Werewolf III - Winter Is Coming - Complete - Village victory

quickbeam

Digital Solitude wrote: »

Only task hint I'm giving is that they don't revolve around typos and misspelling

Thank the Seven for that so - can we all shut up about spelling mistakes now?

crosstownk

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

how do you find out how many posts people have in the thread?

Click on the number of replies in the main forum and it will show you the list of posters and number of posts.

Nopeare

It won't allow me to click on it

ShatterProof

Just noticed, the Starks are not killing business directly but must aid the village and attempt to us in the correct direction for the lynch. This could very well look like wolfish behaviour as it will have to be similar tactic used by the Lannisters & Baratheons. There could be 3 very suspicious groupings in the game.

1 y0ssar1an22
2 gufc21
3 Stoogie
4 dottie_lottie
5 crosstownk
6 tritium - munched by The Baretheons
7 quickbeam
8 Maximus Alexander
9 MrsFlushdraw
10 Sullivlo
11 MicksJaguar
12 Uriel
13 Mahamageehad
14 nopeare
15 JasonS246
16 The_Valeyard
17 A Neurotic
18 Barney92
19 andy125
20 Shatterproof
21 The_Dazzler
22 Xaracats
23 partyjungle
24 Shane. C
25 Persepoly


Everybody votes for the person on the list below them except for
1) crosstownk who votes quickbeam
2) The_Valeyard who votes for Barney92
3) Persepoly who votes for y0ssar1an22
4) the sheriff, a deeply mentally deranged individual, will have the casting vote on who to be lynched

This would remove ability of the Lannisters & Baratheons to gang up during voting - they'll be happy to kill anybody. Hopefully it will be each other.

Could give the Starks some time to come up with a plan that will help us humble villagers

I'd find it hard to believe that Neurotic would have been assigned 2 roles if they were generated ramdonly.

This plan is bound to have some flaws but at least it starts the discussion.
One glaring flaw is our troubled friend has already indicated he might vote for me.

MrsFlushdraw

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

You might want to have someone take a look at that radar so. What sort of lunatic with a role would paint this big of a target on themselves?

Not sure we have satellite shops in Westeros anyway! Might have to head to Old Valyria for a job like that

pxdf9i5cmoavkz

Nopeare wrote: »

It won't allow me to click on it

You're clicking on the wrong item. Click the number under the Replies tab.

MrsFlushdraw

quickbeam wrote: »

Thank the Seven for that so - can we all shut up about spelling mistakes now?

The seven? so you are from Kings Landing or Casterly Rock then? hmmm

y0ssar1an22

ShatterProof wrote: »

Just noticed, the Starks are not killing business directly but must aid the village and attempt to us in the correct direction for the lynch. This could very well look like wolfish behaviour as it will have to be similar tactic used by the Lannisters & Baratheons. There could be 3 very suspicious groupings in the game.

1 y0ssar1an22
2 gufc21
3 Stoogie
4 dottie_lottie
5 crosstownk
6 tritium - munched by The Baretheons
7 quickbeam
8 Maximus Alexander
9 MrsFlushdraw
10 Sullivlo
11 MicksJaguar
12 Uriel
13 Mahamageehad
14 nopeare
15 JasonS246
16 The_Valeyard
17 A Neurotic
18 Barney92
19 andy125
20 Shatterproof
21 The_Dazzler
22 Xaracats
23 partyjungle
24 Shane. C
25 Persepoly


Everybody votes for the person on the list below them except for
1) crosstownk who votes quickbeam
2) The_Valeyard who votes for Barney92
3) Persepoly who votes for y0ssar1an22
4) the sheriff, a deeply mentally deranged individual, will have the casting vote on who to be lynched

This would remove ability of the Lannisters & Baratheons to gang up during voting - they'll be happy to kill anybody. Hopefully it will be each other.

Could give the Starks some time to come up with a plan that will help us humble villagers

I'd find it hard to believe that Neurotic would have been assigned 2 roles if they were generated ramdonly.

This plan is bound to have some flaws but at least it starts the discussion.
One glaring flaw is our troubled friend has already indicated he might vote for me.

i dont understand the bit in bold. could you expand on it please?

y0ssar1an22

never mind, i understand. but will this not result in everyone having 1 vote, so whoever the sheriff votes for gets lynched. ie: barney?

quickbeam

ShatterProof wrote: »

I'd find it hard to believe that Neurotic would have been assigned 2 roles if they were generated ramdonly.

I don't follow that logic. Yossarian has already done the maths and said we've a 29% chance of lynching a baddie tonight, which are pretty good odds (compared with previous games anyway), but it's the same odds that the Sheriff is a baddie - ie, entirely possible. So say, Neurotic was a baddie, he'll have the advantage of knowing at least one other of his siblings and avoid them for the lynch. I don't like all the power in one person like that.

quickbeam

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

never mind, i understand. but will this not result in everyone having 1 vote, so whoever the sheriff votes for gets lynched. ie: barney?

The sheriff's bonus vote doesn't have to be the same person as his regular vote.

Maximus Alexander

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

never mind, i understand. but will this not result in everyone having 1 vote, so whoever the sheriff votes for gets lynched. ie: barney?

Under the proposed system, sheriff is exempt and has a free vote. So yes, whoever he votes for gets lynched, but it doesn't have to be the person below him.

Nopeare

Clare Whining College wrote: »

Nopeare wrote: »

It won't allow me to click on it

You're clicking on the wrong item. Click the number under the Replies tab.

There isn't another button under replies when I'm on the forum below is what my screen is like


[RPGs] WWIII - Winter Is Coming - Live Game Thread For Living Players Only!! (312 Replies)
Last post Today 15:41 by Maximus Alexander Started by WerewolfGM

quickbeam

Go to the actual forum. To the right of the title you'll see the number of posts.

quickbeam

Between the column for Last Post and Views.

Nopeare

Problem solved thank you - I was been an idiot and not on the legacy site

Maximus Alexander

MrsFlushdraw

Nopeare wrote: »

Problem solved thank you - I was been an idiot and not on the legacy site

That caught me for ages, I am not keen on the other way of viewing the site. Prefer the legacy

Uriel.

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

Task?










:P

Nopeare

Anyway back to point I think there are maybe 3/4 of the role players in the low posts and since we are all going off nothing this is a good point to start.

So could tasks be completed when the thread open or after 10am which it says in OP is the start of the game?

Maximus Alexander

WerewolfGM wrote: »

tut tut.....

This again!! How could I have edited it at midnight? Look again. :P

quickbeam

Nopeare wrote: »

Anyway back to point I think there are maybe 3/4 of the role players in the low posts and since we are all going off nothing this is a good point to start.

I think this is a good theory but as I said before, we really need to take RL in to account, so no point judging people on their post count right now. Come evening it may become more relevant.

quickbeam

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

This again!! How could I have edited it at midnight? Look again. :P

That got me a few times last game too! V. annoying!!

WerewolfGM

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

This again!! How could I have edited it at midnight? Look again. :P

Yeah very weird that. OK, after an appeal the yellow card has been rescinded!!

Maximus Alexander

WerewolfGM wrote: »

Yeah very weird that. OK, after an appeal the yellow card has been rescinded!!

It's my signature

Triceratops Ballet

quickbeam wrote: »

I think this is a good theory but as I said before, we really need to take RL in to account, so no point judging people on their post count right now. Come evening it may become more relevant.

I agree, come 8pm if the count is still low then I think that's a valid option

WerewolfGM

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

It's my signature

I should reissue the card again for twatery!! :pac:

Maximus Alexander

WerewolfGM wrote: »

I should reissue the card again for twatery!! :pac:

It's been like that for years. I just fixed it though...

Deleted User

Deleted User wrote: »

So could tasks be completed when the thread open or after 10am which it says in OP is the start of the game?

WWMOD can you answer this or would it give too much away

Nopeare

quickbeam wrote: »

I think this is a good theory but as I said before, we really need to take RL in to account, so no point judging people on their post count right now. Come evening it may become more relevant.

I agree with that I'd say if we took the 8-10 lowest posters there will be 3/4 roles in them which will only be a hit rate of low about 30% to a high of around 40/50%. By no means perfect but a good starting point with nothing else to go on and it makes them start posting/defending themselves. Which will also raise the possibility of a slip.

I know we shouldn't discuss previous games but in the list of low posters someone did up in the last game (luckily it didn't take traction), but there were 3 of 4 wolves in that list and we were just trying not to draw attention to ourselves especially if it's someone that hasn't had a role before.

MrsFlushdraw

Deleted User wrote: »

WWMOD can you answer this or would it give too much away

Did you not get told all that in your PM :P

quickbeam

Nopeare wrote: »

I agree with that I'd say if we took the 8-10 lowest posters there will be 3/4 roles in them which will only be a hit rate of low about 30% to a high of around 40/50%. By no means perfect but a good starting point with nothing else to go on and it makes them start posting/defending themselves. Which will also raise the possibility of a slip.

I know we shouldn't discuss previous games but in the list of low posters someone did up in the last game (luckily it didn't take traction), but there were 3 of 4 wolves in that list and we were just trying not to draw attention to ourselves especially if it's someone that hasn't had a role before.

And then we lynched poor Barney - the one out of four who wasn't :mad: I was dead by then so can't be blamed for that one though.

Nopeare

Nopeare wrote: »

I agree with that I'd say if we took the 8-10 lowest posters there will be 3/4 roles in them which will only be a hit rate of low about 30% to a high of around 40/50%. By no means perfect but a good starting point with nothing else to go on and it makes them start posting/defending themselves. Which will also raise the possibility of a slip.

I know we shouldn't discuss previous games but in the list of low posters someone did up in the last game (luckily it didn't take traction), but there were 3 of 4 wolves in that list and we were just trying not to draw attention to ourselves especially if it's someone that hasn't had a role before.

my list

MrsFlushdraw

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

Did you not get told all that in your PM :P

Ah miss flushy I actually think you a good guy still do but Im a villa

Triceratops Ballet

Deleted User wrote: »

Ah miss flushy I actually think you a good guy still do but Im a villa

Villa? Villain?:D

crosstownk

I think it takes a few days to identify a low poster. With RL stuff, shift work, etc. it could be a day or two before a low posting pattern emerges. After a couple of days a low poster is more than likely either a sleeper with a role or a disinterested player.

So if you're a low poster in this game then give us your read on the situation so far and what you think of tonight's lynch and the various accusations and theories that have been bounced around today.

The village awaits your responses..........

Nopeare

On my previous post I think single posters are people with RL commitments.

But the following is where I think some of the roles are, posting a little that they're active but also probably active in their other forum. I know it's a large list (1/3 of remaining players) and likely to put a target on my back from the innocent villagers and role players. Since we have nothing to go on I think it's a starting point for people to start posting to defend themselves and hopefully slip up.

dottie_lottie 7
Shane.C 7
JasonS246 7
partyjungle 7
The_Valeyard 6
A Neurotic 5
mahamageehad 5 (Personally I'd give a by as they posted about been busy in work)
gufc21 5
Digital Solitude 3

quickbeam

^^ Valeyard you say???

y0ssar1an22

Nopeare wrote: »

On my previous post I think single posters are people with RL commitments.

But the following is where I think some of the roles are, posting a little that they're active but also probably active in their other forum. I know it's a large list (1/3 of remaining players) and likely to put a target on my back from the innocent villagers and role players. Since we have nothing to go on I think it's a starting point for people to start posting to defend themselves and hopefully slip up.

interesting. thats not something i ever considered. this makes me suspicious of nopeare :P

Nopeare

quickbeam wrote: »

^^ Valeyard you say???

Surely couldn't be 3 for 3 :pac:

Triceratops Ballet

Nopeare wrote: »

On my previous post I think single posters are people with RL commitments.

But the following is where I think some of the roles are, posting a little that they're active but also probably active in their other forum. I know it's a large list (1/3 of remaining players) and likely to put a target on my back from the innocent villagers and role players. Since we have nothing to go on I think it's a starting point for people to start posting to defend themselves and hopefully slip up.

ah here, I'm in work! I can't completely abandon my real life responsibilities!!

MrsFlushdraw

Nopeare wrote: »

Surely couldn't be 3 for 3 :pac:

More reason to lynch him as everyone will assume the same!

crosstownk

dottie_lottie wrote: »

ah here, I'm in work! I can't completely abandon my real life responsibilities!!

Where's your commitment, dottie? The village needs your commitment.

y0ssar1an22

dottie_lottie wrote: »

ah here, I'm in work! I can't completely abandon my real life responsibilities!!

yes you can and you should. westeros needs you

Triceratops Ballet

crosstownk wrote: »

Where's your commitment, dottie? The village needs your commitment.

ok you got me I'm in, responsibilities schmonsibilities!!

how about instead of waiting for possible tasks to appear, we try and think what tasks could be, that way we have an idea what we might be looking for? (unless that's not allowed!)

WerewolfGM

WerewolfGM wrote: »

In order for Tyrion, Renly and Jon to join their teams they will have to complete a secret mission in the game thread.

WerewolfGM wrote: »

Rules:

5) Game starts with a wolf slaughter to be revealed at 10am tomorrow morning.

Dont want to waste time looking back from start if I dont have to

Nopeare

dottie_lottie wrote: »

ah here, I'm in work! I can't completely abandon my real life responsibilities!!

Dottie not meant personally but we have nothing to go on so far IMO and it was a good suggestion in the last game that people didn't enforce. When it's this early it can be a kick up the ar*e to get people posting, which will then lead to people making mistakes hopefully.

MrsFlushdraw

crosstownk wrote: »

Where's your commitment, dottie? The village needs your commitment.

My hubby said he wont hear from me in a week with this

least he gets it!

A Neurotic

dottie_lottie wrote:

how about instead of waiting for possible tasks to appear, we try and think what tasks could be, that way we have an idea what we might be looking for? (unless that's not allowed!)

No reason it wouldn't be allowed. I lurked the last game, I recall one of the tasks being the first letter of each of the guy's posts spelling out something or other.

What were the tasks in the first game? Didn't catch that one.