Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

BARF Diet

  • 03-05-2012 9:38pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,508 ✭✭✭


    Bones & Raw Food Diet.

    Anyone try it with dogs (especially large breeds)? Experiences?


«1

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,811 ✭✭✭Hooked


    Ayla wrote: »
    Bones & Raw Food Diet.

    Anyone try it with dogs (especially large breeds)? Experiences?

    A quick search in this forum should get you plenty of info. It's been discussed a fair bit. I've yet to take the plunge with my Husky.

    From what I remember, main points were... Don't feed raw and dry kibble in the same feed. Different digestion rates i think. Raw chicken bones etc were fine with cooked being a danger due to splintering.

    I remember my auld lad gave me a large brisket? (sp) bone with plenty of meat on. Left it with Hugo for three hours. Couldn't get over how clean his teeth were afterwards.

    The odd raw egg in with kibble was suggested I think. With all manners of hearts, livers, chicken necks/backs etc... being on the menu too.

    I'm sure more experienced folk will point you in the right direction...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,634 ✭✭✭TooManyDogs


    +1 on searching the forum

    My lot have been on it for 4 years now and doing really well on it, I wouldnt change for the world. I have from JRT up to lab x and GSD x, friends of mine that I've converted have rotties, GSDs and red setters, they're all doing great on it too. The red setter is 14 and his owner is able to tweak the diet to make it easier on his kidneys and liver now that he's elderly.
    Everyone remarks on how well muscled my terriers are and that's because of the diet.

    What exactly do you want to know?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 32,634 ✭✭✭✭Graces7


    Half and half here. Raw in the morning as in chicken necks, or raw chicken joints, and I cook for them for a warm feed last thing. Meat, stock with vegetables and bread or rice etc. Would not go back to canned or dried ever. Works out cheaper too which matters these days and on a pension. They are supremely fit.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,045 ✭✭✭✭tk123


    I switched my guy (Retriever) about 4 months ago and haven't looked back. I do it a little differently in that I grind/mince the chicken legs for convenience but it works for us and means he gets a much healthier diet and I save money - win win!! I did his meals for a month there the other week and it cost me €20. The improvement in his coat is amazing - he's finally getting a fluffy retriever coat, spotless teeth, nice small poos etc etc


  • Registered Users Posts: 105 ✭✭_Lady_


    Hi guys, thanks for the info here - I've always been brought up to believe that the raw food diet is a bad idea for dogs in rural areas? i.e. giving them a potential taste for livestock? What are people's thoughts on this? But I did give my guy a few raw rib bones as a pup and he spent days with them, absolutely loved it - but my parents were shaking their heads - surely not such a big deal with it's not a farm dog etc etc?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,045 ✭✭✭✭tk123


    _Lady_ wrote: »
    Hi guys, thanks for the info here - I've always been brought up to believe that the raw food diet is a bad idea for dogs in rural areas? i.e. giving them a potential taste for livestock? What are people's thoughts on this? But I did give my guy a few raw rib bones as a pup and he spent days with them, absolutely loved it - but my parents were shaking their heads - surely not such a big deal with it's not a farm dog etc etc?

    It's an urban legend that they get a taste for blood :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,634 ✭✭✭TooManyDogs


    Yep total urban legend.
    If you think about it, the dogs that do chase and attack livestock are normally fed on commercial food, not raw food so clearly something else makes them switch and chase, and the answer is they discover their preditator side! Food has nothing to do with it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 32,634 ✭✭✭✭Graces7


    tk123 wrote: »
    It's an urban legend that they get a taste for blood :)


    I hear this often and my reply is that it is there in them and that feeding raw satisfies it.

    NB these are often folk who let their dogs roam.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,508 ✭✭✭Ayla


    Whew, ok, just read through that monster of a thread that was going on back in January :eek: Sorry, I should have searched boards before starting this thread, naive me thinking that there wouldn't be much info/experience with BARF :o

    That said, I still have a couple lingering questions that weren't really addressed in the other threads, so here goes:

    1) Yoghurt: would this be a daily addition to a raw diet, or less often? Our German Shep seems to have a very sensitive system (I think a packaged bone has caused his explosiveness for the last few days :() so we're wanting to regenerate the healthy gut.

    2) I've heard about soaking bones in cider vinegar prior to eating b/c it completely eliminates the possiblity of creating blockages or injury. Turns the bones quite rubberly actually. Also, the vinegar apparently has nutritional benefits all on its own. Any thoughts?

    3) As the owner of a Great Dane, German Shep & Rottie, our main concerns are for joint maintenance & healthy hearts. Would there be any special supplements to add (or avoid!) in creating a BARF menu? We've already started the salmon oil (15mls/day as suggested on the packaging) - anything else?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,634 ✭✭✭TooManyDogs


    Ayla wrote: »
    1) Yoghurt: would this be a daily addition to a raw diet, or less often? Our German Shep seems to have a very sensitive system (I think a packaged bone has caused his explosiveness for the last few days :() so we're wanting to regenerate the healthy gut.

    I give a spoon of natural low fat yogurt on my lot's dinner every day, helps keep farts down and good intestinal flora
    Ayla wrote: »
    2) I've heard about soaking bones in cider vinegar prior to eating b/c it completely eliminates the possiblity of creating blockages or injury. Turns the bones quite rubberly actually. Also, the vinegar apparently has nutritional benefits all on its own. Any thoughts?

    I know cider vinegar is very very good for them, haven't heard about soaking bones in it though so can't comment about making them rubbery. Part of the benefit of feeding whole bones would be the cleaning effect on their teeth which you would miss if you made the bones soft.
    Ayla wrote: »
    3) As the owner of a Great Dane, German Shep & Rottie, our main concerns are for joint maintenance & healthy hearts. Would there be any special supplements to add (or avoid!) in creating a BARF menu? We've already started the salmon oil (15mls/day as suggested on the packaging) - anything else?

    Avoid cod liver oil, there's too much vitamen A in it for dogs. Fish oils in general are excellent. You could also feed whole oily fish like mackrel to help with joints. Pet shops also sell pet glucosamine for joints so that would be another option.

    Make sure you start them off on an exclusion diet, so give one type of meat for 3 or 4 days and make sure they're ok on it before introducing somehting else. If they're allergic to something you'll see straight away. There's a large number of dogs allergic to chicken so bear that in mind if your dog is still explosive, it may not be the bone content rather the type of meat. A GSD I know that went on the diet didn't start on it well due to runny bum but after a trip to a animal allergist (didn't know such a thing existed!) they discovered he was allergic to chicken and pork, they cut those out and he's absolutely thriving.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 425 ✭✭Vince32


    I have been feeding raw for about 3 months now, and I could not be happier with the results. My dog is happier, healthier and more alert, for the difference in food.

    The only tricky thing, and it's not very tricky, is to make sure they don't get the same meats too often in a row.

    Usually once a month I go out shopping for meats, some from wholesalers, and some from supermarkets. I know my dog will need a minimum of 500g of meat and bone a day, so I know I'll need 15Kg for the month. The reason I know this, is the rule of thumb that acts as a guide to raw feeding, if you know the ideal adult weight of the breed of dog, we can use my dog for an example here, Siberian Husky, breed standard weight for a female is 18-23Kg, depending on the frame of the dog.

    Lets aim for the middle ground and say her ideal adult weight is 20Kg, we need to find out what 3% of 20Kg is, lets ask google....600g, and that is her daily food intake. Minus 100g for treats and scraps you may give during the day, and were looking at 500g of meat and bone + treats = 600g a day.

    I usually get beef,pork,duck (whole), chicken (whole) and tinned mackerel or sardines.

    Then I spend an hour, dividing up the whole birds, and weighing 250g packets into freezer bags, can be a bit messy at first , but you will soon learn the best methods of dividing up the birds. (if you don't have a Meat Cleaver, get one for this)

    When I'm done, I have 60x250g bags (meals), and I freezer the lot in a large plastic bag, to keep it separate from my own meats and veggies.
    Then at meal times 8am and 6pm, my dog is given one meal, and the other comes out to defrost.

    When it comes to feeding bone, you need to remember, raw bones are softer than cooked bones, cooked bones are dehydrated, raw bones are not, there is a serious risk of cutting or tearing your dogs GI track or stomach with cooked bones, so please don't ever give them, and load bearing bones are really bad also don't give those in any circumstance.

    If she refuses the meal, after 20 minutes, it gets fridged and given back at the next meal, and the other one goes back into the freezer. It's not uncommon for a dog to refuse a meal, or two, I've heard of dogs holding out for up to 4 days, this is where you have to be very strong, showing weakness and feeding something else at this point will give the dog the upper hand, and it will lord it over you for life, so don't get upset by it, a dog will not allow itself to starve, offer the food and it will eat eventually.

    A good tip I was given recently was not to give treats or scraps if it doesn't eat, that way the dog has nothing to arm itself with in the battle of wills they will go through every couple of months.

    Personally I don't believe that dogs are omnivores, they can eat veggies and some fruits, but in general they will get all the sustenance they need from raw meat and bones as long as they get a varied diet, beef,pork,fowl,fish. It's what nature intended for them right at the start, and as humans we assume we know what's best, and to some extent we do, but without getting bogged down in nutritional data, graphs and spreadsheets, lets just assume mother nature knows what she is doing. ok? :)

    Other peoples beliefs and opinions are other peoples, these are my thoughts and experiences and you may use them to your advantage, or discard them as you see fit, however there is a website and forum designed for raw feeding, specialising in working dogs, but can be used for any dog, and if you like, you can pm me, and I will send you the link to the site.

    I have found it to be a wealth of knowledge and information and the owners and site team take great personal pride in providing the best information they can to all its members.

    If all goes well, you will see the difference in your dog in just a few days, and you'll both enjoy a healthy and happy partnership for many, many years.

    Take care, and best of luck with your BARF endeavours

    Vince


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,634 ✭✭✭TooManyDogs


    Vince32 wrote: »
    I
    I know I'll need 15Kg for the month.

    I go through that a week :D

    That is another point though. I had to buy a chest freezer for dog food.

    I also give mine blended veggies, but like Vince said, each to their own. Do your research, look up forums and groups but don't get put off by the raw food nazi's, there's some in every forum. There's a number of ways to feed raw and you'll have to figure out what way suits your dogs and don't mind what anyone else says


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,524 ✭✭✭Zapperzy


    I find this handy http://www.petforums.co.uk/dog-health-nutrition/111437-raw-feeding-everything-you-need-know.html Haven't converted myself yet but I'v done some reading on it and feed the odd few raw meals.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 23 BennyBlanc0


    Vince32 wrote: »

    Usually once a month I go out shopping for meats, some from wholesalers, and some from supermarkets. I know my dog will need a minimum of 500g of meat and bone a day, so I know I'll need 15Kg for the month. The reason I know this, is the rule of thumb that acts as a guide to raw feeding, if you know the ideal adult weight of the breed of dog, we can use my dog for an example here, Siberian Husky, breed standard weight for a female is 18-23Kg, depending on the frame of the dog.

    Lets aim for the middle ground and say her ideal adult weight is 20Kg, we need to find out what 3% of 20Kg is, lets ask google....600g, and that is her daily food intake. Minus 100g for treats and scraps you may give during the day, and were looking at 500g of meat and bone + treats = 600g a day.

    Vince

    Age and activity level are probably going to throw this out, that was my worry

    Poster called DBB put me on to dogsfirst Dogsfirst.ie from my first nose around boards on raw feeding a few months ago. Seems to be fairly vocal about raw food. Has a brilliant dog food calculator on it, with all the food groups there that you can plug in to see what your mix actually contains. Also heap of articles, including one on bones for poster above.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 838 ✭✭✭bluecherry74


    I'm just starting out with raw feeding and so far it's going really well. Both dogs are thriving and my skinny 8 month old pup is finally starting to fill out. They get mostly chicken leg quarters with some beef, mackerel, the odd egg and small amounts of liver.

    My butcher sells massive ox hearts for €2.99 each - I bought one at the weekend and it weighed in at almost 2kg :eek: Just wondering though, is it ok to give them a meal with mostly heart or would it be too rich? I know with liver you should only feed small amounts at a time but not sure if heart is the same?

    My big concern is what to do about their diet when the go to kennels (usually 2-3 times a year). I don't expect the kennels to store and feed their raw food so they would have to have dry. At the moment, I'm still feeding them high quality dry food at breakfast (Barking Heads) so that their system stays used it. Their main meal is all raw. I would love to switch to 100% raw but I'm not sure how I would handle kennel stays if I did. Would be interested in hearing how other raw feeders deal with this!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 838 ✭✭✭bluecherry74


    tk123 wrote: »
    I grind/mince the chicken legs for convenience

    What do you use to grind the chicken legs? I've been thinking of doing this myself to make things easier and save space in the freezer but I figured a proper grinder would be crazy expensive.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 406 ✭✭Rommie


    I'd love to put my guys on the BARF diet, but find it really confusing about how much they should get and supplementing. If they're eating what they would naturally eat in the wild, are supplements still necessary?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,524 ✭✭✭Zapperzy


    What do you use to grind the chicken legs? I've been thinking of doing this myself to make things easier and save space in the freezer but I figured a proper grinder would be crazy expensive.

    +1
    Where would I get a meat grinder? What brands should I be looking at and how much? I'd love to give it a try properly but it's a pain in the arse when his entire allowance for the day is less than the average chicken leg!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,045 ✭✭✭✭tk123


    I use this baby Thou I might add it was 30 quid cheaper when i got it from Amamzon (they were the seller) a few months ago!! So far it's done veg, 45kgs of chicken legs and 2 x leftover lamb for pies lol :D

    I do a months supply at a time so buy 6 packs of legs from the butcher which gives 9kgs (sometimes a little more) of chicken which I then skin (as I need to keep him lean) and weigh to get the total amount of meat. I have a spreadsheet done up lol and I change the number of days (usually 28-31) to match the amount of meat I have and from that I know how much veg I need in total. Hopefully that makes sense! I make up extra veg portions too so once a week he'll get a tin of sardines or mackeral or a piece of liver etc


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,508 ✭✭✭Ayla


    We were actually just thinking on this again & came up with the idea of grinding/mincing our own bones/meat/veg and then making up sausages for freezing & feeding convenience. Anyone else do this?

    We thought we could mince together a few different mixes (chix, beef, fish) with a variety of veg, throw in a tbsp of rice & then push it into sausages. These could then be easily frozen, taking up much less room, then we'd only need to pull out a predetermined number of sausages/dog/meal.

    Make sense? Any thoughts on this idea?

    Oh, and another question: I thought I read that only non-weight bearing bones should be given (ie: chix wings/backs) - is this the case or is it really ok to give legs? I think our GSD has problems w/ pork, so what about beef bones - can they be used in the diet, or just as a chew?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,524 ✭✭✭Zapperzy


    tk123 wrote: »
    I use this baby Thou I might add it was 30 quid cheaper when i got it from Amamzon (they were the seller) a few months ago!! So far it's done veg, 45kgs of chicken legs and 2 x leftover lamb for pies lol :D

    I do a months supply at a time so buy 6 packs of legs from the butcher which gives 9kgs (sometimes a little more) of chicken which I then skin (as I need to keep him lean) and weigh to get the total amount of meat. I have a spreadsheet done up lol and I change the number of days (usually 28-31) to match the amount of meat I have and from that I know how much veg I need in total. Hopefully that makes sense! I make up extra veg portions too so once a week he'll get a tin of sardines or mackeral or a piece of liver etc

    Damn it I was hoping you wouldn't say that one, I found it earlier after posting, £100 minus postage, was hoping for something a little cheaper. :( Can't even find any second hand ones knocking about the place.

    Do you plan on adding any other meats or offal in? Was doing a bit of reading there and he would need about 235g a day or 1.6kg a week, the chicken leg he got this evening was 300g and that was a small to medium sized one one! I'l have to buy a cleaver and see if I can hack them up a bit. Anyone any recommendations for nice sharp meat cleavers that don't cost an arm and a leg? :D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,524 ✭✭✭Zapperzy


    Ayla wrote: »
    Oh, and another question: I thought I read that only non-weight bearing bones should be given (ie: chix wings/backs) - is this the case or is it really ok to give legs? I think our GSD has problems w/ pork, so what about beef bones - can they be used in the diet, or just as a chew?

    I think that only counts for larger animals like cattle and sheep, the weight bearing bones would be too hard that they might damage their teeth trying to chew them. I'v been feeding the odd chicken leg whole to a litter terrier with no problems for a few years. I got what I think was a beef rib once and while he didn't realy like it (and buried it :rolleyes:) it was perfectly fine, especially for a larger dog, just avoid leg bones.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,508 ✭✭✭Ayla


    Zapperzy wrote: »
    Anyone any recommendations for nice sharp meat cleavers that don't cost an arm and a leg? :D

    An off chance (and what may only be a short-term solution b/c the quality wouldn't be brilliant) but if you're in Sligo have you tried the home store (can't remember the name) up by Homebase/McD's? They have all sorts of kitchen stuff, may have a cleaver that would do for awhile.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,045 ✭✭✭✭tk123


    Ayla wrote: »
    Make sense? Any thoughts on this idea?

    Do you mean like use the sausage attachment thing? If so it'd be time consuming both for making it and cleaning (the kenwood bits can't go in the dishwasher and I'd assume other makes could be the same if they're stainless steel?). Anyhoos for say chicken legs you mince with the disc with the biggest holes and then would need to use a finer disk for the sausage thing so you'd have to mince the mix twice?

    I mince the chicken legs into one bowl and then mince the veg into another..I use scoops and make up daily portions of meat and add a daily portion of veg (quicker than mixing up the meat and veg and I don't have a bowl big enough for everything lol), bag and freeze.. x 30 :p After the first few portions you automatically get more accurate with the measurements so it gets a lot faster. You don't need to do single meals - much easier and quicker to do a daily portion and then split in half at breakfast time. If it's slightly off it doesn't matter as the daily amount will still be the same ;) That said I do a few single meals so he'll have a normal breakfast and then a treat dinner - sardines etc Our local butchers where I get the legs don't give bones but the one I order from online every few weeks will throw some in the order if I ask in the comments :)

    204257.jpg


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 838 ✭✭✭bluecherry74


    tk123 wrote: »
    I use this baby Thou I might add it was 30 quid cheaper when i got it from Amamzon (they were the seller) a few months ago!! So far it's done veg, 45kgs of chicken legs and 2 x leftover lamb for pies lol :D

    Thanks tk! Will definitely think about getting one of those. It only just occurred to me after reading your post that I could use if for human food too!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 584 ✭✭✭Mauser 308


    If you look up a site www.dogsfirst.ie you will get some great Ideas and advise. It is full of info, and has a great recipe calculator. I have been PM'd the site owner for advise on several occasions and found him great.
    I changed my two working dogs (Irish setter and english pointer) over to the raw diet and cant see myself ever going back.


  • Moderators, Recreation & Hobbies Moderators Posts: 9,770 Mod ✭✭✭✭DBB



    My butcher sells massive ox hearts for €2.99 each - I bought one at the weekend and it weighed in at almost 2kg :eek: Just wondering though, is it ok to give them a meal with mostly heart or would it be too rich? I know with liver you should only feed small amounts at a time but not sure if heart is the same?

    My understanding is that heart is considered a muscle meat, as opposed to offal. So, in BARF terms, it's the same as beef, lamb or any other meat.
    Speaking of which... some call it Bones and Raw Food Diet, others (me!) call it the Biologically Appropriate Raw Food Diet. Anyone know why the difference?:)
    Edit: a quick wiki search tells me that the founder of the diet, Billinghurst, used both names!
    My big concern is what to do about their diet when the go to kennels (usually 2-3 times a year). I don't expect the kennels to store and feed their raw food so they would have to have dry.

    I *think* I found a reasonable solution to this problem, though it's a bit more expensive. I friend of mine even caught an avid raw feeder and supplier of raw meat to dog owners with a stash of this in his van for the same reasons!
    I buy a stash of Naturediet to feed my crew when we're away. For the price, it seems to be a really well-balanced, meaty alternative that'll certainly do the job of tiding them over. I may supplement it with a small bit of spud or rice, but only a small bit, and a dollop of tinned pilchards or sardines.
    I think it's reasonable enough to ask of a kennels? Do you think?:o


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 838 ✭✭✭bluecherry74


    DBB wrote: »
    I buy a stash of Naturediet to feed my crew when we're away. For the price, it seems to be a really well-balanced, meaty alternative that'll certainly do the job of tiding them over. I may supplement it with a small bit of spud or rice, but only a small bit, and a dollop of tinned pilchards or sardines.
    I think it's reasonable enough to ask of a kennels? Do you think?:o

    Good idea, I did look at Naturediet before trying raw and it seems a pretty good quality food. I'll give them a trial run on it I think and see how they get on. The guy who runs the kennels gives tinned fish to his own dogs, so I know he wouldn't have a problem with that.

    Thanks for the info re: the heart too. :)
    Mauser 308 wrote: »
    If you look up a site www.dogsfirst.ie you will get some great Ideas and advise. It is full of info, and has a great recipe calculator.

    Great site, the "recipe maker" is really useful!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,508 ✭✭✭Ayla


    tk123 wrote: »
    Do you mean like use the sausage attachment thing? If so it'd be time consuming both for making it and cleaning ...for say chicken legs you mince with the disc with the biggest holes and then would need to use a finer disk for the sausage thing so you'd have to mince the mix twice?

    Ah, good point. Hadn't thought of that.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 73 ✭✭FlowerGarden


    I started my bichon on the BARF diet about three weeks ago on the advice of a vet. She suffers from allergies and was constantly scratching her muzzle and licking her paws. I have another dog and decided to put them both on it.
    There has been a great improvement with the scratching, about 80% better. She still licks her feet a lot. I was advised not to feed her pork or beef.
    One of the big changes is how little water they drink now. Also they absolutely love the food. She was never a big eater and would leave her nuts as often as eat them. Now the bowl is licked clean. I give her chicken wings but I stopped giving them to the other fellow as he was almost swallowing them whole and gave me a fright a couple of times. He gets other types of bones instead.
    The diet is expensive, I haven't sourced a meat wholesaler yet but I would find it hard to go back to dry commercial food now.


Advertisement