WWX: Hogwarts goes to war

Ectoplasm

My original suspects yesterday were Tritium (till they died), Andy (til he outed himself), GUFC and RTA.

I was a bit suspicious of grumpylumpy but the fact that both RTA and gufc voted for them lifted that suspicion somewhat.

I was also a bit suspicious of mahama but I think that was mostly based on what other people were saying.

I'm still suspicious about RTA.

Amandadon

Amandadon wrote: »

Uriel was Dudley
Andy was a G3 but not Harry.
I'm very surprised to still b alive to be honest

It would be wise to not reveal Harry. Or you should lie about it. Or you should tell the truth. Only the SK and wolves gain from knowing Harry's exact fate.

Lord TSC

I'm probably going to be registering my vote for Raze unless anyone can come up with something more concrete.

y0ssar1an22

Lord TSC wrote: »

I'm probably going to be registering my vote for Raze unless anyone can come up with something more concrete.

what was the reasoning for raze?

grumpylumpy

Would it be worth doing an FFA and then collating the evidence against the most mentioned contenders rather than just the numbers?

My #FFA2

Mahamageehed
Grumpy
quickbeam

grumpylumpy

grumpylumpy wrote: »

Would it be worth doing an FFA and then collating the evidence against the most mentioned contenders rather than just the numbers?

evidence/individual reasoning. Maybe we'd be able to draw something concrete

sKeith

my #ffa2
Raze. Being left of list of suspects makes me suspect. (brownie points go to FD)
DanMan. For attempting to fly under the radar for too long.
Mahamageehed. Still haven't shaken my original suspicion.

Lord TSC

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

what was the reasoning for raze?

Originally, it was his comment about fearing a lynching, despite not being discussed as a candidate. Seemed a weird fear to have at that point.

Mind, not locked in. But not much to go on elsewhere.

grumpylumpy

sKeith wrote: »

Mahamageehed. Still haven't shaken my original suspicion.

What was the original suspicion based off?

y0ssar1an22

raze_them_all_ wrote: »

someone from my reading came out as 1 of the normal villagers, then two more did, one of these 3 is 100% lying

raze_them_all_ wrote: »

They are lying 100% I will even take a death to prove im a villager and expose one of them for lying

raze_them_all_ wrote: »

Dont one of them is lying. Seriously.

raze_them_all_ wrote: »

you aint paying attention i already outed who and what i am

still think their lying? and why?

what are you?

y0ssar1an22

mahamageehad wrote: »

Apparently. I don't fancy either though. :P Don't see anything yet strongly against Grumpy. I'd like to wait til this evening to see how everything develops, but I have 2 suspects right now. I also have 2 that I'm convinced are on the good team.

Do we have a plan for how we're going to lynch, or are we going to panic and mess it up as usual? :pac: might as well start figuring this out now.

I'd be in favour of an FFA. (For n00bs it's when you post your top three suspicions with the hashtag #FFA1 on day 1, #FFA2 on day 2 etc. The top two or three are then put up for a public vote.) I also see the benefits of blind voting, but only if reasons are given afterwards. Anyone have any preferences?

this is why i initially suspected mahama. this looks like a subtle hint to claim HRH

Ectoplasm

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

what was the reasoning for raze?

My original reason was actually a bit flawed but his reaction when the G3 outed themselves convinced me.

sKeith

I was pulled up on that earlier, it was a tit for tat between mahama and FD. (I mistakenly recalled it as trit, but was corrected, thanks.)

mahamageehad

I'm for FFA. No idea why a few are on my back, but let me state once and clearly that I'm a vanillager. The picking two was in no way intended as a hint, ye are just reading into it. Ye did something like that to me last game as well, I'm genuinely not that clever to be thinking up subtleties like that. I didn't want to whitelist anyone and drop the pool of suspects for the wolves, no point in doing their work for em. I'm down to two for seer now and pretty sure I've the BG pegged since yesterday.

For me, I think QB is most suspicious right now coz she's playing different to usual. I'm unsure on grumpy. Evidence is flimsy as far as I know, isn't is mainly based on a strange Snape comment about everyone being confused? Need to review her posts. I think we've a hidden wolf too, one of Vale, sKeith, or maybe Dan Man. I need to review posts when I'm home on my laptop again tonight, so my FFA below is provisional.

My FFA for now would be:
Quickbeam
Grumpy
The_Valeyard

mahamageehad

sKeith wrote: »

my #ffa2
Raze. Being left of list of suspects makes me suspect. (brownie points go to FD)
DanMan. For attempting to fly under the radar for too long.
Mahamageehed. Still haven't shaken my original suspicion.

If you're adding Raze for being left off the list, surely you should include the person who left him off the list? Dottie I think? I think that was a mistake. There's some other stuff against him but I don't think the list thing is one.

mahamageehad

mahamageehad wrote: »

If you're adding Raze for being left off the list, surely you should include the person who left him off the list? Dottie I think? I think that was a mistake. There's some other stuff against him but I don't think the list thing is one.

Strawberry not Dottie, I just reviewed.

WerewolfGM

The lynch form is now open.

mahamageehad

WerewolfGM wrote: »

The lynch form is now open.

You could have attempted to find something potter related. :pac:

y0ssar1an22

is that the fat lady singiing?

WerewolfGM

mahamageehad wrote: »

You could have attempted to find something potter related. :pac:

y0ssar1an22

thats the fat lady

Ectoplasm

Uh oh, does this mean the Gryffindors have been locked out of their common room?
Because that does look like the fat lady singing

mahamageehad

EMF2010 wrote: »

Uh oh, does this mean the Gryffindors have been locked out of their common room?
Because that does look like the fat lady singing

I'd guess so yeah. Wasn't sure with the first pic, but the second ones pretty clear. Hope the G2 had perfected their plan. Yesterday I mused that Harry had some kind of dueling power and if he close to use it hed have to "go alone" meaning the lads would be kicked from the room so it's potentially going to be another v exciting day!!!

MrsFlushdraw

#FFA2

Grumpy- Is wolfy AF
RTA - From yesterdays accusations still
Mahama - From yesterday

There are 3/4 baddies in the unknowns so I'm throwing 4 names into the arena.

Quickbeam - as per Andy's advice that if GUFC is a baddie then QB probably is too.

The Valeyard - saying enough to not have a low post count but nothing to help us.

MrsFD - I think her time to be selected at random as a baddie has come. As far as I am aware, you have only been a baddie once and that was when the evil team chose you themselves. Oh, I also like picking you at same stage anyway

SKeith - c'mon, with initials like that, I have to!

Strawberry Milkshake

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

There are 3/4 baddies in the unknowns so I'm throwing 4 names into the arena.

Quickbeam - as per Andy's advice that if GUFC is a baddie then QB probably is too.

The Valeyard - saying enough to not have a low post count but nothing to help us.

MrsFD - I think her time to be selected at random as a baddie has come. As far as I am aware, you have only been a baddie once and that was when the evil team chose you themselves. Oh, I also like picking you at same stage anyway

SKeith - c'mon, with initials like that, I have to!

Sorry forgot #FFA2

Triceratops Ballet

EMF2010 wrote: »

Uh oh, does this mean the Gryffindors have been locked out of their common room?
Because that does look like the fat lady singing

Do you think it really means that? I bet the mods are just toying with us!

Ectoplasm

dottie_lottie wrote: »

Do you think it really means that? I bet the mods are just toying with us!

I did think so but now I am wondering. At this stage I wouldn't be surprised but it does seem a bit odd. With so many good roles outed, would preventing them from chatting tip the balance in favour of the baddies?

y0ssar1an22

as the saying goes....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XKj5hlXlW2c