"Big Club" Superthreads

Spud83

In fairness Mitch you are bit of a glory hunter. Sure you had a big whinge, and nearly stopped supporting the club because the best player in the world ever was sold, and not replaced.

Where will the goals come from you shouted!!!!
We will win nothing you said!!!

With Rooney injured you have probably just given up again.

Way off topic here sorry. Mitch you would get access IMO, but one hissy fit that you have been known for and you are gone.

ROCKMAN

Mitch Connor wrote: »

All subjects - everything that would currently be discussed in the super threads. By invitation would mean you have to prove yourself to be a good poster in order to be invited to have access to the sub-forum superthreads.

Who are the chosen few who would be sending these first few invites
Who would you have to prove yourself and your posts to

Frisbee wrote: »

And each thread should have a 'Marshal' or 'Mini Mod'

Ideally this would be the person with the most posts on that thread as they would obviously be the biggest supporter of that club and the most suitable for the job.

Their job would be to liaise with the SF Mods and would have the ability to give infractions but not Bans.

Sorry Frisbee but top posters are not automatically the best or most suitable

baz2009 wrote: »

Just let the posters on the superthreads vote who they want to be the mod of the forum?

Much better and fairer way IMO

herbieflowers

leninbenjamin wrote: »

I don't think anybody rightly knows...

Funny thread, though. I can't tell whether posters are taking the piss or not!

Headshot

right calm down folks, we dont want to close this thread, we're trying to improve the sf here

Spiritoftheseventies

leninbenjamin wrote: »

I don't think anybody rightly knows...

We will find out soon enough

RasTa

You two take it to PM, good debate going on here for once.

Mitch Connor

Frisbee wrote: »

There's an Ignore Function.

I suggest you use it barstooler.

oh - and the word is You're. Not Your.:rolleyes:

herbieflowers

Headshot wrote: »

right calm down folks, we dont want to close this thread, we're trying to improve the sf here

Someone's got their eye on a Marshal post... :pac:

Mitch Connor

Spud83 wrote: »

In fairness Mitch you are bit of a glory hunter. Sure you had a big whinge, and nearly stopped supporting the club because the best player in the world ever was sold, and not replaced.

Where will the goals come from you shouted!!!!
We will win nothing you said!!!

With Rooney injured you have probably just given up again.

Way off topic here sorry. Mitch you would get access IMO, but one hissy fit that you have been known for and you are gone.

1 hissy fit limit? seems harsh.

3hn2givr7mx1sc

ROCKMAN wrote: »

Much better and fairer way IMO

At least someone agrees with me.:D

RasTa

What about other team posters? I don't want SOTS and Mr Alan near the United thread

Frisbee

ROCKMAN wrote: »

Sorry Frisbee but top posters are not automatically the best or most suitable

Imo they are as they're the ones who spend most time on the thread so obviously have more to talk about and know more.

Headshot wrote: »

right calm down folks, we dont want to close this thread, we're trying to improve the sf here

Sorry, you're right.

Spiritoftheseventies wrote: »

We will find out soon enough

If it is I will be seriously ****ing annoyed that the Mods allowed it with so serious an issue.

Mitch Connor wrote: »

oh - and the word is You're. Not Your.:rolleyes:

Picking at my grammar. Nice one, obviously because you have no comeback!

Headshot

ROCKMAN wrote: »

Who are the chosen few who would be sending these first few invites
Who would you have to prove yourself and your posts to

we dont know yet, sots is the liverpool one, not sure about the others yet.

we all know who are the good posters so they will be giving out the invites, that's how i see it anyway

3hn2givr7mx1sc

RasTa wrote: »

What about other team posters? I don't want SOTS and Mr Alan near the United thread

I think other teams posters should be allowed in, but one 'troll post' and a permaban.

SantryRed

Is this not an April Fools?

ButcherOfNog

definately a good idea

Headshot

SantryRed wrote: »

Is this not an April Fools?

you honestly think this is an Aprils joke, mate trust me its far from it.

Spiritoftheseventies

RasTa wrote: »

What about other team posters? I don't want SOTS and Mr Alan near the United thread

Posted nine times there in all. So you have no worries on that front.

Frisbee

Headshot wrote: »

you honestly think this is an Aprils joke, mate trust me its far from it.

It's been brewing for a while now tbf, ever since the last Feedback thread was locked.

wobblyknees

Frisbee wrote: »

If it is I will be seriously ****ing annoyed that the Mods allowed it with so serious an issue.

Headshot

Frisbee wrote: »

It's been brewing for a while now tbf, ever since the last Feedback thread was locked.

true

ROCKMAN

Frisbee wrote: »

Imo they are as they're the ones who spend most time on the thread so obviously have more to talk about and know more.

To quote another Waterford poster... we'll have to agree to disagree

UnitedIrishman

One on hand, think it's a good idea in that it's a change and it'll stop trolling.

On the other there have been genuinely decent discussions/posts/debates in the Chelsea/Man Utd and Liverpool threads about things that wouldn't get talked about if certain people weren't allowed post in them.

As long as posters from other clubs were discussing things in a decent way then everything should be ok, but shouldn't that be the way things are anyways?

LuckyLloyd

herbieflowers wrote: »

Is this a wind-up? It being April Fools and all...

I imagine so. This whole thing has been rejected numerous times. This is easily the most lol proposal thus far.

To be fair though, I was caught for maybe 30 posts or so!

leninbenjamin

I'm toasting almonds. So much more straightforward than figuring out whether this is an April fools or not.

Nulty

Whats trolling? Trying to change topic, trying to piss others off? Is it someone who makes a relavant post and doesn't hang aroound to discuss it?

Where's the line?

ROCKMAN

but it was started after 12 , and everyone knows want that means...

So who's in on it, Frisbee ,Mitch ,Headshot ..................

3hn2givr7mx1sc

Nulty wrote: »

Whats trolling? Trying to change topic, trying to piss others off? Is it someone who makes a relavant post and doesn't hang aroound to discuss it?

Where's the line?

Pissing others off, imo.

peabutler

baz2009 wrote: »

Pissing others off, imo.

That post just pisses me off :P:P

Frisbee

ROCKMAN wrote: »

So who's in on it, Frisbee ,Mitch ,Headshot ..................

The only thing I'd be in one with that twat Mitch is a battering.

3hn2givr7mx1sc

peabutler wrote: »

That post just pisses me off :P:P

Not purposely though.:p

leninbenjamin

Nulty wrote: »

Whats trolling?

A post by a fan of any other team than the accuser about the team the accuser follows.

3hn2givr7mx1sc

Frisbee wrote: »

The only thing I'd be in one with that twat Mitch is a battering.

Definately April Fools, or a banning for Frisbee.:P

Frisbee

baz2009 wrote: »

Definately April Fools, or a banning for Frisbee.:P

Tbh I don't even care anymore, this forum has gone to the dogs. It needs to be split up into different club sections to stay alive.

Nulty

baz2009 wrote: »

Pissing others off, imo.

Meh...**** happens. Thats what mods are for.

I don't care if its AF joke, always worth an argument

Assuming its true, it sterilises the rivalry and diminishes the passion fans are justified in expressing. It's not kindergarten.

If its not, point still stands.

Headshot

Frisbee wrote: »

The only thing I'd be in one with that twat Mitch is a battering.

here here

he's really on my last nerve, bloody whinging all the time

Jazzy

ROCKMAN wrote: »

but it was started after 12 , and everyone knows want that means...

So who's in on it, Frisbee ,Mitch ,Headshot ..................

aye, ya could say a clique :pac:

leninbenjamin

Frisbee wrote: »

It needs to be split up into different club sections to stay alive.

Nah, just needs more delicious crustaceans!

gustavo

I would like to see a clubs sub forum cos it''s annoying when I come on here and 75% of the threads on the first page are threads that I wouldn't want to contribute to

jesus_thats_gre

Please please please please do this!!! PLEASE!!!

Even just reading Boggles bull**** about Riera on the Liverpool thread made me want to kill myself. I am sick to death of having to put up with nonsense from opposing fans who's sole purpose is to wind people up just so I can discuss the club I support.

Jazzy

jesus_thats_gre wrote: »

Please please please please do this!!! PLEASE!!!

Even just reading Boggles bull**** about Riera on the Liverpool thread made me want to kill myself. I am sick to death of having to put up with nonsense from opposing fans who's sole purpose is to wind people up just so I can discuss the club I support.

but its their OPINION DURRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

jesus_thats_gre

Jazzy wrote: »

but its their OPINION DURRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

Mind you, your witty retorts would vanish forever...

5starpool

Jazzy wrote: »

but its their OPINION DURRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

This guy?

Spiritoftheseventies

jesus_thats_gre wrote: »

Please please please please do this!!! PLEASE!!!

Even just reading Boggles bull**** about Riera on the Liverpool thread made me want to kill myself. I am sick to death of having to put up with nonsense from opposing fans who's sole purpose is to wind people up just so I can discuss the club I support.

Yes agree. I just cant stand posters who continually zone in on the negative.

grenache

I agree totally with the OPs idea for separate forums for bigger clubs. Sick to death of coming onto to the soccer forums only to see Liverpool News Thread, Villa News Thread, Arsenal News Thread, United News Thread, etc. The soccer forum is dying from a multitude of exclusivity threads, there's rarely any interesting threads on here anymore.

~Rebel~

Frisbee wrote: »

Ideally having Mr Alan/SOTS/Mike65 as Mod of the Pool thread and Headshot/Mitch as Marshall of the United one's it means they can stop people from other clubs coming in and saying things about their clubs.

tbh, I dont like the idea.

But if it does go ahead, Dear God No! to the idea of modding being decided by thread post count. Postcount on thread has fuk all to do with ones judgement or ability to mod. Either a vote, or it being given to people who have experience modding on boards already imo.

The Sparrow

Funny April Fools joke... had me for a sec. Kudos.

Although the joke is usually over when you have to start defending it as not being a joke.

Kirnsy

Why not just have a kind of Ginormous Megathread entitled 'soccer'?

No other threads allowed. at all.

Iago

and that's all folks.

For future reference; when we want your opinion, we'll give it to you.

Up until then stick to what you know best, i.e. petty squabbling over inconsequential things to try and seem slightly more intelligent than the pond scum you all are

Your friendly Nazi mod team