WW XII - Simpsons Mafia

quickbeam

WerewolfGM wrote: »

VOTING RESULTS:

Kolido (10) : Necrominus, Lord TSC, raze them all, tritium, Xaracatz, quickbeam, dottie lottie, The Valeyard, Digital Solitude, Chagan
The Valeyard (7) : sKeith, MrsFlushdraw, Kolido, MicksJaguar, Barney92, Nopeare, Jayop
sKeith (2) : Gufc21, Petr
Xaracatz (1) : Kolido
Necrominus (1) : y0ssar1an22

Did not vote (1) : Deleted User

For clarity sake - who did Kolido vote for? Vale or Xara? (He's listed under both).

The_Valeyard

Pter wrote: »

There is a scenario where we could think you are converted but you wouldnt be......but i dont really see a benefit in that for the baddies....i think you are right and we should indeed focus elsewhere......

Although.....can we actually verify you are indeed Nelson? We are only going on your own word for it, even if you did lay it up in advance.

Well, only way I'm needed is not to waste a lynch until I turn.

Guffy

WerewolfGM wrote: »

A player has asked a question about the lynch/SK kill.

The lynch and SK kill happen at the same time. This is this case in this game and games before this.

In this game there is no SK kill (from Herman Hermann) at lynch time if there is a failed or missed lynch.

Tonight there was a lynch, Herman got the kill.

The rules say after the kill gm... im sorry but its plain as day.

tritium

The_Valeyard wrote: »

Lynching me is now pointless until converted.

I am now a villager. Focus on actual wolves and not could be wolves.

And no,

Memes continue

Hes actually right here for the moment. If we lynch him we lose a (current) villager and then they munch 1 for a net -2. If we wait till hes turned they miss a munch kill and we lynch an ex villager for net -1 on current position. Gets more complicated in the end game though when the twofer effect begins to matter


For now nelsons in detention

Lord TSC

Sorry for hounding you then, Xara. Glad to have you in team goody (short of another claim).

Baggly

Math is the best way to convince me of stuff.

quickbeam

Xaracatz wrote: »

2. DottieLottie ? confirmed as Smithers on the second night (with a saucy gi toof!)

What confused me at first about the Dottie / Smithers thing was how you'd know her actual role. I figured Wiggam would only be told good / evil and no role, so how could you know she was really Smithers.

Then I figured you were probably told she was good, and figured if she was good she'd hardly lie about her role, so that's how you could confirm it.

But now you're saying that you were actually told her role all along?

Sorry for taking so long to catch on to you

The_Valeyard

Where's my apologies?

OK once the BG protects Xara tongight we will get 3 more peeks so I say we go with those that didnt put Vale on the FFA

Baggly

I think we can all agree that i am Spartacus.

QB, you can be homercles.

The_Valeyard

The_Valeyard wrote: »

Where's my apologies?

Im really sorry you gave yourself away as Nelson and we have to be lynched at some stage

Triceratops Ballet

quickbeam wrote: »

What confused me at first about the Dottie / Smithers thing was how you'd know her actual role. I figured Wiggam would only be told good / evil and no role, so how could you know she was really Smithers.

Then I figured you were probably told she was good, and figured if she was good she'd hardly lie about her role, so that's how you could confirm it.

But now you're saying that you were actually told her role all along?

Sorry for taking so long to catch on to you

I assume it was due to the announcement of wiggums suped up powers following "the bj incident"

The_Valeyard

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Im really sorry you gave yourself away as Nelson and we have to be lynched at some stage

I forgive you

Lord TSC

Pter wrote: »

I think we can all agree that i am Spartacus.

QB, you can be homercles.

Another role claim? Ye are all coming out tonight :P

tritium

tritium wrote: »

Hes actually right here for the moment. If we lynch him we lose a (current) villager and then they munch 1 for a net -2. If we wait till hes turned they miss a munch kill and we lynch an ex villager for net -1 on current position. Gets more complicated in the end game though when the twofer effect begins to matter


For now nelsons in detention

Ya he is right but its a cluster feck, I was trying to imply kolidio was good and was hoping the baddies would take him out so we would have saved all the hassle and got a few things done tongiht

Chagan

So that gives us 5 all but confirmed villagers?

QB
Xara
Nopeare (Through Necro verifiying his claim)
Lord
Dottie

That's a handy little block to have working together, coupled with any Simpsons family members that may still be alive. We also have Valeyard for another while too (if he's being truthful).

The_Valeyard

The_Valeyard wrote: »

I forgive you

*internet hugs*

Baggly

Lord TSC wrote: »

Another role claim? Ye are all coming out tonight :P

Nah just a meme. Couldnt find any actual Spartacus Simpsons memes.

Guffy

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Ya he is right but its a cluster feck, I was trying to imply kolidio was good and was hoping the baddies would take him out so we would have saved all the hassle and got a few things done tongiht

What are you on about?

Hermon shouldn't have gotten a kill... kolido should have reduced the kill rate. Nelson would then be killed in a munch by 2 wolves reducing the kill rate

The_Valeyard

[Deleted User] wrote: »

*internet hugs*

Awwwwwww




























If I turn I'm munching you.

Baggly

Chagan wrote: »

So that gives us 5 all but confirmed villagers?

QB
Xara
Nopeare (Through Necro verifiying his claim)
Lord
Dottie

That's a handy little block to have working together, coupled with any Simpsons family members that may still be alive. We also have Valeyard for another while too (if he's being truthful).

Sorry to be the party pooper, but only QB and Nopeare are confirmed. None of the others are verified.

Xars revelation, which great if true, doesnt present us with much new info apart from Lord being good - and Xar and Lord could be working together as baddies.

A Neurotic

Chagan wrote: »

So that gives us 5 all but confirmed villagers?

QB
Xara
Nopeare (Through Necro verifiying his claim)
Lord
Dottie

That's a handy little block to have working together, coupled with any Simpsons family members that may still be alive. We also have Valeyard for another while too (if he's being truthful).

Did I miss where we confirmed Lord?

I presume we'll be notified if Vale is turned? Mods, can you clarify?

Xaracatz

quickbeam wrote: »

What confused me at first about the Dottie / Smithers thing was how you'd know her actual role. I figured Wiggam would only be told good / evil and no role, so how could you know she was really Smithers.

Then I figured you were probably told she was good, and figured if she was good she'd hardly lie about her role, so that's how you could confirm it.

But now you're saying that you were actually told her role all along?

Sorry for taking so long to catch on to you

Yeah - I got the actual roles by then due to the extra powers. Loved the crayon remark!

I've been trying to catch hidden evils, but if I get my peek tomorrow morning, I'm open to bribery suggestions.

gufc21

gufc21 wrote: »

What are you on about?

Hermon shouldn't have gotten a kill... kolido should have reduced the kill rate. Nelson would then be killed in a munch by 2 wolves reducing the kill rate

I didnt know he was Hermon if im being honest, I thought he was bad so was hoping hermon or one of the other bad teams would kill him for us while we lynched Vale

Baggly

I guess what im saying, to no-ones surprise, is that i have doubts.

quickbeam

Chagan wrote: »

So that gives us 5 all but confirmed villagers?

QB
Xara
Nopeare (Through Necro verifiying his claim)
Lord
Dottie

That's a handy little block to have working together, coupled with any Simpsons family members that may still be alive. We also have Valeyard for another while too (if he's being truthful).

In theory one of, Lordy, Dottie and sKeith could be the Alpha. We have two dead evils from mafia teams (Andy & Sully) - if we were lucky it was one from each team and therefore any peeks after Sully's death were 100% accurate. But if they were both from the same team, the other team would still have a full quota and their Alpha would continue to remain un-peekable?

Or, did I miss where it was confirmed they were from separate teams?

Lord TSC

A Neurotic wrote: »

Did I miss where we confirmed Lord?

I presume we'll be notified if Vale is turned? Mods, can you clarify?

Xara, claiming to be Wiggum, says she checked me tonight and I was confirmed as good.

I'm guessing, if the bodyguard is alive, Xara is priority tonight yeah?

Baggly

Lord TSC wrote: »

Xara, claiming to be Wiggum, says she checked me tonight and I was confirmed as good.

Which will be great when we get Xar confirmed.

I think that only happens if real Wiggum steps up (please dont).

quickbeam

Lord TSC wrote: »

Xara, claiming to be Wiggum, says she checked me tonight and I was confirmed as good.

I'm guessing, if the bodyguard is alive, Xara is priority tonight yeah?

Yes. Xara is priority for Willie!! :P

Triceratops Ballet

quickbeam wrote: »

In theory one of, Lordy, Dottie and sKeith could be the Alpha. We have two dead evils from mafia teams (Andy & Sully) - if we were lucky it was one from each team and therefore any peeks after Sully's death were 100% accurate. But if they were both from the same team, the other team would still have a full quota and their Alpha would continue to remain un-peekable?

Or, did I miss where it was confirmed they were from separate teams?

except Xara didn't confirm I'm good, she confirmed I'm smithers