Suarez, Aguero or RVP

Take Your Pants Off

Which one do you think is better ?
Who do you prefer watching play ?

Don't judge this by the top scorer or top assists.
I am talking about overall.

Kerrigooney

This isn't going to go well...

Kerrigooney

Suarez tho innit?

Take Your Pants Off

If anyone has another play you would like me to add in this poll tell me please.

happyoutscan

Suarez for me but then again I'm biased. Aguero is a class act too, especially for this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQ7k2Otl_vk

Take Your Pants Off

FFS, I knew I should not have added Heskey.
Now people would just take the fun out of it.
Come on people vote fairly and don't just go for heskey unless you 'ACTUALLY THINK HE IS BETTER'

CSF

Suarez better player, love watching Aguero though. My favourite player in the Premiership

Agueroooo

I absolutely love Aguero now for years (hence the username) but I voted for Suarez.

The guy is ripping up the premiere league this season and is topping and smashing most stats.

What he gives the team is so much more than just goals.

and if it's a pissy cup game against a 2nd division side, or a battle against a premier league big boy then the level of commitment is the same.

The guy is made of Win.

mike65

Suarez but I'd happily have Aguero in the team (though his knocks history is a bit worrying)

Alfred Borden

Suarez the better player this year no doubt but think I would rather have Aguero, lad just loves the big games and always proves his worth in them.

Take Your Pants Off

Lads stop voting for Heskey, It was my fault I admit it for putting him on, Don't know what came over me.
Ok from now on Heskey is Van Persie, if your voting for Heskey your basically going for Van Persie

Kerrigooney

Take Your Pants Off wrote: »

Lads stop voting for Heskey, It was my fault I admit it for putting him on, Don't know what came over me.
Ok from now on Heskey is Van Persie, if your voting for Heskey your basically going for Van Persie

No we're not...we're voting for Heskey :P

The_Kew_Tour

This is good

Glico Man

Heskey is best...key

The_Kew_Tour

Can't believe more people have voted for Suarez over Heskey.

Unbelievable Jeff!!!

Will I Amnt

I'd take Suarez at this moment in time but if Aguero had the same injury free season I'm sure it would be him. Fantastic player and a big game player at that.

SantryRed

Only thing stopping Aguero is his injuries. I think he's the better two of the players. They are by far the two best players in the PL though.

Mickeroo

I voted for Heskey and I'd do it again.

Seriously though, it's pretty hard to call. I think I'd have to go for Suarez, just about though. Would be easier to make an informed decision if Aguero hadn't been injured for two relatively long periods so far this season.

Shane St.

Aguero does it in the big games unlike Suarez. Aguero for me incredible player

CSF

SantryRed wrote: »

Only thing stopping Aguero is his injuries. I think he's the better two of the players. They are by far the two best players in the PL though.

Yaya and Kompany would take exception to that.

Blatter

They are both insane talents but Suarez's productivity when he's been on the field this season has been a notch above.

Blatter

Shane St. wrote: »

Aguero does it in the big games unlike Suarez. Aguero for me incredible player

Maybe Aguero being in a better team influences his chances of producing in games v top sides, rather than it being down to his ability actually being greater?

And I wouldn't say Suarez doesn't do it in big games, that's a fallacy.

Bleating Lamb

Suarez shows same commitment in every game,Aguero scores spectacular goals but on his day no striker could hold a candle to Heskey!....non PC comment......the man had the touch of a rapist.

Soft Falling Rain

Suarez can't do it against the big teams? Just an inane stick to beat him with tbh. If it was the other way round you'd have the same lot saying "ah sure he turns up when he wants to but can he do it in a cold night at Stoke!!11!1!!1"

Consistently, the man has been a monster over the last 2 years.

LuckyLloyd

Always enjoy the old 'Suarez doesn't do it in big games' chestnut.

Blatter

LuckyLloyd wrote: »

Always enjoy the old 'Suarez doesn't do it in big games' chestnut.

Away to the best team in the league imo (City), he was the best player on the field. He was at the heart of creating several clear cut openings.

Marty McFly

LuckyLloyd wrote: »

Always enjoy the old 'Suarez doesn't do it in big games' chestnut.

I remember people used to say the same thing about C Ronaldo at one stage.

Washington Irving

I voted Heskey to show my disdain for such a thread but I would have went Suarez otherwise.

Just far more unpredictable (in more ways than one) than Aguero and can do things Kun can only dream of. Suarez' scoring and assists rates only show part of what he contributes to the team. Both fantastic players obviously.

Should mention I'm a Liverpool fan and may be biased unawares to myself, which is why these threads/polls just don't work imo, people's club allegiances cloud their judgement.

Sir Gallagher

I think i started all this by saying Suarez is better than Ibra in the other thread...soz.

Kerrigooney

Shane St. wrote: »

Aguero does it in the big games unlike Suarez. Aguero for me incredible player

....aaaannnnnndddd we're off.

NukaCola

Heskey is a beast

Has it all IMO

Hangballlouie

Bleating Lamb wrote: »

Suarez shows same commitment in every game,Aguero scores spectacular goals but on his day no striker could hold a candle to Heskey!....non PC comment......the man had the touch of a rapist.

I've never really understood this expression. It implies that a rapist is not great at touching but if that's the case that surely the expression would be, 'the man had a touch of an attempted rapist.'

Or maybe I just don't understand it.


(note, my comment is in no way aimed at trivialising rape.)

LuckyLloyd

Marty McFly wrote: »

I remember people used to say the same thing about C Ronaldo at one stage.

I know, idiots every last one.

LuckyLloyd

The best thing about Heskey is that one of his middle names is Ivanhoe. Yep.

KERSPLAT!

Heskey for me.

Both are incredible players.

Suarez this season has really upped his game and I think he'e ahead of Aguero imo.

NukaCola

LuckyLloyd wrote: »

The best thing about Heskey is that one of his middle names is Ivanhoe. Yep.

Emile Ivanhoe scoregoals Heskey

Corholio

It's pretty close to be honest, not as clear cut as some are making out. While im not gonna use the 'he doesnt do it in big games', I dont think Suarez's record against top teams can't be dismissed either. Aguero's overall contribution to the team is being a bit downplayed as well.


If it comes down to what player I'd prefer to have in my team, I'd just, just about choose Aguero.

This season - Suarez. I do think Aguero is a better player though, his increasing time on the treatment table is worrying though, even watching him play you just think something is going to go on him.

hefferboi

Shane St. wrote: »

Aguero does it in the big games unlike Suarez. Aguero for me incredible player

Wrong.

Suarez, for me, is the best player in the PL at the moment. He's the best player I've ever seen play for Liverpool. Not just for his goals, but his all round game. His appetite for football week in week out is amazing and so rare to see in top flight football these days. I know its a cliche but he genuinely looks like a kid playing in the park every week. Even if he's having a bad game he's still better than 90% of the players on the pitch. He also hasn't scored in the last few games so what does he do? Goes and tops the assists charts as well. I feel bad for him that he's not playing in Europe at the moment, because I've no doubt he'd destroy it on the big stage as well and I guarantee he'll do the same to England.

I do like Aguero though. Fantastic player and an athlete, but not better than Suarez, imo of course. I'd give my left one to see the 2 play together.

AdamD

hangballlouie wrote: »

I've never really understood this expression. It implies that a rapist is not great at touching but if that's the case that surely the expression would be, 'the man had a touch of an attempted rapist.'

Or maybe I just don't understand it.


(note, my comment is in no way aimed at trivialising rape.)

I imagine its implying that rapists have heavy touches..

hefferboi

For the lads saying Suarez doesn't do it in the big games? Can ye back that up or is it just an "opinion"?

Blatter

Deleted User wrote: »

This season - Suarez. I do think Aguero is a better player though, his increasing time on the treatment table is worrying though, even watching him play you just think something is going to go on him.

Out of interest, what are the aspects that lead you to think Aguero is a better player?

Liamalone

hangballlouie wrote: »

I've never really understood this expression. It implies that a rapist is not great at touching but if that's the case that surely the expression would be, 'the man had a touch of an attempted rapist.'

Or maybe I just don't understand it.


(note, my comment is in no way aimed at trivialising rape.)

lol I think it refers to the thought that a rapist's would be far from nice and gentle, a bit rough. Apply that to a footballer controlling a ball and there you go.

As for the choice between the two players, Aguero for me. Both are super players in there own way but I love watching Aguero's strength on the ball for a little guy, you rarely see him get outmuscled.
On the other hand Suarez has the unpredictability along with undeniable skill and brain, but he dives and was found guilty of racism, not a great person to have on your team who he can be liable for the odd lengthy suspension. He eats people too.

Gbear

Blatter wrote: »

Out of interest, what are the aspects that lead you to think Aguero is a better player?

He has more pace.
He's a bit more of a consistent finisher.

But I don't think Suarez is just better. I think he's better by a distance.
He's shown that he's just as good at scoring and assisting as nearly anyone around this season but he has more of an ability to pull something out of his arse than nearly anyone else in the world.

Blatter

Blatter wrote: »

Out of interest, what are the aspects that lead you to think Aguero is a better player?

Ha good question that has me stumped, I tried to think of Aguero strengths only to realize that Suarez does that too, then trying to decipher who edges it in a given category, its very fine margins. I probably plump for Aguero as I think he is a more likable character (and I am a City fan (since 2000))

xerces

He's just so classy Martin.

Backstreet Moyes

Gbear wrote: »

He has more pace.
He's a bit more of a consistent finisher.

But I don't think Suarez is just better. I think he's better by a distance.
He's shown that he's just as good at scoring and assisting as nearly anyone around this season but he has more of an ability to pull something out of his arse than nearly anyone else in the world.

The bolded part just is a load of nonsense. Their are only two players in the world a distance better than Aguero and Suarez is a long way of them.

hefferboi

Suarez this season against the top teams:

Arsenal away - Nothing of note.

Everton away - 1 goal, 1 assist.

City away - Fantastic game from him. Got an assist for Coutinho's goal, should have had 3 more assists only for shocking finishing from Sterling x2 and Coutinho in 1v1 situations.

Chelsea away - Assist and should of had a penalty.

Spurs away - 2 goals, 3 assists.

Everton home - 1 goal, 1 assist.

Arsenal home - 1 Assist.


I can go back the last 2 season's if ye're still not happy?

michael999999

Nuts102 wrote: »

The bolded part just is a load of nonsense. Their are only two players in the world a distance better than Aguero and Suarez is a long way of them.

Yep. Most appropriate username on Boards!

Soups123

Blatter wrote: »

Out of interest, what are the aspects that lead you to think Aguero is a better player?

It's hard to argue for or against either both are exceptional .

I went Aguero because I think he is a more naturally gift player, looks much more comfortable on the ball and is a better finisher, he is also excellent in the big games.

But I think it's a flip of the coin discussion