Werewolf IV - All Hallows' Eve - GAME OVER - Villagers Win

mahamageehad

Stoogie wrote: »

Mamageehad is Van H when was she peaked exactly CJ , if it was after yosser shifted she is a definate villager
Mrs flush when was she peeked, although she could still be Lucifer.
Barney was just peeked there I assume so can't be the Thing might be Lucifer

peeks are to catch the thing only at this stage, I think the witch should come out and be peeked. This is my logic and if it's wrong don't jump down my throat.
There is no advantage for the evils to kill her as she gets better at the next lynch if she does so no net gain.
If she is the witch she can't be lucifer and if she is peeked she can't be the thing.

So I strongly recommend this

Excellent suggestion.

The_Valeyard

Wonder if everyone declares who they are. We can whittle down the numbers.

The_Valeyard

Witch.


Come forth and identify yourself.

MrsFlushdraw

The_Valeyard wrote: »

Lucy is that you?

Uriel. wrote: »

By reverting to standard play. Post and vote analysis. But with different groupings vote analysis may not be valuable.

How about a trial with a power play judgment process?

I don't mind how we do it but not wasting the evening arguing

I am MrsFD I am a villager, I was relieved at getting that role as the seer last game was just a nightmare as so much happens and it is hard to not show you are the Seer but still try to stay alive.

I am a terrible villager as I always seem to look wolfy, just the way I play I guess. But as to why I am who I say I am, well I have been peeked good for a start so we can't accuse every player that shows good and all be right.

I was on tigger from the start, I have done my best to help the village from the start but can't force you guys to believe me. I hope we make the right decision and we get the last baddie but it isn't me folks.

Over to the next one...

Oh and I know there is a claim on VH but I take it they were never peeked?
I am sure they are who they say they are anyway

Stoogie

I was thinking about everyone coming out but the. I thought only one can be clarified at a time so the witch was the clear choice
Also I don't want the hero coming out or the apprentice seer.
So please stop that.

A Neurotic

The_Valeyard wrote:

Witch.

Come forth and identify yourself.

It meeeeeee!

*cackles*

The_Valeyard

A Neurotic wrote: »

It meeeeeee!

*cackles*

Really?

Triceratops Ballet

oh look! there's the crazy refresh lady!

sullivlo

End of hunting period

RIP cee_jay

A Neurotic

The_Valeyard wrote:

Really?

Yep.

sullivlo wrote:

RIP cee_jay

F*ck.

Triceratops Ballet

mahamageehad - van helsing
A neurotic- The witch
Uriel.
The_Valeyard - The priest
Stoogie
dottie_lottie
barney92
MrsFlushdraw
Crosstownk

The_Valeyard

Ceejay Was The seer. RIP sweet prince.


Apprentice seer, remain low until called.

Triceratops Ballet

The_Valeyard wrote: »

Ceejay Was The seer. RIP sweet prince.


Apprentice seer, remain low until called.

CJ was a bloke?!! I'd thought female!

I'm engaging in my weird hobby this evening, so I'm eager to pick a lynchee early!!

The_Valeyard

dottie_lottie wrote: »

CJ was a bloke?!! I'd thought female!

I'm engaging in my weird hobby this evening, so I'm eager to pick a lynchee early!!

Princess........then.

crosstownk

OK. It's getting tougher and the room for mistakes is getting less and less.

I'm open to suggestions here but at the moment I'm probably most suss of MrsFD and Barney. I'm not really sure why but maybe I'm suss of Barney due to his stormer in the last game so I'll probably need to try not to let that affect me.

I'm inclined to think that Dottie is a villager and I honestly don't know what to make of Uriel or Stoogie.

MrsFlushdraw

What I hate about these games is that the seer peeking you doesn't clear you!

mahamageehad - van helsing
A neurotic- The witch
Uriel.
The_Valeyard - The priest
Stoogie
dottie_lottie
barney92 - peeked villager but could be evil
MrsFlushdraw - Peeked Villager
Crosstownk

So we have Uriel, Stoogie, Dottie and Crosstownk who are total unknowns.

I really think we need to try one of these guys first. Starting with Uriel

That is who my vote will be for

Barney92

Understandable that people suspect me after last time, and the fact I'm one of the lower posters. Although that's more because people in most cases have gotten to an idea before I have and then it seems a bit silly for me just to say "yeah, sounds good to me". So when I feel I can add something I have done so. The main time I suggested someone was in my vote for crosstown the first time around, and that showed quite clearly as I was the only one not to vote for Tigger or Molly.

I'm just a bog-standard villager this time around. However, I don't expect you to believe me on that. But you do know I'm not the thing due to the seer, which means that I am certainly not one of the two remaining baddies. So unless you are pretty certain that I am Lucifer then you should go for one of the people who haven't been cleared of either baddy role.

Barney92

By the way my original suspicion of crosstown was as a vampire role (converted), so whilst they aren't in the clear my suspicions are lessened.

The_Valeyard

Right, who should we look at for the next lync Make your case.

Uriel.

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

What I hate about these games is that the seer peeking you doesn't clear you!

mahamageehad - van helsing
A neurotic- The witch
Uriel.
The_Valeyard - The priest
Stoogie
dottie_lottie
barney92 - peeked villager but could be evil
MrsFlushdraw - Peeked Villager
Crosstownk

So we have Uriel, Stoogie, Dottie and Crosstownk who are total unknowns.

I really think we need to try one of these guys first. Starting with Uriel

That is who my vote will be for

Why?

Triceratops Ballet

right my suspect list is

Uriel
Barney
MrsFD
Crosstownk

I don't have feelings good or bad about stoogie, I'm a villager. I don't suspect any of the outed players

sullivlo

Okay folks, the lynch form is open again and it will close at 9.

mahamageehad

We can only afford one mistake people. I'm also for Uriel and flush.

The_Valeyard

mahamageehad wrote: »

We can only afford one mistake people. I'm also for Uriel and flush.

I'll go with Uriel and flushy.

A Neurotic

MrsFlushdraw wrote:

mahamageehad - van helsing A neurotic- The witch Uriel. The_Valeyard - The priest Stoogie dottie_lottie barney92 - peeked villager but could be evil MrsFlushdraw - Peeked Villager Crosstownk

My safelist:
The Valeyard
-> worth pointing out that Vale isn't automatically safe just because of his role, as literally anyone can be The Thing now, but because he's so far proven to be a force for villager good with it.

My 90% safelist:
Mahamageehad - had little to lose by coming out as VH so still potentially Thing, but has otherwise given me absolutely no cause for suspicion

Barney - peeked as safe, so still potentially Lucifer but again has given me no reason to suspect.

My unknowns:
Dottie
Crosstown
Stoogie

My, admittedly vague, suspicions:
Flush - peeked as safe but something isn't sitting right with me. Possible Lucifer in my book.
Uriel - has posted slightly defensively/aggressively IMO. No smoking gun obviously but enough to get on my list.

Barney92

So are the following roles still in play? Or have I missed something?
priest
apprentice seer
witch
sam
van helsing

lucifer
the thing

If i'm right we've got 5 good roles, 3 of which have been claimed (Maha, Vale and Neurotic). I agree that the apprentice should stay quite, as well as Sam. I fear from previous hints that the apprentice is no more though. We would also have then 2 just normal villagers, as well as 2 baddies. Am I right in this?

A Neurotic

Barney92 wrote:

If i'm right we've got 5 good roles, 3 of which have been claimed (Maha, Vale and Neurotic). I agree that the apprentice should stay quite, as well as Sam. I fear from previous hints that the apprentice is no more though. We would also have then 2 just normal villagers, as well as 2 baddies. Am I right in this?

We know the apprentice priest is dead as Vale chose his apprentice and said they subsequently died, are you sure you're not thinking of that?

If the apprentice Seer died, would the priest know their role when they died or would they just be seen as a villager until the first Seer died?

MrsFlushdraw

Uriel. wrote: »

Why?

I just thing you have played different. Loads have me on their radar and I know I am a villager. Getting accused is just par of the course.

Barney92

A Neurotic wrote: »

We know the apprentice priest is dead as Vale chose his apprentice and said they subsequently died, are you sure you're not thinking of that?

If the apprentice Seer died, would the priest know their role when they died or would they just be seen as a villager until the first Seer died?

Oh I know the apprentice priest is dead, through Vale saying it. I mean the apprentice seer. I would guess that since the role was given at the start vale would've been told if the apprentice seer had died.

Uriel.

A Neurotic wrote: »

My safelist:
The Valeyard
-> worth pointing out that Vale isn't automatically safe just because of his role, as literally anyone can be The Thing now, but because he's so far proven to be a force for villager good with it.

My 90% safelist:
Mahamageehad - had little to lose by coming out as VH so still potentially Thing, but has otherwise given me absolutely no cause for suspicion

Barney - peeked as safe, so still potentially Lucifer but again has given me no reason to suspect.

My unknowns:
Dottie
Crosstown
Stoogie

My, admittedly vague, suspicions:
Flush - peeked as safe but something isn't sitting right with me. Possible Lucifer in my book.
Uriel - has posted slightly defensively/aggressively IMO. No smoking gun obviously but enough to get on my list.

Defensively and aggressively? Lol