Man alleges wife too ugly. Court agrees.

Pat Mustard

In the Irish Examiner today. Link.

A Chinese man sued his wife for tricking him into marrying her under false pretences, after she had extensive plastic surgery to alter her appearance.

He described their newborn daughter as 'incredibly ugly', decided that there was no way that the child was his, and concluded that his wife must have had an affair. She eventually told him that she was responsible for the child's looks. She admitted that she had undergone extensive plastic surgery (costing €77,000) to drastically alter her appearance, prior to getting married.

Mr Feng has since been awarded $120,000 from his wife, as a sympathetic judge agreed she had tricked him into marrying her under "false pretences". Since his wife used intense surgery to drastically alter her appearance before she met Mr Feng, and since she never told him of it, the courts determined that she had convinced Mr Feng to marry him under "false premises," and thus sided with him.

Crimewatch before and after:



According to The Young Turks, the poor kid is going to end up getting slagged off in school with "You so ugly, yo Daddy sued yo Mamma!"

So, would you blame the man or his wife, is the judge right or wrong, and should that surgeon get a nobel prize?

shopaholic01

It's fairly obvious she has surgery - she has a Caucasian nose.

MadsL

$120k will pay for a lot of cosmetic surgery for the kid, or a Ferrari.

Hmmm. Tough choice.

Uriel.

Proof that marriage is just a contracted business agreement?

admiralofthefleet

she looks like yer man off telly bingo, linda martin

genericguy

The kid's nickname could be "what went wong"

MadsL

Uriel. wrote: »

Proof that marriage is just a contracted business agreement?

Only if you are doing it right.

Iron Hide

The title is like a simpsons headline á la "Man marries woman in wedding ceremony"

Pat Mustard

shopaholic01 wrote: »

It's fairly obvious she has surgery - she has a Caucasian nose.

You're not impressed with the surgeon, I take it.

I think that man is a goddamned miracle worker.

admiralofthefleet

genericguy wrote: »

The kid's nickname could be "what went wong"

like his dad, the champion footballer bang wan inn

Teyla Emmagan

Poor baby

If that's the same woman though that's the most amazing plastic surgery make over ever.

inmyday

A bit of make up in the left picture. Id marry her.

But does my opinion matter. Im desperate. Id mount a woman with a face like a drunk horse!

shopaholic01

The Mustard wrote: »

You're not impressed with the surgeon, I take it.

I think that man is a goddamned miracle worker.

No, it's a definite improvement but she looks more 'Western'.

Pat Mustard

shopaholic01 wrote: »

No, it's a definite improvement but she looks more 'Western'.

Ah, I dunno. About as Western as Lucy Liu, maybe.

Pat Mustard

Teyla Emmagan wrote: »

Poor baby

If that's the same woman though that's the most amazing plastic surgery make over ever.

Couldn't agree more - with both sentiments.

TheUsual

I'll bet you $120k and a Ferrari that the husband is no oil painting himself.

Blaming all the bad baby DNA on the wife ... yeah right.

genericguy

admiralofthefleet wrote: »

like his dad, the champion footballer bang wan inn

yep, and his car thief uncle, jonny tookamomo.

Andrew33

You'd think she'd have got her ears done too. Dead giveaway.

Halloran springs

genericguy wrote: »

yep, and his car thief uncle, jonny tookamomo.

Or their brother "John Smith"..

Garzorico

I also agree.

B.A._Baracus

This is insane ... But doesnt this also open up things for other insane martial sue-jobs?

Couldn't a wife now turn around and sue her husband for letting on that he had more money than what he actually did? :pac:
Couldn't a husband sue his wife for claiming she never had sex? :pac:

After all a false pretense is a false pretense.

King Of Wishful Thinking

What nonsense.

He should have got pissed, started a bar fight and got on with his life.

Guy's a cunt for describing his daughter "incredibly ugly" also.

MistyCheese

King Of Wishful Thinking wrote: »

Guy's a cunt for describing his daughter "incredibly ugly" also.

Yes, this was completely unnecessary. All babies are incredibly ugly.

3rdDegree

King Of Wishful Thinking wrote: »

What nonsense.

He should have got pissed, started a bar fight and got on with his life.

Guy's a cunt for describing his daughter "incredibly ugly" also.

You're taking this far too seriously. It's not as though its real life. It's a whole different country!

3rdDegree

King Of Wishful Thinking wrote: »

What nonsense.

He should have got pissed, started a bar fight and got on with his life.

Guy's a cunt for describing his daughter "incredibly ugly" also.

You're taking this far too seriously. It's not as though its real life. It's a whole different country!

3rdDegree

King Of Wishful Thinking wrote: »

What nonsense.

He should have got pissed, started a bar fight and got on with his life.

Guy's a cunt for describing his daughter "incredibly ugly" also.

You're taking this far too seriously. It's not as though its real life. It's a whole different country!

Pat Mustard

King Of Wishful Thinking wrote: »

Guy's a cunt for describing his daughter "incredibly ugly" also.

Agreed.

He also said:

Our daughter was incredibly ugly, to the point where it horrified me.

I'd say that if he wanted to start a barfight now, there'd be a queue a mile long.

ArtSmart

Classic Thread Title.

(CTT)

ArtSmart

inmyday wrote: »

But does my opinion matter. Im desperate. Id mount a woman with a face like a drunk horse!

yup, they're cute when they're drunk.

Spunge

http://weknowmemes.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/plastic-surgery-you-cant-hide-it-forever.jpg

Zab

TheUsual wrote: »

I'll bet you $120k and a Ferrari that the husband is no oil painting himself.

Blaming all the bad baby DNA on the wife ... yeah right.

http://normannorman.com/2011/10/12/chinas-chen-jian-feng-is-manhunt-international-2011/

I'll PM you my address. You can drive the cash over in my Ferrari.

666irishguy

The surgeon is gifted with that blade. I wonder though is it more the case with the husband that he got a daughter and not a son. Sons are more desired in China and with the one child law in China perhaps this is his way of abandoning the daughter.

zenno

Even worse if you actually met this bird and fell in love. Imagine you were totally head over heels in love with her, asked her to spend the rest of your lives together, devoted yourself to her, and then she tells you she used to be called harold !!!!!!! :eek:

TheUsual

Zab wrote: »

http://normannorman.com/2011/10/12/chinas-chen-jian-feng-is-manhunt-international-2011/
I'll PM you my address. You can drive the cash over in my Ferrari.

I clicked on that in an internet shop. Oh silly trusting me, and then we (in the shop) all get to see some naked-assed asian bodybuider in a speedo showing off his spring rolls.

My lawyers will be in contact, Sir. :mad:

Emeraldy Pebbles

Well, it's not cool that he was misled... but surely the surgery was noticeable.

Also, how can you tell a baby is ugly? Most newborns are.

King Of Wishful Thinking

Emeraldy Pebbles wrote: »

Also, how can you tell a baby is ugly? Most newborns are.

Here is a pic of the girl as a baby and she looks fine:

http://tinyurl.com/d79u495

zenno

zenno wrote: »

Even worse if you actually met this bird and fell in love. Imagine you were totally head over heels in love with her, asked her to spend the rest of your lives together, devoted yourself to her, and then she tells you she used to be called harold !!!!!!! :eek:

Well if you're willing to go interspecies in the first place, the male part of it isn't that bad

wilkie2006

B.A._Baracus wrote: »

This is insane ... But doesnt this also open up things for other insane martial sue-jobs?

How disappointed would you be with that?!

"Hey, come here. I'm going to give you an insane marital sue-job."
"Fooking sound!!! What's that??!!.... Oh. That's not what I was expecting at all."

granturismo

Irish examiner is a bit late with this piece of news from Feb 2012;

flutterflye

One look at her and most people could tell her nose is fake - It looks so fake ffs! What an idiot for not noticing!

Anyway, I don't see much wrong with her before picture.
She obviously looks better now, but she wasn't 'ugly' before, just a normal looking Chinese woman imo.

Anyway, that man is an a$$hole.
My kids are good looking kids, but I wouldn't care less if they weren't!
I wouldn't have thought that it mattered to any parent