Malaga v Borussia Dortmund

RuggieBear

defo offside when ball game in but i presume the player in the goal negates the second offside for the winning goal...

bit like the dutch goal against italy in euro 2008

edit: or do you need two defenders defending players to be played onside ?

elefant

RuggieBear wrote: »

defo offside when ball game in but i presume the player in the goal negates the second offside for the winning goal...

bit like the dutch goal against italy in euro 2008

He doesn't because Santana was standing beyond the goalkeeper. To be onside there must be 2 players between the attacker and the goal.

Al Capwned

blueser wrote: »

Is that clear enough for you? Just the four of them offside.

You're right, but i would hope that comment was tongue in cheek...

RuggieBear wrote: »

defo offside when ball game in but i presume the player in the goal negates the second offside for the winning goal...

bit like the dutch goal against italy in euro 2008

edit: or do you need two defenders to be played onside ?
two players - he was off.

Aidric

The Malaga President isn't happy.

Abdullah N Al Thani ‏@ANAALThani 9m
This is not football, but racism and clear of all

Abdullah N Al Thani ‏@ANAALThani 11m
I hope to open a thorough investigation UEFA regarding the Spanish club out this way

Which does not affect the spirit of sport

https://twitter.com/ANAALThani

markie29

racism?

i would just say the referee and linesmen were shyt!

blueser

Al Capwned wrote: »

You're right, but i would hope that comment was tongue in cheek...

It was.

daRobot

Aidric wrote: »

The Malaga President isn't happy.






https://twitter.com/ANAALThani

Public relations rule number 1:

Stay off twitter when you're angry

ThunbergsAreGo

blueser wrote: »

Is that clear enough for you? Just the four of them offside.

Wow, saw the man who scored offside at the end but not this. Felt for Malaga

two offside goals, but one in the last minute gives you no time to come back.

thought it was poor defending but from that pic its great defending let down by the officials

Easy Rod

Off the Germans.

losthorizon

naughtb4 wrote: »

Wow, saw the man who scored offside at the end but not this. Felt for Malaga

two offside goals, but one in the last minute gives you no time to come back.

thought it was poor defending but from that pic its great defending let down by the officials

Spotted that immediately. How did the officials not see that?

elefant

Aidric wrote: »

The Malaga President isn't happy.






https://twitter.com/ANAALThani

wait a minute......



his name is Anal?

Thrill

blueser wrote: »

Its not just the offside, that Malaga player is never 10 yards back from the free kick.

Poor officials.

blueser

Thrill wrote: »

Its not just the offside, that Malaga player is never 10 yards back from the free kick.

Poor officials.

It wasn't a free kick. I've just watched it again (thanks Sky Plus!), and the Dortmund player there has just received the ball from a throw in.

darced

This post has been deleted.

Thrill

blueser wrote: »

It wasn't a free kick. I've just watched it again (thanks Sky Plus!), and the Dortmund player there has just received the ball from a throw in.

Yeah, I only saw a few replays myself. Looked like two clear offsides from what I saw. One for either side.

Oat23

Aidric wrote: »

The Malaga President isn't happy.






https://twitter.com/ANAALThani

Haha, racism!
Sit on it, rich boy.

RandolphEsq

elefant wrote: »

wait a minute......



his name is Anal?

I picture you as a 10 year old boy, am I correct?

Will I Amnt

darced wrote: »

Looked as if they would let anything go as long as Dortmund scored a winner,shocking stuff.

What rubbish you are spouting. They could have easily disallowed Malaga's second goal if there was some conspiracy going on and they wouldn't have any backlash as it was offside.
It was just poor officiating for both teams.

The_Kew_Tour

No conspiracy.

Just bad officiating

darced

This post has been deleted.

eagle eye

I was absolutely gutted for Pellegrini and Malaga but fair play to Dortmund.

Lets just forget about the offsides now, games over and nothing can be done about. Congrats Dortmund, make the most of the breaks you got in that game and go on and win the thing now. They are definitely talented enough.

Will I Amnt

darced wrote: »

I'm spouting rubbish because I said it looked like they would let anything go in a goal which included a player 3 yards from the ball when the free was taken and a total of 5 players offside.

It's your bedtime kid,jog on.

Maybe you should stick on your air max classics and do a bit of jogging on yourself...

darced wrote: »

Looked like a fix there to me if I'm honest.

darced

This post has been deleted.

carlop

There were two, and possibly even three clear instances of an offside in the Dortmund goal, however to be fair Malaga's goal was also offside (imagine how Eliseu would have felt if the officials had whistled!).

Malaga's president can go fcuk himself to be honest. He doesn't care at all about the club, has used it to further his own business interests, and has basically disappeared bar for popping up around the time of the odd CL match.

The sad thing for Malaga is that they will almost certainly never be back in the tournament, let alone at this late stage of it. Hopefully in time they will look back on it as a positive, and not dwell on what might have been or harbour any ambitions of returning to this level.

Will I Amnt

darced wrote: »

Quit trawling the internet looking for a row I'm not interested,sorry to disappoint you kiddo.

Guess I win that "row" so.

blueser

darced wrote: »

This post has been deleted.

It wasn't a free kick (assuming it's the winning Dortmund goal you're talking about). The Dortmund player in possession and about to cross the ball had just received it from a throw in (I've checked it on Skyplus). So; in that case, yes. You are spouting rubbish. Also; four players offside, not 5. Look at the picture again;

darced

This post has been deleted.

Will I Amnt

darced wrote: »

My mistake on the defender,yours on the offsides for the goal watch the goal again and get back to me.

What are you compo's back up?leave it out.

This is a discussion board. If you want to post controversial, stupid or plain wrong opinions, don't go crying that someone's looking for a row when you're challenged on it.

blueser

darced wrote: »

This post has been deleted.

I see four. The player who eventually put the ball in was also offside, but not at that stage of the attack. Who and where, is the fifth player? If you can show it to me, I will gladly hold up my hands and admit I was wrong.

Mars Bar

Stop the sniping.

swoody

great interview and Jurgen Klopps reaction at 1:13 is priceless

what a character......

Mars Bar

"Hahaha...what?"

Henlars67

Santana was offside when he scored the winning goal. There can't even be a debate about that. It's clear as day in all the replays.

That's without even mentioning the offside in the build up.

darced

This post has been deleted.

darced

This post has been deleted.

Corholio

Gotze needs a few hours on the training ground with his finishing after those 2 legs.

blueser

darced wrote: »

This post has been deleted.

As I said, you can't count players who were offside at diffferent stages (4 +1) as being 5 players offside. That sort of massaging of statistics belongs in the Dail.

darced

This post has been deleted.

GavRedKing

Dream Semi Final :

Real v Barca
Bayern v Dortmund

:pac:

sReq | uTeK

Not for me,

Dortmund v Barca
Bayern v Real

Classico final, Madrid winners, Ronaldo with a 90th minute winner.

LuckyLloyd

sReq | uTeK wrote: »

Not for me,

Dortmund v Barca
Bayern v Real

Classico final, Madrid winners, Ronaldo with a 90th minute winner.

Which comes while a Barca player is rolling around on the ground feigning injury and them all screaming for the ball to be put out of play.

One can but dream...

Nuri Sahin

LuckyLloyd wrote: »

YEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!

Justice. What a ****ing big balls performance. Dortmund and their hype ****ed out. Brilliant.

Moneymaker wrote: »

Yet another German side chokes in a major game.

Germany are the new Spain.

Or not!

Reading back on the thread for the first time, let me just say I didn't think my grin this morning could get any bigger but thanks to the above, it certainly is. Thanks

Giggsy11

Would like to see

Barca Vs Bayern (Assuming Bayern wins against PSG)
Madrid Vs Dortmund.

Bayern are very impressive this season so there can't be a better test than Barca.

Nuri Sahin

On a serious note, Dortmund cap off for a moment. Somewhat saddened for the likes of Toulalan, Joaquin, Caballero and Pellegrini. Caballero certainly didn't deserve to be on the losing side. Would add Isco but for the fact he'll be competing for the Champions League trophy for years to come, more than likely with another club.

GavRedKing

Caballero has been in excellent form for Malaga in Europe and La Liga TBF.

Barca are favourties tongiht with their away goals, if tonights game are half as entertaining as last nights it will be a great night.

Lawrence1895

The famous final four minutes on a local radio station, you don't need to speak German, to understand how much this win means to Dortmund

http://www.radio912.de/topslider/art372,627540

Irishcrx

Fantastic game last night & delighted for Dortmund , they've been outstanding this season and deserve to be in the Semi final , would love to see a Bayern vs Dortmund final. Dortmund to play Barca in the semi would be a great game , possesion based side against a side with the quick countering quality of Dortmund would be amazing. I've said it since last year that of all games I'd like to see it's that one , I think Barca would really struggle with them.

I think fair was fair last night , Malaga shouldn't have been awarded their second goal and Dortmund shouldn't have got the third that still would make it 2-1 so Malaga should have no complaints.

On the negative side from last night , Gotze missed a couple of sitters as he does seem to do a bit too often and needs to work on his finishing , it's the one side of his game that lets him down which is why I think Reus is the better of the two right now.

Hummels needs to get back into the 11 and stay fit for the Semi's , Santana did well but I think Subotic suffers without Hummels , his consentration went waining more than once in the game and he was lucky Malaga didn't take more advantage of his mistakes.

Sahin is starting to settle back in , would like to see him hit some form and push on into the starting 11 maybe even with Gundogan!

Come on BVB!!

inforfun

As Willem Van Hanegem once said: "You are only sure you have won against Germans when they are back in the bus."

Lawrence1895

inforfun wrote: »

As Willem Van Hanegem once said: "You are only sure you have won against Germans when they are back in the bus."

As a famous German football chant goes 'Ohne Holland fahrn wir zur WM' (=without the Dutch we are going to the World Championchips)

Crann na Beatha

This post has been deleted.