Manchester United v Stoke 02/10/16 k/o 12.00pm BT1

NomadicGray · 02-10-2016 1:14pm

Nasty, playing for a different team and he'd have seen red there.

PhlegmyMoses · 02-10-2016 1:14pm

Not a red for me. Very awkward but not out of control but he was well within his rights to go for it honestly and the way the two collide makes it look bad. Hard to get away from the optics of it though

Hotblack Desiato · 02-10-2016 1:14pm

NomadicGray wrote: »

Nasty, playing for a different team and he'd have seen red there.

:rolleyes:

02-10-2016 1:14pm

NomadicGray wrote: »

Nasty, playing for a different team and he'd have seen red there.

Lol

PhlegmyMoses · 02-10-2016 1:14pm

NomadicGray wrote: »

Nasty, playing for a different team and he'd have seen red there.

Lol. Stoke have blatantly dived twice today and haven't seen a yellow yet.

TitianGerm · 02-10-2016 1:15pm

PhlegmyMoses wrote: »

Lol. Stoke have blatantly dived twice today and haven't seen a yellow yet.

That doesn't justify a bad tackle.

PhlegmyMoses · 02-10-2016 1:16pm

emmetkenny wrote: »

That doesn't justify a bad tackle.

Read his post again. His suggestion is that United only get decisions in their favour. I'm saying that's not the case.

Liam O · 02-10-2016 1:18pm

It was certainly borderline but it wasn't malicious and he pulls out a bit after the contact so yellow isn't really something that you can argue with.

Corholio · 02-10-2016 1:19pm

It was a red for me certainly. He stretches for the ball and ends up planting the sole of his foot on Allen's thigh. Thats not colliding and not way you should be tackling with a bouncing ball.

abarkie · 02-10-2016 1:20pm

If Stoke had a decent striker they could be 2 or 3 goals to the good here

Shows what they are lacking

TitianGerm · 02-10-2016 1:20pm

PhlegmyMoses wrote: »

Read his post again. His suggestion is that United only get decisions in their favour. I'm saying that's not the case.

I did read his post and what I got was that if a stoke/palace player made a tackle like that they could have had a red but Andre could have easily had a red as well.

No where in his post would I have got that only United get decision in their favour.

PhlegmyMoses · 02-10-2016 1:21pm

We still have huge problems at wingback and centre mid. Quick counters from better teams will destroy us throughout the season.

02-10-2016 1:22pm

Nice play, unlucky

Rayne Wooney · 02-10-2016 1:22pm

If it's Rooney for Mata we may as well settle for the point now

02-10-2016 1:23pm

Mata off

Liam O · 02-10-2016 1:23pm

Would have taken Rashford off before Lingard.

PhlegmyMoses · 02-10-2016 1:23pm

emmetkenny wrote: »

I did read his post and what I got was that if a stoke/palace player made a tackle like that they could have had a red but Andre could have easily had a red as well.

No where in his post would I have got that only United get decision in their favour.

I have no idea what you are on about tbh. I'm seeing something very different to you.