Clermont vs Munster buildup thread **read post one

awec

Clermont by 1-10

.ak wrote: »

I keep coming back to this thread and get a fright thinking I'm missing the game because of the all score updates..

You realise you are wrong when you see a post that has Munster winning, right? :P

Quint2010

Clermont by 1-10

Clermont 35 Munster 21

oneZeroOneZero

andrewdcs wrote: »

Didn't they change the shootout rules after that Blues Leicester game? that was kerazy.

I remember that game Martyn Williams played an absolute blinder only to miss the spot kick.

Have they changed the rules since ?

Lelantos

Clermont 17- Munster 22
I've just taken my arthritis meds & I'm feeling happy & optimistic.

Grimebox

Clermont by 1-10

Two people have followed me with 36-9! Get yer own feckin score predictions!!

Actually only one... I read 36-6 wrong

armchaircoach

Clermont by 1-10

I'm gonna say 36-12.

I think it's too much of an ask for Munster. They failed to get over the line against quinns, despite having all the possession, territory and line outson their side (as well as something like 95% breakdown success). They will be given nothing even approaching those opportunities against clermont, so Unfortunately I can see it being only penalties keeping the munster side of the scoreboard ticking over. I don't think that will be enough. Ckermont to get in behind a slow turning hurley/downey for a score or 2, with 1 or to more coming from some forwards grunting.

totallegend

Clermont by 1-10

oneZeroOneZero wrote: »

I remember that game Martyn Williams played an absolute blinder only to miss the spot kick.

Have they changed the rules since ?

Yes, I think the shoot out now uses three players from each team taking two kicks each.

Rightwing

Munster by more than 10

Guess the exact score, let's see who is the best forecaster:
It's gone heavily in favour of Clermont now.

rightwing: 19-23
mrpdap: 18-19
thomond2006: 25-06
podge_irl: 23-16
awec: 25-12
clareman: 14-19
schools rugby 18-19
grimebox: 36-9
glass prison 1214: 39-16
DDC1990: 11-18
donfers: 31-17
somefool: 10-12
Jermaine Breezy Squadron: 29-12
desertcircus: 36-9
dubliner28:33-18
andrewdcs: 24-12
backgreen: 38-12
eyeball kid: 30-12
suckfisher: 36-6
Gambas: 28-11
trouttrout: 0-0
monkeybutter: 15-19
mlc61: 45-9
quint2010: 35:21
lelantos: 17:22
armchaircoach: 36-12
teferi: 34-3
tomtom364:19-21
who me: 17-18
tbm: 14-16
ssaye: 37-23
leeroyjones: 28-22

(last entries this evening, unless someone else wants up to update from tomorrow on).

Teferi

This has all the makings of Leinster v Cardiff for me so I will say 34 - 3 to Clermont.

Tomtom364

Munster by more than 10

Clermont 19 - 21 Munster

Forever the optimist.
Radge the ligind to get a drop goal to win it :P

who_me

Munster by more than 10

17 - 18 , Munster.

Heart threatened to cut off supply to Head if he didn't comply, Head had no come-back.

tbm

14 - 16 Munster

Coverted try (from a maul) and peno see Munster take a surprising early lead which they'll hold on to untill halftime. Clermont to come roaring back with 2 coverted tries in the first 15 minutes of the second half. Then Cudmore loses the rag after POM gets away with punching him in the town halls and lashes out at Murray, getting red carded. The Munster ship steadies, they tighten up and ROG knocks over 2 penalties in the last 10 minutes.

{fanfare, exeunt}

who_me

Munster by more than 10

I love the way most of the predictions are either 30 point thrashings by Clermont, or 2-3 point wins for Munster. The most brazen prediction yet is a 5 point win for Munster. Even the most wildly optimistic, are being a little realistic.

CIARAN_BOYLE

Clermont by 1-10

who_me wrote: »

I love the way most of the predictions are either 30 point thrashings by Clermont, or 2-3 point wins for Munster. The most brazen prediction yet is a 5 point win for Munster. Even the most wildly optimistic, are being a little realistic.

DDC1990 suggested a 7 point win for munster

DDC1990

Munster by more than 10

CIARAN_BOYLE wrote: »

DDC1990 suggested a 7 point win for munster

? Really Where?

I must have been on crack!

EDIT:

DDC1990 wrote: »

18-11 Munster


or 33-9 Clermont

Heart v Head

God damn PCP. :P

who_me

Munster by more than 10

CIARAN_BOYLE wrote: »

DDC1990 suggested a 7 point win for munster

You're right, thanks.

(What was he thinking?? Still, I like the cut of his jib!)

.ak

ssaye wrote: »

37 - 23

Timeline

MUN - Penalty 0-3

MUN - Penalty 0-6

Cler Try (Conv) 7-6 - Nalanga

MUN - Penalty 7-10

Cler - Penalty - 10 -10
HT

Cler - Penalty - 13 -10

Cler Try (Conv) 20-10 - Nalanga

Cler Try (Conv) 27 - 10 Fofana

MUN - Penalty 27-13

MUN - Penalty 27-16

Cler - Penalty 30 - 16

MUN - Try (Conv) 30 - 23 Zebo

Clermont - Try (Conv) 37 - 23 Sivivatu

FT

Wow, that was a cracking game. Can't wait for next year's H-Cup.

ssaye

Always screw up with simple math

Im an idiot :pac:

LeeroyJones

Munster by more than 10

28-22 Clermont

ssaye

http://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&layout=2&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cybervulcans.net%2Fforum%2F&act=url

They seem nervous

sydthebeat

Munster by 1-10

27 _ 17 ca

gooch2k9

Munster by more than 10

16-10 Munster!

Rightwing

Munster by more than 10

Guess the exact score, let's see who is the best forecaster:
It's gone heavily in favour of Clermont now.

rightwing: 19-23
mrpdap: 18-19
thomond2006: 25-06
podge_irl: 23-16
awec: 25-12
clareman: 14-19
schools rugby 18-19
grimebox: 36-9
glass prison 1214: 39-16
DDC1990: 11-18
donfers: 31-17
somefool: 10-12
Jermaine Breezy Squadron: 29-12
desertcircus: 36-9
dubliner28:33-18
andrewdcs: 24-12
backgreen: 38-12
eyeball kid: 30-12
suckfisher: 36-6
Gambas: 28-11
trouttrout: 0-0
monkeybutter: 15-19
mlc61: 45-9
quint2010: 35:21
lelantos: 17:22
armchaircoach: 36-12
teferi: 34-3
tomtom364:19-21
who me: 17-18
tbm: 14-16
ssaye: 37-23
leeroyjones: 28-22
sydthebeat: 27-17
gooch2k9: 10-16
opinionatedfan: 23-13
benny cake: 16:19
nimbinsurfer: 11-12
diabhal beag: 29-10
garseys: 33-12
spudmonkey: 19-23
buer: 22-9
aidric: 24-26

(last entries this evening, unless someone else wants up to update from tomorrow on).

opinionatedfan

Clermont by 1-10

Clermont 23 - 13

Benny Cake

Munster by more than 10

19:16 in favour of Munster.

Drop goal by Paulie to win it it injury time.....

nimbinsurfer

Clermont 11 - 12 Munster

Diabhal Beag

Clermont by 1-10

'ont 29 - 10 'ster

Garseys

Clermont by 1-10

Clermont 33-Munster 12

Garseys

Clermont by 1-10

Clermont 33-Munster 12

Spudmonkey

Benny Cake wrote: »

19:16 in favour of Munster.

Drop goal by Paulie to win it it injury time.....

Ah be realistic.

Paulie to carry 5 Clermont players over the line ala Ginger McLoughlin for an injury winner.

23-19 to Munster.

totallegend

Clermont by 1-10

ssaye wrote: »

http://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&layout=2&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cybervulcans.net%2Fforum%2F&act=url

They seem nervous

I think no fan feels comfortable when his side are such overwhelming favourites, some of them seem to be looking for ways to hype Munster up and talk down their own chances. See it all the time on boards too.

P_1

ssaye wrote: »

http://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&layout=2&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cybervulcans.net%2Fforum%2F&act=url

They seem nervous

Just appeasing les dieux de mocker everyone does it

Buer

22-9 Clermont.

Aidric

Munster by more than 10

24-26

danthefan

Munster by 1-10

Rougerie is out apparently, according to a French poster on PR.

Buer

Whilst he bleeds for Clermont, Stanley is a class player in his own right. If I was to take the Clermont aspect out of it, I'd probably rate a 28 year old Stanley more highly than a 32 year old Rougerie.

Benny Cake

Munster by more than 10

Buer wrote: »

Whilst he bleeds for Clermont, Stanley is a class player in his own right. If I was to take the Clermont aspect out of it, I'd probably rate a 28 year old Stanley more highly than a 32 year old Rougerie.

Rougerie is one of their talisman. If he's out its definitely a positive for Munster. 14 more injuries and we're in with a real shout....

Rightwing

Munster by more than 10

Benny Cake wrote: »

Rougerie is one of their talisman. If he's out its definitely a positive for Munster. 14 more injuries and we're in with a real shout....

I agree he is a loss, but they can take hit better than we can in terms of injuries. I'm hoping James is fit, then someone should barge into Parra, then James becomes the goal kicker,,,,& on the way to the final.

Penney is going up in my estimation, hoping he can pull a rabbit out of the hat.

totallegend

Clermont by 1-10

Buer wrote: »

Whilst he bleeds for Clermont, Stanley is a class player in his own right. If I was to take the Clermont aspect out of it, I'd probably rate a 28 year old Stanley more highly than a 32 year old Rougerie.

Regan King is the more likely replacement, no? Also a class act so Clermont won't lose much in playing ability but losing your captain so close to the game can't be good.

Edit: people know that the Rougerie injury is confirmed and he will not be playing, right?

thomond2006

Everywhere is reporting it, including l'équipe. He won't be playing.

totallegend

Clermont by 1-10

L'Equipe are also reporting that Brock James will start.

Rightwing

Munster by more than 10

Scorecast closed.
42 entries. Thanks for entering. 1 or 2 may have wanted to wait for teams to be named so maybe someone else can update if they wish. Hopefully it will be an away forecast that's won the inaugural boards scorecast.
Have a great trip to anyone else from boards that's heading over.

rightwing: 19-23
mrpdap: 18-19
thomond2006: 25-06
podge_irl: 23-16
awec: 25-12
clareman: 14-19
schools rugby 18-19
grimebox: 36-9
glass prison 1214: 39-16
DDC1990: 11-18
donfers: 31-17
somefool: 10-12
Jermaine Breezy Squadron: 29-12
desertcircus: 36-9
dubliner28:33-18
andrewdcs: 24-12
backgreen: 38-12
eyeball kid: 30-12
suckfisher: 36-6
Gambas: 28-11
trouttrout: 0-0
monkeybutter: 15-19
mlc61: 45-9
quint2010: 35:21
lelantos: 17:22
armchaircoach: 36-12
teferi: 34-3
tomtom364:19-21
who me: 17-18
tbm: 14-16
ssaye: 37-23
leeroyjones: 28-22
sydthebeat: 27-17
gooch2k9: 10-16
opinionatedfan: 23-13
benny cake: 16:19
nimbinsurfer: 11-12
diabhal beag: 29-10
garseys: 33-12
spudmonkey: 19-23
buer: 22-9
aidric: 24-26

Buer

Benny Cake wrote: »

Rougerie is one of their talisman. If he's out its definitely a positive for Munster. 14 more injuries and we're in with a real shout....

I'd agree he's a loss. He's the spiritual leader of the side (and, given he's captain, the actual leader also, duh). However, he's getting a little bit older. He relies on reading the game these days more than his pure power and pace that he once had. Stanley is a very, very good player. Not quite top class but he'd walk into international sides in several other countries.

Losing Rougerie might weaken them in terms of pure drive and desire but not at all in terms of ability and class, for me.

Buer

totallegend wrote: »

Regan King is the more likely replacement, no? Also a class act so Clermont won't lose much in playing ability but losing your captain so close to the game can't be good.

It's definitely a good chance. Overall this season, Stanley has played more at 13 than King but you'd never know with Clermont. Both are very handy players. King is probably more of a natural 13 and Stanley a natural 12 but both have featured regularly in both positions this season.

I think we're all agreed that Munster will be much better off keeping their eyes on the man at 12 this weekend anyway!

durkadurka

A line from Franno's preview in the Herald today:


"The key to the game, as it always is, will be O'Gara's contribution. His role is not to release the Munster backs – you wouldn't release them even on parole."

molloyjh

Munster by 1-10

durkadurka wrote: »

A line from Franno's preview in the Herald today:


"The key to the game, as it always is, will be O'Gara's contribution. His role is not to release the Munster backs – you wouldn't release them even on parole."

Ouch!

19543261

Clermont by 1-10

Has this been posted? What the French are saying in their thread:

http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=auto&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cybervulcans.net%2Fforum%2Ftopic%2F53585-demi-finale-hcup-asm-vs-munster-avant-match%2Fpage__st__2880

Seems like some of them want to avenge Kearney! :P

thomond2006

durkadurka wrote: »

A line from Franno's preview in the Herald today:


"The key to the game, as it always is, will be O'Gara's contribution. His role is not to release the Munster backs – you wouldn't release them even on parole."

To be fair, if you look at the season as a whole he's not entirely wrong!

durkadurka

It's a good line, and wouldn't be funny if it wasn't partially true!

Lelantos

thomond2006 wrote: »

To be fair, if you look at the season as a whole he's not entirely wrong!

Even a broken clock is right twice a day