Werewolf III - Winter Is Coming - Complete - Village victory

sullivlo

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Could be wrong but I think Max was just a villager drawing attention away from someone else.

The more I think about it the more that comes to mind.

crosstownk

WerewolfGM wrote: »

Yossar1an22 - 13 Votes - Barney - Sully - MicksJag - Neurotic - Xaracatz - Andy - Valeyard - MrsFD - Dottie - Crosstownk - Persepoly - Nopeare - The Sheriff
Micksjaguar - 8 votes - Partyjungle - Jason - Yosser - Gufc - Stoogie - Quickbeam - Uriel -
MrsFlushdraw - 2 votes - Max Alex - Mahama
JasonS246 - 1 vote - Shatterproof
Shatterproof - 1 vote - ShaneC

Did Note Vote - 1 The Dazzler

The votes from last night just for reference.

I agree with quickbeam about it being uncharacteristic of Dazz to be a low poster. Missing the vote may seem odd but it could be just one of those things and maybe he wasn't aware of the new lynch time although that seems unlikely given he's played before.

I'm not convinced either way on Jason nor am overly suss of Nopeare in the way that MrsF is. I could be convinced either way.

Max and mahama both voted for MrsF - is there something in that perhaps?

Wow. I was just down by the river having a scrub. I thought Max had a role. That's what I took from him defending Mick. Of course the other may be the case that Max and Mick were both members of the same family. Starks have very strong family values so would be more inclined to protect each other. The other two groups are far more ruthless.


Why were zara and mahama targeted though? I must look back at their posts and see was there anything in them which would make the baddies nervous. The Baratheons in their own room, Lannisters in theirs, Starks as well. The Night King, is he in a room with the Bars or the Lans as well or a complete loner?

Nopeare

I have only read a few posts after the slaughter so still a bit to catch up but others have said max and mahama both voted for her and my original vote was the one to get her in the race and now she wants me to be raced!!

sullivlo

Current state of play:
1 y0ssar1an22
2 gufc21
3 Stoogie
4 dottie_lottie
5 crosstownk
6 tritium - munched by The Baretheons
7 quickbeam
8 Maximus Alexander - killed by B
9 MrsFlushdraw
10 Sullivlo
11 MicksJaguar
12 Uriel
13 Mahamageehad - killed by NK
14 nopeare
15 JasonS246
16 The_Valeyard
17 A Neurotic
18 Barney92
19 andy125
20 Shatterproof
21 The_Dazzler
22 Xaracats - killed by L
23 partyjungle
24 Shane. C
25 Persepoly

Starks + villagers
Lannister's - killed 1
Baratheons - killed 2
Night King - killed 1

Sheriff - A Neurotic - immune from munch and lynch
Bran Stark
Melisandre
Barristan Selmy

A Neurotic

A Neurotic wrote:

Me pls? Haven't had a go yet!

Jesus Christ this app. Posted in the complete wrong thread. Cue people suspicious of this being a task.

Stoogie

Stoogie wrote: »

We are supposed to be lynching Lions or Stags if he's a Wolf he should be left alone .

Stoogie wrote: »

I think you mean a Stag or Lion. The Starks are the Wolves and as such would protect their brother.

I want stoogie up for the chop

We had the 5 messages all with smileys, we have the 2 above mentioning stags lions and wolfs in 2 messages he has a lot of posts but most of it is filler.

My vote tonight

quickbeam

Deleted User wrote: »

Wow. I was just down by the river having a scrub. I thought Max had a role. That's what I took from him defending Mick. Of course the other may be the case that Max and Mick were both members of the same family. Starks have very strong family values so would be more inclined to protect each other. The other two groups are far more ruthless.


Why were zara and mahama targeted though? I must look back at their posts and see was there anything in them which would make the baddies nervous. The Baratheons in their own room, Lannisters in theirs, Starks as well. The Night King, is he in a room with the Bars or the Lans as well or a complete loner?

I've no idea about mahama. Only thing I can think of about Xara is that she did a great post (423) which was analytical. I think there might be some clues in there, if we knew which pieces were the bits that scared the Lannisters.

sullivlo

Proposing MrsF for the race, simply because the two people who voted for her were killed.

Unsure about who to race her against.

quickbeam

Xaracatz wrote: »

Long post ahead...:

Ok

Bad guys

1. The Lannisters

3 people / 1 kill per night

2. The Baratheons

3 people / 1 kill per night

3. The Night King

1 person / .5 kills per night

So,

The Night King is the most valuable to kill, but, equally, they’d be fking crazy to out themselves for this reason. Assumption – the Night King is flying low for the moment.

Three things to raise suspicion at this point:

1. People behaving weird (multiple posts, strange requests – possible tasks)

Shatter did make those three posts in a row. I’m thinking that was a joke though. He did hint about being a seer, however, which seems a bit odd to do.

Partyjungle claimed to be the Night King. Bit fking crazy as I said – unless it’s a task. He also posted “Sounds like I'm playing dumb here but what exactly are the tasks...?”. Guilty conscious?

MicksJag did that can you write out my name post. He did explain it – still weird though. Then the “Snow” bit in white – that makes me very suspicious – even the explanation doesn’t ring true for me.

2. People coming out with unfounded accusations

Yossar – ‘nuff said. But, will go on anyway. Sullivo, Uriel, Jason, Crosstown (kinda), Barney (kinda)

3. Low post count

I’m gonna defend this one – even though it’s the one I was accused of. It’s day 1, and during working hours. However, low post count:

Jayop 2

Persepoly 2

Xaracatz 2

Barney92 2

The_Dazzler 2

And – I’m going to throw in a fourth:

4. Over defence of posters

I only thought of this one when I was going through the later pages – but it might be worth looking at.

My two cents – I would race Yossar and Micksjag.

I’d go for Yossar for the lynch. I read a lot of the last thread, and it’s like he’s trying to channel the spirit of Tigger so that he can get a following.

Micksjags’ behaviour is weird though, so I’d put him in as a second potential.

That took fecking ages!

Here's Xara's post again.

crosstownk

crosstownk wrote: »

Max and mahama both voted for MrsF - is there something in that perhaps?

They were killed my different teams though

quickbeam

quickbeam wrote: »

Here's Xara's post again.

what do you make of it?

Deleted User

Deleted User wrote: »

Wow. I was just down by the river having a scrub. I thought Max had a role. That's what I took from him defending Mick. Of course the other may be the case that Max and Mick were both members of the same family. Starks have very strong family values so would be more inclined to protect each other. The other two groups are far more ruthless.


Why were zara and mahama targeted though? I must look back at their posts and see was there anything in them which would make the baddies nervous. The Baratheons in their own room, Lannisters in theirs, Starks as well. The Night King, is he in a room with the Bars or the Lans as well or a complete loner?

NK is a complete loner.

I find this far too hard at the moment. We have next to nothing to go on. Even the NK/Barath/Lannister kills are mostly randomly selected. How can we infer anything if the killers had no master plan themselves? It is only day 2 so I guess its supposed be hard at this stage.

I suggest racing two people to see what they say so they can be possibly caught in a lie later on.

I suggest MicksJaguar vs MrsFD

sullivlo

Xaracatz wrote: »

Long post ahead...:

Ok

Bad guys

1. The Lannisters

3 people / 1 kill per night

2. The Baratheons

3 people / 1 kill per night

3. The Night King

1 person / .5 kills per night

So,

The Night King is the most valuable to kill, but, equally, they’d be fking crazy to out themselves for this reason. Assumption – the Night King is flying low for the moment.

Three things to raise suspicion at this point:

1. People behaving weird (multiple posts, strange requests – possible tasks)

Shatter did make those three posts in a row. I’m thinking that was a joke though. He did hint about being a seer, however, which seems a bit odd to do.

Partyjungle claimed to be the Night King. Bit fking crazy as I said – unless it’s a task. He also posted “Sounds like I'm playing dumb here but what exactly are the tasks...?”. Guilty conscious?

MicksJag did that can you write out my name post. He did explain it – still weird though. Then the “Snow” bit in white – that makes me very suspicious – even the explanation doesn’t ring true for me.

2. People coming out with unfounded accusations

Yossar – ‘nuff said. But, will go on anyway. Sullivo, Uriel, Jason, Crosstown (kinda), Barney (kinda)

3. Low post count

I’m gonna defend this one – even though it’s the one I was accused of. It’s day 1, and during working hours. However, low post count:

Jayop 2

Persepoly 2

Xaracatz 2

Barney92 2

The_Dazzler 2

And – I’m going to throw in a fourth:

4. Over defence of posters

I only thought of this one when I was going through the later pages – but it might be worth looking at.

My two cents – I would race Yossar and Micksjag.

I’d go for Yossar for the lynch. I read a lot of the last thread, and it’s like he’s trying to channel the spirit of Tigger so that he can get a following.

Micksjags’ behaviour is weird though, so I’d put him in as a second potential.

That took fecking ages!

Quoted to save everyone going back searching

quickbeam

Deleted User wrote: »

what do you make of it?

Just re-read it there and absolutely nothing jumps out. But she was mostly quiet, and this was the one analytical post she made, so it's the best chance of being the reason.

Though the Lannisters themselves might have just shot in the dark and picked Xara, it might have no reason to it at all.

So confusing

Triceratops Ballet

Deleted User wrote: »

They were killed my different teams though

Maha was killed by the NK though, and Max by the Baratheons Mrs FW could still be a Lannister

dottie_lottie

dottie_lottie wrote: »

Maha was killed by the NK though, and Max by the Baratheons Mrs FW could still be a Lannister

Ya she could be but people are infering, 2 people who voted for her got killed so she is more likley to be bad which isnt the case.

quickbeam

Agree, I don't think we can infer anything from two victims having voted for the same person as the votees were working separately.

[Deleted User]

[Deleted User] wrote: »

NK is a complete loner.

I find this far too hard at the moment. We have next to nothing to go on. Even the NK/Barath/Lannister kills are mostly randomly selected. How can we infer anything if the killers had no master plan themselves? It is only day 2 so I guess its supposed be hard at this stage.

I suggest racing two people to see what they say so they can be possibly caught in a lie later on.

I suggest MicksJaguar vs MrsFD

I had forgotten about zara's post. As it stands now we have absolutely nothing to go on
But perhaps like you say the baddies have no real master plan either. At least that puts us in a less precarious position if they are just as clueless. I think.

MrsFlushdraw

quickbeam wrote: »

Just trying to get the ball rolling on nominees for a race. Who are your nominations?



He'd be mod-killed immediately. So true, a wasted lynch. But he might not miss the vote this time. And yes, there could be other reasons for his lying low. So what, are we just going to ignore all low posters because they could be a roled player? Who are your nominations to run in a race?

If he was about to be modkilled then maybe he is a good idea for a lynch subject? prob daft but if he isn't interested in playing then it's better to lose 1 player at lynch instead of 1 lynchee and 1 modkill? better for village anyway.

crosstownk wrote: »

The votes from last night just for reference.

I agree with quickbeam about it being uncharacteristic of Dazz to be a low poster. Missing the vote may seem odd but it could be just one of those things and maybe he wasn't aware of the new lynch time although that seems unlikely given he's played before.

I'm not convinced either way on Jason nor am overly suss of Nopeare in the way that MrsF is. I could be convinced either way.

Max and mahama both voted for MrsF - is there something in that perhaps?

sullivlo wrote: »

Proposing MrsF for the race, simply because the two people who voted for her were killed.

Unsure about who to race her against.

This logic is just stupid. Why would either a Baratheon team or a Lannister team get me to take one for the team and make things so obvious.

It is a GoT theme, not Suicide Squad!

And as to the Night King, that would just be really stoopid on my part to do such an obvious kill.

I think those trying to lynch me need to be looked at as they are clutching at straws and there is no real evidence.

I would be more inclined to look at say, Dazzler & Andy. I think one of them or maybe both is a baddie.

Triceratops Ballet

quickbeam wrote: »

He'd be mod-killed immediately. So true, a wasted lynch. But he might not miss the vote this time. And yes, there could be other reasons for his lying low. So what, are we just going to ignore all low posters because they could be a roled player? Who are your nominations to run in a race?

Ok I have to go do some actual work for a while, for the moment i'm gonna say Mrs FW, I suspected her yesterday and changed my vote to go with the consensus and 2nd nomination Stoogie, I noticed the triple post that Mick pointed out too and thought it had a wiff of task off it.

quickbeam

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

I would be more inclined to look at say, Dazzler & Andy. I think one of them or maybe both is a baddie.

Why Andy?

MrsFlushdraw

quickbeam wrote: »

Why Andy?

Gawd you are quick to defend? team mate??

He is just different this game, maybe he has other stuff going on but it is just something I am picking up. I just think he may be a baddie. Could be wrong but just on looking at his previous play I think he may be a Stag or a Lion!

crosstownk

It looks like the Lannisters/Baratheons may also be targeting low posters in case they are roled players.

I don't see any reason for lyching Andy at this point.

Yesterday we Mick was one of most peoples choices to be raced. It seems that may have swayed somewhat due to Max's post.

I'm still a bit suspect of the coloured posting. Have most people now dismissed this?

crosstownk

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

Gawd you are quick to defend? team mate??

He asked why (s did I) - I'd hardly call that defending.

quickbeam

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

Gawd you are quick to defend? team mate??

He is just different this game, maybe he has other stuff going on but it is just something I am picking up. I just think he may be a baddie. Could be wrong but just on looking at his previous play I think he may be a Stag or a Lion!

No, just curious when people accuse but offer no explanation. This is the first accusation for Andy I've seen and it just seemed out of the blue and strange. Andy hasn't struck me as baddie at all, personally. Even the above "I just think he may be a baddie" is very vague. Odd.

quickbeam

crosstownk wrote: »

I'm still a bit suspect of the coloured posting. Have most people now dismissed this?

Not dismissed it (sorry, Mick! ), but put it on the back-burner for the moment.

Actually who the good of the village it might be best to lynch me my ****ing around yesterday with the writing will be brought up the whole time while im alive and distract from finding the bad guys.

Might also be a case to landslide me too.

*for not who

MrsFlushdraw

But all the logic that I must be a baddie because of who the baddies killed last night is more logic? I said I felt his posting style was different and that is what I am going by.

All you guys are using silly flimsy evidence that says I am either the worst Night King or the Lannisters wanted to make me look guilty!

I would be looking at all you that are accusing me tbh.

quickbeam

Deleted User wrote: »

Actually who the good of the village it might be best to lynch me my ****ing around yesterday with the writing will be brought up the whole time while im alive and distract from finding the bad guys.

Might also be a case to landslide me too.

How very noble of you

A landslide will teach us nothing. And you'd be insulting the sacrifice Max made for you by killing yourself the same day

Who do you propose for a race?

quickbeam

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

But all the logic that I must be a baddie because of who the baddies killed last night is more logic? I said I felt his posting style was different and that is what I am going by.

All you guys are using silly flimsy evidence that says I am either the worst Night King or the Lannisters wanted to make me look guilty!

I would be looking at all you that are accusing me tbh.

I haven't accused you. Quite the opposite actually.

MrsFlushdraw

quickbeam wrote: »

How very noble of you

A landslide will teach us nothing. And you'd be insulting the sacrifice Max made for you by killing yourself the same day

Who do you propose for a race?

Races tell us nothing since we don't get to know the result of the lynch,

If folk want to lynch me that is fine. But it's a mistake as I am not a baddie. But I am not going to make 464351 posts saying the same thing over and over.

crosstownk

Deleted User wrote: »

Actually who the good of the village it might be best to lynch me my ****ing around yesterday with the writing will be brought up the whole time while im alive and distract from finding the bad guys.

Might also be a case to landslide me too.

I was all set to vote for you last night but Max's post swayed me at the last minute - for better or worse - I don't know just yet.

At the moment I'd like to give you the benefit of the seer rather than the priest but I'm confused and unsure about anything - that's just how I'm thinking at the moment.

MrsFlushdraw

quickbeam wrote: »

I haven't accused you. Quite the opposite actually.

I was meaning you as in all the people accusing me, not directed at anyone except those.

crosstownk

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

I would be looking at all you that are accusing me tbh.

I think you'll find that everybody is look at everybody!

quickbeam

quickbeam wrote: »

How very noble of you

A landslide will teach us nothing. And you'd be insulting the sacrifice Max made for you by killing yourself the same day

Who do you propose for a race?

I have a reason for the landslide but I cant say as it on thread as it might point out something (flimsy I know) but for the sake of one day it'd be worth it.

I want stoogie lynched tbh against who im not sure, im suspect of james and a little bit of party jungle.

Stoogie had posted about 16 times at this stage yesterday and nothing so far today yes real life stuff it could be possible was doing a task and wanted to hide it in a mass of messages?

I pointed out 2 things that could possibly his tasks

The ok 5 times

And mention lions, wolfs and stags in 2 seperate messages

MrsFlushdraw

crosstownk wrote: »

I think you'll find that everybody is look at everybody!

Those Lannisters and Baratheons are sitting back and watching us all squabble

quickbeam

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

Races tell us nothing since we don't get to know the result of the lynch,

True, races won't tell us anything at the moment. But hopefully we will find out what the Priest and Seer know and then it'll be good to have that information.

Just looking back at who voted for a race, we have, so far:

QB - Jason v Dazz
Mick - Stoogie vs Mick?
Sullivo - MrsF vs
PartyJungle - Mick vs MrsF
MrsF - Dazz vs Andy
Dottie - MrsF vs Stoogie

Guffy

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

Races tell us nothing since we don't get to know the result of the lynch,

.

We do though... i dont know if the race is a good idea as there are 3 badie groups, each with their own agenda. Would it not take to long to find a pattern?

Tbh i think the fact that both people who voted for you by the badies was intentionally done to arouse suspicion for you.

quickbeam

gufc21 wrote: »

Tbh i think the fact that both people who voted for you by the badies was intentionally done to arouse suspicion for you.

It's really not possible!! It has to be co-incidences. Baddies don't get to communicate with each other. There could be no coordinated voting.

Triceratops Ballet

quickbeam wrote: »

True, races won't tell us anything at the moment. But hopefully we will find out what the Priest and Seer know and then it'll be good to have that information.

Just looking back at who voted for a race, we have, so far:

QB - Jason v Dazz
Mick - Stoogie vs Mick?
Sullivo - MrsF vs
PartyJungle - Mick vs MrsF
MrsF - Dazz vs Andy
Dottie - MrsF vs Stoogie

If I was asked to make a 3rd choice, QB it would be you, I'm always suspicious of those who try to lead the hunt, putting themselves in a place of (false) trust to try and deflect. Granted, we're a mess, and last night was manic, so we do need some organising so that could be all you're doing

quickbeam

I'm trying, dottie, I'm trying!!

Guffy

quickbeam wrote: »

It's really not possible!! It has to be co-incidences. Baddies don't get to communicate with each other. There could be no coordinated voting.

I know and it would have been pure luck that they both had the same plan and both picked a different one of 2. But that's the same reason that, Shane c i think who pointed it out, being suspicious of mrs because of it is silly.

Granted had it been 1 vocal, ya thats susicious but when its 2, odds are its coincidence.

quickbeam

quickbeam wrote: »

It's really not possible!! It has to be co-incidences. Baddies don't get to communicate with each other. There could be no coordinated voting.

Well they could have came to the same conclusion themselves seperatley and managed to avoid killing the same person.

For me the reason for the kills

Max may have looked like he had a role so that tells us the Baratheons have a full team of 3 so there is 1 completed task on thread.

Maham looked like a villager I thought she had a role so thats why she was likely killed

Xaracatz just looked like a helpfull villager but maybe it was a shot at a role from a low poster as someone else pointed out

Deleted User

Deleted User wrote: »

Actually who the good of the village it might be best to lynch me my ****ing around yesterday with the writing will be brought up the whole time while im alive and distract from finding the bad guys.

Might also be a case to landslide me too.

That colour thing was such nonsense tbh. There is no good reason to do that other than a task. If you did you just because you were giddy, hard luck; but this is the only evidence we have of someone attempting a task imo.

I voted for you last time as will continue to do so until something with more evidence comes along. We literally have nothing else right now.

"Use three different colours when referring to something GoT related in the OP" - sounds like a very plausible task. There was three colours: purple for The Night King, white for Jon Snow and red for The Red Wedding. I'm convinced. There is a 1/3 chance its a Stark task. Let's at least race Mick.

Deleted User

Deleted User wrote: »

"Use three different colours when referring to something GoT related in the OP" - sounds like a very plausible task. There was three colours: purple for The Night King, white for Jon Snow and red for The Red Wedding. I'm convinced. There is a 1/3 chance its a Stark task. Let's at least race Mick.

you forgot the orange in my monty python post people should really check stuff out and not have me pointing it out for ye

Triceratops Ballet

Deleted User wrote: »

"Use three different colours when referring to something GoT related in the OP" - sounds like a very plausible task. There was three colours: purple for The Night King, white for Jon Snow and red for The Red Wedding. I'm convinced. There is a 1/3 chance its a Stark task. Let's at least race Mick.

We were told tasks wouldn't be GOT related and than no foreknowledge of the books/show would be required to play the game

dottie_lottie

dottie_lottie wrote: »

We were told tasks wouldn't be GOT related and than no foreknowledge of the books/show would be required to play the game

Thats why I specifically said something that is in the OP. The three things I mention are in the rules in the first post.