Lou Macari Award for Most Biased Poster - Please Vote!

SlickRic

and so we continue...

we've narrowed this down to 4 candidates...

The Lou Macari Award for 'Most Biased Poster'

Nominees:

Mr Alan
Homerjay2005
Le King
BERBA

the choice is yours...and keep it clean!

goddevil

I think its quite unfair to Compare Mr Alan with the likes of BERBA... I lurk around here a lot and i have never found Mr Alan posting biased comments in the United thread... To be fair to him, he always provides insightful posts and is always up for a good debate if his posts are challenged. He is also gracious enough to accept defeat. He's one of the better rival posters.

To compare him with the likes of BERBA who just winds people up and takes cheap digs at rival supporters with his insensitive posts while disappearing when spurs are doing badly - is not right imo

OPENROAD

Le King

Why are votes all public?

SlickRic

Homerjay2005

OPENROAD wrote: »

Why are votes all public?

why not?

everyone should be able to stand over their vote.

SlickRic

Homerjay2005

goddevil wrote: »

I think its quite unfair to Compare Mr Alan with the likes of BERBA... I lurk around here a lot and i have never found Mr Alan posting biased comments in the United thread... To be fair to him, he always provides insightful posts and is always up for a good debate if his posts are challenged. He is also gracious enough to accept defeat. He's one of the better rival posters.

To compare him with the likes of BERBA who just winds people up and takes cheap digs at rival supporters with his insensitive posts while disappearing when spurs are doing badly - is not right imo

i know what you mean, and i agree, but there are different kind of bias.

this doesn't mean to say that they equate in terms of quality in their posts, it's simply comparing them in terms of how biased they are; which is very different.

you'll notice that Mr Alan wasn't nominated for shít-stirrer as proof of that.

OPENROAD

Le King

SlickRic wrote: »

why not?

everyone should be able to stand over their vote.

More so in the **** stirrer category though, some might get the hump, just a thought anyway.;)

Necronomicon

I was just about to say something similar to Slick. I don't think saying someone is biased is necessarily bad - you can be biased but still be a very good poster. Mr Alan and homerjay2005 are quite biased but are also two of my favourite posters.

ilovelamp2000

Homerjay2005

I mainly stick to the LFC superthread so Mr. Alan gets this by a mile.

I think "Ludicrous" is his first name.

3hn2givr7mx1sc

Le King

Necronomicon wrote: »

I was just about to say something similar to Slick. I don't think saying someone is biased is necessarily bad - you can be biased but still be a very good poster. Mr Alan and homerjay2005 are quite biased but are also two of my favourite posters.

Homerjay2005 is a great poster, but I do laugh at his bias.:D

racso1975

Homerjay2005

Mr alan. He'd told me his dna is liverpool

BERBA

Homerjay2005

goddevil wrote: »

I
To compare him with the likes of BERBA who just winds people up and takes cheap digs at rival supporters with his insensitive posts while disappearing when spurs are doing badly - is not right imo

chri$t i've been there in the good times and bad as a spud , whats this about disappearing? bit harsh

Nalz

at the risk of breaking one of my own rules, what the fook is all this ****

seriously

The Muppet

Homerjay2005

OPENROAD wrote: »

More so in the **** stirrer category though, some might get the hump, just a thought anyway.;)

It's only a bit of a laugh, I doubt anyone's going to take the hump over it, I certainly won't.

Nailz

Never saw Mr. Alan as biased at all to be honesty! Well, maybe a little, as we all are, but not enough to constitute being nominated for this prestigious award - BERBA walks this one for me.

And Lou Macari is biased, but couldn't hold a candle to this man;

JimsAlterEgo

Homerjay2005

Alan Benitez

101001

not sure Mr. Alan belongs on this list. Bias implies a lack of logic and a complete lack of recognition of possible alternatives. Mr. Alan has his opinions and fights them but if you engage in a reasonable discussion Ive found that he can see a valid point.

keane2097

Homerjay2005

Is there some way we can get a minus 1 on the Mr Alan count? I accidentally voted for him while browsing on the phone - my fingers must be getting fat...

IvySlayer

keane2097 wrote: »

Is there some way we can get a minus 1 on the Mr Alan count? I accidentally voted for him while browsing on the phone - my fingers must be getting fat...

Who were you voting for? Someone who was going to vote for Mr Alan can vote for your guy therefore leveling it.

SlickRic

Homerjay2005

keane2097 wrote: »

Is there some way we can get a minus 1 on the Mr Alan count? I accidentally voted for him while browsing on the phone - my fingers must be getting fat...

i don't think so, but i can take it into account at the end.

who do you want to vote for instead?

keane2097

Homerjay2005

SlickRic wrote: »

i don't think so, but i can take it into account at the end.

who do you want to vote for instead?

TY, was going to vote for Le King.

flahavaj

Homerjay2005

Voting for Mr Alan in the most respectful way possible, he's a great supporter of his team who always backs up his views with good arguments. Theres nothing wrong with being biased in favour of your team tbh,I miss him a lot around here, when Mr Alans is posting life is rarely dull. He should really be in the Best Poster as well actually and have his ban cancelled or something. Make him use a Utd Sig for the duration of his ban instead.:pac:

pickarooney

Poll is missing redout. I shall not vote.

Le King

keane2097 wrote: »

TY, was going to vote for Le King.

Thanks, bud

SlickRic

Homerjay2005

bump!

just in case some haven't voted, all welcome!