Retaken penalty after the match was over

Thud

Uefa setting an unusual precident with this, will we see a few managers demanding a retake for dodgy penalty decisions from now on?
http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/32242750

Pudsy33

In fairness it wasn't a dodgy penalty decision, the referee didn't know the rules.

Mars Bar

It would have been the correct decision if Williamson missed the penalty! It's harsh on the ref in the middle to get sent home when there was a whole ref team involved.

Seve OB

seen that yesterday

first of all, the penalty was not deemed invalid because there was a player in the box.... there wasn't... i freeze framed the video and clearly no player in the box

whatever about that, the ref should have allowed the kick be taken again

whatever about that, i don't think there should be a replay allowed. how many times down through the years have we seen referees making mistake after mistake... how many times have we seen a replay been given as a result?... never.... a dangerous precedent to set IMO

mush better off cleaning up their act and allowing the likes of a video ref

Thud

Seve OB wrote: »

seen that yesterday

first of all, the penalty was not deemed invalid because there was a player in the box.... there wasn't... i freeze framed the video and clearly no player in the box

whatever about that, the ref should have allowed the kick be taken again

whatever about that, i don't think there should be a replay allowed. how many times down through the years have we seen referees making mistake after mistake... how many times have we seen a replay been given as a result?... never.... a dangerous precedent to set IMO

mush better off cleaning up their act and allowing the likes of a video ref

it wasn't even a full replay which might have been fairer, it was the penalty and the couple of second that were left to play after the original penalty....ridiculous the rest of the team had to get togged out for it....weird decision

Mars Bar

But playing on from that minute was the correct decision. It seems ridiculous coz it happened at the last kick of the game. It happened between Bahrain and someone else and the full match was replayed. Bahrain should have been at the wrong side of the decision but ended up drawing the replay and qualifying on goal difference.

CSF

Mars Bar wrote: »

It would have been the correct decision if Williamson missed the penalty! It's harsh on the ref in the middle to get sent home when there was a whole ref team involved.

I wouldn't say harsh. Clearly she shouldn't have been there in the first place

Guy:Incognito

Thud wrote: »

.ridiculous the rest of the team had to get togged out for it....weird decision

They both played matches before it I think. Definitely at some stage yesterday.

Hulk Hands

I haven't seen this incident so not talking about this specifically, but surely that rule has to be changed. If the attacking teams players encroach when their player is taking a penalty, then why should it be retaken? Theyre gaining an advantage from encroaching (first to rebounds), with zero punishment if caught. The same with goalkeepers encroaching on the other side, although ref's can use a bit of common sense there by not retaking if the pen is actually scored in that scenario

Seve OB

Hulk Hands wrote: »

I haven't seen this incident so not talking about this specifically, but surely that rule has to be changed. If the attacking teams players encroach when their player is taking a penalty, then why should it be retaken? Theyre gaining an advantage from encroaching (first to rebounds), with zero punishment if caught. The same with goalkeepers encroaching on the other side, although ref's can use a bit of common sense there by not retaking if the pen is actually scored in that scenario

take a look at it... you will be hard pushed to find any encroachment

Hulk Hands

Seve OB wrote: »

take a look at it... you will be hard pushed to find any encroachment

ffs read the first line of my post again

hullaballoo

Seve OB wrote: »

take a look at it... you will be hard pushed to find any encroachment

Are you sure you're watching the first penalty? It's pretty clear that there's an English player with both feet inside the penalty area:

bucketybuck

hullaballoo wrote: »

Are you sure you're watching the first penalty? It's pretty clear that there's an English player with both feet inside the penalty area:

And she is just standing there after the ball has been kicked, not going for any rebound at all. A bit of common sense from the referee wouldn't have gone amiss, never mind knowing the bloody rules at all.