X Factor 2011 (UK show)

Deeper Blue

Janet was good but it was hardly rock now was it?

dee.

Sammi looks gorgeous without makeup...they need to get new makeup artists/stylists for sure.

edit: okay she looked better in the pink top with her hair tied back

ibarelycare

"I'll sit in the head judges seat"...Gary's a f*cking tosser.

Handsome Bob

"I sit in the head judges seat"

STFU Gary

xsiborg

Gary just said there he wouldn't give one of his acts an old song, and yet that exactly what he HAS done!

ibarelycare

Oh I need to eat my words, it IS the Cher version. Is that rock??? Terrible choice, there are thousands of songs she could have sung instead of this.

LizT

mr kr0nik wrote: »

Think i'll do a Bill O'Herlihy and throw this out to the panel.

I think one of Louies acts will win this yearr. The reason, he has had the modt experience of this competition of will be able to manage his acts better when the pressure really starts.

now discuss (swivels on chair and plays with pen)

Nope. You can be the best mentor but you need to have the talent in your category and I don't think Louis does, apart from Kitty who doesn't have the popularity to win.

dee.

I feel bad for Sammi, you'd think Louis would let her do something different if shes comfortable

SeaFields

emeraldstar wrote: »

No.

hmm...thought that was the case. Anyway, just a small issue.

py2006

Belly wobble!

dee.

Of course Louis would pick this song........dear god.

Biggins

Meh!

Kiwi_knock

That was some awkward dancing at the start

Min

Good song choice by Louis.

LizT

Meh. Possibly in trouble in this week

xsiborg

christ, sack the "stylist" already!

Handsome Bob

Poor arrangement of the song, needs more build up to the chorous. Underwhelming unfortunately.

Cupcake_Crisis

Sami looks fantastic! But that's hardly a rock song...

RonBo88

gary is a smug cnut

Busi_Girl08

That dress is horrendous

And I agree with everything Gary says. She is kicking arsee though.

Deeper Blue

A bit boring imo

Kiwi_knock

Still not a rock song

py2006

Some girls should wear skirts and some girls shouldn't!

ibarelycare

Sami's a great singer. I hate that I'm going to be agreeing with Gary though, that this is cruise-ship. Cher should never be covered by an artist that wants to be "current"

mr kr0nik

lizt wrote: »

Nope. You can be the best mentor but you need to have the talent in your category and I don't think Louis does, apart from Kitty who doesn't have the popularity to win.

Okily dokily then.

bets a big battleships appears during song

keps

I'd say it's awful - but then again i'm watching Merlin:)

Paparazzo

mr kr0nik wrote: »

Think i'll do a Bill O'Herlihy and throw this out to the panel.

I think one of Louies acts will win this yearr. The reason, he has had the modt experience of this competition of will be able to manage his acts better when the pressure really starts.

now discuss (swivels on chair and plays with pen)

One thing for sure, if I wanted a career and to make some cash, I'd want to be one of Louis' acts!

SeaFields

Karaoke central!

_Kaiser_

Poor .. she looks awful and uncomfortable and (maybe it was my tv?) half the early part of the song was very mumbly?

dee.

Her outfit isn't flattering at all, you could see her belly through the top when the light was on it. The song was awful for her.