Thoghts on River Song

mach1982

The first time Amy meets River is in Flesh and stone this before the Doctor reboots the Universe. She says the next time they meet will be when the Pardorica opens this when the Doctor reboots the universe , which creates a new reality, and we learn time can be rewritten , therefore if time can rewritten, dose this mean that the Doctor might be able to save River in Library and is this the River the 10th Doctor meets?. Also the Doctor calls Amy by her Surname Pond , and Pond = River , so River real name is Song River ( Melody Pond ) so he calls both Mother and daughter by their surname .

In Flesh and Stone , the clerics know who and what River is ie Amy's Daughter and a Time Lady ,and know about the Doctor. Current events are a part of their history .River chooses to be placed in the stormchage as she knows how dangerous she is.It's self exile. I think the River we see at moment is a bit like 9th Doctor or jenny both born in war, and after spending time with the 11th doctor learn to be more human like Rose did for the 10th.
The when the 10th doctor meets River in Forest of the Dead, she compare diary's , and seem to think that he's a future version as she ask if they did the "Crash of Bayantzium "
If she saw the 11th killed in 1969, she know that not he did regenerate . Also when talking to Rory he ask if there two are Doctors and she said No , but said something like "that would a different Birthday altogether". So i think it's the doctors Gangger that get killed ,by an Young River, as when the River shoot at the astronaut and it doses not hit she says " of course not" as she has already experience this event .The ganner who is the Doctor is also a good man. Everyone thinks she killed the Doctor , which takes the heat off him, as they are arid of him , so he a rive a fee to travel .

I love to know Rivers Time line , what age was she when died? How may times did she regenerate ?

BaconZombie

Cyndaquil

mach1982 wrote: »

If she saw the 11th killed in 1969, she know that not he did regenerate . Also when talking to Rory he ask if there two are Doctors and she said No , but said something like "that would a different Birthday altogether". So i think it's the doctors Gangger that get killed ,by an Young River, as when the River shoot at the astronaut and it doses not hit she says " of course not" as she has already experience this event .The ganner who is the Doctor is also a good man. Everyone thinks she killed the Doctor , which takes the heat off him, as they are arid of him , so he a rive a fee to travel .

Not sure about Ganger Doctor theory - it seems too obvious an answer. Plus wouldn't he have dissolved into that gooey-liquid when shot? (that said maybe The Doctor found some way of stabilizing the ganger form). Would he have the ability to regenerate? (Yes he remembered previous incarnations but that only means he had access to 11's memories).

Feral Mutant

Cyndaquil wrote: »

Not sure about Ganger Doctor theory - it seems too obvious an answer. Plus wouldn't he have dissolved into that gooey-liquid when shot? (that said maybe The Doctor found some way of stabilizing the ganger form). Would he have the ability to regenerate? (Yes he remembered previous incarnations but that only means he had access to 11's memories).

Someone asked Moffat about that on twitter before.

so hopefully it's something bettter than that.

Also, while we're on the subject of Moffat's twitter feed in a thead about River Song, this amused me

cloud493

Maybe rivers more in on the doctors plan than they said? She's from his future, maybe she knows things. If it was a ganger doctor, she might have been in on it.

DirtyBollox

Just thought of it now. River herself said that she was in jail for killing "a good man", wasnt the last episode before the split called "A good man goes to war" now say if i am wrong but wasnt that episode referring to rory?

ríomhaire

Well in Let's Kill Hitler

the guys in the robot are under the impression that River killed the Doctor in Utah.