dirtiest ever premier league player

chiefwiggum

ok everybody goes on about jones/ruddock/dicks and so on but can anyone beat them???
i would have to nominate that timid little ex spurs full back mauricio tarricco(deuce bigalow)
a fair tackle for this guy was anything below the knee and chuck norris would have been proud of his killer elbows

who else can live up to this ?

john"take your head off gary mabbut"fashanu maybe?

lets hear it....

inB4Keano :rolleyes:

chiefwiggum

yep keane was up there with the best of them alright....good call there

Nalz

David Ginola.......so so duurty

IrishIrish

Michael Brown.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UNugWnNjwwg

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4n3Nutns0I

If either challenge had resulted in a bad injury they would be considered one of the worst challenges ever. They are much worse than many of the challenges that have broken legs.

SomethingElse

Vidic

Barton

De Jong

And this guy was so dirty he needed an early bath...



cozy stuff

28064212

Kevin Davies. He's committed the most fouls of all time in the Premiership, and he was top of the fouls committed league 3 years in a row. He's a striker FFS!

Nozebleed

vinny jones.

Daemos

Ben Thatcher

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F_8b1pd3Mas

mink_man

kevin davies does like using his elbow. :rolleyes:

applehunter

Denis Wise was a nasty little man.

mike65

Blackburn Rovers.

therokerroar

Lee Cattermole

Hard as fcuk.

ctrl-alt-delete

28064212 wrote: »

Kevin Davies. He's committed the most fouls of all time in the Premiership, and he was top of the fouls committed league 3 years in a row. He's a striker FFS!

Yeah but sometimes he gets a raw deal, his game is a physical one, I would say most of the ones he gives away are 50/50 ones where the ref always sides with the defender/keeper.

I'd go for Brown too.

chiefwiggum

i was wondering how long it would take before thatcher came in....thats probably the worst foul in the history of english football

Degag

Danny Shittu IMO.

ctrl-alt-delete

chiefwiggum wrote: »

i was wondering how long it would take before thatcher came in....thats probably the worst foul in the history of english football

Definitely, he should have been jailed.

Dante

Danny Mills

greendom

Kevin Muscat - suprised he's not been mentioned yet

NinjaTruncs

Hartson, anyone?

chiefwiggum

scotty parker can put it about abit too

super_furry

John Terry, always get the impression that he's actually trying to hurt people. The fact that he always gets away with it makes it worse.

That_Guy

Surprised Barton hasn't been mentioned yet. He's not the worst tbf. It's his off pitch antics that has him under the scope.

Fromvert

Chris Morgan

greendom

That_Guy wrote: »

Surprised Barton hasn't been mentioned yet. He's not the worst tbf. It's his off pitch antics that has him under the scope.

He'd be up there with the scummiest (is that a word, it is now) I suppose

chiefwiggum

morgan was sheffield united wasn't he?

mikemac

Danny Mills

chiefwiggum

anyone remember essiens tackle on hammann in the champions league...i didnt know a leg could bend that much without breaking

Fromvert

chiefwiggum wrote: »

morgan was sheffield united wasn't he?

Yeah, suppose he didn't do to much the one year he played in the PL. Still a dirty ****er though.

DundalkDuffman

Francis Benali.

FearDark

Has to be Roy Keane, absolute thug on the pitch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRF2Zjyl29g

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=10WpPVyoAZ0

In before the "Love Keano" brigade. Man is a thug, end of.

funkyjebus

3 pages and no robbie savage. for shame;)

chiefwiggum

jesus yeah how could robbie savage be forgotten

FearDark

funkyjebus wrote: »

3 pages and no robbie savage. for shame;)

chiefwiggum wrote: »

jesus yeah how could robbie savage be forgotten

Agreed a ratty little shít at times but the dirtiest premier league player ever? No.

chiefwiggum

i hate the whole paul scholes is a great player but he just cant tackle....bull....he was a great player with a nasty little streak to go with it

allthedoyles

how about Graeme Souness ?

yabadabado

vinny jones imo was the dirtiest .the man had **** all ability and relied on reputation and dirt to get by.

chiefwiggum

allthedoyles wrote: »

how about Graeme Souness ?

souness never played in the premier league

ilovelamp2000

Stefan Postma

pwd

yabadabado wrote: »

vinny jones imo was the dirtiest .the man had **** all ability and relied on reputation and dirt to get by.

JohnnyRyan99

Has to be Keane! Although if Barton hadnt been in jail so much he'd def be up there!

therokerroar

chiefwiggum wrote: »

scotty parker can put it about abit too

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kmxTgPS5fmQ

eagle eye

Eric Cantona wins this hands down. A great, great player and I like him but he was a filthy player who often went in with both feet as well as stamping on players.

lord lucan

Lee Bowyer. Little dirtbag!

Honorary mention to Nelson Vivas!:D

ankles

Julian Dicks. Bona fide nutter. Man and ball, or preferably just man

The_Kew_Tour

chiefwiggum wrote: »

i hate the whole paul scholes is a great player but he just cant tackle....bull....he was a great player with a nasty little streak to go with it

Hi Arsene Wenger:D

nullzero

mike65 wrote: »

Blackburn Rovers.

Is that you Arsene?

nullzero

adrian280582 wrote: »

Hi Arsene Wenger:D

Bloody hell, I didn't even see this post before I made mine:pac:

nullzero

Still no mention of this git...

#15

FearDark wrote: »

Has to be Roy Keane, absolute thug on the pitch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=10WpPVyoAZ0

In before the "Love Keano" brigade. Man is a thug, end of.

Nothing at all dirty in that video. It was stupidity to rise to provocation. Stupid? Yes. Dirty? No.

I don't think anyone would deny that Keane had a dirty element to his game, but dirtiest ever premier league player is a stretch.

#15

chiefwiggum wrote: »

i hate the whole paul scholes is a great player but he just cant tackle....bull....he was a great player with a nasty little streak to go with it

He's old school dirty, rather than thug dirty.