Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Lyric fm's Breakfast show presenter - Marty Whelan.

Options
1565759616272

Comments

  • Registered Users Posts: 8,219 ✭✭✭Calina


    Yvonne23R wrote: »
    I heard one of the stories last week that I loved, but I can't remember what it was about.

    That really says a lot, so it does.


  • Registered Users Posts: 406 ✭✭Yvonne23R


    Calina wrote: »
    That really says a lot, so it does.
    I mean I can't remember exactly what it was about! I remember it like a dream - only half there. -- But it was hilarious and at the same time deep. There's always something to take away from the Daphne story.


  • Registered Users Posts: 7,410 ✭✭✭jmcc


    Yvonne23R wrote: »
    I mean I can't remember exactly what it was about! I remember it like a dream - only half there. -- But it was hilarious and at the same time deep. There's always something to take away from the Daphne story.
    Perhaps you and Marty can write a book (or napkin) - the "Musings of Marty". It might sell well in the RTE canteen. It really has no place on what used to be a Classical/Arts station.

    Regards...jmcc


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,138 ✭✭✭SaveOurLyric


    jmcc wrote: »
    Perhaps you and Marty can write a book (or napkin) - the "Musings of Marty". It might sell well in the RTE canteen. It really has no place on what used to be a Classical/Arts station.

    Regards...jmcc

    Thats taking a very narrow view of a classical arts station. As it happens, I was thinking we could do with a new thread here collecting these stories. I am sure a lot of people would enjoy them. That one last week was a gem but I cant remember it well enough to do justice to retelling it. And I missed this mornings show completely because I had to help out at my daughter's school.

    Light chat to give us a giggle at that time of the morning is just what we need. Nobody wants a discussion on the Schopenhaurian elements of Parsifal (we probably aren't even in the mood for some Parsifal at all). If you just want music, then power up your ipod or spin a disc. This thread seems to have attracted a particular type of poster who doesn't take kindly to people approving of the current new improved Lyric, and hankers after some highfaluting musical purity. Hugo Brady Brown and Almiviva came in for a lot of abuse and seem to have been driven away, but its great to see Yvonne had a change of heart after a hiatus and decided to speak up for the majority again. But thats just the nature of people enjoying something I think - they just get on with enjoying it and dont need to say so on a place like this. But someone needs to redress the imbalance that gives a very poor impression of the success of Marty's show.


  • Registered Users Posts: 7,410 ✭✭✭jmcc


    Thats taking a very narrow view of a classical arts station.
    Yeah. The idea that it should play Classical music rather than MOTR schlock punctuated by bozoid babbling is quite a narrow view, isn't it?
    Almiviva came in for a lot of abuse and seem to have been driven away,
    I think that there was some problem where he/she was replying to posts as Yvonne without bothering to change usernames.
    but its great to see Yvonne had a change of heart after a hiatus and decided to speak up for the majority again.
    Evidently the majority here thinks that Marty sucks and a Classical/Arts stations should be for Classical music and the Arts rather than a digout for a failed 2FM DJ pushing the same sub-Tubridean 2FM schlock that lost something like 50K listeners on 2FM. Most of us just want to listen to Classical music in the morning. Not the babbling bozo and his make-believe talking cat and friends. Just Classical music.

    Regards...jmcc


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 406 ✭✭Yvonne23R


    jmcc wrote: »
    Yeah. The idea that it should play Classical music rather than MOTR schlock punctuated by bozoid babbling is quite a narrow view, isn't it?

    I think that there was some problem where he/she was replying to posts as Yvonne without bothering to change usernames.

    Evidently the majority here thinks that Marty sucks and a Classical/Arts stations should be for Classical music and the Arts rather than a digout for a failed 2FM DJ pushing the same sub-Tubridean 2FM schlock that lost something like 50K listeners on 2FM. Most of us just want to listen to Classical music in the morning. Not the babbling bozo and his make-believe talking cat and friends. Just Classical music.

    Regards...jmcc

    I'm very broadminded and I know that all music is the same no matter what its provenence. I think you can get too much of the pure classical at that hoar of the morning. I don't mind light stuff like Morricone, Gabriel's Oboe, Cavatina, Alfie Bow, Strauss, the Sleepers' Wake, the Arrival of the Queen of Sheba (which Mart says is really about Linda Martin ;) - that's an RTE in-joke), and so on. You can have your Brahms in the Coffee Concert later on. (Brahms was addicted to coffee incidentally, Marty told us last year on his anniversary.) Imagine if Marty started playing Brahms's Lullaby in the morning! Nobody would get to work. :)

    No, it's all about linking you see: the different kinds of music and building an audience. You can't make bricks without straw, you know. :cool:

    I wish Liz Nolan [who is good at doing her program] would do a bit more of the funnies too. I heard her do the Muppets last week and that brought a smile to my face. "It's time to play the music," she said. "It's time to dress up right. For the Muppets tonight!"


  • Registered Users Posts: 29,193 ✭✭✭✭HeidiHeidi


    OK, I'm going to come straight out and ask..... and take the slap if I get it.

    Can either Yvonne or SaveOurLyric convince the rest of us that you're not one and the same poster please?

    Because I'm convinced you are, and you'll be hard pushed to tell me otherwise.

    And on a different note (pun intended), can we please get past the nauseating posts about the merits of Daphne and Hugo and all those bloody stupid jokes and banter, and the rest of us posting about our undoubtedly equally nauseating (to two posters anyway) hifalutin tastes and superior knowledge?

    This thread has gone around in circles for a very long time, and as much as I've contributed to it (and I'll admit I have), I think it might be time to call a truce. If that were possible.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,138 ✭✭✭SaveOurLyric


    HeidiHeidi wrote: »
    OK, I'm going to come straight out and ask..... and take the slap if I get it.

    Can either Yvonne or SaveOurLyric convince the rest of us that you're not one and the same poster please?

    Because I'm convinced you are, and you'll be hard pushed to tell me otherwise.

    And on a different note (pun intended), can we please get past the nauseating posts about the merits of Daphne and Hugo and all those bloody stupid jokes and banter, and the rest of us posting about our undoubtedly equally nauseating (to two posters anyway) hifalutin tastes and superior knowledge?

    This thread has gone around in circles for a very long time, and as much as I've contributed to it (and I'll admit I have), I think it might be time to call a truce. If that were possible.

    Is it so incredible that more than one person could enjoy the show ? Other fora here seem to get along without such conspiracy theories (even using langauge analysis software - what is this CSI ?!?!). If we disagree with those not happy with the MITM or Lyrics general policy, are we also to suggest that surely there can only be one person with that opinion, and so all posters with that point of view are in fact all the one person ?


  • Registered Users Posts: 29,193 ✭✭✭✭HeidiHeidi


    Is it so incredible that more than one person could enjoy the show ? Other fora here seem to get along without such conspiracy theories (even using langauge analysis software - what is this CSI ?!?!). If we disagree with those not happy with the MITM or Lyrics general policy, are we also to suggest that surely there can only be one person with that opinion, and so all posters with that point of view are in fact all the one person ?
    No to all of the above - but for two people to post in such outstandingly distinctive and similar styles (even without the fancy software it's obvious to my naked eye) is really very remarkable. And unbelievable in my book.


  • Registered Users Posts: 7,410 ✭✭✭jmcc


    Is it so incredible that more than one person could enjoy the show ?
    Other than Marty, perhaps his production team, his travel agent and some character called Hugo Brady Brown? You see, Marty and the rest of them are background noise - the kind of thing that most people ignore. It becomes irritating when babbling bozos think that they are more important than the music. Perhaps in the cult of RTE and its "personalities" they tell all these sad non-entities that they are famous and are "personalities". People want to listen to music on LyricFM not some sub-talkradio wibbling from people who think they are being "creative" and "clever".
    Other fora here seem to get along without such conspiracy theories (even using langauge analysis software - what is this CSI ?!?!).
    No. There is even a forum here called "Conspiracy Theories". This isn't CSI. This is the web.
    If we disagree with those not happy with the MITM or Lyrics general policy,
    Obviously you, Yvonne and closed accounts such as Almaviva, SaveOurLyricFM (who seems to have a rather similar posting style to you) and a handful of other single topic accounts seem to be promoting Martydom and his Opera tours.
    are we also to suggest that surely there can only be one person with that opinion, and so all posters with that point of view are in fact all the one person ?
    This is the web and people have digital footprints. The shills and the sockpuppet accounts tend to be quite apparent. The classic example would have been Almaviva replying to a reply to Yvonne as Yvonne but without changing to the Yvonne account. Then there is the abrupt oscillation between the "ordinary plain people of Ireland housewife" and the person au fait with a lot of broadcast industry terminology like there were two people posting. The pro-Martydom posters seem to be quite a minority here so there may be a temptation to create multiple accounts to make it seem like there are more listeners than there are in reality and more people on Boards.ie who like the MOTR and can't figure out how to retune their radios to 2FM or some other station.

    Regards...jmcc


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 406 ✭✭Yvonne23R


    jmcc wrote: »
    Other than Marty, perhaps his production team, his travel agent and some character called Hugo Brady Brown? You see, Marty and the rest of them are background noise - the kind of thing that most people ignore. It becomes irritating when babbling bozos think that they are more important than the music. Perhaps in the cult of RTE and its "personalities" they tell all these sad non-entities that they are famous and are "personalities". People want to listen to music on LyricFM not some sub-talkradio wibbling from people who think they are being "creative" and "clever".

    No. There is even a forum here called "Conspiracy Theories". This isn't CSI. This is the web.

    Obviously you, Yvonne and closed accounts such as Almaviva, SaveOurLyricFM (who seems to have a rather similar posting style to you) and a handful of other single topic accounts seem to be promoting Martydom and his Opera tours.

    This is the web and people have digital footprints. The shills and the sockpuppet accounts tend to be quite apparent. The classic example would have been Almaviva replying to a reply to Yvonne as Yvonne but without changing to the Yvonne account. Then there is the abrupt oscillation between the "ordinary plain people of Ireland housewife" and the person au fait with a lot of broadcast industry terminology like there were two people posting. The pro-Martydom posters seem to be quite a minority here so there may be a temptation to create multiple accounts to make it seem like there are more listeners than there are in reality and more people on Boards.ie who like the MOTR and can't figure out how to retune their radios to 2FM or some other station.

    Regards...jmcc

    It seems to me that some people want to keep classical/crossover music for themselves. What Mart does very successfully is he gives a leg up to ordinary people to get into the classical stuff without being frightened off. :pac:

    I listened to almost the entire Marty Show this morning and it was a joy to behold. It must have sickened the snobs to know that Marty is held in the highest favour by the Wexford Festival Opera because he was offering a Gala Opening Night to the Wexford Opera Festival production of Salome to two loyal listeners with an overnight in the Ferrycarraig Hotel and a chance to attend a reception with Mart and the gang. For the second day running! ;)

    And there was great news on the Verona outing too but I missed the detail of that because I'd things to do. :eek:

    And the Modern Major General was on with a really good joke about Sir Elton John who's birthday it is today. 67 years young! :cool:

    Oh and I'm not the other person you mention or any of them. I think a person would want to be off her rocker to start spending their life on a thing like this arguing with themselves. Who has the time? ;)

    And I haven't a digital footprint either, by the way. I have a carbon one - would that do? :D

    Keep it up, Mart! The majority - nay, the vast majority - of the plain people of Ireland are loving your work. :)

    And to the small band of critics - all I can says is : try to be nice. It's only a radio show - even if it's too popular for the heavy classical pureists.


  • Registered Users Posts: 8,219 ✭✭✭Calina


    I listen to YLE Klassinen now for anyone who is interested. They play classical music, works in their entirety; no ads and the speaking is largely restricted to telling me what the music is and the occasional - and I mean very occasional - newscast.

    Yvonne - you have a digital footprint. Every post you make in this forum contributes to it.

    It seems to me that people who want quiet, calm music in the mornings are not served at all. Telling them to listen to their iPod is let them go eat cake version of radio.

    The radio waves are full of bouncy drivel. Lyric FM used to have a nice relaxing start to the morning. Marty Whelan's show is nowhere near that nature. I don't listen any more. Telling me that I'm a snob, or elitist in the face of a radio show which is on a specialist station but which plays Bon Jovi and kettle loads of Van Morrison is deliberately avoiding the issue. If I wanted to listen to joviality and 80s rock. I'd listen to 4FM.

    If I wanted to learn about classical music, I actually wouldn't expect to hear Duran Duran in the middle of it. It's not like 2FM play much Bach, is it?


  • Registered Users Posts: 7,410 ✭✭✭jmcc


    Yvonne23R wrote: »
    I listened to almost the entire Marty Show this morning and it was a joy to behold.
    In the studio?
    It must have sickened the snobs to know that Marty is held in the highest favour by the Wexford Festival Opera because he was offering a Gala Opening Night to the Wexford Opera Festival production of Salome to two loyal listeners with an overnight in the Ferrycarraig Hotel and a chance to attend a reception with Mart and the gang. For the second day running! ;)
    You seem to be promoting whatever "competition" or tour that is on the show. Odd that. But then the Wexford Opera Festival might have some other random RTE personality promoting their little competition - it is all just marketing.
    And there was great news on the Verona outing too but I missed the detail of that because I'd things to do.
    And again.
    And the Modern Major General was on with a really good joke about Sir Elton John who's birthday it is today. 67 years young! :cool:
    Another one of Marty's "voices" like he does on the Tesco advert?
    Keep it up, Mart! The majority - nay, the vast majority - of the plain people of Ireland are loving your work.
    The vast majority of Irish people are unaware of the existence of that radio show. If they listen to radio, they listen to RTE1, 2FM and other stations. But then your beloved Marty was fired from his natural home, 2FM, because he was just not bringing in the audience figures.
    And to the small band of critics - all I can says is : try to be nice. It's only a radio show - even if it's too popular for the heavy classical pureists.
    It would be nice to think that there's a special place in Hell reserved for those who foisted the babbling Whelan on LyricFM where they have to listen to the babbling, his "jokes" and banter for eternity without any ad breaks or music. But then some, like you and SaveOurLyric(FM) might regard that as heaven.

    Regards...jmcc


  • Registered Users Posts: 8,219 ✭✭✭Calina


    jmcc wrote: »
    It would be nice to think that there's a special place in Hell reserved for those who foisted the babbling Whelan on LyricFM where they have to listen to the babbling, his "jokes" and banter for eternity without any ad breaks or music. But then some, like you and SaveOurLyric(FM) might regard that as heaven.

    Regards...jmcc

    I think a choice of selected Bartok works for the piano on eternal loop might work though.


  • Registered Users Posts: 406 ✭✭Yvonne23R


    Calina wrote: »
    I think a choice of selected Bartok works for the piano on eternal loop might work though.
    I wouldn't wish that on my worst enemy: I've just listened to some of it on YouTube and I can see why he isn't popular. :cool:


  • Registered Users Posts: 7,410 ✭✭✭jmcc


    Calina wrote: »
    I think a choice of selected Bartok works for the piano on eternal loop might work though.
    And I thought I was being tough on them. :)

    Regards...jmcc


  • Registered Users Posts: 406 ✭✭Yvonne23R


    I was thinking about this because I was listening to Arena tonight here on Radio 1, and Abie Philbin-Bowman was interviewing Julian Fellows from Downton Abbey who was in Belfast last night to meet Ian Paisley (Junior).

    Mart has a great devotion to Downton and the Daphne & Myrtle story is like an Irish version of D.A. I hadn't thought of that but that's really how it is. If Mart goes back on TV in a big way it could be transferred to the screen. He really 'gets' the voices.

    Loved, loved, loved his jokes today too. I think he makes a great breakfast of the radio show.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,138 ✭✭✭SaveOurLyric


    jmcc wrote: »
    Other than Marty, perhaps his production team, his travel agent and some character called Hugo Brady Brown? You see, Marty and the rest of them are background noise - the kind of thing that most people ignore.

    So you might like to believe and have us believe.

    But none other than the leader of our country, An Taoiseach, Enda Kenny TD, would disagree with you and is witness, even with his hectic official schedule, to hearing supporters and converts to the feel-good oasis that is MITM:
    Originally said by Enda Kenny TD
    "Yet… in the worst of the economic downturn time and again we heard even news addicts say ’I couldn’t take any more of the bad news about banks and bailouts I switched to Lyric FM in the car in the mornings Marty Whelan makes me feel so much better.’"

    http://www.merrionstreet.ie/index.php/2014/03/speech-by-the-taoiseach-mr-enda-kenny-t-d-radiodays-europe-conference-at-the-convention-centre-on-24-march-2014/?cat=11

    So....the conspiracy theorists are correct.....finally unmasked....Marty, Almaviva, Yvonne, Hugo, SaveOurLyricFM..., on top of juggling the affairs of state.....juggling multiple boards.ie accounts, is..... our Taoiseach Enda Kenny ! :)

    Yeah right.


  • Registered Users Posts: 7,410 ✭✭✭jmcc


    So....the conspiracy theorists are correct.....finally unmasked....Marty, Almaviva, Yvonne, Hugo, SaveOurLyricFM..., on top of juggling the affairs of state.....juggling multiple boards.ie accounts, is..... our Taoiseach Enda Kenny ! :)
    Did you forget the password for your previous account (if you had one)?

    And people wonder why this country is f*cked.

    Regards...jmcc


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,138 ✭✭✭SaveOurLyric


    jmcc wrote: »
    Did you forget the password for your previous account (if you had one)?

    And people wonder why this country is f*cked.

    Regards...jmcc

    Is the phrase 'tin foil hat time' the right one? I think it might be.

    Back to the music though, listen out for a treat coming up, with the lovely Hayley Westenra to visit MITM before her outing in the NCH this weekend. She's quite a fan of the show as well !


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 406 ✭✭Yvonne23R


    The Marty Whelan Show is just a fabulous mixture of good tunes and great comedy. The best joke from Mart this morning was this. And people say that they're Marty's intellectual superior!



    A man went for a job on a building site and the foreman warned him that he'd have to answer some hard questions.

    "'That's OK,' said the man.

    "'You're absolutely sure?' asked the foreman.

    "'Absolutely,' said the man.

    "'Right,' said the foreman. 'What's the difference between a joist and a girder. Think carefully.'

    "'Well,' said the man, 'Didn't Joyce write Ulysses and Goethe write Faust?'"


  • Registered Users Posts: 82 ✭✭DownBeaten


    If you like schoolboy jokes, listen to Tubridy or Today FM. Leave the only music and arts channel available to us music lovers.


  • Registered Users Posts: 406 ✭✭Yvonne23R


    DownBeaten wrote: »
    If you like schoolboy jokes, listen to Tubridy or Today FM. Leave the only music and arts channel available to us music lovers.
    I do. :pac:

    And I think we've a duty to attract schoolboys' to Lyric and to classical music and this is one sure way to do it. It's like laying a trap for the next generation with chocolate biscuits and getting them to stay for the roughage. :cool:

    (Oh, and Ryan Uubridy isn't on Today FM, by the way: he's on 2fm, on national radio. :D )


  • Registered Users Posts: 29,193 ✭✭✭✭HeidiHeidi


    ..... and round and round and round it goes........ this thread is getting worse than MITM, and that's saying something.


  • Registered Users Posts: 8,219 ✭✭✭Calina


    Yvonne23R wrote: »
    I do. :pac:

    And I think we've a duty to attract schoolboys' to Lyric and to classical music and this is one sure way to do it. It's like laying a trap for the next generation with chocolate biscuits and getting them to stay for the roughage. :cool:

    (Oh, and Ryan Uubridy isn't on Today FM, by the way: he's on 2fm, on national radio. :D )

    TodayFM is national radio as well and we have a duty to do nothing. IN my opinion, people tend to treasure what they have found more than what is rammed down their throats.

    You're ramming pop music and nonsense down my throat in the mornings. There are umpteen radio stations in the country which do the same.

    A beacon of calm would be useful. An island of classical music with no banter and chat, a nice way to ease into the day and remain calm in the face of traffic.

    Instead, the choice is either politics or inane banter.

    In other words, you've alternatives to Lyric if banter and drivel is what you want.

    Unfortunately I can't get YLE K or Classic FM on the car in the mornings.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,138 ✭✭✭SaveOurLyric


    Yvonne23R wrote: »
    I do. :pac:

    And I think we've a duty to attract schoolboys' to Lyric and to classical music and this is one sure way to do it. It's like laying a trap for the next generation with chocolate biscuits and getting them to stay for the roughage. :cool:

    (Oh, and Ryan Uubridy isn't on Today FM, by the way: he's on 2fm, on national radio. :D )

    Thats so true and very well put.

    Ireland lags behind our more sophisticated European neighbours in the widespread enjoyment of classical music in its widest sense. When Ireland was a poorer and more insular country, such music was only known or accessible to a very small minority. But the world has changed. Thank you prosperity, wider horizons, and the internet. And (despite the attitudes of some of the old guard http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=2055554034, and a few other sulking around these parts), the likes of MITM is at the cutting edge, providing a 'beginner slope' into classical music, sprinkling it as he goes with a smattering of 'cross-over', and assorted 20th century styles to attract all, and capture them to the fabulous world that is classical music (and all done with a delicious dollop of infectious good cheer).

    Bravo Ireland on your maturity ! And thank you Marty !


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,138 ✭✭✭SaveOurLyric


    HeidiHeidi wrote: »
    worse than MITM, and that's saying something.

    Where does this negative attitude come from? A popular and wide ranging show that surely uplifts all but the most sombre of moods. Why damn it so ? How many programmes prompt people to nudge our Taoiseach describing how it improves their morning? Surely you are not questioning the artistic and serious music credentials of the Wexford Opera Festival, yet they choose as a marquee face, Marty.
    Cribbers, your case simply does not stand up.


  • Registered Users Posts: 7,410 ✭✭✭jmcc


    Yvonne23R wrote: »
    The Marty Whelan Show is just a fabulous mixture of good tunes and great comedy. The best joke from Mart this morning was this. And people say that they're Marty's intellectual superior!
    It is not Marty's joke. It has been around for decades. A bit like your beloved Marty. Most people seem to just want Classical music rather than that babbling bozo and his "jokes" and banter.

    Regards...jmcc


  • Registered Users Posts: 2,005 ✭✭✭Expunge


    How many programmes prompt people to nudge our Taoiseach describing how it improves their morning?

    Except it seems our Taoiseach never said it. Apparently, he made no reference to Lyric or Marty Whelan.
    It was in his published speech alright, which he apparently made a complete hash of when he went to read it in front of 1300 radio professionals from around the world. It was reported by some of the mortified Irish people there that he made reference to 'Deserted Island Discs' instead and not 'Desert Island Discs' - one of the most famous radio shows in the world.
    This was in front of Helen Bowden, head of BBC Radio.
    The 'speech' was apparently met by stunned silence, head scratching and finally polite applause.
    Kenny and Whelan are well suited to each other. Both on a wing and a prayer with no class!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 7,410 ✭✭✭jmcc


    Where does this negative attitude come from? A popular and wide ranging show that surely uplifts all but the most sombre of moods.
    We want Classical music rather than some babbling bozo waffling on about decades old pop music and dad-dancing tunes, his humming and his tedious radio version of Fair City or whatever.
    Why damn it so ?
    See the part above about wanting to listen to Classical music rather than the mutterings of a failed 2FM DJ?
    How many programmes prompt people to nudge our Taoiseach describing how it improves their morning?
    We just want Classical music.
    Surely you are not questioning the artistic and serious music credentials of the Wexford Opera Festival, yet they choose as a marquee face, Marty.
    They'd use a pack of rashers if it got them coverage on RTE as the face of their festival. It is all just marketing.

    Regards...jmcc


This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement