2 Decisions To Be Made

SantryRed · 14-09-2012 5:33pm #1

Two things have now popped up that we need to discuss before I create the league tonight/tomorrow.

1. The accelerated clock currently does not work for human to human games. Will we go ahead with having it turned off for now until a patch is released? Hopefully a patch will be released by the time the regular season starts. Will we go with 6 minute quarters with no acceleration to start with?

2. As you all know, there is a bug currently in CC which if we start with pre existing injuries off, if I touch the game sliders at all, ALL of the injuries that have happened in the season will be wiped. What way do people want to move ahead with this? I don't think it's fair on players missing players all season through injuries that haven't happened when we are playing. Also, as we are now a full league, I don't think we'll need to adjust the sliders at all, just stick it at All Pro and leave it at that.

Let me know what people think.

helimachoptor · 14-09-2012 5:35pm

Leave the games at 8 mins and when the patch comes out we'll be back to normal. Would imagine it'll be fixed soon anyway.

Pre-existing injuries off..

SantryRed · 14-09-2012 5:36pm

helimachoptor wrote: »

Leave the games at 8 mins and when the patch comes out we'll be back to normal. Would imagine it'll be fixed soon anyway.

Pre-existing injuries off..

I can change the time any time during the season anyways so don't want people trudging through 8 minutes a quarter with no accelerated clock.

Paully D · 14-09-2012 5:37pm

1) EDIT - Just seen you can change it at any time. Reduce the quarters by 1 minute/2 minutes from the usual.

2) Definitely pre-existing injuries off. There's no need to touch the sliders anyway.

Danger_dave1 · 14-09-2012 5:37pm

1. sounds good

2. will injuries be on though ? or will it bug and will no one be able to get injured? If its turns injuries off i think we stick with pre existing injuries

SantryRed · 14-09-2012 5:42pm

Danger_dave1 wrote: »

1. sounds good

2. will injuries be on though ? or will it bug and will no one be able to get injured? If its turns injuries off i think we stick with pre existing injuries

Nope it doesn't turn injuries off. All it does is delete all injuries if I was to change any sliders.

helimachoptor · 14-09-2012 5:42pm

Ben.. if you change the sliders for the Q length will that not wipe the injuries?

SantryRed · 14-09-2012 5:47pm

helimachoptor wrote: »

Ben.. if you change the sliders for the Q length will that not wipe the injuries?

The sliders aren't for quarter length. The sliders are for gameplay. How accurate the QB will be, how often a pick will occur and the likes.

madalig12 · 14-09-2012 6:12pm

Does the fake fg not allowed rule overwrite the 'if you wouldnt see it in the nfl' rule due to greenbays play last night or should we have a maximum we can do per season?

adrian522 · 14-09-2012 6:50pm

Aghh some of us haven't watched the game yet..

matthew8 · 14-09-2012 6:50pm

adrian522 wrote: »

Aghh some of us haven't watched the game yet..

Yeah same. Recording failed and have to watch the sky highlights at 8.

etloveslsd · 14-09-2012 7:01pm

I agree with both proposals.

The_Gatsby · 14-09-2012 7:01pm

madalig12 wrote: »

Does the fake fg not allowed rule overwrite the 'if you wouldnt see it in the nfl' rule due to greenbays play last night or should we have a maximum we can do per season?

just adding to that...the no huddle is becoming more popular in the NFL. I know the Falcons and Ravens use it quite a lot. Do we need to change the rule because I do see no huddle offense in the middle of the 2nd quarter in the NFL so does that mean i can do that in the franchise?

madalig12 · 14-09-2012 7:04pm

Sorry to the guys who hadn't seen the game! Agree with both proposals.

etloveslsd · 14-09-2012 7:06pm

Lukebray wrote: »

just adding to that...the no huddle is becoming more popular in the NFL. I know the Falcons and Ravens use it quite a lot. Do we need to change the rule because I do see no huddle offense in the middle of the 2nd quarter in the NFL so does that mean i can do that in the franchise?

If that's the case we should always be onside kicking, cause the Saints did it to the Colts in The Superbowl a few years back!!!!

I don't think we should change the rules. The reason for the rules is not only to be a sim NFL league but also to not be like the dicks in lobby games

The_Gatsby · 14-09-2012 7:14pm

etloveslsd wrote: »

If that's the case we should always be onside kicking, cause the Saints did it to the Colts in The Superbowl a few years back!!!!

I don't think we should change the rules. The reason for the rules is not only to be a sim NFL league but also to not be like the dicks in lobby games

No well my point was the no huddle is pretty commonplace nowadays and the reason and NFL team might use it would be the same reason a BFL player would use it. The onside kick is seen only in certain situations. Not really a big deal if it gets changed or not, more of a technicality I suppose :P

etloveslsd · 14-09-2012 7:17pm

Manning has been using no huddle for years

matthew8 · 14-09-2012 7:19pm

I think because the statistics say you should going for it on 4th and 1/2 should be fine.

Paully D · 14-09-2012 7:48pm

Lukebray wrote: »

just adding to that...the no huddle is becoming more popular in the NFL. I know the Falcons and Ravens use it quite a lot. Do we need to change the rule because I do see no huddle offense in the middle of the 2nd quarter in the NFL so does that mean i can do that in the franchise?

If it was like NCAA 13 which brings up a quick screen to allow you to quickly change to any play in your playbook when the opponent moves into no huddle then I think it would be fine, but because Madden doesn't allow us to do that (well, from my experience anyway you can only make small adjustments) I wouldn't be a fan of a rule change.

Personally I think it's perfect the way it is.

PADRAIC.M · 14-09-2012 8:06pm

Agreed on the 2 Original proposals

SantryRed · 14-09-2012 10:10pm

Lukebray wrote: »

just adding to that...the no huddle is becoming more popular in the NFL. I know the Falcons and Ravens use it quite a lot. Do we need to change the rule because I do see no huddle offense in the middle of the 2nd quarter in the NFL so does that mean i can do that in the franchise?

No.

Madden does not offer proper no huddle like NCAA so it can't be used.

SantryRed · 15-09-2012 12:03am

Unfortunately lads, the changing of the minutes of quarters causes the injury bug to occur. So we will have to roll with pre existing injuries off. Apologies Pudsy.

Pudsy33 · 15-09-2012 12:04am

SantryRed wrote: »

Unfortunately lads, the changing of the minutes of quarters causes the injury bug to occur. So we will have to roll with pre existing injuries off. Apologies Pudsy.

Ah sure you're grand, Upshaw is ready for action

SantryRed · 15-09-2012 12:15am

League will be set up in the morning

Berty44 · 15-09-2012 12:18am

Do not allow No huddle unless final 2 minutes of 1st half or end of game

Do not allow fake anythings

Do not allow onside kicks

If we do the league will degenerate into a farce. This is a game not the real NFL and although it tries to be sim there are certain things that if you allow will destroy the game and make it like playing in the lobbies, which we all want to avoid.

The guys have come up with good rules, they are fine as they are.

etloveslsd · 15-09-2012 2:37am

SantryRed wrote: »

Unfortunately lads, the changing of the minutes of quarters causes the injury bug to occur. So we will have to roll with pre existing injuries off. Apologies Pudsy.

So we will have pre existing injuries? When is that dated from? I could be loosing DeCastro, my best lineman!!

BigBadRob83 · 15-09-2012 1:29pm

Both proposals sound good.

Rules are fine as they are. If people want otherwise you can find lobby games easily enough

2 Decisions To Be Made

Comments