Fair City [News, Spoilers & Discussion v6] Read Post #1 Before Contributing

Wanderer2010

I still reckon Stella might be in on it, theres no way FC would introduce her, AND give her this strange girl gang background, for no other reason as to have her as a possible abductor in the early days of her disappearance. And on top of that they were very specific to have her know about the affair. And I really got suspicious when she came back for that interview and of all the people they picked to have Love Hate hear about the affair, they picked her. Definitely something with that girl...

I do wish they would conclude it now though, I'm presuming Love Hate is a pure psychopath who loves to kidnap and torture young girls. But she just seems to be kept in a room for no reason, its weird that really nobody would have THAT much of a reason to do that to her so maybe there is more to come but I wish they would just wrap it up now.

On a side note, how many people bet that this time next year, despite all the affairs and blackmail etc..Niamh will STILL be with Paul?!

Strazdas

Wanderer2010 wrote: »

I still reckon Stella might be in on it, theres no way FC would introduce her, AND give her this strange girl gang background, for no other reason as to have her as a possible abductor in the early days of her disappearance. And on top of that they were very specific to have her know about the affair. And I really got suspicious when she came back for that interview and of all the people they picked to have Love Hate hear about the affair, they picked her. Definitely something with that girl...

I do wish they would conclude it now though, I'm presuming Love Hate is a pure psychopath who loves to kidnap and torture young girls. But she just seems to be kept in a room for no reason, its weird that really nobody would have THAT much of a reason to do that to her so maybe there is more to come but I wish they would just wrap it up now.

On a side note, how many people bet that this time next year, despite all the affairs and blackmail etc..Niamh will STILL be with Paul?!

Normally there is a sexual element when a girl Katy's age is abducted but that would be very dark for FC and a pre-watershed audience.

Katy being abducted and held hostage by her former girlfriend / date would be downright weird but I suppose you could put nothing past FC.

Wanderer2010

Strazdas wrote: »

Normally there is a sexual element when a girl Katy's age is abducted but that would be very dark for FC and a pre-watershed audience.

Katy being abducted and held hostage by her former girlfriend / date would be downright weird but I suppose you could put nothing past FC.

There might be more to it though, Stella was genuinely freaked out about her past being exposed on social media so what started as an attempt to silence her for a few weeks may have led to Katy forming a kind of bond with her and agreeing to stay away as a punishment for her mother having the affair. That's pure speculation I know but I definitely think there is more to Stella than meets the eye.

The Talking Bread

Wanderer2010 wrote: »

There might be more to it though, Stella was genuinely freaked out about her past being exposed on social media so what started as an attempt to silence her for a few weeks may have led to Katy forming a kind of bond with her and agreeing to stay away as a punishment for her mother having the affair. That's pure speculation I know but I definitely think there is more to Stella than meets the eye.

Its definitely not implausible its Stella but it would hardly be a surprise to the casual viewer, would it? The surprise element and the fact that the family haven't even considered or suspected Ciaran and his only function is to show is to beem into scenes when the word Katy is spat out just shouts out classic soap line plot.

The spoiler somewhere I read points out that

something on the lines of "living right under their nose the whole time"

Stella is seen once every 4 months so its very misleading if it were her

The Talking Bread

also surely she would be number one (identifiable ) suspect given what the guards know about her and there is no way garda surveillance wouldn't have kept an eye on her movements for a while or ensured she had legitimate alibi.

Ciaran was only one not interviewed and we saw him in Katy's last scene giving her that shifty look

Wanderer2010

^ Yeah its very obviously Love Hate who has taken her (but not raped her?, so I dunno he may just get kicks from doing it which is a weird way to drag out a story for 6 months) but I still have a niggling feeling that the whole Stella coming back for an interview was way too out of whack even for FC and Love Hate could have easily have overheard Deegan mentioning the affair, or Alana, or the Ram, or Melanie, but no, they specifically picked Stella to come back and blurt out the affair and right in front of Ciaran, just way too staged for my liking..

In the end the simplest answer is usually the truth so Ciaran has her with possible help from Stella and is defo keeping her in some makeshift pit near his private garage premises. Nothing else makes any sense.

The Talking Bread

Wanderer2010 wrote: »

^ Yeah its very obviously Love Hate who has taken her (but not raped her?, so I dunno he may just get kicks from doing it which is a weird way to drag out a story for 6 months) but I still have a niggling feeling that the whole Stella coming back for an interview was way too out of whack even for FC and Love Hate could have easily have overheard Deegan mentioning the affair, or Alana, or the Ram, or Melanie, but no, they specifically picked Stella to come back and blurt out the affair and right in front of Ciaran, just way too staged for my liking..

In the end the simplest answer is usually the truth so Ciaran has her with possible help from Stella and is defo keeping her in some makeshift pit near his private garage premises. Nothing else makes any sense.

I think Cathal and Stellas respective returns were intended to throw out some red herrings for viewers before the revelation.

Strazdas

Wanderer2010 wrote: »

^ Yeah its very obviously Love Hate who has taken her (but not raped her?, so I dunno he may just get kicks from doing it which is a weird way to drag out a story for 6 months) but I still have a niggling feeling that the whole Stella coming back for an interview was way too out of whack even for FC and Love Hate could have easily have overheard Deegan mentioning the affair, or Alana, or the Ram, or Melanie, but no, they specifically picked Stella to come back and blurt out the affair and right in front of Ciaran, just way too staged for my liking..

In the end the simplest answer is usually the truth so Ciaran has her with possible help from Stella and is defo keeping her in some makeshift pit near his private garage premises. Nothing else makes any sense.

That's actually not a bad theory. Stella and Ciaran working in conjunction with each other. We don't know how Ciaran could know Stella but then again, we know nothing about his past pre-Carrigstown......he's this mysterious character who appeared out of nowhere and started befriending complete strangers, which may be a bit suspicious. Where are his own friends and family for example? He never mentions anyone.

bazermc

It be gas if it turned out to be someone nobody suspected and was say Dermo or the Don or even bunion Kelly

dirkmeister

Katy being held hostage is like Silence of the Lambs at this stage


"It puts the lotion on its skin or else it gets the hose again!"

bottlebrush

Comet has replaced bursary as the buzz word of the moment

The Talking Bread

Bunnion Kelly mixing voices tonight

So its clear they are KTs clothes handed in to Helping Hand. But Bunnion didn't recognise the person..........hmmmmmmmmmm

paleoperson

dirkmeister wrote: »

Katy being held hostage is like Silence of the Lambs at this stage

"It puts the lotion on its skin or else it gets the hose again!"

Reminds me of the Horror Channel on a bad afternoon...

bottlebrush

The Talking Bread wrote: »

Bunnion Kelly mixing voices tonight

So its clear they are KTs clothes handed in to Helping Hand. But Bunnion didn't recognise the person..........hmmmmmmmmmm

Very perceptive of the Bunion all the same saying the clothes smell like they've been in an attic ... like what does an attic smell like?? Since when did a charity shop leave in clothes to be a launderette to be cleaned?

The Talking Bread

what sort of id1ot hostage taker leaves the victims clothes into a charity shop!!!!!!!!!!!!

groucho marx

Oh Hughie you sly dog

Raven Runner

Debbie is a bitch

bottlebrush

The Talking Bread wrote: »

what sort of id1ot hostage taker leaves the victims clothes into a charity shop!!!!!!!!!!!!

especially the local one

The Talking Bread

well its not underground in the pit!

groucho marx

Ha I'm starting to like niamh

The Talking Bread

Zoe has no expression in her voice!!

The Talking Bread

groucho marx wrote: »

Ha I'm starting to like niamh

same scene over and over again!!

groucho marx

The Talking Bread wrote: »

same scene over and over again!!

Poor Paul's going to get a heart attack with all these women
I don't think niamhs smart enough to not get caught though

bottlebrush

Eoin has a very strange 'angst' face

Karen23

I reckon Tommy has Katie , he's known for building hiding places and filming people.

The Talking Bread

Karen23 wrote: »

I reckon Tommy has Katie , he's known for building hiding places and filming people.

too obvious! Zero motive!Had alibi!

donkeykong5

bottlebrush wrote: »

Eoin has a very strange 'angst' face

Would you blame him. ?

bottlebrush

The Talking Bread wrote: »

what sort of id1ot hostage taker leaves the victims clothes into a charity shop!!!!!!!!!!!!

Love/Hate, obviously........!

groucho marx

Heh an officer and a gentleman...Deegan is a funny chap.

Karen23

The Talking Bread wrote: »

too obvious! Zero motive!Had alibi!

Ye but this is Fair City , silly things like that will be forgotten about