Nintendo DS retrospective

Retr0gamer

I wrote this up on my blog, thought I'd post it here see what people think. Hope it's not tl;dr

http://lifein16bit.blogspot.ie/2013/03/nintendo-ds-retrospective.html


Announcement and build up to launch

For what became the second best selling console of all time (according to wiki, I’m pretty sure it’s the best selling) the DS had quite humble beginnings. Even Nintendo didn’t hold out much hope. Despite the underperformance of the N64 and Gamecube, Nintendo still had a vice like hold over the portable gaming market with the Gameboy range. However that was about to be challenged by the arrival of the Sony’s PSP which offered near PS2 levels of graphical and aural fidelity.



The DS was announced in early 2004 (21st of January is about as accurate as I can predict) and the hardware shown a few weeks later. With its dual screens, microphone and stylus controlled touch pad it was unlike any other console out there. It was ugly and underpowered and the subject of a lot of gamer scorn especially when compared to the high tech PSP. It felt like Nintendo was afraid of losing its only stronghold, the handheld market, to Sony and had rushed out a console to challenge it. Even Nintendo didn’t seem confident, announcing that it wasn’t a successor to the Gamecube or the Gameboy line, although it was backwards compatible with GBA software. To quote an article from Eurogamer from around the time of the DS announcement:

‘Nintendo president Satoru Iwata has publicly stated that the company will be happy if just ten per cent of people find the DS interesting enough to buy’

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/comment_nintendods

The last time Nintendo sounded this unsure about a console was the Virtual Boy.

At E3 2004 Nintendo decided to show how the unique features of the DS could bring new ideas to gaming. A strong showing garnered some positive public perception although there was still concern that what was shown was nothing more than a few tech demos and good ideas rather than fully fleshed out games. Showing Super Mario 64 running on the machine showed that it was quite capable technically but still far from matching the power of the PSP.


Launch

The Nintendo DS was released across North American and Japan in winter 2004. PAL territories had to wait until spring 2005.The DS just beat the PSP to store shelves in all territories. Strangely for a Japanese product it launched in North America first. It was quite a subdued launch in comparison to most modern console launches with their massive queues outside stores at midnight. Many places reported being sold out one launch day but my own experience was of strolling into a very quiet Gamestop on my lunch break and picking one up no problem. Initial sales were quite good and enough for Nintendo to be satisfied. Half a million consoles were sold in the first week in America with a million sold by the year end a month later. Despite the subdued launch it still went on to break console launch sales records in many places although the fact that it was well stocked might have been a contributing factor. In comparison the PSP worldwide launches were much more hectic with shipments being sold out in hours and a high number import consoles in European regions (which lead to Sony calling out its lawyer brigade but that’s another story).

The launch line up for the DS was surprisingly good. Super Mario 64 DS was the big launch title and while technically impressive was ultimately a disappointing port due to the lack of analogue controls and some late game breaking bugs. The best games of the launch were the games that showed off the DS’s unique control inputs. Warioware Touched! and Project Rub were the two that best showed off the unique touch screen and microphone interface of the DS. Despite being rather short they were a hell of a lot of fun. Puzzle game fans were well served with Mr. Driller and the superb Zoo Keeper, the previously free flash game made a surprisingly great fit on the DS. One title that gets over looked is Polarium, a very minimalistic puzzle game that was released at a budget price. DS games were supposed to come at two price points but Polarium is the only one I recall being released at this budget price. Unfortunately the excellent rhythm game Daigasso! Band Brothers was only available for the Japanese launch although the sequel Jam with the Band did eventually get a surprise late European release in 2010


Yes, Project Rub was kind of weird but in the best way!

Of course there was a lot of crap in the launch line up as well. Many were ports of older games (Rayman DS) or mobile phone games (Asphalt GT) with tacked on touch screen controls. Tacking on touch screen and microphone features unfortunately became common place until developers understood the hardware. Then there were the truly horrifyingly bad games like Sprung and Ping Pals (a rare mishap by WayForward Technologies). Overall it wasn’t a bad launch line up although again comparing it to the PSP launch line up it was quite lacking. The PSP had what I consider to be one of the most impressive launch line ups of any console.


Post Launch

Then the inevitable post launch drought settled in. I find it funny when people complain there’s not enough new games on the WiiU and before that the 3DS as if it’s something out of the ordinary where every console experiences a drought of quality releases after launch. The DS was no different. There were a few long quiet months with nothing of any worth appearing on the console.

Yoshi’s Touch and Go was the first big game out of the gates and proved to be a huge disappointment. It was nothing more than a tech demo stretched out into a full release game. Things would have been bad for the DS if it the PSP wasn’t having similar problems and suffered from a raft of terrible ports of PS2 games.

All that changed around in the Autumn of 2005. Konami released Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow on the DS, a wonderful follow up to the DS’s Aria of Sorrow. Despite having some tacked on touch interface and using that stupid ‘DS’ naming scheme of early games Dawn of Sorrow was one of the best games in the long running franchise. Dawn of Sorrow would be the first of many excellent Castlevania adventures on the DS.


Remember when Castlevania used to be this awesome?

Nintendo followed up its successful Advance Wars series on the GBA with Advance Wars Dual Strike. While it didn’t add much to the Advance Wars formula it was still a must own for any strategy game fan.

Puzzle fans were satiated with Meteos. A strange puzzle game that used touch screen controls, it’s a game that really wouldn’t have worked on any other system. Designed by Tetsuya Mizuguchi, it was a good puzzler but not a patch on his other recent puzzle game Lumines on the PSP.

In a big gamble that paid off Capcom decided to release a remake of one of its visual novel series and bring it to the West. Visual novels had always been popular in Japan but the genre had died off with text based adventures in the West. A hilarious comedy that was also a harsh satire of the Japanese legal system Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney became a surprise critical and commercial hit on the system. A localisation by the translation legend Alexander O. Smith helped the game resonate with western gamers and made Phoenix Wright into a successful franchise. It opened the doors for many more visual novels such Hotel Dusk and Theresia.


Courtroom justice was never sweeter. Or funnier

It was the release of Kirby: Canvas Curse, or Power Paintbrush in Europe, that really showed the potential of touch control. Canvas Curse remains a unique game even to this day. The player has limited control over the spherical ball of pinkness and must instead rely on painting a path out for Kirby to traverse each hazardous stage. Kirby: Canvas Curse remains one of the best games on the system and showed developers how to utilise touch controls instead of shoehorning them in.

However the arrival of good software really wasn’t what pushed the DS into mass market mainstream appeal.


Nintendo DS mania!

Over in Japan a game released in April 2005 was making the headlines. Nintendogs was a pet simulator and had a received a rare (at the time) 40/40 score from Famitsu. It was wildly popular with children and especially females. Sales of the DS increased rapidly on its release. It was the same story when it was released in the west. The DS became one of the hottest gifts for Christmas 2005 but it proved only to be the beginning of DS mania.


I wanted to like this game but the dog just didn't understand my dublin accent

The popularity of the DS grew even further with the release of Dr. Kawashima's Brain Training: How Old Is Your Brain? on May 2005 in Japan and Spring/Summer of 2006 in the West. Nintendo had managed to entice the untapped female market with Nintendogs and shrewdly targeted an older market. Brain Training was popular with people of all ages. It wasn’t uncommon to see people of 50+ playing Brain Training on their DS. It became one of the DS’s biggest sellers with close to 19 million sales worldwide according to Wikipedia. With just two games Nintendo had cleverly introduced gaming to people outside of the usual 10-25 year age range that normally would never have considered gaming to be anything other than a waste of time.

It wasn’t until the release of the DS Lite that the DS really hit its peak. Released in March 2006 and June 2006 in the rest of the world, the DS Lite was the console that the DS should always have been. Smaller, lighter and much more compact it’s one of the nicest looking and best designed consoles ever made. People went crazy for it. Nintendo could not keep up with demand in Japan where the DS Lite constantly sold out on the day shipments arrived in shops and this continued for months after release. Although not as bad in the West there were still cases of shipments selling out and shortages during the Christmas period. The arrival of the Pokemon juggernaut with Diamond and Pearl in 2007 meant continuing DS Lite shortages in 2007. The DS had become the toy every kid wanted.


A thing of beauty


Piracy

Unfortunately the DS like the PSP was hit by piracy pretty early in its lifespan. Although I can’t put an exact time frame on when DS flashcarts started to be made it looks to be around 2006 when they first started to hit the market. With a cheap Chinese made adapter and a micro SD card any owner with an internet connection had access to the entire DS library. With none of the complex soldering or firmware flashing required on other platforms quite literally a child could set up their DS to play pirated software. By the following year anyone could go to a local market and find a dodgy person selling overpriced flashcarts filled with pirated games. You would be more likely to see a child with a flashcart in their DS than a genuine game.


The Chinese ruin everything :P

Unfortunately piracy stunted the DS market very far too early and many developers abandoned the platform to work on mobile or PSP in the case of Japanese developers. By 2008 only big games, like Dragon Quest IX or Pokemon, or niche publishers with dedicated fanbases, like Atlus or XSeed, could survive on the platform. While the DS flashcarts did lead to some fantastic homebrew and fan translations of games such as Nanashi no Game and Tales of Innocence the fact remains that these games probably didn’t get English releases in the first place due to the rampant piracy on the system. In the end many Japanese games such as Blood of the Bahamut and ASH: Archaic Sealed Heat have remained untranslated and unreleased to westerners.


The Games and Legacy of the DS

The huge install base of DS users and the low cost of making games on the system lead to a publishing eco system similar to the Playstation and Playstation 2. With such a low barrier of entry many small experimental games could be profitable with only minor sales. Many of these were made for the Japanese market but small publishers were willing to take risks publishing these games in the west. The fact that the system was region free meant that word of mouth would spread about great Japanese only DS games. Boing! Docomodake, Touch Detective and their ilk would probably never have seen the light of day if it wasn’t for this publishing eco system and import scene. Famously the superb rhythm action title Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan! proved so popular with importers that Nintendo westernised it as Elite Beat Agents.


'Linda Linda!'. You need to play this game!

New game genres and concepts were introduced by the DS and some old ones were resurrected. There’s really no doubt that the DS and its touch screen were precursors to today’s touch enabled mobile gaming. Considering Apple’s aversion to videogames it might be a happy coincidence that the touch panel on the iPhone lent itself to similar game types but no doubt a generation of developers were inspired by ideas that started on the DS. The 3DS street pass idea began as a popular feature in Dragon Quest IX where users could share maps with each other through Wi-Fi. While the street pass feature didn’t make sense outside of Japan where everyone was playing Dragon Quest IX, it evolved into the much better implemented street pass feature of the 3DS.

As mentioned the visual novel that was so popular in Japan was introduced to the west by Phoenix Wright and was followed by games like 9 Hours 9 Persons 9 Doors and Time Hollow. The genre has also gained quite the niche for itself on the PC. Then there’s the first person dungeon crawler. Despite having died in the West with the Wizardry series first person dungeon crawlers remained popular in Japan. Etrian Odyssey, released by Atlus in 2007, brought the old school dungeon crawler back into the limelight and added its own modernised twist. It’s quite simply one of the best RPGs ever made and led the way for many others in the genre such as the excellent Shin Megami Tensei Strange Journey and might even have had an influence on the success of Legend of Grimrock.


Etrian Odyssey really is amazing.

The DS was the platform to own if you liked RPGs. People complain that there’s no good Japanese RPGs anymore but that’s because they are playing the wrong platform. Old school classics like the Dragon Quest games and Chrono Trigger were joined by highly experimental RPGs such as The World Ends with You and Contact. Even the staid unchanging Dragon Quest series decided to change things up with Dragon Quest IX being one of the most progressive and forward thinking RPGs in recent years. Of course there was Pokemon and if you were sick of that there was always the equally good Dragon Quest Monsters. Strategy RPG fans were well served with the likes of Front Mission and Shin Megami Tensei Devil Survivor. Even rogue-like games were represented with Izuna the Unemployed Ninja and Shiren the Wanderer. Hell, there’s even soccer RPGs in the form of the Inazuma Eleven games.


If you play one Dragon Quest game, make sure it's DQV

The DS’s biggest success however was introducing people to gaming that may never have considered gaming before. Finding a girl gamer my age is about as rare as a legendary pokemon but the younger generation has a lot more females that game and it’s pretty much a direct result of the DS and games like Nintendogs. Brain Training may have also been responsible for introducing older people to games. While Apple have now taken that baton from Nintendo it was Nintendo that really started making gaming more acceptable to people that previously looked down on it.

The success of the DS brought Nintendo out of the rut it was in and inspired them to try something different with the Wii. If it wasn’t for the DS, Nintendo might still be the has-been it was in the early 2000’s except even worse with a weaker handheld market to fall back on. I also believe New Super Mario Bros. DS was the game that made Mario popular again. Despite it being far and away the most disappointing of the main series Mario games it became possibly (reports are a bit divided on this) the best selling game on the system. Now Mario merchandise is everywhere.


To Cap it off


Canvas Curse!

It’s amazing how a console that seemed like such a rush job could become so successful. I doubt even Nintendo expected the success they had with the DS. What I love about the DS is the wide variety of software on the system that spans so many genres. It’s got one of the best and most diverse libraries of any system and that for me makes it my best system of all time (I’m sorry Super Nintendo). With game budgets spiralling ever higher and the risk adverse nature of the games industry it was nice to have that little handheld niche of creativity. I’m just glad the 3DS seems to be following in the footsteps of the DS.

Mr E

Fantastic post, Retr0. I really need to dig up those three Castlevania games again (the first two especially).

Kirby Canvas Curse is my favourite Kirby game of all time too.

cloud493

Best game console ever. You have

Sonic rush
Sonic rush adventure
Metroid prime hunters
Zelda phantom hourglass
Zelda spirit tracks
Mario 64 DS
Pokemon diamond
Pokemon platinum
Pokemon heartgold
Pokemon black 2
Pokemon black 2
Pokemon ranger series
Chrono trigger re-release
The world ends with you
New super mario bros
Mario & Luigi bowsers inside story
Star fox command
Mario kart DS
Phoenix wright
Professor layton
Elite beat agents
Kirby canvas curse
Animal crossing

I'm sure people have more than that

Retr0gamer

I might do a PSP and Wii one soon.

Deano7788

Great post. It's obvious a lot of effort went into it. When you think of all the great games that weren't even mentioned it shows it really was a fantastic system

cherryghost

Retr0gamer wrote: »

I might do a PSP and Wii one soon.

I'd be very interested in your PSP retrospective. I know you're on good terms with the handheld, but I don't expect any biased opinions :P

Great post by the way.

cloud493

In retrospect, DS is so much better than PSP. The PSP is pretty cool in itself. But the DS....

GTR63

The nicest compliment to the DS I can give is that i`m still buying & discovering new games to play on my 3DS. And replaying Phoenix Wright waaaaaaayy to many times. :p:p

penev10

Nice article Retro.

Just on the Piracy bit, there were a few flash cart variants available in 2005 by my reckoning. Not simple R4 types but ones that required you to use the GBA slot with a CF card and have a legit game going through a flasher in the top slot. They were convoluted pieces of kit but they pre-dated the R4 by about a year.

Doesn't really contradict anything in your article though as the pirating didn't really take off until the easy-to-use R4 was launched. Just thought it might be of interest.

Retr0gamer

Thanks for that, it's hard to pin that down since those chinese manufacturers don't exactly advertise their release dates

K.O.Kiki

So am I the only DS player here who hasn't got an R4

yet

?

Mr.Saturn

K.O.Kiki wrote: »

So am I the only DS player here who hasn't got an R4

yet

?

Nope, I don't.

Granted, it's only cause my one broke due to a dodgy emulator, but I don't currently have one.

noodler

tl;dr

cloud493

I never owned an R4, too much hassle.

Retr0gamer

I admit to having a R4 but never use it except for fan translations and there's not many of them around. I own every DS game I've played.

super_furry

Without doubt my favourite handheld console and second only to the PS2 as my favourite console. I remember using my Club Nintendo points to secure one two weeks before launch through their early release rewards and getting pissed off as GLS took three days to deliver from just down the road to me.

Still hoping for a 3DS Warioware.

noodler

noodler wrote: »

tl;dr

Joking of course.

I loved it.

Will look forward to your PSP one if you do it.

Never got a DS. Mario and alot of the games in the other poster's list look too platformy for me (platformy/childish/from my childhood/simplistic etc etc - I know these are superficial impressions but I never invested anything in overthrowing them).


I know I would play DQ9 if I got a DS but thats all I can honestly say I would play.

Steve O

I bought one 2nd hand with phoenix wright.

Never thought Phoenix wright would turn out to be one of my favourite franchises ever. I bit my nails to a bloody stub waiting for trials and tribulations and Apollo justice.

Retr0gamer

noodler wrote: »

I know I would play DQ9 if I got a DS but thats all I can honestly say I would play.

Well you like RPGs and that's one fo the systems strong suits. It's well worth getting just for the library of RPGs, although I'd more recommend a 3DS since it's backwards compatible and looks like it will be a strong RPG system as well.

Chris_Heilong

best where,

the castelvania games,
Hotel Dusk,
Pheonix wright games,
Meteroid zero,
and that Kirby colours games was kinda cool

cloud493

I remember at the launch, we went to asda to get it, (I was 12 at the time) and I of course wanted, mario 64. Till my brother chipped in and persuaded her to get me the sims instead :mad:

Amalgam

penev10 wrote: »

Nice article Retro.

Just on the Piracy bit, there were a few flash cart variants available in 2005 by my reckoning. Not simple R4 types but ones that required you to use the GBA slot with a CF card and have a legit game going through a flasher in the top slot. They were convoluted pieces of kit but they pre-dated the R4 by about a year.

Doesn't really contradict anything in your article though as the pirating didn't really take off until the easy-to-use R4 was launched. Just thought it might be of interest.

Don't forget the likes of the CycloDS Evolution, very very versatile little item.

Cracks me up everytime I'm emulating our first house computer on it, an Oric-1 48K..

Mr. K

Great post Retr0! The sheer number of quirky, clever games on the DS is astounding; I just hope the 3DS follows suit.

I think the name Dawn of Sorrow was a pretty clever way to incorporate DS into the game's title, even though it sounded like the game was a prequel to Aria of Sorrow...that was the first DS game I really got into.

I really loved Resident Evil: Deadly Silence too. It was a remake of the original RE; the Rebirth Mode incorporated touch screen controls into the game. There was a really cool CPR minigame where you had to blow into the microphone. To be fair, some of the touch screen stuff was tacked on, but it was fun. You could also skip the door opening loading screens, I remember speed running the game in less than two hours because of that!

Oh, the nostalgias...

Star Lord

Chris_Heilong wrote: »

Meteroid zero

Metroid Zero Mission was a GBA game, a remake of the original Metroid game.

Metroid Prime Hunters was the only DS one, which I just couldn't get into at all!

Kirby

I quite enjoyed that. I thought you did a good job with it and I enjoyed reading about some of the things I had forgotten over the years. It especially made me smile remembering Elite Beat Agents!

One thing though. You touched on piracy briefly but I think a retrospective piece on the DS needs to examine the topic of piracy in a more in-depth fashion. I read somewhere that it was the most heavily pirated system ever made. That doesn't sound too far-fecthed to me. I know dozens of small kids who all had a DS with a pirated cart.

Piracy with the DS broke the mainstream which normally doesn't happen. It's normally just the hardcore. "Soccer moms" were buying R4's for their kids. Surely it's worth examining the link between the stellar hardware sales of the DS and it's ease of piracy?

The low attachment rate of games to consoles, the fact that it was cracked so early in it's life cycle, the plug and playability of the pirated carts when compared to the more complex methods of the PSP. Worth examining I would think.

I get that it's not a piracy piece, it's a DS piece. But the two are heavily intertwined.

Good article nonetheless.

Retr0gamer

TBH I was DS piracy is a whole orther article in itself

ebbsy

Nintendo DS, what a machine. And you could play advance games on it.........

Something Nintendo did'nt take on board with later machines, so I did'nt buy em.

Deano7788

ebbsy wrote: »

Nintendo DS, what a machine. And you could play advance games on it.........

Something Nintendo did'nt take on board with later machines, so I did'nt buy em.

Which ones, the Wii you could play Gamecube games on, the 3DS you can play DS games on or the Wii U you can play Wii games on?

Retr0gamer

Well the DSi dropped GBA support.

Deano7788

Retr0gamer wrote: »

Well the DSi dropped GBA support.

Ah yeah, that's true but it was just a new iteration of an existing system that streamlined some aspects and added others. I just think it's unfair to criticise Nintendo regarding backwards compatibility when each of their new systems since the DS have had it. It's not like they abandoned it. They're arguably the most dedicated to it out of the 3 platform holders.

cloud493

I actually prefer the DSI to the lite, even with the lack of BC.