General Soccermanager transfer/deals help

GT_TDI_150

Ok, i know there is a topic like this on the soccermanager forum, but here you'll 'know' the people giving the opinions/advise

This isnt limited to any boards related GWs, any transfers that people are unsure of .... Fire away!

GT_TDI_150

I'll start, in a new GW (still at pre season friendly stage) at Real madrid, i got offered 26.5m for luka modric should i take it?

MODRIĆ, Luka(28yr) DM,M,AM(C) 93rated


Ive spent 41.5m bringing in from external clubs:

Damiao, Rui patricio, cuadrado, james rodriquez all 90s all young and also got some very talented risers

I have kadhira, alonso and isco all for the mc position

Seamo87

I think you have too many teams!! lol

GT_TDI_150

Seamo87 wrote: »

I think you have too many teams!! lol

LOL, thats not helping me in this instance tho

tupac_healy

No.... Worth more

tupac_healy

Actually since I'm in this thread!!

I recently swapped Rossi for Lavezzi and got a bit of a shock with some of the reaction to it?


Apparently Rossi is currently on song in Seria a? Anyhow the deal suited me so I'm happy but interested to hear feedback

circadian

It's only worth selling players if it's a profit and you have adequite cover/replacement or if they're surplus and drawing wages for nothing.

Just my two cents.

hufpc8w3adnk65

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

I'll start, in a new GW (still at pre season friendly stage) at Real madrid, i got offered 26.5m for luka modric should i take it?

MODRIĆ, Luka(28yr) DM,M,AM(C) 93rated


Ive spent 41.5m bringing in from external clubs:

Damiao, Rui patricio, cuadrado, james rodriquez all 90s all young and also got some very talented risers

I have kadhira, alonso and isco all for the mc position

I'd drop too 40mill and ask him too include 1 prospect who you may sell at profit later on

tupac_healy

MrMac84 wrote: »

I'd drop too 40mill and ask him too include 1 prospect who you may sell at profit later on

Sent you a Schmelzy offer too man!

hufpc8w3adnk65

tupac_healy wrote: »

Sent you a Schmelzy offer too man!

Seen it but was only online a second will have a good look later on

GT_TDI_150

Another one,

was offered 10m + Mandzukic(?spelling?) for Benzema

tupac_healy

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

Another one,

was offered 10m + Mandzukic(?spelling?) for Benzema

Personally no, but its close....

Blondie919

I have a player on loan. Someone wants to buy him. What's the deal here? Do I still have his services for the season?

GT_TDI_150

if it is the first season of the GW, and the player is on loan at your club than you have him for the entire season, however if it is the second or any subsequent season then his parent club call recall him at any point

GT_TDI_150

Angel Di Maria + Pepe for Gotze?

hufpc8w3adnk65

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

Angel Di Maria + Pepe for Gotze?

Na! Di Maria's not as good as Gotze & Pepe's on the way down imo

GT_TDI_150

MrMac84 wrote: »

Na! Di Maria's not as good as Gotze & Pepe's on the way down imo

thats what he seemed to think too..turned me down so he did :rolleyes:

tupac_healy

The offer for Pérez MICHU of AS Roma from SS Lazio has been accepted. The transfer will be completed within the next 24 hours.



Muriel & Schar for him, I really rate him but you know what, I fully fully expect to see the deal reversed even though it was Roma contacted me with the offer.....


So barring that, what do ye think, good deal or what???



AND.....


The offer for Stevan JOVETIĆ of Barcelona from SS Lazio has been accepted. The transfer will be completed within the next 24 hours.


Imagine if I actually got both of those, happy days!!!!!!!!!!

GT_TDI_150

Whats the deal for jovetic?

tupac_healy

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

Whats the deal for jovetic?

6.0M + Yassine BENZIA + Roberto FIRMINO....



So..... Question remains, will this deal (or the Michu one) be reversed do people think?

KERSPLAT!

How long is a piece of string

hufpc8w3adnk65

tupac_healy wrote: »

6.0M + Yassine BENZIA + Roberto FIRMINO....



So..... Question remains, will this deal (or the Michu one) be reversed do people think?

IMO theirs nothing wrong here

GT_TDI_150

OK, Ive Lazio in a Gold Championship and got offered:

Tottenhams' Nacer CHADLI for my Felipe Anderson

opinions please, looking at you mr Italian footie (swoody )

Seamo87

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

OK, Ive Lazio in a Gold Championship and got offered:

Tottenhams' Nacer CHADLI for my Felipe Anderson

opinions please, looking at you mr Italian footie (swoody )

lol So you have even more then the 8 teams in your signature?:eek:

GT_TDI_150

have been watching the gold championships get created for a while now, the 'BIG' clubs are always gone by the time the open, but finally there was a team available that I wanted ....

there was a mounting of F5ing at 15:00 when the league finally opened today

But anyway, have you an opinion on the deal?

Seamo87

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

have been watching the gold championships get created for a while now, the 'BIG' clubs are always gone by the time the open, but finally there was a team available that I wanted ....

there was a mounting of F5ing at 15:00 when the league finally opened today

But anyway, have you an opinion on the deal?

Phew....if it's a straight swap then I'd go with Chadli. Anderson's just a prospect, who'll be doing well to exceed Chadli.

tupac_healy

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

have been watching the gold championships get created for a while now, the 'BIG' clubs are always gone by the time the open, but finally there was a team available that I wanted ....

there was a mounting of F5ing at 15:00 when the league finally opened today

But anyway, have you an opinion on the deal?

I'd go Anderson only because of the sheer amount of competition at Spurs, once Lamella settles in its him and Lennon/Townsend for me, don't see Chadli getting much game time

GT_TDI_150

Seamo87 wrote: »

Phew....if it's a straight swap then I'd go with Chadli. Anderson's just a prospect, who'll be doing well to exceed Chadli.

tupac_healy wrote: »

I'd go Anderson only because of the sheer amount of competition at Spurs, once Lamella settles in its him and Lennon/Townsend for me, don't see Chadli getting much game time

Now thats what I created the thread for ... opinions on transfers from all sorts of GWs! Thanks guys

swoody

both have similar circumstances, Petkovic doesn't like Anderson and is leting him rot on the bench.......Keita, there other santos import is his love child. Chadli is injured but has been behind sigurdsson in the pecking order since day one. its a tough call......

Felipe was amazing when playing with Neymar but hasnt got a chance at lazio, i bought Felipe in the boards.ie league in the hope he breaks into the team.......its a gamble i'm was willing to take!

GT_TDI_150

Swap Falcao(mine) for Aguirro(his)?

KERSPLAT!

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

Swap Falcao(mine) for Aguirro(his)?

Yup

Seaneh

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

Swap Falcao(mine) for Aguirro(his)?

I'd take hand and all.

GT_TDI_150

must go make the offer so :cool:... thanks gys

btw, I feel like I'm the only one looking for opinions here .... this is a thread for all to use

KERSPLAT!

Robben and Mandzukic for Cavani? I'm Bayern

GT_TDI_150

.... can your midfield take the loss of Robben? if you can plug that gap with existing players it might be a worthwhile deal

KERSPLAT!

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

.... can your midfield take the loss of Robben? if you can plug that gap with existing players it might be a worthwhile deal

I'm not sure tbh, will have to mull it over

hufpc8w3adnk65

Princess Petulia Pissy Pants wrote: »

Robben and Mandzukic for Cavani? I'm Bayern

I'd do it as the 2 bayern players are 30+ ya?

KERSPLAT!

29 and 27

GT_TDI_150

Guys,

I've southampton in a Gold Championship and was offered Coentrao for Luke Shaw ...

With Shaw being SUCH a talent I'm unsure what to do ...

tupac_healy

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

Guys,

I've southampton in a Gold Championship and was offered Coentrao for Luke Shaw ...

With Shaw being SUCH a talent I'm unsure what to do ...

Do it, Coentreau is playing for a better club and country, shaw is quality but don't forget Contreau is not old either

GT_TDI_150

Do you think Shaw will get a rise based on his season in the prem?

Seaneh

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

Do you think Shaw will get a rise based on his season in the prem?

Definitely.

GT_TDI_150

Seaneh wrote: »

Definitely.

That makes it hard to do the swap

tupac_healy

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

Do you think Shaw will get a rise based on his season in the prem?

10000%


He has to but I don't think it will be near 90 anytime soon. Maybe if he moves club might happen sooner but Fabio Con all day

tupac_healy

Coentrao is only 25, easily 8-9 years as a 90+ player

Seaneh

GT_TDI_150 wrote: »

That makes it hard to do the swap

Oh, I'd make the swap.

Shaw won't be 91 for a few years yet, if ever.

Lord TSC

With only five games left till I start publically whoring out Bale, thought I'd ask what people think I should be looking for.

He's 94 right now. Do people think he'll get a rise, and do people think I'll be able to demand two solid 90s for him?

GT_TDI_150

I think you should get 2 90 for him at a minimum ...as luck would have it I have 2 90 and some spare cash

GT_TDI_150

Gustavo Luiz (wolfsburg - have them in a gameworld ) how good is he? Man United were negotiating with me, offering me:

Nani + Fabio
Young + Smalling
Evra + Cash

I didnt fancy any of those and asked for:

Kagawa + Jones
Kagawa + Smalling


I've set him to unavailable for now ...

what's people's opinion on this? how good is this dude?

Thanks

Seaneh

Starter for Brazil, still can't understand why Bayern let him leave.

I'd keep him myself. Covers left back, centre back and defensive midfield.

Peanut Butter Jelly

Is there a rating guideline for 16 - 18 year olds? I've some of them in the 70's and thinking of selling them but I don't want to end up missing out.