WW XII - Simpsons Mafia

Necro

andy125 wrote: »

I agree its our best chance of a win tbh

Wolf Andy first posts after the mod clarification on thread.

sKeith wrote: »

bodyguard can't protect himself.
magee can't kill when dead
homer isn't invincible when any simpson dead

3 reasons a reveal all might not be in our interests.

This is sKeith's direct response to Andy's post. Casting doubt on andy's agreement.

sullivlo wrote: »

Can we coordinate a time to reveal though? We can barely coordinate a #ffa most of the time

Wolf Sully pops in moments later... possible mafia team?

raze_them_all_

tritium wrote: »

I figure sully was team Andy based on his post. On the upside that means one more wolf from there and the kill rate drops for us

Ned - am i right that hes lost his powers now.Whats the consensus on ned revealing himself? Any reason not to?

While ned losing his powers revealing gives wolves and SK a free kill that won't have them off each other

tritium

Hey necro when does grandpappys power kick in?

tritium

raze_them_all_ wrote: »

While ned losing his powers revealing gives wolves and SK a free kill that won't have them off each other

Fair point. How do you think this balances against building a villager voting block. Key is likely to get the kill rate down here

Necro

tritium wrote:

Hey necro when does grandpappys power kick in?

I have to survive tonight's munch. I highly doubt that will happen

Kolido

After the 3rd munch

tritium

Necrominus wrote: »

I have to survive tonight's munch. I highly doubt that will happen

Ok depending on how the mods announce things we may have to peek you after that so

Triceratops Ballet

Gramps, your power could be good or evil, we don't know how that's gonna fall. Maybe that's why they're keeping you. Hoping for another baddie

Necro

sKeith wrote: »

+1 for revealing. have we a consensus yet? we also need a consensus for when to reveal.

sKeith wrote: »

bodyguard can't protect himself.
magee can't kill when dead
homer isn't invincible when any simpson dead

3 reasons a reveal all might not be in our interests.

These posts are in direct contradiction of each other.

sKeith is a wolf

So, to summarise - I believe one wolf team is/was sKeith, Andy and Sully.

Necro

dottie_lottie wrote: »

Gramps, your power could be good or evil, we don't know how that's gonna fall. Maybe that's why they're keeping you. Hoping for another baddie

Highly possible. I suggest you lynch me tomorrow.

Xaracatz

Yay. I'm alive. Boo people want me dead.

We would want to be lynching Kolido btw.

raze_them_all_

tritium wrote: »

Fair point. How do you think this balances against building a villager voting block. Key is likely to get the kill rate down here

As far as I can tell the only good without doubt is about as homer. Ned can come out but its only 2 people? None of the Simpsons can come out or qb gets munched. We will know tomorrow if necromancer is Abe as he will have powers should he survive.

I assume homer will know if a family member dies. If that happens I doubt about will live long. Necro is probably not long for the world as his powers kick in tomorrow and Dou the bad teams want to deal with that as nobody knows what power he wields

Digital Solitude

Xaracatz wrote: »

Yay. I'm alive. Boo people want me dead.

We would want to be lynching Kolido btw.

Why?

Necro

Xaracatz wrote: »

Yay. I'm alive. Boo people want me dead.

We would want to be lynching Kolido btw.

I'm fine with either you or Kolido

Triceratops Ballet

Necrominus wrote: »

These posts are in direct contradiction of each other.

sKeith is a wolf

So, to summarise - I believe one wolf team is/was sKeith, Andy and Sully.

ok, and I can't commit to this right now but we need to look at what they were posting while Andy was spouting off about whatever role he pretended to have (Nelson I believe)

It's likely that in a back room he was like I'm toast anyway guys so i'll provide cover for you and you do x y z.

Like I said I can't commit to that now, it's madness at the plant now that Burnsey has become evil, I don't have the heart to release the hounds but I need to try keep the workers in line

Kolido

Xaracatz wrote: »

Yay. I'm alive. Boo people want me dead.

We would want to be lynching Kolido btw.

Haha... yeah lynch someone else on the list to take the heat of yourself. What makes you think I'm a baddy?

Necro

raze_them_all_ wrote: »

As far as I can tell the only good without doubt is about as homer. Ned can come out but its only 2 people? None of the Simpsons can come out or qb gets munched. We will know tomorrow if necromancer is Abe as he will have powers should he survive.

I assume homer will know if a family member dies. If that happens I doubt about will live long. Necro is probably not long for the world as his powers kick in tomorrow and Dou the bad teams want to deal with that as nobody knows what power he wields

If I survive the night, I should be lynched tomorrow. No two ways about it.

Triceratops Ballet

I'm gonna suggest a blind vote tonight, we need more info and we can't afford a bandwagon or a forgone conclusion like yesterday. We need to know where the wolves might put their vote without a steer from the village.

Necro

dottie_lottie wrote: »

ok, and I can't commit to this right now but we need to look at what they were posting while Andy was spouting off about whatever role he pretended to have (Nelson I believe)

It's likely that in a back room he was like I'm toast anyway guys so i'll provide cover for you and you do x y z.

Like I said I can't commit to that now, it's madness at the plant now that Burnsey has become evil, I don't have the heart to release the hounds but I need to try keep the workers in line

I can try, but will be fairly limited here until 3pm myself.

Triceratops Ballet

Necrominus wrote: »

I can try, but will be fairly limited here until 3pm myself.

no rush, as long as we get it done

Triceratops Ballet

dottie_lottie wrote: »

I'm gonna suggest a blind vote tonight, we need more info and we can't afford a bandwagon or a forgone conclusion like yesterday. We need to know where the wolves might put their vote without a steer from the village.

For clarity, blind vote and then declare on thread at lynch time who we voted for

Necro

dottie_lottie wrote: »

For clarity, blind vote and then declare on thread at lynch time who we voted for

I'm fine with that. I think it's a very good idea

Xaracatz

Kolido wrote: »

Haha... yeah lynch someone else on the list to take the heat of yourself. What makes you think I'm a baddy?

That's not my style Mr. Mann.

raze_them_all_

Necrominus wrote: »

If I survive the night, I should be lynched tomorrow. No two ways about it.

That's a smart way of thinking but we should wait to see what power you get if you live. They said you get a power is read that as not a role change just a new power for the village to use

Kolido

dottie_lottie wrote: »

I'm gonna suggest a blind vote tonight, we need more info and we can't afford a bandwagon or a forgone conclusion like yesterday. We need to know where the wolves might put their vote without a steer from the village.

It's a decent plan, however, I'm not sure how much the results will help us. They will be quite spread out I would imagine.

On the other hand though, we have lost a goody more often than not with this bandwagon voting so I don't think thats the way to go either.

Lord TSC

Xaracatz wrote: »

Yay. I'm alive. Boo people want me dead.

We would want to be lynching Kolido btw.

Kolido wrote: »

Haha... yeah lynch someone else on the list to take the heat of yourself. What makes you think I'm a baddy?

Xaracatz wrote: »

That's not my style Mr. Mann.

*Enter, Stage left, a dashing young man. He points.*

J'accuse!

*The crowd applauds*

:P

Lord TSC

I'm down for the blind vote too

Necro

Tigger wrote: »

He should have been dead by now it's a good move to organise and help do more after the munch
His team has clearly missed the munch and the other team are goin
Glad to see We have them rattled

I still need to be protected btw and yes I will lie about goodies who died
Since he says he's Tony he probably isn't
I wonder if they have a cross communication room and this is all a bluff
Someone be cleared is probably a wolf as well

Ok, wanted to post this for clarity. I think this actually backs up my theory yesterday.

sKeith wrote: »

better maggie end him or we gain no info from lynch results tomorrow.

sKeith hanging around again. Probably told to ask Maggie to take him out? Interesting sully wasn't around but given the time of night she was probably in bed so it was these guys.

Barney92 wrote: »

Well this was quite the day zero to get my head around. I leave to go find something to do in this town and by the time I'm back from moe's (where else) Andy has admitted guilt. It wasn't looking great for him as time went on and then the plan really has confirmed it. I was going to say that I doubt he is Fat Tony, but then realised it doesn't really matter. If one of the team is dead the alpha loses their special status right? I wouldn't be surprised if he's actually on team burns though.

This was the only other interesting post I found around that time. I figure because all the stuff went down late at night. It could be that Barney is trying to cast shade on what team Andy is on.
I should mention he clarifies below it doesn't matter what team. But the idea was out there straight away. I'm suspicious of Barney now too. Will analyse his posts some more later when I get some time.

quickbeam

Okay, only getting on for the first time today. My thoughts:

BJ was Willie - Necro's theory that he was actually Nelson is a non-runner, I think. Somebody suggested avork was killed because the baddies were looking for Nelson, I think that's a very good theory, and I still think Nelson is out there. On the off-chance that Willie is still around, please don't protect me. Protect somebody with power - Clancy, Snyder Moe, Ned (if he still has powers), I'm basically just a NRV. If you're not sure who any of the above are, then by all means protect me as the only confirmed goodie, but otherwise go with them.

Hermann would have been mad at my plan to get lynched last night which prevented him getting his first kill. I'd expect him to be among those who didn't vote for me - Necro, Vale, Xara (of those still alive) or else he voted for me, but was reluctant to do so. Will see if I can see anything on-thread where somebody gave me a begruding vote.

At the moment, I kinda trust the following:
Mick - pretty sure
Trit - could be a wolf, but tending to lean him towards believing his Krusty claim
Necro - if he's a wolf he's playing a blinder, really coming across as villagery and helpful
Dottie - believe she's Smithers as she says
MrsF - believe she's Carl as she says as she was sort of tricked in to revealing it
Guffy - pretty happy with him as a villager

Am suspicious of:
Vale
sKeith - I can buy in to Necro's theory that he's the third mafia
Xara

I don't really have an opinion one way or another on anybody else. I don't remember what was against EMF (and therefore Kolido) so will have to read back on that to see what there was. Low posters, of course, I'll always be wary of.

So that's where I'm at.

Necro

raze_them_all_ wrote: »

That's a smart way of thinking but we should wait to see what power you get if you live. They said you get a power is read that as not a role change just a new power for the village to use

We have a list of suspects now. I should be added to them should I survive the night. The only other possibility is that the wolves decide to counterclaim Grandpa tomorrow at 10am and leave us with another Tiggergate for day 3.
No other reason to not kill me as you just said.

The list is growing again.

Xaracatz
Kolido
sKeith
Valeyard
Barney