong decision. can't see how it will benfit Celtic in any way at all.Just my opinion

everdead.ie · 25-03-2010 4:57pm

I never understood why Mowbray (I didn't think he was able to keep it tight enough at the back or sharp enough going forward) got the job in the first place I think O'Leary would go for it to get his career back on track but I think he'd be hoping to use it as a stepping stone

kryogen · 25-03-2010 4:59pm

If he wants to use it as a stepping stone he would be mad imo, unless there is some new investment going to be put into the squad that i havent heard about?

Vanbis · 25-03-2010 5:00pm

Anyone know if Charlie Nichollas has being on Skysports news about this? I'm sure he has alot to say on the matter

kryogen · 25-03-2010 5:02pm

Vanbis wrote: »

Anyone know if Charlie Nichollas has being on Skysports news about this? I'm sure he has alot to say on the matter

hadnt been on it the last time i looked anyway

Vanbis · 25-03-2010 5:04pm

kryogen wrote: »

hadnt been on it the last time i looked anyway

He might fancy his chances with Phil Thompson as his No. 2 :rolleyes:

Joyce Country · 25-03-2010 5:05pm

Vanbis wrote: »

He might fancy his chances with Phil Thompson as his No. 2 :rolleyes:

:pac:

the thought of the 2 of them on the sideline at CP made me laugh out loud there.

Tony Mowbray leaves Celtic?

Comments