If vote yes,can brothers get marry?

wenxue

I just want to know

If We say yes to referendum,

if man and man can get marry,Can parents get marry with their children(adult) can brother marry with his brother/sister?If we say no to them,why not?

Can man marry marry with 2 more women? if we say no,why not?

TheChizler

Can brothers and sisters currently marry? It's the same answer to all questions..

Gone West

All the posts here are archived and on the internet forever.
At some point, certain people's kids and grandkids will see the posts and exclaim that they never knew their grandmother was such a childish bigot.

Arsemageddon

In Ireland incest can only take place between a male and a female...

http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/1908/en/act/pub/0045/print.html

Galway K9

I know it sounds really out there, but when will it stop. Next is... Paedophiles are born that way and can't change who they are, so we should decriminalize that act and allow get married or have relations with kids? Will I be labelled paedophobic if I disagree with it? Or humans with animals?

Flood

Jaysus op what are you saying a mother marries her son or sisters marry each other.

Lisha

Galway K9 wrote: »

I know it sounds really out there, but when will it stop. Next is... Paedophiles are born that way and can't change who they are, so we should decriminalize that act and allow get married or have relations with kids? Will I be labelled paedophobic if I disagree with it? Or humans with animals?

I'm going to pretend the above query is serious.
Paedophilia can never be A valid option as a child can never give consent. Paedophilia will always be wrong as consent can never be given by a child to an adult.
Comparing paedophilia to homosexuality is simply incorrect.

RayM

Meanwhile, back in the early 20th Century, when female suffrage was being debated:

"Well, if you’re going to allow women to vote, aren’t you effectively also extending the franchise to children? Perhaps hamsters should be allowed to vote too."

Cody montana

Galway K9 wrote: »

I know it sounds really out there, but when will it stop. Next is... Paedophiles are born that way and can't change who they are, so we should decriminalize that act and allow get married or have relations with kids? Will I be labelled paedophobic if I disagree with it? Or humans with animals?

How borderline simple.
I think the word you are forgetting in "consenting".
No normal functioning individual would be in favour of animals and humans marrying or allowing paedophilia.
Two adults wanting to get married is pretty normal IMO.

Miguel_Sanchez

Honestly you have to wonder at people who ask these sorts of questions.

Have you no critical faculties whatsoever?

Permabear

This post has been deleted.

Gone West

Why are you fools responding to this with serious answers?

Permabear

This post has been deleted.

Joe prim

Without proper legislation, this could happen!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYlJH81dSiw

Youse have been warned!

Miguel_Sanchez

Fuzzy wrote: »

Why are you fools responding to this with serious answers?

That'd be me! Unfortunately there's so many people who actually ask these questions seriously it can be hard to tell the trolls from the real thing!

wenxue

RayM wrote: »

Meanwhile, back in the early 20th Century, when female suffrage was being debated:

"Well, if you’re going to allow women to vote, aren’t you effectively also extending the franchise to children? Perhaps hamsters should be allowed to vote too."

that's totally different

Stormington

If vote yes,can brothers get marry?

I'm sure black guys are legally allowed to get married at the minute.

Phoebas

wenxue wrote: »

that's totally different

Good. Good. Just a couple more steps; you're almost there.

Slydice

The answer is: No, brothers won't be able to marry brothers.

Here's the file with the words of the Bill:
http://www.justice.ie/en/JELR/General%20Scheme%20of%20the%20Marriage%20Bill%202015.pdf/Files/General%20Scheme%20of%20the%20Marriage%20Bill%202015.pdf

Here's the section on what isn't allowed:

Head 6: Prohibited degrees of relationship in marriage
Provide that:
6._ (1) Any prohibition on marriage between persons of the opposite sex based on
the degree of consanguinity or affinity between them contained in any provision of
law shall, with the necessary changes, be construed as applying to marriage between
persons of the same sex within the equivalent degree of consanguinity or, as the case
may be, affinity.
(2) Any marriage entered into contrary to the prohibition contained in subsection (1) shall be void.

Notice the word "consanguinity". Here's it's wikipedia page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consanguinity

So, where the old law only had a list of women to be not married, "consanguinity" means the it'll also apply to the menfolk.

Here's the "consanguinity" picture. If you see men in the same box as women, the new law will treat them like the old law only treated women:


Citizens information has the list of the women who can't be married here:
http://www.citizensinformation.ie/en/birth_family_relationships/getting_married/legal_prerequisites_for_marriage.html

Consanguinity – blood relationships

A man may not marry his:

Grandmother
Mother
Father’s sister (aunt)
Mother’s sister (aunt)
Sister
Father’s Daughter (half sister)
Mother’s Daughter (half sister)
Daughter
Son’s Daughter (granddaughter)
Daughter’s Daughter (granddaughter)
Brother’s Daughter (niece)
Sister’s Daughter (niece)

So, because Sister is included in the old law, brother would be included in the new law.



Really? Discussing it when you could've googled it? Really?

johnnyskeleton

Fuzzy wrote: »

Why are you fools responding to this with serious answers?

Mod: Because it's a serious forum

Satori Rae

Galway K9 wrote: »

I know it sounds really out there, but when will it stop. Next is... Paedophiles are born that way and can't change who they are, so we should decriminalize that act and allow get married or have relations with kids? Will I be labelled paedophobic if I disagree with it? Or humans with animals?[/QUOTE

What a complete idiotic comment............

mister gullible

wenxue wrote: »

I just want to know

If We say yes to referendum,

if man and man can get marry,Can parents get marry with their children(adult) can brother marry with his brother/sister?If we say no to them,why not?

Can man marry marry with 2 more women? if we say no,why not?

Like when I last watched Borat?

GerB40

wenxue wrote: »

I just want to know

If We say yes to referendum,

if man and man can get marry,Can parents get marry with their children(adult) can brother marry with his brother/sister?If we say no to them,why not?

Can man marry marry with 2 more women? if we say no,why not?

You're astonishingly stupid. I won't insult your use of the English language because it's clearly not your first language. But seriously, where did you find incest and bigamy being discussed regarding the upcoming referendum?

K-9

The question has been answered, I think we'll leave it there for everybodies sake.