Critical Mass

gloobag

Discovered this just now via a link in my GReader:

http://www.photolucida.org/current.php

Just wondering what people make of this sort of stuff? I'm always a bit suspicious of these "have your portfolio critiqued by pros in the industry, but for a fee" stuff. But, I have to admit, their Top 50 photographers thing has some great images in there, so I'm guessing the judges may actually know their stuff.

2010 Top 50

What Is Critical Mass?

The aim of Critical Mass, and all Photolucida programming, is to provide participants with career-building opportunities and to promote the best emerging and mid-career artists working today.

Critical Mass is a program about exposure and community. The idea is simple—photographers (from anywhere) submit a 10 image portfolio for $75. This work then gets pre-screened by a committee of approximately 20 great jurors and from there, 175 top Finalists are determined. These top Finalists then pay an additional submission fee ($200) and their work goes on to a jury of approximately 200 of the world’s best curators, editors, and other professionals who have agreed to view and vote on these Finalists. From these votes, at least one photographer is chosen to receive a book award and once the monograph is published, everyone who enters and reviews will receive a copy of the book(s).

We are pleased to continue to give scholarships to pre-selected photographers by geographical region. In previous years, Photolucida gave scholarships to photographers from Poland, Mexico, and Italy. This year, the lucky country is The Netherlands!
What to expect?

As an entrant to Critical Mass, you shouldn’t necessarily expect feedback from the jurors unless they want to contact you about doing something with your work. Jurors are given the opportunity and encouraged to provide written feedback, but we can’t guarantee anything other than:

* Everyone who enters will receive a copy of the Book Award Winner’s monograph(s).
* Everyone who enters will receive a CD containing all of the submitted work.
* Everyone who enters will have their work seen, and voted on, by the Pre-Screening committee.
* Those who continue on in the top 175 Finalists will have their work seen, and voted on, by over 200 jurors.

Click here for Critical Mass Success Stories.
Book Awards!

Photolucida will publish a monograph for at least one photographer from among the top-scoring finalists. The book award is reserved for artists without a previously published monograph. Photographers with self-published books are still eligible for the book award. If you already have a monograph, you still have over 200 great reasons to participate in Critical Mass!

CM 2009 Winners - Alejandro Cartagena, Birthe Piontek (in production)
CM 2008 Winners - Andy Freeberg, Céline Clanet, Priya Kambli
CM 2007 Winners - Joni Sternbach, Peter van Agtmael
CM 2006 Winners - Camille Seaman, Donald Weber, Amy Stein
CM 2005 Winners - Hiroshi Watanabe, Louie Palu, Sage Sohier
Click here to see!
Other Awards!

This year, in addition to the book award, Photolucida is pleased to partner with Blue Sky in offering a solo show to one of the Critical Mass Finalists. Founded in 1975 as the Oregon Center for the Photographic Arts, Blue Sky is one of the leading venues exhibiting contemporary photography in the United States.

Also this year, Photolucida is partnering with Newspace Center for Photography and RayKo Photo Center to produce a Critical Mass Top 50 Exhibit. Newspace is a non-profit organization dedicated to promoting photographic education, with a wonderful exhibition space. RayKo is also a public photographic facility with a beautiful gallery.

Both exhibits will take place in April 2011, coinciding with Photolucida’s Reviews.

Also, in conjunction with photo-eye, three of the Top 50 photographers will receive complimentary VisualServer websites and portfolios on photo-eye’s Photographer’s Showcase for one year.

Photolucida will also award five free spots in our April 2011 Portfolio Reviews! These awards will go to five randomly selected photographers in the Finalist group. For more information on our quick-to-sell-out biennial event, click here!
Procedure

Critical Mass has a two-part submission process.

1. First you pay a $75 registration fee to upload your images and text. We will then format your work and distribute the pages to the pre-screeners for scoring.

The 2010 Pre-Screening committee comprises the following people (as of July 26):
* Leslie K. Brown, Independent Curator
* Crista Dix, Director, wall space Gallery
* John Feinstein, Curatorial Director, Humble Arts Foundation
* Melanie Flood, Melanie Flood Projects/Portland Art Museum Photo Council
* Roy Flukinger, Research Curator of Photography, Harry Ransom Center
* Cherie Hiser, Photoludica Board
* Tricia Hoffman, Photolucida Programs Coordinator
* Jim Leisy, Portland Art Museum Photo Council
* Stu Levy, Photoludica Board/Portland Art Museum Photo Council
* Kate Menconeri, Independent Curator
* Laura Moya, Director, Photolucida
* Claire Annette Mussard, Curator/Consultant
* Ruben Natal-San Miguel, Collector
* Shawn Records, Photolucida Board
* Tina Schelhorm, Director, Galerie Lichtblick
* P. Elaine Sharpe, Independent Curator
* George Slade, Curator/Program Manager, Photographic Resource Center
* Christina Spielvogel, Blue Sky Exhibition Committee
* Susan Spiritus, Founder/Director, Susan Spiritus Gallery
* Paula Tognarelli, Executive Director, Griffin Museum for Photography
* Laura Valenti, Program Director, Newspace Center for Photography
* Bryan Wolf, Photolucida Board
2. If you are one of the top 175 photographers chosen by the pre-screeners, then you will pay an additional $200 fee and your work will be sent out to the full panel of over 200 jurors.

200 Jurors!

Like last year, this is a truly international group of jurors representing a wide variety of photographic interests. The full list of jurors will be available shortly – we have made a great effort to represent the range of professional affiliation (gallery owners, curators, publishers, editors, etc.). In addition to seeing the work during the online process, jurors will also be sent a CD of the Finalists’ work, which serves as a good reference tool in a multitude of ways.

Note: Critical Mass jurors are not allowed to submit their own work to Critical Mass.
Online Submissions

Download and print this pdf with clear instructions on how to enter.

Photolucida reserves the right to reproduce all work submitted for Critical Mass in the materials distributed to Critical Mass jurors and participating photographers. One may not pull work from Critical Mass once it has been submitted. Photolucida reserves the right to reproduce submitted work in announcements, catalogs, web sites and publications that report on or promote our programming. Any necessary permissions required to use images of people and/or property are the responsibility of the photographer. Submission of an entry to this program signifies acceptance of all conditions stated.

Captain Flaps

I came in here expecting to hear about a really important church service. Thread did not deliver.

Merrion

Captain Flaps wrote: »

Thread did not deliver.

It has now delivered "critical", but not Mass.