Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Waterford GAA Discussion Thread 3 ***Updated Mod Note Post 1***

15354565859203

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,851 ✭✭✭Mountainlad


    Taught Moran with his past in defence could be up to it...but in hindsight we'll need someone with pace....could dunford be up to it :)

    If he's going to play center forward and be man marked I'd say you'll see Jamie Barron on him.'


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 16,768 ✭✭✭✭tomwaterford


    If he's going to play center forward and be man marked I'd say you'll see Jamie Barron on him.'

    Jesus I recall Jamie Barron filling in the centre back spot in the nowlan park massacre last year...bad memories

    Though I know he tends to play as a kinda playmaker/midfieldeR


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,851 ✭✭✭Mountainlad


    Jesus I recall Jamie Barron filling in the centre back spot in the nowlan park massacre last year...bad memories

    Though I know he tends to play as a kinda playmaker/midfieldeR

    He was put on Colin Fennelly, was a physical mismatch. Hogan is obviously very strong with great balance but I still think this suits him better. But if you're marking Hogan it's a case of damage limitation anyway.

    Either way, I'm only guessing.


  • Registered Users Posts: 328 ✭✭HatchetMan7


    HillFarmer wrote: »
    Ok, lets look forward to the Kilkenny match.
    Below is their team that played in the Leinster final along with the scorers.

    E Murphy;

    P Murphy, J Holden, J Tyrrell;

    P Walsh, K Joyce, C Buckley;

    C Fogarty (0-01), W Walsh (0-02);

    R Hogan (0-04), J Power, C Fennelly (0-02);

    G Aylward (0-03), TJ Reid (1-09), E Larkin (0-04).


    So if you were Derek Mcgrath what chinks / vunrabilities do you see to exploit? If our system can nullify 2 out of Hogan, Larkin and Reid I think we have a chance.

    Would love to here people views.
    Will Kilkenny employ the same tactic as Dublin and push a person forward on the sweeper?

    If tyrell is out then the only experience in that full back line is Murphy, Holden is a new Fullback.

    Will watch the Leinster final later



    I would think that Waterford will start with normal 6 backs and the sweeper (7 total) and either 2/3 in midfield and 4/5 in attack. Kilkenny will line out the normal 15. I would say that that's what the positioning will look like for both teams for the first 10 mins. After this both managers will start to tweak a few things here and their depending how the game is evolving.
    The reason why Waterford should line out this way at the start is because Kilkenny always try and go for the jugular early on. It takes about 5/10 min for a lot of teams to get into the game where as Kilkenny usually hit the ground running. Waterford must keep it tight early on to gain confidence. But for Waterford to win this game they'll have to take some risks as the game progresses and IMO we'll need to get at least 2 goals because its hard to see us scoring more points over the 70 mins.
    If there is a player that Waterford might be able to exploit in the Kilkenny backline it may be Joyce at centre back. Walsh is a very good wing back and Buckley is as good a wing back as is out there right now. Murphy is probably the best corner back in the country and Holden has dealt with everything thrown at him so far. Tyrrell hasn't had a good year so far by his own standards but he could be a different animal come semi final stage in Croke Park. (Prendergast looks solid enough if Tyrrell doesn't make it). Waterford will need to really mix up their play from moving the ball wide out the wings and pulling the corner backs and wing backs as far away from the centre as possible, to making deep runs through the centre off loading to secondary runners quickly.


  • Registered Users Posts: 134 ✭✭Tramore84


    deiseach wrote: »
    I'd say you couldn't pass a cigarette paper between Tipperary and Kilkenny at this point. The ease with which Galway swatted aside Cork might suggest that Tipp are going to have the tougher examination in the semi-final though.

    Agreed - its hard to call at this stage who will win the final, Tipp or Kk. The semi-finals should give a good indication of where their form is at. I think Kk would be better off getting a good test against Waterford.


  • Registered Users Posts: 397 ✭✭carter10


    Id go with

    SOK

    S FIVES B COUGHLAN N CONNORS

    T de B

    K MORAN D FIVES P MAHONY

    J BARRON BRICK

    A GLEESON J DILLON S BENNETT

    Id start with that set up anyway. Would be losing Morans point scoring ability having him that far back. I dont have Dunford in as I think his confidence is low and his shooting has been off for the last 3 games. His pace may be an asset later in the game.

    MAURICE P CURRAN


  • Registered Users Posts: 328 ✭✭HatchetMan7


    Here's an alternative 15 we could see (Que the jokes about formation)

    S O' Keeffe

    S Fives---B Coughlan---N Connors

    T De Burca

    S Daniels--D Fives--P Mahoney

    K Moran
    J Barron

    J Dillon---M Walsh---A Gleeson

    ---M Shanahan---S Bennett---


  • Registered Users Posts: 328 ✭✭HatchetMan7


    Just read a piece on Stephan Daniels on the papers. He has been out since 2012, forgot how long he was out for. He has been putting ice on his knee every day for the last 2 and a half years. Now thats commitment fair play to him. Played well when he got the call. Thats what Waterford need players that can overcome adversity and he's not alone.


  • Registered Users Posts: 134 ✭✭Tramore84


    Just read a piece on Stephan Daniels on the papers. He has been out since 2012, forgot how long he was out for. He has been putting ice on his knee for the last 2 and a half years. Now thats commitment fair play to him. Played well when he got the call.

    Thought he played very well and made some important catches/clearances in the the full back line


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 488 ✭✭Ropaire


    Here's an alternative 15 we could see (Que the jokes about formation)

    S O' Keeffe

    S Fives---B Coughlan---N Connors

    T De Burca

    S Daniels--D Fives--P Mahoney

    K Moran
    J Barron

    J Dillon---M Walsh---A Gleeson

    ---M Shanahan---S Bennett---

    I like the look of this team. I'd prob swap Shane Fives to wing back for Daniels purely for his scoring threat, if it turns into a long range shootout we need anyone who can take a score on the ball! The balance of it looks nice though.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 580 ✭✭✭HillFarmer


    Just read a piece on Stephan Daniels on the papers. He has been out since 2012, forgot how long he was out for. He has been putting ice on his knee every day for the last 2 and a half years. Now thats commitment fair play to him. Played well when he got the call. Thats what Waterford need players that can overcome adversity and he's not alone.

    I'm a great fan of Daniels, i think hes going to be a serious half back in the next few years, that's where I'd put him anyway.

    With someone of his and D fives calibre, Connors loss wont be as hard felt ( if he can't make it)


  • Registered Users Posts: 325 ✭✭MUFC91CS


    Here's an alternative 15 we could see (Que the jokes about formation)

    S O' Keeffe

    S Fives---B Coughlan---N Connors

    T De Burca

    S Daniels--D Fives--P Mahoney

    K Moran
    J Barron

    J Dillon---M Walsh---A Gleeson

    ---M Shanahan---S Bennett---

    This except i'd put Daniels in the corner and leave Noel pick up Richie Hogan. The best man marker we have and probably one of the best in the country at it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 580 ✭✭✭HillFarmer


    MUFC91CS wrote: »
    This except i'd put Daniels in the corner and leave Noel pick up Richie Hogan. The best man marker we have and probably one of the best in the country at it.


    But then who loses out?

    I see guys on here saying Dunford should be dropped but I'd disagree with that.


  • Registered Users Posts: 325 ✭✭MUFC91CS


    HillFarmer wrote: »
    But then who loses out?

    I see guys on here saying Dunford should be dropped but I'd disagree with that.

    Actually from the above team that Hatchetman has id probably replace Dillon with Dunford. Id basically go with

    Sok
    Fives, Coughlan, Daniels
    TDB
    Fives, Connors (mm Hogan) Mahoney,
    Moran Barron
    Dunford, Walsh, Gleeson,
    Bennett, Shanahan


  • Registered Users Posts: 495 ✭✭Formosa


    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=S6P0DYa7zu8

    How many all Ireland's did Cha win again?

    Surprised at you using that one ML (regardless of the idiocy of the comment you were responding to), Cha got Tom Kenny's hurl to the nuts and had to be stretchered off, there was no faking it there.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 1,243 ✭✭✭deiseach


    It would take some cojones to drop Dunford at this stage. Then again, that's what management are there for - to make the hard decisions...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 580 ✭✭✭HillFarmer


    MUFC91CS wrote: »
    Actually from the above team that Hatchetman has id probably replace Dillon with Dunford. Id basically go with

    Sok
    Fives, Coughlan, Daniels
    TDB
    Fives, Connors (mm Hogan) Mahoney,
    Moran Barron
    Dunford, Walsh, Gleeson,
    Bennett, Shanahan


    Check out the first two minutes of the all ireland replay last year.
    The amount of blocks KK get in is ridiculous, sets the tone early.
    In regards to workrate we'll have to be vicious if we've any chance.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lc1t9VrhG34


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 905 ✭✭✭skaface


    Does anyone know uf there Will there be "match specials" trains going directly to Connolly station from Waterford for the semi final ??
    I presume there would be enough demand for at least two of them.. Especially with the crowd going the next day


  • Registered Users Posts: 428 ✭✭blueflame


    If Waterford are to win, they need to believe in their own game and keep focused all the time from start to finish with a savage work rate. Alot of talk about RichiesHogan who is a fabulous player and about how he hurt Galway. That was because he played deep off the centre back and found alot of space around midfield. This is where Barron has a vital roll to play, if de Burca Continues to play just in front of the back three, Barron will most likely find himself face to face with Hogan a lot of the time and if going to have to pick him up on breaking balls. Incidentally I feel that Barron has the right temperament to do that like Hogan he is relatively small and nippy with fast feet and a low center of gravity. Remember how effective he was as a corner back at underage. Don't agree with man to man marking because it is to easy to drag defences apart and create space to run into and KK forwards will absolutely love that. Equally with TJ Reid we need to be sure that a very tight reign is kept on him and double teamed as often as possible. I believe Moran and Gleeson running from midfield will be key along with a savage work rate from the forwards hassling and harrying the KK back and not giving them time to pick their clearances.

    Key also will be the use of our bench, This will not doubt with the level of work rate expected be a 20 man game. Subs will play a key part and for once I feel that potentially we have a bench to match the KK one, especially with the potential injuries they face. Felt we were a bit slow the last day to use the bench and were tiring in the last few minutes,. We will need to act quicker on Sunday week.

    Am looking forward to a mighty battle. KK are justifiably favourites and are an excellent side but are not unbeatable. Forget about last years result in Nolan Park, we are a million miles from there now, and forget about 2008, water under the bridge. Our lads must believe in themselves and have no fear of the KK jersey, it is the players inside the jersey that win the game, not the jersey itself. Likewise history and tradition might help, but they will not win the game.

    Waterford despite the odds being stacked against them have earned their right to their place in this semi-final. They have come from a position where they were no hopers for promotion from 1B at the start of the year having been drawn away to their three main rivals for promotion Limerick, Offaly and Wexford. They overcame that challenge. They overcame Galway, Tipp and Cork to win the league when no one had given them a prayer at the outset. They lost Pauric Mahony after the league final and according to the pundits with him went our chances of progress as we were totally reliant on our free taker - it didn't happen. Cork were to catch us with a backlash, but did they no. Tipp would put manners on us, despite what many would have you believe, i believe they far from did this. I believe there was very little in it and i don't buy into this second or third gear rubbish either. Tipp needed to win that Munster Final more than we did and on their home ground too.

    Dublin had a big game in them and Tipp had found out our system, and how would the team deal with their first loss of the year. They dealt with these issues without too much fuss.

    I am confident that we can put it up to KK and we are capable of triumphing. Our side are not too young, seize the day. I am expecting a tight game that will go very close to the wire and praying we come out on the right side but more than anything else i am hoping to see a Waterford side who honestly believe that they are where they deserve to be and show no fear - i do not expect to be disappointed.


  • Registered Users Posts: 147 ✭✭cascade12


    To TTM, just looking back at a post from 13th of December last, and my reply to you. What is your opinion now?


    Quote:
    Originally Posted by thinkstoomuch1
    Lost by six points high scoring game
    Third loss in row last week in wexford, Galway and now dublin beat them
    You would hope for sake Waterford hurling mcgrath gets sacked as soon as possible

    and then TTM
    Don't get excited, I'm not making insult Waterford merely saying many geuine real real knowledge Waterford fans know there's real trouble in the camp , two coaches gone, players gone, etc not happy camp

    Fellas like yourself are always around credit due can't see what realism shows but just like cork football don't critise the shambles exists and say ah its woeful but hey don't be harsh thinks can only get better

    Waterford played tonight as individuals not team talent is there but no team work
    I think many Waterford fans here disagree your view ye beat cork under current set up
    Cork have problems yes but Waterford management won't expose them
    That's not geuinely being arrogant, it's called realism.



    cascade12
    Maybe you should concentrate on the state of Cork hurling. Agreed, Derek McGath did not have a great first year in charge but looking to sack a manager after 3 challenge matches in December is a little over the top. He has brought in an excellent coach in Fintan O Connor who has led Cappoquin to a County and Munster title in his first year with the club and winning a Fitzgibbon with WIT earlier in the year. He also did an excellent job with Fourmilewater previous to that, and I have no doubt will be a very good addition to the Waterford set up.
    FWIW I was at the game tonight and was very pleased with what I saw from a very experimental side. Jamie Barron was very good at centre field as was Brick at centre and full forward, Paudie Mahoney and Mickey Kearney impressed also against a good and very fit and athletic Dublin team. Look out for Barron at midfield next year, quality.
    If I was you , I would be more than a little worried about Waterford next June. You might then be wishing that it was JBM who should have been sacked. For the sake of Cork hurling I hope he is not even though they were a shambles against Tipp in the semi. But lets give him and McGrath the next year before passing judgement and dont forget we could go back and inspect JBMs, Eamon O Sheas or even the great Brian Codys first year in charge and it might not make for great reading. So lets stop the witch hunt and discuss the games we attend, and not depend on second hand information.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,851 ✭✭✭Mountainlad


    Formosa wrote: »
    Surprised at you using that one ML (regardless of the idiocy of the comment you were responding to), Cha got Tom Kenny's hurl to the nuts and had to be stretchered off, there was no faking it there.

    To be honest I was responding in kind. It was a really dirty stroke by Tom Kenny. It's the first time I've ever seen a lad be stretchered off having been hit in the balls though but like somebody said about Maurice I'm not gonna volunteer to find out if the stretcher really was necessary.


  • Registered Users Posts: 488 ✭✭Ropaire


    To be honest I was responding in kind. It was a really dirty stroke by Tom Kenny. It's the first time I've ever seen a lad be stretchered off having been hit in the balls though but like somebody said about Maurice I'm not gonna volunteer to find out if the stretcher really was necessary.

    I saw a clubmate lose a nut in a game years ago, stretcher wasn't much use for the lad at all at the time...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,851 ✭✭✭Mountainlad


    Ropaire wrote: »
    I saw a clubmate lose a nut in a game years ago, stretcher wasn't much use for the lad at all at the time...

    I can only imagine the strike was a lot worse than Kennys even in saying his was awful to see.


  • Registered Users Posts: 488 ✭✭Ropaire


    I can only imagine the strike was a lot worse than Kennys even in saying his was awful to see.

    He took a sliotar full force though, what Kenny did didn't seem to have the force to do much damage if we're honest.


  • Registered Users Posts: 1,152 ✭✭✭redlead


    Where do all the half decent seats go these days? It doesn't matter whether I get them through club, online or supervalue, they always seem to be off the far end of the stand. It's pretty bad to try to offload all the worst seats first.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,851 ✭✭✭Mountainlad


    On the Dublin game, in his constant pessimism PTH made a decent point regarding Dublins prep for the game.

    They had 4 championship matches under their belt and some confidence having won two on he bounce. I've watched the first half and though we didn't hit the levels we should be hitting they hurled well. By contrast, though the Munster final was only two weeks ago before that we'd been waiting 5 weeks and 5 weeks again for a match. Kilkenny have an awesome record in semi finals to be fair so on the face of it the 5 week break wouldn't be an issue but last year they were now victors v Limerick, and I recall the 2008 all Ireland semi final it was quite close between themselves and Cork until Larkin goaled after about 25 minutes. Compare that to 2012 when they had the quarter final and it was probably their best ever performance in a semi final.

    Anyway a lot was made of Waterford getting the breaks whatever that means, but between Shane Bennetts fresh air effort at goal and SOKs hard luck with the goal Id argue against that. Much was made of the 10 minutes after half time too, but Dublin got the last 3 scores before half time too.

    Jamie Barron was close to man of the match for me. In contrast to what someone said earlier, he never seems to waste a ball for me and gets on some load of it. There's some difference between the close control skill in tight spots exhibited by himself, Shane Bennett and even Partick Currans quick thinking for the second goal compared to Kevin Morans. I know what Moran brings to the team and its a lot but he ran into trouble twice in the first half and constantly has problems picking the ball up in matches I notice. Hurley looks a bit long. I do remember an interview with him last year where he talked about the soccer and said he was a bit late to commuting to hurling and wouldn't be he most natural hurler. Still gets some brilliant long range scores and takes the game to the opposition.

    As for the next Id ideally like to see 5 forwards, Brick wing Aussie center and both Maurice and Bennett swapping out between wing and full for the game. Leave Dunford in the full forward line for the whole game. I think Joyce can be got at and Aussie is he man to do it as he can punish mistakes and compete in the air plus run at him too. Brick can or deployed on whichever wing backs influence needs to be curbed the most, both are class. And then on the other switched Maurice and Bennett to keep them guessing.

    Midfield would probably be Moran and Darragh Fives if he was fit enough but I think that's where the problem lies in that it requires Darragh and Daniels to start and both are only really just back so it's asking a lot. Bourke would sit deep and Barron would cover in behind midfield, letting Hogan off if he decides to go back into his own half.

    I think though it'll be the same team that started the last day with Austin Gleeson around the middle with Moran.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 39,605 ✭✭✭✭KevIRL


    redlead wrote: »
    Where do all the half decent seats go these days? It doesn't matter whether I get them through club, online or supervalue, they always seem to be off the far end of the stand. It's pretty bad to try to offload all the worst seats first.

    Clubs, county board and season ticket holders and rightly so tbf. Worth remembering as well that tickets for the semi final have been on sale for a couple of months now. Nuetrals and KK fans would have been able to get good seats some weeks back. There was still 304 lower Cusack seats available last Sunday afternoon after the match though.

    Mind you there really isn't a bad view in croker anyway


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,664 ✭✭✭dirkmeister


    redlead wrote: »
    Where do all the half decent seats go these days? It doesn't matter whether I get them through club, online or supervalue, they always seem to be off the far end of the stand. It's pretty bad to try to offload all the worst seats first.

    We got tickets for the Leinster final in the ticket office in Drumcondra the day of the game.
    We were in 406,the old Ard Comhairle.

    I wouldn't panic about crap tickets at all, there will be good ones released next week.


  • Registered Users Posts: 893 ✭✭✭hurler on de ditch


    skaface wrote: »
    Does anyone know uf there Will there be "match specials" trains going directly to Connolly station from Waterford for the semi final ??
    I presume there would be enough demand for at least two of them.. Especially with the crowd going the next day
    most definitely 1 going ,departs 10.15 from what i hear


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 739 ✭✭✭robopaddy2


    skaface wrote: »
    Does anyone know uf there Will there be "match specials" trains going directly to Connolly station from Waterford for the semi final ??
    I presume there would be enough demand for at least two of them.. Especially with the crowd going the next day

    Youd be hard pressed to get a train direct to Connolly from Waterford considering the trainline ends at Heuston


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 905 ✭✭✭skaface


    robopaddy2 wrote: »
    Youd be hard pressed to get a train direct to Connolly from Waterford considering the trainline ends at Heuston

    Tell you what you know about it..


  • Registered Users Posts: 354 ✭✭3ships


    robopaddy2 wrote: »
    Youd be hard pressed to get a train direct to Connolly from Waterford considering the trainline ends at Heuston

    Special Train always serves Connolly. Was a big deal but motorway there now it's handy enough to get there. And no need for the Chartered flights of 2004


  • Registered Users Posts: 354 ✭✭3ships


    Just looking back over previous posts on team selection. I wouldn't drop Dunford but it is great to see the discussion and the options are there.
    Another thing is that I remember going up to semi finals with the cats thinking only Mullane, Brick or maybe Moran would get a look in with our esteemed neighbours. It is different now but granted the like of Hogan and Reid and Larkin are just outstanding.
    Still if you picked a combined team and only for fun

    Murphy
    Murphy
    Fives
    Connors
    Fives
    Bourke
    Buckley
    Fennelly
    Moran
    Reid
    Hogan
    Brick
    Larkin
    Shan
    Gleeson


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 739 ✭✭✭robopaddy2


    3ships wrote: »
    Just looking back over previous posts on team selection. I wouldn't drop Dunford but it is great to see the discussion and the options are there.
    Another thing is that I remember going up to semi finals with the cats thinking only Mullane, Brick or maybe Moran would get a look in with our esteemed neighbours. It is different now but granted the like of Hogan and Reid and Larkin are just outstanding.
    Still if you picked a combined team and only for fun

    Murphy
    Murphy
    Fives
    Connors
    Fives
    Bourke
    Buckley
    Fennelly
    Moran
    Reid
    Hogan
    Brick
    Larkin
    Shan
    Gleeson

    SOK was the 1st choice WIT keeper at Fitzgibbon ahead of Murphy albeit Murphy was able to be accommodated out the field where he is good on the frees. Being a bit generous to us otherwise to be fair. Colin Fennelly would surely have to be in there, Walter Walsh aswell. Although going on current form most lads on our tam would challenge for a place on the KK team.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 739 ✭✭✭robopaddy2


    skaface wrote: »
    Tell you what you know about it..

    It was a joke


  • Registered Users Posts: 328 ✭✭HatchetMan7


    3ships wrote: »
    Just looking back over previous posts on team selection. I wouldn't drop Dunford but it is great to see the discussion and the options are there.
    Another thing is that I remember going up to semi finals with the cats thinking only Mullane, Brick or maybe Moran would get a look in with our esteemed neighbours. It is different now but granted the like of Hogan and Reid and Larkin are just outstanding.
    Still if you picked a combined team and only for fun

    Murphy
    Murphy
    Fives
    Connors
    Fives
    Bourke
    Buckley
    Fennelly
    Moran
    Reid
    Hogan
    Brick
    Larkin
    Shan
    Gleeson

    Ha ha you may get some shtick from some Kilkenny posters on that team but tbf Shane Fives/Holden and Darragh Fives/Walsh and i suppose brick/colin fennelly are the only ones that they could debate imo. If Richie Power and Paudie Mahoney were not injured it would make life a little more difficult.


  • Registered Users Posts: 354 ✭✭3ships


    robopaddy2 wrote: »
    SOK was the 1st choice WIT keeper at Fitzgibbon ahead of Murphy albeit Murphy was able to be accommodated out the field where he is good on the frees. Being a bit generous to us otherwise to be fair. Colin Fennelly would surely have to be in there, Walter Walsh aswell. Although going on current form most lads on our tam would challenge for a place on the KK team.

    I understand that but its only a bit of craic. Murphy was an outfield player on that team and never in competition with SOK. I have full confidence in SOK but very impressed with Murphy on the big day in Croker. SOK well able but last 2 Munster Finals made mistakes. Not too bothered with Colin Fennelly and WW. It is interesting that the debate is open. Again only a bit of craic Hogan and Reid are unreal


  • Registered Users Posts: 354 ✭✭3ships


    Ha ha you may get some shtick from some Kilkenny posters on that team but tbf Shane Fives/Holden and Darragh Fives/Walsh and i suppose brick/colin fennelly are the only ones that they could debate imo. If Richie Power and Paudie Mahoney were not injured it would make life a little more difficult.

    Big fan of the Fives lads. Richie Power is another of the unreal type


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 739 ✭✭✭robopaddy2


    3ships wrote: »
    I understand that but its only a bit of craic. Murphy was an outfield player on that team and never in competition with SOK. I have full confidence in SOK but very impressed with Murphy on the big day in Croker. SOK well able but last 2 Munster Finals made mistakes. Not too bothered with Colin Fennelly and WW. It is interesting that the debate is open. Again only a bit of craic Hogan and Reid are unreal

    A bit of craic but a dangerous bit of craic to be having depending on which side of the county your from.... ;-)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 1,133 ✭✭✭Gardner


    Nice bit of buzz about the town on this. Was thinking back to a couple of years ago and I’m just delighted that upthedeise.com no longer exists. That gob****e Cian Foley was an awful embarrassment. The songs, the pictures and his love affair with the players. It was cringe. Although this page can be bad at times it is nowhere near that.


  • Registered Users Posts: 1,243 ✭✭✭deiseach


    Gardner wrote: »
    Nice bit of buzz about the town on this. Was thinking back to a couple of years ago and I’m just delighted that upthedeise.com no longer exists. That gob****e Cian Foley was an awful embarrassment. The songs, the pictures and his love affair with the players. It was cringe. Although this page can be bad at times it is nowhere near that.

    You're entitled to your opinion and I'm entitled my opinion that this is very mean-spirited.


  • Registered Users Posts: 365 ✭✭JimboJones99


    3ships wrote: »
    Just looking back over previous posts on team selection. I wouldn't drop Dunford but it is great to see the discussion and the options are there.
    Another thing is that I remember going up to semi finals with the cats thinking only Mullane, Brick or maybe Moran would get a look in with our esteemed neighbours. It is different now but granted the like of Hogan and Reid and Larkin are just outstanding.
    Still if you picked a combined team and only for fun

    Murphy
    Murphy
    Fives
    Connors
    Fives
    Bourke
    Buckley
    Fennelly
    Moran
    Reid
    Hogan
    Brick
    Larkin
    Shan
    Gleeson

    Not trying to wind you up but I dont think it is different now, the gap has just significantly closed. I think if both teams had fully fit panels to choose from only Moran and Conners would definitely make the team. De Burca possibly even though if he was forced to man mark, I would pick Joyce over him. The likes of Shanahan and Brick would push Colin Fennelly close. Gleeson has potential to be a gret hurler and but wouldnt be good enough at the minute for me. I have no doubt that in 2-3 years the spread of players will be much more even though when a lot of Waterfords players get more experience. IMO the team would be

    Murphy
    Murphy
    Holden
    Conners
    Walsh
    De Burca
    Buckley
    Fennelly
    Fogarty
    Moran
    Hogan
    Reid
    Fennelly
    Power
    Larkin

    I'm still not writing Waterford off for Sunday week though. I know the system they play is a a controversial point but it is effective and throw in a bit of luck with an early goal and you never know but I envisage something similar to the provinical finals where the game will be tight for the most part but KK will win pulling up.


  • Registered Users Posts: 1,209 ✭✭✭seananigans


    robopaddy2 wrote: »
    Youd be hard pressed to get a train direct to Connolly from Waterford considering the trainline ends at Heuston


    match day trains can utilise the phoenix park tunnel dropping you out in drumcondra station, have taken this train previously.

    http://www.independent.ie/irish-news/plans-for-four-trains-an-hour-in-phoenix-park-tunnel-next-year-31051427.html

    Most traffic through the tunnel is carriages and engines being moved between Heuston and Connolly for maintenance.
    It has occasionally been used for special services, including major GAA fixtures, but less so in recent years.
    The line emerges from the tunnel parallel to the North Circular Road and passes through Cabra and Glasnevin, connecting with the track that goes through Drumcondra station and on to Connolly.


  • Registered Users Posts: 683 ✭✭✭conditioned games


    Gardner wrote: »
    Nice bit of buzz about the town on this. Was thinking back to a couple of years ago and I’m just delighted that upthedeise.com no longer exists. That gob****e Cian Foley was an awful embarrassment. The songs, the pictures and his love affair with the players. It was cringe. Although this page can be bad at times it is nowhere near that.

    Fair play to him or who ever was behind the website, gave me a lot of entertainment over the years. Anything that promotes the game of hurling in Waterford and gets people involved I think is a good thing. You must be rightly pissed off people are now discussing Waterford gaa matters on boards.ie


  • Registered Users Posts: 4,605 ✭✭✭blue note


    Gardner wrote: »
    Nice bit of buzz about the town on this. Was thinking back to a couple of years ago and I’m just delighted that upthedeise.com no longer exists. That gob****e Cian Foley was an awful embarrassment. The songs, the pictures and his love affair with the players. It was cringe. Although this page can be bad at times it is nowhere near that.

    I used to enjoy that site. An awful lot of nonsense posted on the site, but all harmless stuff. There were a few decent posters on it too.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 354 ✭✭3ships


    Not trying to wind you up but I dont think it is different now, the gap has just significantly closed. I think if both teams had fully fit panels to choose from only Moran and Conners would definitely make the team. De Burca possibly even though if he was forced to man mark, I would pick Joyce over him. The likes of Shanahan and Brick would push Colin Fennelly close. Gleeson has potential to be a gret hurler and but wouldnt be good enough at the minute for me. I have no doubt that in 2-3 years the spread of players will be much more even though when a lot of Waterfords players get more experience. IMO the team would be

    Murphy
    Murphy
    Holden
    Conners
    Walsh
    De Burca
    Buckley
    Fennelly
    Fogarty
    Moran
    Hogan
    Reid
    Fennelly
    Power
    Larkin

    I'm still not writing Waterford off for Sunday week though. I know the system they play is a a controversial point but it is effective and throw in a bit of luck with an early goal and you never know but I envisage something similar to the provinical finals where the game will be tight for the most part but KK will win pulling up.

    Ye there is not much in a few of those, the goalies for a start. Shanahan and Gleeson are in the top ten of the betting for Hurler of the year so its not just my bias to prefer them. There are many factors at play: systems, tactics work rate. The Croke Park factor is huge. Richie Powers availabilty another


  • Registered Users Posts: 257 ✭✭dcrosskid


    3ships wrote: »
    Ye there is not much in a few of those, the goalies for a start. Shanahan and Gleeson are in the top ten of the betting for Hurler of the year so its not just my bias to prefer them. There are many factors at play: systems, tactics work rate. The Croke Park factor is huge. Richie Powers availabilty another

    Jamie Barron would give Fogarty a serious run for his money for a spot at midfield considering his form this year. Very impressed with him.


  • Registered Users Posts: 365 ✭✭JimboJones99


    dcrosskid wrote: »
    Jamie Barron would give Fogarty a serious run for his money for a spot at midfield considering his form this year. Very impressed with him.

    Yeah all these things are subjective. Being honest, I have watched Fogarty much more closer than I would have watched Jamie Barron so I suppose this clouds it a bit. I would have massive time for Fogarty and I think he is one of KK's most important players. He does an awful lot of the dirty work and is happy not to stand out and just deliver quick intellingent ball into our big guns to do the damage. Will be even more important if Fennelly is out.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 39,107 ✭✭✭✭PTH2009


    We got tickets for the Leinster final in the ticket office in Drumcondra the day of the game.
    We were in 406,the old Ard Comhairle.

    I wouldn't panic about crap tickets at all, there will be good ones released next week.
    crap tickets on both tickets.ie and ticketmaster. Supervalue use the same system so they wont have any better. perfer upper section myself so going to wait til/if they open the section.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,521 ✭✭✭Dick phelan


    Are they opening the terrace?


  • Advertisement
This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement