The Tipperary GAA (Club and intercounty) Discussion thread 2015

CrowdedHouse

Some Kilkenny or Offaly lad probably started it - they're not the brightest.

evolving tipperary

I say make two threads - keep it in this forum and in the GAA one. OAOP had that idea...

There is a fair few lads who think I write ****e - this way they can avoid me! :angel:;)

The Lost Sheep

Spirit of 67 wrote: »

Why is the 2016 one up and running already ?

Because there's no point in discussing 2016 in the 2015 thread when there's no county games left to be played in 2015, virtually no club games in 2015 to be played and most discussion is about what tipp will be doing in 2016....

The Lost Sheep

The Lost Sheep wrote: »

Because there's no point in discussing 2016 in the 2015 thread when there's no county games left to be played in 2015, virtually no club games in 2015 to be played and most discussion is about what tipp will be doing in 2016....

There was a good few club games left to go in the year. Commercials have won a Munster title and the u21 club hurling is still in progress for example.

There will be many changes to the Tipperary hurling panel between this and the championship so there was no real hurry to open the new thread. Sure it could have been discussed here because the call ups, management ratification, etc happened in 2015. The actual games that Tipp will participate in will occur in 2016 so there is plenty of time yet.

The Lost Sheep

Deleted User wrote: »

There was a good few club games left to go in the year. Commercials have won a Munster title and the u21 club hurling is still in progress for example.

There will be many changes to the Tipperary hurling panel between this and the championship so there was no real hurry to open the new thread. Sure it could have been discussed here because the call ups, management ratification, etc happened in 2015. The actual games that Tipp will participate in will occur in 2016 so there is plenty of time yet.

There is only a small number of club games to be played and while there will be changes to the tipp squad between now and the championship it doesn't mean there cant be discussions about it.
Why not simply just use the 2016 thread to discuss what will/may occur in 2016

evolving tipperary

Why should anyone be told where to discuss what they want to discuss?

At least, Tipp Gunner democratically asked people where we wanted it set up???

I would ask Tipp Gunner to set it up again where he usually sets it up - as it works.

And, the other one is already set up. So, no harm. People will use what they want to use - it's no harm. People will probably use both - it's of no inconvenience to anyone to have two...

If anyone wants to ignore or use either/or let them have at it...

The Lost Sheep

evolving tipperary wrote: »

Why should anyone be told where to discuss what they want to discuss?

At least, Tipp Gunner democratically asked people where we wanted it set up???

I would ask Tipp Gunner to set it up again where he usually sets it up - as it works.

And, the other one is already set up. So, no harm. People will use what they want to use - it's no harm. People will probably use both - it's of no inconvenience to anyone to have two...

If anyone wants to ignore or use either/or let them have at it...

:pac:.. Don't be a complete hypocrite and criticise me for opening a thread on 2016 and then go on to say TG should create one because he sets it up...
Just because TG has started the thread in previous years doesn't mean he has to start the thread every year
There is no reason why the thread I created wont work....

Spirit of 67

Xenophile wrote: »

Because next year is a Leap year.

You can get your coat . . .

Spirit of 67

Deleted User wrote: »

Since late October.

A lot of games played since then up until now also !

Xenophile

As I am not in Ireland at present, I watched the game today in Spain, on the internet and I must give credit to the professional camera work of the camera men and technicians etc. with many well timed action replays. TG4 please take note.

evolving tipperary

The Lost Sheep wrote: »

evolving tipperary wrote: »

Why should anyone be told where to discuss what they want to discuss?

At least, Tipp Gunner democratically asked people where we wanted it set up???

I would ask Tipp Gunner to set it up again where he usually sets it up - as it works.

And, the other one is already set up. So, no harm. People will use what they want to use - it's no harm. People will probably use both - it's of no inconvenience to anyone to have two...

If anyone wants to ignore or use either/or let them have at it...

:pac:.. Don't be a complete hypocrite and criticise me for opening a thread on 2016 and then go on to say TG should create one because he sets it up...
Just because TG has started the thread in previous years doesn't mean he has to start the thread every year
There is no reason why the thread I created wont work....

I didn't criticize you for anything? Where did I do that? I merely stated that TG asked everyone...

Also, I said there is room for two. Is there not?

You have shifted it into a different forum without asking anyone - which is your entitlement. But, people are also allowed to set up another if they wish or keep the same one going where it was. Yes?

No one said yours will not work. It will, and so will TG's thread. Everyone's hapy - I'm hoping that TG keeps his going in the Tipp forum. Quality, not quantity I say!

Xenophile

It is my understanding that Liam Kearns the incoming Manager of the Tipperary Football team was not at the game in Ruislip. This in spite of the fact that his huge reputed fee has now been confirmed.

Hard to believe when one considers that Clonmel Commercials could easily provide the back bone of the 2016 Senior Football team.

Roll on the day when Charlie McGeever is appointed Manager.

1eg0a3xv7b82of

Tipp were always going to find promotion hard fought But what makes it worse is having a manager who knows he was no where near first choice and a panel of players who know the same. You factor the coin hes getting and the last time he managed at inter county level and it equates to a CB who had run out of options and were trying to save face after the next manager will be a show of intent statement. I am still baffled by the whole thing.

Xenophile

Marlee Shrilling Vegetable wrote: »

Tipp were always going to find promotion hard fought But what makes it worse is having a manager who knows he was no where near first choice and a panel of players who know the same. You factor the coin hes getting and the last time he managed at inter county level and it equates to a CB who had run out of options and were trying to save face after the next manager will be a show of intent statement. I am still baffled by the whole thing.

McGeever would have a special rapport with players from the South and with the Commercial players in particular!

The Lost Sheep

evolving tipperary wrote: »

I didn't criticize you for anything? Where did I do that? I merely stated that TG asked everyone...

Also, I said there is room for two. Is there not?

You have shifted it into a different forum without asking anyone - which is your entitlement. But, people are also allowed to set up another if they wish or keep the same one going where it was. Yes?

No one said yours will not work. It will, and so will TG's thread. Everyone's hapy - I'm hoping that TG keeps his going in the Tipp forum. Quality, not quantity I say!

The below is clear criticism.....
"At least, Tipp Gunner democratically asked people where we wanted it set up???"
How have I shifted anything into a different forum. I created the thread in this forum where it always is.
I created the 2016 thread in the Tipperary forum.

Xenophile wrote: »

It is my understanding that Liam Kearns the incoming Manager of the Tipperary Football team was not at the game in Ruislip. This in spite of the fact that his huge reputed fee has now been confirmed.

Hard to believe when one considers that Clonmel Commercials could easily provide the back bone of the 2016 Senior Football team.

Roll on the day when Charlie McGeever is appointed Manager.

I don't see how Kearns not being at the game means anything bad for his management reign. How does it? Clonmel may provide back bone of the county side but Kearns not being in charge doesn't mean he wont see the game, have footage of the game, get reports on the players he needs etc

digzy

Xenophile wrote: »

McGeever would have a special rapport with players from the South

What the fcuk are you on about....have you evidence of this or just further ramblings

I'd like to think the manager would pick the best players as opposed to ones with whom he'd have an alleged 'rapport'. I don't care whether they're from carrick on suir, aherlow, lorrha or templederry.

I seriously doubt Mc Geever sits down before picking his tipp teams thinking 'i don't like those northern, western or mid crowd, just southsiders for me':rolleyes:

digzy

evolving tipperary wrote: »

I didn't criticize you for anything? Where did I do that? I merely stated that TG asked everyone...

Also, I said there is room for two. Is there not?

You have shifted it into a different forum without asking anyone - which is your entitlement. But, people are also allowed to set up another if they wish or keep the same one going where it was. Yes?

No one said yours will not work. It will, and so will TG's thread. Everyone's hapy - I'm hoping that TG keeps his going in the Tipp forum. Quality, not quantity I say!

I cant believe fellas are arguing over whether there's one forum or two or where a forum sits:rolleyes:

obviously, anyone posting here (myself included) have little to be doing but getting into a 'barney' over something sooooo silly..........jesus wept.

Neon_Lights

digzy wrote: »

What the fcuk are you on about....have you evidence of this or just further ramblings

I'd like to think the manager would pick the best players as opposed to ones with whom he'd have an alleged 'rapport'. I don't care whether they're from carrick on suir, aherlow, lorrha or templederry.

I seriously doubt Mc Geever sits down before picking his tipp teams thinking 'i don't like those northern, western or mid crowd, just southsiders for me':rolleyes:

South Tipp has been more football inclined, and has been taken a little more seriously than the north of the county, it would make sense that there are more players flowing through the ranks. Not saying that there arent good players from north tipp cause there are, the setup just isnt conducive for footballers making the bridge from underage to senior level. Case in point 2 senior clubs who are a mishmash of about 5.

evolving tipperary

digzy wrote: »

evolving tipperary wrote: »

I didn't criticize you for anything? Where did I do that? I merely stated that TG asked everyone...

Also, I said there is room for two. Is there not?

You have shifted it into a different forum without asking anyone - which is your entitlement. But, people are also allowed to set up another if they wish or keep the same one going where it was. Yes?

No one said yours will not work. It will, and so will TG's thread. Everyone's hapy - I'm hoping that TG keeps his going in the Tipp forum. Quality, not quantity I say!

I cant believe fellas are arguing over whether there's one forum or two or where a forum sits:rolleyes:

obviously, anyone posting here (myself included) have little to be doing but getting into a 'barney' over something sooooo silly..........jesus wept.

What barney? I didn't ask you for an opinion on a discussion with someone else... - you're the gatekeeper of opinion? Go away and enjoy your life like a good man!

Spirit of 67

Xenophile wrote: »

It is my understanding that Liam Kearns the incoming Manager of the Tipperary Football team was not at the game in Ruislip. This in spite of the fact that his huge reputed fee has now been confirmed.

Hard to believe when one considers that Clonmel Commercials could easily provide the back bone of the 2016 Senior Football team.

Roll on the day when Charlie McGeever is appointed Manager.

He has been at a lot of games , Munster , County Final etc , at this stage I reckon he has seen what he can work with . When he was first appointed unofficially about 2 Months ago , who would have seen Commercials winning Munster ? Tipp will probably be missing the Commercials Players at the start of the League campaign anyway .

McGeever is a good Manager but lets give Kearns a chance ! Oh and remember McGeever didn`t want the job and doesn`t want to be involved with Tipp at any level next year as he is f@cked after having a tough year !

Mantis Toboggan

Xenophile wrote: »

This in spite of the fact that his huge reputed fee has now been confirmed.

How much we talking?

digzy

evolving tipperary wrote: »

What barney? I didn't ask you for an opinion on a discussion with someone else... - you're the gatekeeper of opinion? Go away and enjoy your life like a good man!

Sure open up a third thread.

You wanna have a discussion with someone else pm them.....you're having a discussion on a forum don't have a period when people post:eek:

digzy

Tyson Fury wrote: »

How much we talking?

I wouldn't hold your breath.....

1eg0a3xv7b82of

Tyson Fury wrote: »

How much we talking?

100+

Mantis Toboggan

Marlee Shrilling Vegetable wrote: »

100+

Huh? Spill the beans

1eg0a3xv7b82of

Tyson Fury wrote: »

Huh? Spill the beans

Here you go in code
A=50
T=110+E

I heard this through reliable sources.

Mantis Toboggan

Marlee Shrilling Vegetable wrote: »

Here you go in code
A=50
T=110+E

I heard this through reliable sources.

Ah thanks, that makes sense now..

Xenophile

Tyson Fury wrote: »

Ah thanks, that makes sense now..

The people in the know are keeping quiet, and they are not going to put in writing on the Internet.

ReacherCreature

evolving tipperary wrote: »

Does that mean you rate or don't rate him?

No opinion of him just that if feels like he is on an extended panel at the start of each year and rarely seems to make the final cut.

buggy beag

Tipperary v offaly january 10th 2016 in templemore at 2pm.let the games begin.mon da premier.:)