Werewolf III - Winter Is Coming - Complete - Village victory

Stoogie

So which one are we racing against Shatterproof?

andy125

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

quickbeam

andy125 wrote: »

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

Agree.

Triceratops Ballet

andy125 wrote:

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

andy125 wrote:

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

andy125 wrote:

agree or disagree?

Agree

sullivlo

andy125 wrote: »

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

Agree. I'll cast now for yosser and try get back on around 8.30 to see if we're going with somebody else so that I can change.

Uriel.

quickbeam wrote: »

Home now and I was actually thinking of this post all the way home. Here's my thoughts - I've not read any subsequent posts as I wanted a clear head writing this.

I was actually happy with Mick's answer. It seemed plausible that he'd change colours for the reasons he explained. But your reply now causes me alarm.

How would you know that this was the Stark's task as apposed to the Lannister's or the Baratheon's? Only if you too were a Stark - but that would be an incredibly supid move on your part to out not only Mick, but yourself for baddie munching. And I don't think you're stupid

The alternative is that you're one of the baddy groups and want rid of Mick for some reason.

Either way, it pretty much clears Mick in my head, but puts you right in the spotlight…..

My vote is currently for Uriel.

You can dial down the alarm. Jon snow is a stark in GoT

Maximus Alexander

andy125 wrote: »

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

I've targets I'd prefer, but for the sake of consensus I'll agree with this.

Nopeare

andy125 wrote: »

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

Agree

My idea of low posts hasn't taken, understandably it's a shot in the dark. But you're right we are going in circles so lets go with these 2 and everyone post here who they're voting for so we can check after

Uriel.

andy125 wrote: »

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

A joke is outing a stark.lord help us if that's what we're going... Jon snow is a stark...

Stoogie

andy125 wrote: »

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

I really think that Shatterproof was doing a task at the time of the reveal this morning. Triple posting and spouting gibberish at night is probably inebriation but at 10 am is probably a task. Uriel wouldn't "out " a stark if they found one and were a baddy they would simply kill them tonight. This means Uriel is probably a vanillager ( copyright MA 2016)
Today is task day as MrsFlushdraw pointed out "people will want to get to their respective families" so today we look for tasks
So I'm voting shatterproof but I'd also watch MicksJaguar

Stoogie

Nopeare wrote: »

Agree

My idea of low posts hasn't taken, understandably it's a shot in the dark. But you're right we are going in circles so lets go with these 2 and everyone post here who they're voting for so we can check after

Low post counts on a day 1 Monday where people with hard jobs have been at work and aren't even home yet mean nothing imho.

quickbeam

Stoogie wrote: »

I really think that Shatterproof was doing a task at the time of the reveal this morning. Triple posting and spouting gibberish at night is probably inebriation but at 10 am is probably a task. Uriel wouldn't "out " a stark if they found one and were a baddy they would simply kill them tonight. This means Uriel is probably a vanillager ( copyright MA 2016)
Today is task day as MrsFlushdraw pointed out "people will want to get to their respective families" so today we look for tasks
So I'm voting shatterproof but I'd also watch MicksJaguar

Nah, Shatter has a poetic streak in him. Game one, when it was clear he was about to be lynched he gave a sort of poetic farewell. I'd give him a bye for the poetry. The multiple posting maybe a little more suspicious. But for the moment there are others more suspicious.

andy125

Stoogie wrote: »

Low post counts on a day 1 Monday where people with hard jobs have been at work and aren't even home yet mean nothing imho.

yea we should look into low post count more tomorrow i think

A Neurotic

andy125 wrote: »

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

I find it a bit funny that you're deflecting heat off of Mick, but for the sake of getting something done, I'll agree.

quickbeam

Uriel. wrote: »

You can dial down the alarm. Jon snow is a stark in GoT

Uriel. wrote: »

A joke is outing a stark.lord help us if that's what we're going... Jon snow is a stark...

Yet you didn't start to defend my comment until after Andy put you in a race....

I'm sorta inclined to believe you. I want to believe you, especially since I got you so wrong last game. But.... hard to know.

sullivlo

andy125 wrote: »

yea we should look into low post count more tomorrow i think

Yes. When we can look at voting patterns and processes.

Stoogie

andy125 wrote: »

yea we should look into low post count more tomorrow i think

People work Tuesday's as well
I'd tell you what I'd look at is posts on the other parts of boards but not here. That's shady as flock.

Triceratops Ballet

Stoogie wrote:

I really think that Shatterproof was doing a task at the time of the reveal this morning. Triple posting and spouting gibberish at night is probably inebriation but at 10 am is probably a task. Uriel wouldn't "out " a stark if they found one and were a baddy they would simply kill them tonight. This means Uriel is probably a vanillager ( copyright MA 2016) Today is task day as MrsFlushdraw pointed out "people will want to get to their respective families" so today we look for tasks So I'm voting shatterproof but I'd also watch MicksJaguar

I voted yosser because of the consensus, but I also suspect Mrs Flushdraw.

I named shatterproof earlier but on reflection I think his triple post was a little too early to be a task

I also named Mick, and while I still slightly think the colour posting was odd I'm holding off for now, I wanna see where it goes

Xaracatz

andy125 wrote: »

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

I won't disagree.

andy125

Stoogie wrote: »

People work Tuesday's as well
I'd tell you what I'd look at is posts on the other parts of boards but not here. That's shady as flock.

Yea meta gaming is not cool and should be frowned upon tbh

Maximus Alexander

Stoogie wrote: »

People work Tuesday's as well
I'd tell you what I'd look at is posts on the other parts of boards but not here. That's shady as flock.

That's all well and good, obviously there are some people who just can't post that much. But history has shown that the 'wolves' hide among the low posters, so villagers have no choice but to look there. It's an unfortunate reality of the game in the medium.

Uriel.

quickbeam wrote: »

Yet you didn't start to defend my comment until after Andy put you in a race....

I'm sorta inclined to believe you. I want to believe you, especially since I got you so wrong last game. But.... hard to know.

Im sorry I took an hour or so off the game, but driving and posting on boards is frowned upon... Apparently

A Neurotic

I've voted for yosser, for the record.

Stoogie

Well I think that later on people look at voting history so I'm sticking with Shatterproof and I'm confident I can stand over it.

quickbeam

Uriel. wrote: »

Im sorry I took an hour or so off the game, but driving and posting on boards is frowned upon... Apparently

Arrrrraghhh! That's true too. This game. Head wrecking.

pxdf9i5cmoavkz

andy125 wrote: »

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

50% consensus it shall be.

What did Uriel. do to get marked?

Maximus Alexander

For the record: I'm not super keen on either of the options, but I find the argument for Uriel to be the less compelling of the two, so I'll be voting yosser.

quickbeam

Clare Whining College wrote: »

50% consensus it shall be.

What did Uriel. do to get marked?

He said I'd outted the last Stark. Suspicious thing to say.

Nopeare

Stoogie wrote: »

Nopeare wrote: »

Agree

My idea of low posts hasn't taken, understandably it's a shot in the dark. But you're right we are going in circles so lets go with these 2 and everyone post here who they're voting for so we can check after

Low post counts on a day 1 Monday where people with hard jobs have been at work and aren't even home yet mean nothing imho.

I know it is harsh and i don't mean offence to anyone but there's not a lot to go on. I said it in one of my posts but from the previous game I think it's about a 50/50 chance there is a baddie lurking there trying to avoid attention

Uriel.

quickbeam wrote: »

Arrrrraghhh! That's true too. This game. Head wrecking.

If I was a baddie why would I out a stark? Sure if the village genuinely thought I was correct for about out a stark they'd never vote for that person. It would be a pointless move

ShatterProof

andy125 wrote: »

I suggest putting 2 people that have shown some kind of evidence of doing a task and run from there maybe?

It's a plan we could work with.

I'm on phone so hard to do it, but do we have a list of suspicious task posts?

Don't forgot good guy mr snow would have to perform one also.

y0ssar1an22

andy125 wrote: »

starting to go around in circles again here folks,

2 hours till lynching, yosser and uriel seem to be popular for the running?

yosser for crazy accusations ala tigger
uriel for trying to out a 3rd stark

agree or disagree?

obviously i'm gonna have to disagree. crazy accusations earlier on were just that, crazy.
as i seem to have a few people gunning for me, including sheriff, i think my days are numbered.
all i can say is that i'm not a villian and will try to present a more attractive candidate for lynching.

everyone that voted for me must think i'm a baddie. could a few of you maybe say why?

going along with the consensus to lynch a villager is stupid and waste of a lynch

quickbeam

Okay okay, voting Yossarian.

Uriel.

quickbeam wrote: »

He said I'd outted the last Stark. Suspicious thing to say.

Sigh.
Mick wrote Jon snow and hid the "snow" part. You questioned him on hiding it. I said oh you outed a stark (the joke being Jon snow is a stark in GoT).
It was really nothing more than a joke

Stoogie

ShatterProof wrote: »

It's a plan we could work with.

I'm on phone so hard to do it, but do we have a list of suspicious task posts?

Don't forgot good guy mr snow would have to perform one also.

If we lynch him he'll get over it.

Maximus Alexander

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

everyone that voted for me must think i'm a baddie. could a few of you maybe say why?

I don't, really. So, sorry I guess.

ShatterProof

Stoogie wrote: »

Well I think that later on people look at voting history so I'm sticking with Shatterproof and I'm confident I can stand over it.

Stand over what?

andy125

Uriel. wrote: »

Sigh.
Mick wrote Jon snow and hid the "snow" part. You questioned him on hiding it. I said oh you outed a stark (the joke being Jon snow is a stark in GoT).
It was really nothing more than a joke

reasonable enough explanation , remember uriel that some people dont watch game of thrones and these jokes could fly over their head and be seen as something sinister

Xaracatz

For the record, I voted Jossar.

Stoogie

ShatterProof wrote: »

Stand over what?

You know when people say "over my dead body" ?
Well that.

Nopeare

I'm going to look like a big idiot considering I agreed 2pages ago to the race but I honestly don't believe either are baddies. Also my suggestion was vote low post counts. Now I'm going against both of these.

The most compelling thing I've seen today is MrsFlushdraw posts as highlighted elsewhere.

My vote is for MrsFlushdraw

Uriel.

andy125 wrote: »

reasonable enough explanation , remember uriel that some people dont watch game of thrones and these jokes could fly over their head and be seen as something sinister

I see that now.

quickbeam

Uriel. wrote: »

Sigh.
Mick wrote Jon snow and hid the "snow" part. You questioned him on hiding it. I said oh you outed a stark (the joke being Jon snow is a stark in GoT).
It was really nothing more than a joke

Voted Yossarian.

But ... I thought it odd that a villager would highlight one of our key villagers for all the baddies to see, when my comment (questioning Mick) could easily have gone under their radar.

I'm tending to believe you now. If a real baddy hadn't noticed Mick as a Stark (if he is one), until I'd pointed it out, then he'd not have put it on the main thread but said it in the private forums to the rest of his team mates.

Sorry

In a game where its best to draw some attention to yourself but not too much; Mick's coloured writing doesn't make a lick of sense to me, even with his explanation.

y0ssar1an22

is there a way to get all the posts somebody made in a thread. not by visiting their profile, but in the thread someway?

Maximus Alexander

Nopeare wrote: »

I'm going to look like a big idiot considering I agreed 2pages ago to the race but I honestly don't believe either are baddies. Also my suggestion was vote low post counts. Now I'm going against both of these.

The most compelling thing I've seen today is MrsFlushdraw posts as highlighted elsewhere.

My vote is for MrsFlushdraw

I agree with you. Completely. But unless you can convince the village to change the race I wouldn't advise going against it.

quickbeam

andy125 wrote: »

reasonable enough explanation , remember uriel that some people dont watch game of thrones and these jokes could fly over their head and be seen as something sinister

Even worse, I do know GOT - at least the books (only saw first season of series). But if Uriel was making a joke, a smilie might have not gone amiss. Might have saved a lot of thinking.

The_Valeyard

Howdy all.

Mental day, but very rewarding. Long story.



So, can someone sum up the happenings of today?

Stoogie

Nopeare wrote: »

I'm going to look like a big idiot considering I agreed 2pages ago to the race but I honestly don't believe either are baddies. Also my suggestion was vote low post counts. Now I'm going against both of these.

The most compelling thing I've seen today is MrsFlushdraw posts as highlighted elsewhere.

My vote is for MrsFlushdraw

Oooh tempting another possibility for a task.

andy125

Nopeare wrote: »

I'm going to look like a big idiot considering I agreed 2pages ago to the race but I honestly don't believe either are baddies. Also my suggestion was vote low post counts. Now I'm going against both of these.

The most compelling thing I've seen today is MrsFlushdraw posts as highlighted elsewhere.

My vote is for MrsFlushdraw

since we have a few votes on yosser already, should we run mrsflush against him for the remaining hour?

i think we agree uriel has explained the stark thing