X Factor 2011 (UK show)

phasers · 30-10-2011 9:30pm

LOL at Nicole standing there awkwardly after her song

emeraldstar · 30-10-2011 9:30pm

Didn't give Nicole much talk time either.

Captain Cesc · 30-10-2011 9:30pm

Miming

dee. · 30-10-2011 9:30pm

She looked so bored at the end there when she started bopping up and down lol

rebel girl 15 · 30-10-2011 9:30pm

Wow, is this the first break or the second one?? Amazing if it is only the first one - haven't been paying much attention!

woodoo · 30-10-2011 9:31pm

These established names show why the x factor generally fails to get a successful winner.

We judge on a persons ability to sing perfect live. Its not really about that though really. Its about getting someone who can record sellable records in the studio.

Someone missing a few notes live on this show gets voted off.

Some of the biggest selling stars aren't all that great live.

Biggins · 30-10-2011 9:31pm

rebel girl 15 wrote: »

Wow, is this the first break or the second one?? Amazing if it is only the first one - haven't been paying much attention!

Second.

emeraldstar · 30-10-2011 9:31pm

phasers wrote: »

LOL at Nicole standing there awkwardly after her song

While bouncing up and down?!

dee. · 30-10-2011 9:31pm

Min wrote: »

I would have loved to have Nicole over Kelly anyday on the UK X factor.

Same, ever since she was a guest judge on XF UK (last year I think?) I was hoping she would come to XF UK

LizT · 30-10-2011 9:32pm

3ndahalfof6 wrote: »

OK I got a wee bit excited, super star will have to do.

I red somewhere old wrinkled people don't like her.

I am neither wrinkled nor old and I don't like her.

emeraldstar · 30-10-2011 9:32pm

woodoo wrote: »

Someone missing a few notes live on this show gets voted off.

Eh, no they don't!

mr kr0nik · 30-10-2011 9:32pm

dee. wrote: »

Not memorable but she has a great voice IMO

thats down to a great pair of...lungs

ibarelycare · 30-10-2011 9:32pm

Min wrote: »

I would have loved to have Nicole over Kelly anyday on the UK X factor.

Have you seen her on the US version? She's crap. She comes out with generic and meaningless comments and so far her song choices have been awful. Kelly annoys me but I think she's a far better judge and mentor.

emeraldstar · 30-10-2011 9:33pm

dee. wrote: »

Same, ever since she was a guest judge on XF UK (last year I think?) I was hoping she would come to XF UK

No way. I did think she was alright when she guest-judged on XF UK, but she's awful on XF USA.

LizT · 30-10-2011 9:33pm

Min wrote: »

I would have loved to have Nicole over Kelly anyday on the UK X factor.

She's not that good on the X factor USA though.

Paparazzo · 30-10-2011 9:34pm

woodoo wrote: »

These established names show why the x factor generally fails to get a successful winner.

We judge on a persons ability to sing perfect live. Its not really about that though really. Its about getting someone who can record sellable records in the studio.

Someone missing a few notes live on this show gets voted off.

Some of the biggest selling stars aren't all that great live.

Plenty of what's considered best acts of all time wouldn't get past the first round.

Cupcake_Crisis · 30-10-2011 9:34pm

woodoo wrote: »

Someone missing a few notes live on this show gets voted off.

Frankie.

cgpg5 · 30-10-2011 9:34pm

lizt wrote: »

She's not that good on the X factor USA though.

Agree, I expected her to be much better, she's a massive disappointment tbh

dee. · 30-10-2011 9:34pm

emeraldstar wrote: »

No way. I did think she was alright when she guest-judged on XF UK, but she's awful on XF USA.

Haven't watched much of her on XF USA so I can't say. I usually just catch up on the YouTube clips which don't show the judges comments. Is she that bad?

rebel girl 15 · 30-10-2011 9:35pm

Biggins wrote: »

Second.

Thanks Biggins - was wondering alright!

Please let it be Frankie and Janet in the bottom 2! Don't think it will be though - could see Kitty being there again this week, maybe Sophie or Little Mix

phasers · 30-10-2011 9:35pm

woodoo wrote: »

These established names show why the x factor generally fails to get a successful winner.

We judge on a persons ability to sing perfect live. Its not really about that though really. Its about getting someone who can record sellable records in the studio.

Someone missing a few notes live on this show gets voted off.

Some of the biggest selling stars aren't all that great live.

Then explain Frankie and Janet.

3ndahalfof6 · 30-10-2011 9:35pm

lizt wrote: »

I am neither wrinkled nor old and I don't like her.

you might be some day and then you can really shout it from the tree tops

emeraldstar · 30-10-2011 9:35pm

Cupcake_Crisis wrote: »

Frankie.

Jedward... Wagner...

mr kr0nik · 30-10-2011 9:35pm

Paparazzo wrote: »

Plenty of what's considered best acts of all time wouldn't get past the first round.

probably because they wouldnt be seen dead on the show.

Biggins · 30-10-2011 9:36pm

rebel girl 15 wrote: »

Thanks Biggins - was wondering alright!

Please let it be Frankie and Janet in the bottom 2! Don't think it will be though - could see Kitty being there again this week.

If you trust the papers (LOL) The Mirror says Frankie has a 70% chance of being one of them!

PLEASE BE RIGHT!!!

dee. · 30-10-2011 9:36pm

rebel girl 15 wrote: »

Thanks Biggins - was wondering alright!

Please let it be Frankie and Janet in the bottom 2! Don't think it will be though - could see Kitty being there again this week.

Looking back I think Frankie & Janet should be bottom two also, but I doubt Janet will be.

barleybooley · 30-10-2011 9:36pm

Jedward have to be one of the most successful acts to come out of it though...

R.D. aka MR.D · 30-10-2011 9:36pm

i want the risk to go

ibarelycare · 30-10-2011 9:36pm

You could turn Misha upside down and sweep the road with her hair!

R.D. aka MR.D · 30-10-2011 9:37pm

Kitty's looking well there

X Factor 2011 (UK show)

Comments