Manchester United Talk/Gossip/Rumours Thread - 2013/14 Mod Warning: Post #7871

tallaghtmick

No

Schwiiing wrote: »

Anyone think we could dislodge Varane from Madrid with a decent bid (20-25m)?

Can he play RB and CM :pac:

Maximus Alexander

tallaghtmick wrote: »

Can he play RB and CM :pac:

He's not Reus.

Too Tough To Die

Schwiiing wrote: »

Anyone think we could dislodge Varane from Madrid with a decent bid (20-25m)?

No.

shadowcomplex

No

Deiseboy01 wrote: »

Not dream more realistic

De Gea
Raf Vertonghen Jones Shaw
Nani Carrick/Fellaini Kroos Jan
Mata
RVP

Manager Carlo Ancellotti

Nani, would you go way would you

Nalz

No

shadowcomplex wrote: »

Nani, woujya gewaaaay wouja

fixed that for you

Lord TSC

No

I read that as "please don't turn on me too season ticket holders, ye are all I have left..."

The_Kew_Tour

No

Game this weekend has me as excited as watching paint dry.

Rayne Wooney

Our player of the month had this to say about March

A thrilling month is starting with five Premier League games against important rivals such as Liverpool and Manchester City. We do know it is a crucial month to climb up positions on the league table and we are going to give our best to try and win every single match.

Not thrilling for fans, after watching the game against the Greeks we could be going down the table rather than up

irishfeen

The_Kew_Tour wrote: »

Game this weekend has me as excited as watching paint dry.

Kew at the weekend - you look mightily excited...

Deiseboy01

shadowcomplex wrote: »

Nani, would you go way would you

Fit and with a run of games under his belt he's the best we have out right. My thinking is three new first team players this transfer window is enough with maybe two covering players at midfield and right back. Right wing we've enough cover for with Valencia and Young too. Not saying they are perfect but you're never going to have the perfect squad. I'd give Nani another season and then go back to the market if he didn't live up to expectations.

bucketybuck

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

Great tallies for great teams against weaker opposition, do you really think Ronaldo would score as many as he has for Real if he stayed at United?

The same Ronaldo that scored 42 goals in 46 games for United when he was only 22?

That Ronaldo?

tallaghtmick

No

bucketybuck wrote: »

The same Ronaldo that scored 42 goals in 46 games for United when he was only 22?

That Ronaldo?

And scored a bit less the season after? He would never get the 50-60 mark in England like he does in spain.

He has scored more goals than games at Real, would he have done that in England answer that.

bucketybuck

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

And scored a bit less the season after? He would never get the 50-60 mark in England like he does in spain.

And you think Aguero would hit 50-60 per season in Spain?

bucketybuck

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

He has scored more goals than games at Real, would he have done that in England answer that.

Ronaldo scored 42 in 46 long before he reached his peak. Simple logic would suggest that yes, if he were still in England and at his peak he would have increased that scoring rate even further.

Seriously, if you think the only reason that Messi and Ronaldo have the scoring records they do is that they are in an easy league then there is no point in continuing this conversation.

tallaghtmick

No

bucketybuck wrote: »

Ronaldo scored 42 in 46 long before he reached his peak. Simple logic would suggest that yes, if he were still in England and at his peak he would have increased that scoring rate even further.

Seriously, if you think the only reason that Messi and Ronaldo have the scoring records they do is that they are in an easy league then there is no point in continuing this conversation.

The next season he scored less so by that logic he wouldnt, I love how everyone here doesnt want to keep up the debate......

All I said was Aguero is a more natural finisher, Ronny and Messi are better players! Aguero has a better goal per games ratio than Messi for Argentina what about that? He also has a better goals per game ratio in England than Ronaldo.

TheTownie

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

The next season he scored less so by that logic he wouldnt, I love how everyone here doesnt want to keep up the debate......

All I said was Aguero is a more natural finisher, Ronny and Messi are better players! Aguero has a better goal per games ratio than Messi for Argentina what about that? He also has a better goals per game ratio in England than Ronaldo.

I suppose Aguero came to England as a raw 18 year old like Ronaldo ya...

tallaghtmick

No

TheTownie wrote: »

I suppose Aguero came to England as an raw 18 year old like Ronaldo ya...

I accept that, he also adapted very well to the league and if not injured would rival Suarez for goals this year, he scores unreal goals is a beast of a poacher, I wonder if he wasnt at City would we see all the butthurt about him.

SherlockWatson

tallaghtmick wrote: »

I accept that, he also adapted very well to the league and if not injured would rival Suarez for goals this year, he scores unreal goals is a beast of a poacher, I wonder if he wasnt at City would we see all the butthurt about him.

Nobody is butthurt, you are just making a nonsensical claim and being called on it.

RayCon

Blatter wrote: »

Moyes with a PR stunt apparently sent to season ticket holders.

:pac: I had to double check ... I thought I was still in the Humour thread

tallaghtmick

No

SherlockWatson wrote: »

Nobody is butthurt, you are just making a nonsensical claim and being called on it.

In your opinion.

SherlockWatson

tallaghtmick wrote: »

In your opinion.

In everyone's opinion but yours.

Aguero a better finisher, than probably the two most lethal finishers of ALL TIME, Ronaldo and Messi.

Pure nonsense.

tallaghtmick

No

SherlockWatson wrote: »

In everyone's opinion but yours.

Aguero a better finisher, than probably the two most lethal finishers of ALL TIME, Ronaldo and Messi.

Pure nonsense.

Everyone? Are you bangkok in disguise? Ive had 3 maybe 4 people argue with me over it, I got enough thanks when I said he was the most lethal striker in the world to show that no its not everyone.....but you keep thinking it is Like I said hes lethal plays in a harder league with better defences and in previous seasons didnt have the best players in the world behind him.

SherlockWatson

tallaghtmick wrote: »

Everyone? Are you bangkok in disguise? Ive had 3 maybe 4 people argue with me over it, I got enough thanks when I said he was the most lethal striker in the world to that no its not everyone.....but you keep thinking it is Like I said hes lethal plays in a harder league with better defences and in previous seasons didnt have the best players in the world behind him.

You are making Bangkok look sane with this tripe.

He is not a better finisher than Ronaldo or Messi, utter nonsense.


Counting your thanks? **** off to Facebook and count your likes too while your at it.

bucketybuck

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

The next season he scored less so by that logic he wouldnt, I love how everyone here doesnt want to keep up the debate......

Ok then. What ever you say. Christiano Ronaldo at his peak would have scored less than he did as a 22 year old. One of the two greatest players ever would not have scored as many goals if he had stayed in England, even though he had already demonstrated that even as a kid he could destroy the Premier league. :pac:

There is no debate here, just one loon spouting rubbish.

tallaghtmick

No

SherlockWatson wrote: »

You are making Bangkok look sane with this tripe.

He is not a better finisher than Ronaldo or Messi, utter nonsense.


Counting your thanks? **** off to Facebook and count your likes too while your at it.

8 people agreed with me is all im saying, you said EVERYONE disagreed with me im proving you wrong

bucketybuck

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

I got enough thanks when I said

Are you 12 years old?

tallaghtmick

No

bucketybuck wrote: »

Ok then. What ever you say. Christiano Ronaldo at his peak would have scored less than he did as a 22 year old. One of the two greatest players ever would not have scored as many goals if he had stayed in England, even though he had already demonstrated that even as a kid he could destroy the Premier league. :pac:

There is no debate here, just one loon spouting rubbish.

22 scores 40 odd 23 scores less? Amazing that, he would score 30-40 a year just not the 50-60 in spain.

tallaghtmick

No

bucketybuck wrote: »

Are you 12 years old?

No im not bangkok, thanks on boards is a good way showing people agree with you, as I thank rather than post agreed.

bucketybuck

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

22 scores 40 odd 23 scores less? Amazing that, he would score 30-40 a year just not the 50-60 in spain.

No, no, you have to be consistent. If you are pushing the "scored less at 23" thing then you have to say he would only have scored 20 at age 24, and 15 at 25.

Thats your logic by the way, not mine.

bucketybuck

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

No im not bangkok, thanks on boards is a good way showing people agree with you, as I thank rather than post agreed.

Thanks on message boards are totally irrelevant to anybody over the age of 12. No adult even looks at them never mind counts them.

tallaghtmick

No

bucketybuck wrote: »

No, no, you have to be consistent. If you are pushing the "scored less at 23" thing then you have to say he would only have scored 20 at age 24, and 15 at 25.

Thats your logic by the way, not mine.

No no as you say, you claim he would have gotten better due to scoring 42 at 22 I just pointed out he scored less a year later,ok so we're goals ratio Aguero has a better goals/game ratio than Messi for Argentina how about that?

tallaghtmick

No

bucketybuck wrote: »

Thanks on message boards are totally irrelevant to anybody over the age of 12. No adult even looks at them never mind counts them.

You keep talking about 12 year olds online......

bucketybuck

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

You keep talking about 12 year olds online......

:rolleyes:

tallaghtmick

No

bucketybuck wrote: »

:rolleyes:

You move away from a debate with pointless age ****e ill do the same

secman

No

Getting back to MUFC........... really need a win on Sat, hopefully Moyes puts out a strong team....... could do with a decent win to help confidence.

tallaghtmick

No

secman wrote: »

Getting back to MUFC........... really need a win on Sat, hopefully Moyes puts out a strong team....... could do with a decent win to help confidence.

Mata to score

Paul Tergat

Mata won our player of the month

tallaghtmick

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

Mata to score

Just seen he got player of the month

Edit Paul Got there before me.

ShoulderChip

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

Mata to score

oh I forgot United were playing this weekend!
I heard that chelsea were the only team in the big four to play
and you know, I just forgot...you know... sorry

tallaghtmick

No

ShoulderChip wrote: »

oh I forgot United were playing this weekend!
I heard that chelsea were the only team in the big four to play
and you know, I just forgot...you know... sorry

I guess you could say......next year is our year

Lord TSC

No

Some boy, getting POTM in his first month

bucketybuck

No

tallaghtmick wrote: »

You move away from a debate with pointless age ****e ill do the same

.

bucketybuck wrote: »

There is no debate here, just one loon spouting rubbish.

bucketybuck

No

Paul Tergat wrote: »

Mata won our player of the month

I guess somebody has to get it, but he certainly hasn't been anything special so far. Speaks volumes about our season that there was nobody better.

Was Mata man of the match in any of the games played?

The_Kew_Tour

No

he was not even that great, just shown flashes of brilliance.

tallaghtmick

No

bucketybuck wrote: »

.

Fair enough lets just agree to disagree yeh?

BloodBath

No

Does anyone else think we would be better off selling Van Persie in the summer?

I know he's fantastic but we have to play Rooney, Kagawa and Mata out of position to accommodate him. The problem is if/when Rooney get's injured we're stuck with Welbeck or Hernandez up front but if we had a fantastic attacking 3 behind it shouldn't be a problem.

Rayne Wooney

secman wrote: »

Getting back to MUFC........... really need a win on Sat, hopefully Moyes puts out a strong team....... could do with a decent win to help confidence.

We're 6th in the league if Moyes plays anything other than his strongest team he's a dead man walking

IamtheWalrus

BloodBath wrote: »

Does anyone else think we would be better off selling Van Persie in the summer?

I know he's fantastic but we have to play Rooney, Kagawa and Mata out of position to accommodate him. The problem is if/when Rooney get's injured we're stuck with Welbeck or Hernandez up front but if we had a fantastic attacking 3 behind it shouldn't be a problem.

Sell RVP to accomodate Kagawa? :eek:

Kerrydude1981

No

The_Kew_Tour wrote: »

he was not even that great, just shown flashes of brilliance.

With the way the season is going flashes is all that is needed

tallaghtmick

No

BloodBath wrote: »

Does anyone else think we would be better off selling Van Persie in the summer?

I know he's fantastic but we have to play Rooney, Kagawa and Mata out of position to accommodate him. The problem is if/when Rooney get's injured we're stuck with Welbeck or Hernandez up front but if we had a fantastic attacking 3 behind it shouldn't be a problem.

If Moyes is there he's gone, cant see him wating to stay with our rigid Moyes game.