McGeady is class - discuss

DOC09UNAM

the realpigiron wrote: »

DOC09UNAM wrote: »

people criticize him because for the large part, he's fairly ****.

You're entitled to you're opinion but you're wrong bud. In fact i'd safely say you haven't a balls notion what you are talking about.

Says the man who claims irish people dislike him because they hate celtic for some reason, lol.

Celtic supporter?

lordgoat

the realpigiron wrote: »

You're entitled to you're opinion but you're wrong bud. In fact i'd safely say you haven't a balls notion what you are talking about.

You're entitled to your opinion but you're wrong bud. He's sh-ite. In fact i'd safely say you haven't a balls notion what you are talking about.

As good an argument as a footballer McGeady is tbh.

NufcNavan

You'd swear we have a huge list of world class left wingers in the squad waiting to take McGeady's place.

And no, Hunt is not a better player than McGeady.

lordgoat

NufcNavan wrote: »

You'd swear we have a huge list of world class left wingers in the squad waiting to take McGeady's place.

And no, Hunt is not a better player than McGeady.

No but Coleman and Duff are.

Helix

why does everyone keep saying balls notion?

NufcNavan

lordgoat wrote: »

No but Coleman and Duff are.

Duff already plays. It would be a bold move to try and get him to play on both wings. Not sure that it would work.

Coleman will probably replace Duff after the Euros.

Broxi_Bear_Eire

This discussion seems to have taken a turn from is McGeady world class to should he be in the Ireland team
Well for me he isn't world class but he should be in the Ireland team we don't have an abundance of players for that position

clubberlang12

NufcNavan wrote: »

Duff already plays. It would be a bold move to try and get him to play on both wings. Not sure that it would work.

Coleman will probably replace Duff after the Euros.

So now Duff is going to be past it after the Euro's. FFS.

Duff (left wing) + Coleman (right wing) > McGeady (left) + Duff (right)

NufcNavan

clubberlang12 wrote: »

So now Duff is going to be past it after the Euro's. FFS.

Duff (left wing) + Coleman (right wing) > McGeady (left) + Duff (right)

Use a bit of common sense. Duff is likely to retire from international football after the Euros.

lordgoat

NufcNavan wrote: »

Duff already plays. It would be a bold move to try and get him to play on both wings. Not sure that it would work.

Coleman will probably replace Duff after the Euros.

Duff on one wing (L) and Coleman on the other (R), tis not difficult to figure out.

However Duff on both wings would probably be a shade better than McGeady. At least he wouldn't be out of position as much!

clubberlang12

Has he told you he is going to retire? Until he comes and states why would you presume it. He's playing club football week in, week out......is a first teamer in the national.

NufcNavan

clubberlang12 wrote: »

Has he told you he is going to retire? Until he comes and states why would you presume it. He's playing club football week in, week out......is a first teamer in the national.

Well done Captain Obvious. Another thing you should acknowledge is that he is currently 32. He will be 33 when the Euros are taking place, which will susbsequently mean he will be 35 when WC2014 is on. Highly unlikely that he will play beyond the Euros and common sense would point towards his retirement.

And regarding Coleman, I'm sure Trappatoni will play him in friendlies between now and the Euros. He will get a fair chance along with McCarthy etc.

clubberlang12

I'd rather be "obvious" than "presumptuous".

NufcNavan

clubberlang12 wrote: »

I'd rather be "obvious" than "presumptuous".

Ok.

Laois_Man

Not only do I not believe McGeady is world class, I don't even believe he should be in the starting 11.

Move Duff to the left and let Laurence and Coleman slog it out for the right side position sounds better to me!

PARKHEAD67

Laois_Man wrote: »

Not only do I not believe McGeady is world class, I don't even believe he should be in the starting 11.

Move Duff to the left and let Laurence and Coleman slog it out for the right side position sounds better to me!

Sweet mother of Christ.I think Im gonna puke.The ignorance is making my stomach heave.

Vanbis

Laois_Man wrote: »

Not only do I not believe McGeady is world class, I don't even believe he should be in the starting 11.

Move Duff to the left and let Laurence and Coleman slog it out for the right side position sounds better to me!

I'd agree, he was next to useless against Andorra but a little better last night. He's a headless chicken with the ball most of the time. I'd have Hunt or Coleman starting ahead of him everytime.

PARKHEAD67

Vanbis wrote: »

I'd agree, he was next to useless against Andorra but a little better last night. He's a headless chicken with the ball most of the time. I'd have Hunt or Coleman starting ahead of him everytime.

If your not a stand-up comedian, you should be.Love your sense of humour(or stupidity):rolleyes:

Vanbis

PARKHEAD67 wrote: »

If your not a stand-up comedian, you should be.Love your sense of humour(or stupidity):rolleyes:

The only comedian here is yourself if you seriously believe Mcgeady is world class But your a Celtic fan so it's hardly suprising :rolleyes:

PARKHEAD67

Vanbis wrote: »

The only comedian here is yourself if you seriously believe Mcgeady is world class But your a Celtic fan so it's hardly suprising :rolleyes:

Yes, I support the team who were the 1st in Britain to lift the European Cup(With 11 Glaswegians). I regularly go to Glasgow to support my team. You????

Keano

Laois_Man wrote: »

Not only do I not believe McGeady is world class, I don't even believe he should be in the starting 11.

Move Duff to the left and let Laurence and Coleman slog it out for the right side position sounds better to me!

OT but should be no slog - Coleman should be in the team

Helix

PARKHEAD67 wrote: »

I regularly go to Glasgow to support my team.

and do you get there on the flying pig necessary to make mcgeady world class?

G.K.

PARKHEAD67 wrote: »

He does things with a football that are absurd. Things that most other players simply cannot do. He is world class. Simple as that.

This guy can Seal Dribble, as far as I know only Kerlon has consistently done it apart from him. Is he world class?

1mcampo1

Laois_Man wrote: »

Not only do I not believe McGeady is world class, I don't even believe he should be in the starting 11.

Move Duff to the left and let Laurence and Coleman slog it out for the right side position sounds better to me!

Vanbis wrote: »

I'd agree, he was next to useless against Andorra but a little better last night. He's a headless chicken with the ball most of the time. I'd have Hunt or Coleman starting ahead of him everytime.

Hunt and Lawrence aren't good enough though. Hunt's best attribute is his workrate but that shouldn't be a winger's better part of the game. Havn't seen Lawrence play in a bit, but what i can remember is he's pretty average. And i suppose that's why he hasn't been in the starting 11 in a while...

Coleman could/should be breaking into the 1st team in the near future, but i think it'll be at RB. Defiantly shouldn't be taking McGeady's place

PARKHEAD67

Helix wrote: »

and do you get there on the flying pig necessary to make mcgeady world class?

Your question would confuse Einstein.:rolleyes:

clickhere

Look lads Mcgeady is no world class player, he is an honest player with alot to learn.Dont start calling me a Mcgeady hater becau
se i have nothing but the height of respect for all the players who play for our country.The team are no world beaters,but they will give you all they have on the pitch, and we cant ask for anymore than that. ROLL ON THE SUMMER..................................

PARKHEAD67

clickhere wrote: »

Look lads Mcgeady is no world class player, he is an honest player with alot to learn.Dont start calling me a Mcgeady hater becau
se i have nothing but the height of respect for all the players who play for our country.The team are no world beaters,but they will give you all they have on the pitch, and we cant ask for anymore than that. ROLL ON THE SUMMER..................................

McGeadys got the minerals.Hes world class.End of.;)

PARKHEAD67

G.K. wrote: »

This guy can Seal Dribble, as far as I know only Kerlon has consistently done it apart from him. Is he world class?

No.

Helix

PARKHEAD67 wrote: »

Your question would confuse Einstein.:rolleyes:

i doubt it

Laois_Man

PARKHEAD67 wrote: »

Sweet mother of Christ.I think Im gonna puke.The ignorance is making my stomach heave.

Quite ironic how someone talking about other peoples ignorance is the person who thinks the reason McGeady isn't at Man Utd is because they can't afford him! Yeah they decided to spend something like £18 Million on Ashley Young to play in the same position just for the craic. They really think McGeady is better. But he'd cost too much more!

Blatter

What age are you PARKHEAD? Genuinely interested.

PARKHEAD67

Laois_Man wrote: »

Quite ironic how someone talking about other peoples ignorance is the person who thinks the reason McGeady isn't at Man Utd is because they can't afford him! Yeah they decided to spend something like £18 Million on Ashley Young to play in the same position just for the craic. They really think McGeady is better. But he'd cost too much more!

Alex had the proverbial nightmare with that one.

PARKHEAD67

Blatter wrote: »

What age are you PARKHEAD? Genuinely interested.

3

orourkeda

Shouldnt a world class player have the ability to cross the ball accurately more often than not?

Mars Bar

Parkhead is clearly just doing this for the rise and it's working. To use a Bateman-ism, anyone who knows anything about football will know that McGeady isn't even close to being world class.

Laois_Man

1mcampo1 wrote: »

Coleman could/should be breaking into the 1st team in the near future, but i think it'll be at RB. Defiantly shouldn't be taking McGeady's place

I think there's a bit too much hype about Coleman. He's not THAT good. And if he does break into the team, and he will get chances, I certainly wouldn't dare put him at right back. Not to be trusted!

G.K.

PARKHEAD67 wrote: »

No.

So what are the things that McGeady can do with the ball 'that most other players simply cannot do' that make him World class, if the seal dribble, which most players simply cannot do, doesn't make Braaten World Class?

PARKHEAD67

orourkeda wrote: »

Shouldnt a world class player have the ability to cross the ball accurately more often than not?

Haters gonna hate.............:P

Blatter

PARKHEAD67 wrote: »

30

Sad that you could be that disillusioned at that age.

Laois_Man

mars bar wrote: »

Parkhead is clearly just doing this for the rise and it's working. To use a Bateman-ism, anyone who knows anything about football will know that McGeady isn't even close to being world class.

Well you're a moderator. Is he breaking no rule?

orourkeda

PARKHEAD67 wrote: »

Haters gonna hate.............:P

Haters can cross a ball

PARKHEAD67

G.K. wrote: »

So what are the things that McGeady can do with the ball 'that most other players simply cannot do' that make him World class, if the seal dribble, which most players simply cannot do, doesn't make Braaten World Class?

McGeadys an unreal player.Hes Scottish.Is this the reason for the hatred?He acknowledged his Irish roots, much to the disgust of most of the Scottish public.Hes got balls of steel.All ye haters out there GIRFUY.

orourkeda

PARKHEAD67 wrote: »

McGeadys an unreal player.Hes Scottish.Is this the reason for the hatred?He acknowledged his Irish roots, much to the disgust of most of the Scottish public.Hes got balls of steel.All ye haters out there GIRFUY.

No its because he's shyte. Hatred may be the wrong word

G.K.

PARKHEAD67 wrote: »

McGeadys an unreal player.Hes Scottish.Is this the reason for the hatred?He acknowledged his Irish roots, much to the disgust of most of the Scottish public.Hes got balls of steel.All ye haters out there GIRFUY.

Answer the question.

G.K. wrote: »

So what are the things that McGeady can do with the ball 'that most other players simply cannot do' that make him World class, if the seal dribble, which most players simply cannot do, doesn't make Braaten World Class?

tommyhaas

Vanbis wrote: »

The only comedian here is yourself if you seriously believe Mcgeady is world class But your a Celtic fan so it's hardly suprising :rolleyes:

Knowing many Celtic fans, and having been to Parkhead numerous times, I have never heard another Celtic fan claim McGeady is either world class or better then Rooney

So what exactly are you basing this opinion that its hardly surprising for a Celtic fan to come out with drivel from? Its not as if your own clubs support is exempt from such dreamers, yet I wouldn't define their supporters as a whole by these people

orourkeda

tommyhaas wrote: »

Knowing many Celtic fans, and having been to Parkhead numerous times, I have never heard another Celtic fan claim McGeady is either world class or better then Rooney

So what exactly are you basing this opinion that its hardly surprising for a Celtic fan to come out with drivel from? Its not as if your own clubs support is exempt from such dreamers, yet I wouldn't define their supporters as a whole by these people

I thought the answer to that question was obvious.

RoryMac

orourkeda wrote: »

tommyhaas wrote: »

Knowing many Celtic fans, and having been to Parkhead numerous times, I have never heard another Celtic fan claim McGeady is either world class or better then Rooney

So what exactly are you basing this opinion that its hardly surprising for a Celtic fan to come out with drivel from? Its not as if your own clubs support is exempt from such dreamers, yet I wouldn't define their supporters as a whole by these people

I thought the answer to that question was obvious.

Wasn't obvious to me either, care to explain?

orourkeda

RoryMac wrote: »

Wasn't obvious to me either, care to explain?

No.

Mars Bar

Laois_Man wrote: »

Well you're a moderator. Is he breaking no rule?

If I said I believe what he is at, I'd get an infraction.

PARKHEAD67

orourkeda wrote: »

No its because he's shyte. Hatred may be the wrong word

You really dont watch football often .Do you?;)