West Ham v Manchester United 02/1/17 k/o 17.15 SS1

jimmytwotimes 2013

The Talking Bread wrote: »

No, it was 100% not a red card, that is why most think it wasn't a red card. Simple!

I disagree, also simple.

Cantona's Collars

Wow,a card.

Mr.Crinklewood

Rossi IRL wrote: »

Deliberate handball to stop a goal scoring opportunity

Not even a booking

The ref has been bought.

PhlegmyMoses

zerks wrote: »

Wow,a card.

Should have been his second.

Rossi IRL

And that should be Nordveits second yellow....

But decisions have only gone for United this game apparently

Hammer Archer

Hammer Archer wrote: »

I'd like some evidence. Even your fellow Man U fans agree that Mike Dean has ridden us today.

Linmim cleared it up. Have a read of his post

There's another that didn't get a yellow

Hammer Archer

jimmytwotimes 2013 wrote: »

I disagree, also simple.

I see you never replied to my earlier query. Was Lingard's tackle minutes after the red also a sending off offence? He left the ground and tackled from behind. Consistency please.

raze_them_all_

Mr.Crinklewood wrote: »

West Ham away used to be an intimidating atmosphere.

Cannot belive how dead the new stadium is.

Grandfather is a hammers fan all his life, in his words the fans are too far away, in the old stadium they were practically standing on the sideline

raze_them_all_

Rashers motm, good man rashford

Hammer Archer

M!Ck^ wrote: »

Linmim cleared it up. Have a read of his post

There's another that didn't get a yellow

So no evidence then. Just say so then.

PhlegmyMoses

Hammer Archer wrote: »

I see you never replied to my earlier query. Was Lingard's tackle minutes after the red also a sending off offence? He left the ground and tackled from behind. Consistency please.

Lingards tackle was nothing like Feghoulis. You're making a silly argument now. You got ****ed over, 99% of people agree.

RobertKK

...and the reds go marching on, on, on...

Mr.Crinklewood

raze_them_all_ wrote: »

Grandfather is a hammers fan all his life, in his words the fans are too far away, in the old stadium they were practically standing on the sideline

Yup.


Spurs are probably lucky they ate building a football stadium from scratch.

TitianGerm

Dean quick to grab the ball after a MOTM performance :pac:

MD1990

Rashford has done well. But Neville as usual overhyping him not a MOTM performance. Up against the worse RB in the league who can't move.

Ludo

West Ham Football ‏@westhamfootball 3m3 minutes ago
West Ham fans clap medical staff who stretcher away Man Utd fan who has been receiving CPR. He has drips so hopefully he will pull through

Hammer Archer

PhlegmyMoses wrote: »

Lingards tackle was nothing like Feghoulis. You're making a silly argument now. You got ****ed over, 99% of people agree.

I agree. But the poster in question said that leaving the ground is a red card offence. I find it strange that he never made any comment about that foul.

Bret Hart

Fantastic win. Great to see we're finally getting the rub of the green from the officials. Just hope our players and fans will be alright after the game.

We all know how that lot react after a loss.Now to concentrate on defending our Cup.

Unearthly

Good win. Well deserved.

Great subs by Mourinho to win the game.

Hammer Archer

Hammer Archer wrote: »

So no evidence then. Just say so then.

What are you on about, that's plenty of evidence

jimmytwotimes 2013

Hammer Archer wrote: »

I see you never replied to my earlier query. Was Lingard's tackle minutes after the red also a sending off offence? He left the ground and tackled from behind. Consistency please.

Post a video if you can, didn't see it. If it was or wasn't a red for lingard doesn't impact my view on the west ham red tho.

I have not been arguing the ref screwing either team, so I don't see why it would make a difference if lingard deserved a red. All I said was West Ham red deserved, that won't change because of a different incident.

Hammer Archer

M!Ck^ wrote: »

What are you on about, that's plenty of evidence

Yet you can't point to any :pac:
Good stuff.

Hammer Archer

Hammer Archer wrote: »

Yet you can't point to any :pac:
Good stuff.

I just did. Not sure how you are not getting this

The_Kew_Tour

Great result and delighted to get bit of luck over that lot.

niallo27

Bret Hart wrote: »

Fantastic win. Great to see we're finally getting the rub of the green from the officials. Just hope our players and fans will be alright after the game.

We all know how that lot react after a loss.Now to concentrate on defending our Cup.

No fear of utd fans in fairness. Have you been to an away game. They are able to look after themselves.

Rainman16

Fantastic, 6 wins in a row for United. Things are really coming together now. Think we could be on for a top 3 finish

Dave0301

MD1990 wrote: »

Rashford has done well. But Neville as usual overhyping him not a MOTM performance. Up against the worse RB in the league who can't move.

Who would you have picked for MOTM instead?

Hammer Archer

M!Ck^ wrote: »

I just did. Not sure how you are not getting this

So a handball at the edge of the box in the 89th minute that should have been a yellow makes up for a non existent red, an offside goal and another offside that woild have resulted in a goal were it not for Randolph.
Right!

Rainman16

MOTH for me was Rashford. He was the difference maker in this one

Jayop

Hammer Archer wrote: »

So a handball at the edge of the box in the 89th minute that should have been a yellow makes up for a non existent red, an offside goal and another offside that woild have resulted in a goal were it not for Randolph.
Right!

No it doesn't. You were rode. It happens unfortunately.

Nalz

Dave0301 wrote: »

Who would you have picked for MOTM instead?

De Gea? Some great saves tbf

Hammer Archer

Hammer Archer wrote: »

So a handball at the edge of the box in the 89th minute that should have been a yellow makes up for a non existent red, an offside goal and another offside that woild have resulted in a goal were it not for Randolph.
Right!

Sky Sports just confirmed that kueyates tackle on miki Ryan was a clear red for wreckless play

Did that go against Utd?

Hammer Archer

M!Ck^ wrote: »

Sky Sports just confirmed that kueyates tackle on miki Ryan was a clear red for wreckless play

Did that go against Utd?

It should have been a yellow. Good to know that you judge all your opinions on what Sky say though. They've also just said that Man U benefitted from the officiating today.

Nalz

emmetkenny wrote: »

Dean quick to grab the ball after a MOTM performance :pac:

You need to score a hattrick to claim the ball babe

limnam

Hammer Archer wrote: »

It should have been a yellow. Good to know that you judge all your opinions on what Sky say though. They've also said that Man U benefitted from the officiating today.

Foot over the top is a yellow?

Should be a red.

What about stompping on someones face? What's that? a word in the ear?

get out of it

chupacabra

M!Ck^ wrote: »

Sky Sports just confirmed that kueyates tackle on miki Ryan was a clear red for wreckless play

Did that go against Utd?

Sky just confirmed? It was more like "Gary Neville just gave his opinion"

enzo roco

M!Ck^ wrote: »

Sky Sports just confirmed that kueyates tackle on miki Ryan was a clear red for wreckless play

Does that make it a fact???

limnam

enzo roco wrote: »

Does that make it a fact???

Only when Rafa is doing analysis.

TitianGerm

Nalz wrote: »

You need to score a hattrick to claim the ball babe

I'm not an idiot, it was a joke and pull your neck in quickly and don't call me babe again.

Nalz

Hammer Archer wrote: »

It should have been a yellow. Good to know that you judge all your opinions on what Sky say though. They've also just said that Man U benefitted from the officiating today.

Manchester United benefitted from the decisions. As did West Ham. Arguably more decisions went against United but the fact that a dubious red card on 15mins which is so early on, plus an offside goal would mean United benefitted more.

West Ham tackled hard and could of had more cards to be fair.

Nalz

emmetkenny wrote: »

I'm not an idiot, it was a joke and pull your neck in quickly and don't call me babe again.

Wow. Sorry hun.

The_Kew_Tour

emmetkenny wrote: »

I'm not an idiot, it was a joke and pull your neck in quickly and don't call me babe again.

Chill out hunny bunny

niallo27

Is it so hard to admit that Utd got lucky today with decisions. What's the big deal saying it.

Korat

West Ham's luck ran out today, they've been due a red card or two against Utd for a while now. How Adrien wasn't sent off in the cup game I'll never know.

Flint Fredstone

emmetkenny wrote: »

I'm not an idiot, it was a joke and pull your neck in quickly and don't call me babe again.

Ooooh the mask is slipping...

Trigger

niallo27 wrote: »

Is it so hard to admit that Utd got lucky today with decisions. What's the big deal saying it.

who the **** ISNT saying that, virtually everyone is saying that we did but also saying that the ref made mistakes that benefitted West ham as well.. basically, the officials are incompetent arses

limnam

niallo27 wrote: »

Is it so hard to admit that Utd got lucky today with decisions. What's the big deal saying it.

It's as easy as been able to say west ham got lucky with decisions

Next question..

Flint Fredstone

niallo27 wrote: »

Is it so hard to admit that Utd got lucky today with decisions. What's the big deal saying it.

No it's not. United got lucky today with decisions. There I just said it.

enzo roco

enzo roco wrote: »

Does that make it a fact???

Nope, it shows that most here share the same opinion as sky

Again what's your point it was wreckless

I'd argue that the blinkers need to get checked if certain people only think that was a yellow

A leg breaking tackle, wreckless

Herrera was stamped on his face with clear visible damage, not a mention of that

A yellow card for Darmian in the first half for nothing?

Will I continue?

Nalz

Poor joke tbf... His reply to me even poorer. I wasn't trolling. Relax.