ATH knockout syle: the great PW Debate (brackets in the OP & voting open to all)

waltersobchak

interesting choice, ill be very curious to see the counter argument

D2D

waltersobchak wrote: »

interesting choice, ill be very curious to see the counter argument

+1

Bounty Hunter

thing about the counter arguement is you can approach it whatever way you want, you could run down the choice of Joe or talk up your own pick and why they would make more of an impact as your arguement

Jolt2007

And my counter is up. The booking isn't as in depth as Volt's great answer, but I'm positive you good folks are more than intelligent enough to see the idea I was going for and how it could all work.

waltersobchak

Awesome outside the box choice there Jolt.. fair play:cool:

Bounty Hunter

does anyone object to me allowing (counting) everyone in PW's votes when i add the polls? im only not adding the polls at this stage so that people only vite when all have had their say (counters and all).

Danger_dave1

No objection

D2D

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

does anyone object to me allowing (counting) everyone in PW's votes when i add the polls? im only not adding the polls at this stage so that people only vite when all have had their say (counters and all).

No, that's grand

waltersobchak

Sounds good to me:cool:

D2D

:pac::pac:

I just turn on ESPN America and Around the Horn is on. Great:D:D:D

The Volt

My response to Jolt's suggestion is now up.

D2D

Voltwad wrote: »

My response to Jolt's suggestion is now up.

It was a great response imo. Agreed with pretty much all of it

Jolt2007

Voltwad wrote: »

My response to Jolt's suggestion is now up.

You're a worthy adversary young Volt.

campo

both really good arguments and counter arguments there thank crunchie I did not get one of ye I would have just thrown in the towel at this stage

The Volt

And my final response is up.

waltersobchak

What happens now? Do we thank the person with the better argument?

flahavaj

Sorely tempted to use the following as a counter argument no matter what is said.

"Yore maaaaaaaaaaaa!!!"

Reckon I could go all the way.:pac:

D2D

waltersobchak wrote: »

What happens now? Do we thank the person with the better argument?

I guess we wait for BH to tell us who...advances??

That was a great argument between Volt and Jolt. Really great stuff and, hopefully, it's a sign of things to come in this

The Volt

Dare_2_defy wrote: »

I guess we wait for BH to tell us who...advances??

That was a great argument between Volt and Jolt. Really great stuff and, hopefully, it's a sign of things to come in this

Jolt is due one more response as far as I'm aware.

Edit - Just relaized he responded. That's a wrap from us anyway.

Bounty Hunter

waltersobchak wrote: »

What happens now? Do we thank the person with the better argument?

you vote. poll added.

D2D

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

you vote. poll added.

Damn it, it's too tough to pick 1. How long do we have??

waltersobchak

Dammit hate closed polls:pac:

Bounty Hunter

youve got till im sober... who knows when taht will be

waltersobchak

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

youve got till im sober... who knows when taht will be

Up a mountain again BH?:pac:

D2D

waltersobchak wrote: »

Up a mountain again BH?:pac:

Thanks, now my Pepsi is on my laptop:mad:

So we've got a good while to vote anyway

Bounty Hunter

well id say 24 hours atm, ive come down my metaphorical mountain as this time there are no real ones within walking distance.

thn ill announce the winner and start match 2

Mr.Nice Guy

Just saw the two arguments. Both made a good case and made two good choices. Couldn't call it.

Cactus Colm

Made my vote ... good answers from both sides, although neither would have been my first (or second) choices.

JP Liz V1

Cactus Colm wrote: »

Made my vote ... good answers from both sides, although neither would have been my first (or second) choices.

Who would you have picked Colm? I'm curious

I would have picked Desmond Wolfe or AJ Styles

Both are good choices and valid points it will interesting to see who wins

waltersobchak

I would have gone for Hulk Hogan, pay him for a one shot deal to come out on Raw, run down TNA and then fire him:pac:

Cactus Colm

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

Who would you have picked Colm? I'm curious

I would have picked Desmond Wolfe or AJ Styles

Both are good choices and valid points it will interesting to see who wins

Desmond Wolfe would have been my top choice. But Kurt Angle wouldn't have been too far behind. Use him to fill the gap HBK has left, with a lighter schedule similar to 'Takers.

And maybe Rob Terry As a pale batista clone.

I don't think Styles has what it takes to make it to the top of the WWE. At best, maybe a transitional world champion, but I doubt even that.

waltersobchak wrote: »

I would have gone for Hulk Hogan, pay him for a one shot deal to come out on Raw, run down TNA and then fire him:pac:

I don't think you'd have to fire him, no doubt as soon as you asked him to put over a younger talent (like 'Taker) he'll quit.

waltersobchak

Rob Terry was actually in WWE's Developmental about 18 months ago but got fired for failing the wellness policy(Is that really a surprise? :pac:)

The Volt

waltersobchak wrote: »

Rob Terry was actually in WWE's Developmental about 18 months ago but got fired for failing the wellness policy(Is that really a surprise? :pac:)

There must be something uber depressing about WWE that drives all of these superstars to drugs :pac:

waltersobchak

Voltwad wrote: »

There must be something uber depressing about WWE that drives all of these superstars to drugs :pac:

They have an alternative.. *cough BWE cough* bang bang cough cough*

The Volt

waltersobchak wrote: »

They have an alternative.. *cough BWE cough* bang bang cough cough*

That reminds me, we haven't discussed our wellness policy. To the Batcave.

Mr. Guappa

Can anyone vote in this or is it just the guys involved in the game?

When I saw the 2 choices the lads had made I immediately thought one was a better choice, but after the arguments I think its pretty close, good job lads!

Bounty Hunter

anyone can vote but tonight is the last night to vote for this matchup.

Cactus Colm

Good job to the two lads, a shame to see someone go out. Well done Voltwad. and tough luck Jolt.

JP Liz V1

Congrats Voltwad and good job Jolt

D2D

No shame in going out early Jolt, that was extremely close imo:)

Congrats Volt:)

Bounty Hunter

---

Cactus Col

---

Gimmick

---

SF

---

Flahavaj
Voltwad

---

Voltwad
Jolt2007

---

Final
Campo
Degag

---

QF
Waltersobchak
Danger Dave

---

SF
Dare 2 Defy

---

Bye
Dieselqueen

ill add this to the OP, and will get the Campo vs Degag thread up soon (probably within the hour).

D2D

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

---

Cactus Col

---

Gimmick

---

SF

---

Flahavaj
Voltwad

---

Voltwad
Jolt2007

---

Final
Campo
Degag

---

QF
Waltersobchak
Danger Dave

---

SF
Dare 2 Defy

---

Bye
Dieselqueen

ill add this to the OP, and will get the Campo vs Degag thread up soon (probably within the hour).

I speak for all of us when I say fair play to ya BH for all the effort you're putting into this

Itll be interesting to see the topic for this 1. The last topic was a tough 1 but it had a lot of options. I'll send a PM to both of them to let them know its their go when the thread is put up:):)

Bounty Hunter

Dare_2_defy wrote: »

I speak for all of us when I say fair play to ya BH for all the effort you're putting into this

Itll be interesting to see the topic for this 1. The last topic was a tough 1 but it had a lot of options. I'll send a PM to both of them to let them know its their go when the thread is put up:):)

thanks man.

The Volt

Good show Jolt, perhaps you being stuck for time was your only downfall. Bring on the flah

Bounty Hunter

hmm i sense an escolation of the trash talk is on the horizon as Volt calls out The Flah

D2D

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

hmm i sense an escolation of the trash talk is on the horizon as Volt calls out The Flah

Well he backed it up against Jolt. Volt vs the Flah = €€€'s :pac:

Bounty Hunter

Dare_2_defy wrote: »

Well he backed it up against Jolt. Volt vs the Flah = €€€'s :pac:

as does does the ATH co-champions collision in the other already announced quater final and the potential meeting of the BWE booking comitee members down the line... wonder will peoples arguements give us any ideas to steal for that in the future :pac:

2nd match up / question is up. Have at it lads.

D2D

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

as does does the ATH co-champions collision in the other already announced quater final and the potential meeting of the BWE booking comitee members down the line... wonder will peoples arguements give us any ideas to steal for that in the future :pac:

2nd match up / question is up. Have at it lads.

PM's sent

That'd be interesting to see 2 BWE writer's face off. Since the BWE was mentioned, new booker's are always welcome

*bang bang*

D2D

So far, we've had...

Round 1:
Match 1: Volt vs. Jolt
Match 2: Degag vs. campo

I'll update this as we go along

campo

My answer is up was really tempted to go with Shad Romance..bwe style