Most Overrated Musicians/Groups

saywhatyousee

filthymcnasty wrote: »

You're not right in the head

Coming from the man that said Bob Marley

Saila

Doctor Jimbob wrote:

I don't like the stone roses though.
Never has such a pish band got so much recognition. With most bands i can at least understand why some people like them. But the stone roses? No. Just no. Fuck right off Ian Brown.

a bit like velvet underground, most bands today from britian wouldnt be around without them and they paved the way for them and the whole madchester scene

Saila

Doctor Jimbob wrote: »

Well, I can understand that I suppose. Still think they're an awful band though.

compared to?

filthymcnasty

saywhatyousee wrote: »

Coming from the man that said Bob Marley

Yeah I sure did - a pile of shiite, like all reggae.

MrStuffins

filthymcnasty wrote: »

Yeah I sure did - a pile of shiite, like all reggae.

Comments like this disqualify you from giving your opinion on any music.

Saila

Doctor Jimbob wrote: »

Anything. Well. I'll make obvious exceptions for Beiber and the like.
I'm not just trying to be over the top here. I really think they're one of the most mind numbingly boring things I could listen to.
But that's all my opinion. I'm not saying anyone else is wrong to like them, just that I don't get it

challenge accepted..:)

skip to 3min 30 after you listen to the first 1 min or so for the first one

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6QnK0yql8s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FuPfbfJm2rc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qTpxRycvfYs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ZQ4HJPVoTw

MyPeopleDrankTheSoup

The National and James Blake

And probably The Beatles, who were unreal obviously but the thread title is overrated, and the way some people talk about them you'd think all recorded music should have stopped in 1970. Mostly from 'fake' music fans like Ryan Tubridy who like bands he thinks he's supposed to like.

Freddie59

georgiecasey wrote: »

The National and James Blake

And probably The Beatles, who were unreal obviously but the thread title is overrated, and the way some people talk about them you'd think all recorded music should have stopped in 1970. Mostly from 'fake' music fans like Ryan Tubridy who like bands he thinks he's supposed to like.

I would agree with that. Unfortunately there are an awful lot of Beatles and Dylan fans who look down their noses at everyone else. ME? I'm a MUSIC fan. I thought the Stones were way better.:)

Welruc

The majority of this thread is utter tripe!!!
Where are ye getting these ratings from anyway? And then how do you decide if it's too high?
Seems to me like its "lets pick a few bands that have been very successful and then say they are crap" sortra vibe.

Some of the names that have been thrown in here as been overrated makes my head hurt.

Thread should be remaned "Really successful bands that i dont like"

Donal Og O Baelach

The Republic of Loose.

Ohh Yeeeaaawwwwwggghhhh. Oooooooeeeeghhh!.

Always sounds like he's on the toilet fighting a terminal case of constipation.

Sky King

Coldplay.

If their music was food it would be ricecakes.

30txsbzmcu2k9w

partyguinness wrote: »

Nirvana...never been convinced.

The old adage that dying can be the best career move springs to mind.

I was not an angsty teenager so maybe I just don't get it.

Ugh... Fair enough you're entitled to your opinion but conceited nonsense like this does my head in.
Plus the career move thing is a bit out of wack with Nirvana being the biggest band in the world for the 2/3 years previous to Cobains suicide.
Great band IMO. Totally shook up the music industry.

Dudess

deuceswild wrote: »

The majority of this thread is utter tripe!!!
Where are ye getting these ratings from anyway? And then how do you decide if it's too high?
Seems to me like its "lets pick a few bands that have been very successful and then say they are crap" sortra vibe.

Some of the names that have been thrown in here as been overrated makes my head hurt.

Thread should be remaned "Really successful bands that i dont like"

These threads always turn into "xyz I simply dislike personally". Always surprises me how many folks miss a basic point.
Cher Lloyd and Justin Bieber - wtf?!
Presume the inclusion of Crystal Swing is a joke.
And of course the "I can say whomever I want is over-rated but damn anyone who dares say MY favourite acts are over-rated" phenomenon.

Badgermonkey

brummytom wrote: »

Definitely Bob Dylan.
I saw him at the London Feis in June. Walked off to the Saw Doctors instead - great decision.

Now I'm no fan of Dylan, but the Saw Doctors are Supermacs in musical form.

adomino

most 'The ........' bands

paulosham

The Hype

Junco Partner

the pistols - fair enough they kicked off the uk punk scene but they folded after eighteen months and their 2nd bassist couldnt even play. they didnt have half the intelligence or message of other groups like the clash who have basically been forgotten even though they brought so much to the table in comparison to the pistols.

bob marley- how many of you have had this conversation 'hey you ever listen to reggae?" "yeah man i love bob marley like" "ever listen to the maytals or dillinger?" "who.....?" does my head in. yes he was brilliant and i love his music he's in my top five but there's so much more reggae out there if you just listen.

storker

Not in order of overratedness...

1. Pink Floyd
2. The Divine Comedy
3. Coldplay
4. The Beatles
5. Any singer who performs with a backing dance troupe
6. Boy/girl groups with the exception of those from the Motown era.
7. Oasis

Stork

newmug

U2:mad:

I just cant believe how much they're NOT being mentioned on this thread! Their music is pure sh1te. The Edges "guitar style" sounds the way it does, because he just cant play! Its all single string plucking stuck into an echo machine! They've been playing the same crap 3 songs with different crap lyrics since they started! Bono is the most anti-humble, anti-sound, attention seeking gobsh1te in the music world. He'd eat sh1te and say it was for charity as long as the spotlight was on him, and he can't sing for skins! He "talks" out in a long, breathy, Dylan style, with the odd attempt at hitting high scrapey sounding notes at the end, to just about qualify their noise as a song instead of a talked-out poem

--Kaiser--

Anyone putting The Beatles down as overrated:

1) Are trying to be different/cool/interesting (you're not)
2) Have only heard their earlier stuff, 'She Loves You' etc (which is still brilliant)
or
3) Have some sort of brain disease

That is all

St.Spodo

Red Hot Chilli Peppers. I can't their their music seriously. What American state are they from, btw? They haven't taken the opportunity to tell us in about 15 songs. I wish they'd bore off with their frivolous music.

Arcade Fire: Indulgent hipster rubbish.

In fact any band that aspire to be nothing more than pretentious, elitist and 'indie' have my contempt.

Biggins

Elvis.
The Beatles.
Oasis.
Beyonce.
...And as for Cher Lloyd - PURE SCHITE!!!

Junco Partner

St.Spodo wrote: »

. What American state are they from, btw? They haven't taken the opportunity to tell us in about 15 songs.

You have heard under the bridge haven't you? "the city i live in the city of angels." that should make it fairly obvious where they're from.

Dudess

Biggins wrote: »

Elvis.
The Beatles.
Oasis.
Beyonce.
...And as for Cher Lloyd - PURE SCHITE!!!

Anyone into music knows that - she's hardly over-rated.

For me it's REM. I like some sings by them, but overall, I find them really boring.

shamrock55

bob dylan
oasis
rolling stones
nirvana
lady gaga
rhianna

i could go on...

boobar

The Doors
Stall The Digger
Joan Armatrading

W123-80's

Dana
Richie Kavanagh

Welruc

Biggins wrote: »

Elvis.
The Beatles.
Oasis.
Beyonce.
...And as for Cher Lloyd - PURE SCHITE!!!

Maybe the only time in the history of the internet that cher lloyd is rated along side the beatles

I pretty certain she is not over rated as she is hardly rated at all.

St.Spodo

f0ggy92 wrote: »

You have heard under the bridge haven't you? "the city i live in the city of angels." that should make it fairly obvious where they're from.

I know, Californication, Dani California, Under the Bridge, Out in L.A all refer to it. That was my(sarcastic) point!

Orando Broom

newmug wrote: »

U2:mad:

The Edges "guitar style" sounds the way it does, because he just cant play! Its all single string plucking stuck into an echo machine!

There is nothing wrong with an echo machine...echo machine...echo machine...echo machine...echo machine...

Orando Broom

Dudess wrote: »

For me it's REM. I like some sings by them, but overall, I find them really boring.

Some sings staywnge in ze neighbourhudt!

Oranage2

Surely after 10 pages somebody has said snow patrol?


Aslan

Wibbs

Sky King wrote: »

Coldplay.

U2 lite.

Freddie59 wrote: »

I would agree with that. Unfortunately there are an awful lot of Beatles and Dylan fans who look down their noses at everyone else. ME? I'm a MUSIC fan. I thought the Stones were way better.:)

I love the Stones. Big fan of a lot of their output, but "better" is very subjective. On the songwriting, innovation, evolution and sheer quality of output year after year for only 7 years front the Beatles were/are objectively better. Plus they did the decent thing and gave up on a high(and turned down crazy amounts of money in the 70's to reform). The Stones and many others became watered down cabaret parodies of themselves. U2 a good example of that. If they'd called it a day 15 years ago, they'd be a lot more liked and respected.

Pink Floyd I never really "got" TBH. I wouldn't say overrated. Well up to a certain point anyway. Another band who wobbled on after they had passed their best.

Badgermonkey

I honestly have no idea who Cher Lloyd is.

By the sounds of it, I should keep it that way.

Logical Fallacy

Orando Broom wrote: »

There is nothing wrong with an echo machine...echo machine...echo machine...echo machine...echo machine...

Oh stop being so heinous....einous....einous....einous.

Adele.
Yeah we get it.. He broke up with you because you are fat. Build a bridge and run across it a few times. Its the same structure for almost every song. Bores the tits off me.

Biffy Clyro.
Syrupy bollox aimed at kids who want to be 'Alt'

Kings of Leon.
Immense first and second albums but then they turned into a pop band.

The Coronas
My mammy was Mary Black. Give me a record deal roysh so I can sing ****e songs about my J1er and playing songs on my guitar for the girlies at house parties... ****.

Oasis
Im a fan but in fairness they are over rated for what they offer musically.

Junco Partner

St.Spodo wrote: »

I know, Californication, Dani California, Under the Bridge, Out in L.A all refer to it. That was my(sarcastic) point!

ah i see text makes sarcasm harder to spot.

markesmith

Snow Patrol, Mumford & Sons...easy targets really.

Always felt the Rolling Stones were a bit overrated. I love Beggar's Banquet and Exile on Main Street, but a lot of their stuff is just foppy Englishmen playing ouija board with the Delta Blues masters, and the last decent album they made was in the late '70s.

The Smiths have two or three good songs, they get way too much credit. The Queen is dead is heralded as a classic, but 'Frankly Mister Shankly' is an abomination and there's several other weak tracks on there.

Elvis, after his early stuff, was sh1te. The Who, with a couple exceptional tracks aside, aren't all that great in the studio. Prince has some class tunes, but 'Sign O The Times' is not a classic album, despite the critics.

My Bloody Valentine never did it for me either.

CHealy

Useless thread.

Everyone has their own style in music, one persons "best band ever" is anothers headwrecker.

Im a big big fan of Oasis, Stone Roses, but another person might be big into dubstep or something completely different.

Dudess

Yeah, never understood the MBV thing, bar the odd number by them.

Dudess

W123-80's wrote: »

Dana
Richie Kavanagh

Who over-rates these?

Balmed Out

The Ramones

JJJJNR

White Stripes

Naomi00

partyguinness wrote: »

1. Red Hot Chilli Peppers...I mean they are just a joke band IMO....I cannot take them serious.

2. Foo Fighters....see above.

It's music for simpletons.

Have you ever heard an album or read any lyrics?

I think you're just repeating things you've heard, making you the 'simpleton' :rolleyes:

Foo Fighters are really talented musicians. You obviously don't know a lot about music because even if they weren't your type of band you'd still admit that they have two of the best drummers in the world. I don't care if you don't like them but calling them overrated is stupid.

A pop band like Kings of Leon being treated as a proper band is what being overrated is.

Wattle

Arcade Fire. I'm not saying their rubbish. I actually like some of their songs but their just not as brilliant as some people say they are.

Donal Og O Baelach

The Manic Street Preachers - pseudo intellectuals playing to the gallery.

Morrisey

Logical Fallacy

Wattle wrote: »

Arcade Fire. I'm not saying their rubbish. I actually like some of their songs but their just not as brilliant as some people say they are.

I'd agree with Arcade Fire i must say. I just never really saw what the fuss was about. A lot of their tunes are very similar to stuff that was previously done by the likes of The New Pornographers.

It's just the same basic guitar music that has been done for a long time by a lot of people, the drum work is normally pretty pedestrian.

W123-80's

Dudess wrote: »

Who over-rates these?

Anybody who has ever parted with their hard earned cash on either of these websites..!

http://www.dana-music.com/

http://www.richiekavanagh.ie/the-music/

If only 2 people buy from those websites, then its over rated.!

parrai

Logical Fallacy wrote: »

I'd agree with Arcade Fire i must say. I just never really saw what the fuss was about. A lot of their tunes are very similar to stuff that was previously done by the likes of The New Pornographers.

It's just the same basic guitar music that has been done for a long time by a lot of people, the drum work is normally pretty pedestrian.

:pac:

Dudess

Plenty of people know they're sh1t. This thread is about acts you hear nothing but praise for.
If it was just about sh1t acts, it would be named as such.