WW XII - Simpsons Mafia

Deleted User

Deleted User wrote: »

I didnt know he was Hermon if im being honest, I thought he was bad so was hoping hermon or one of the other bad teams would kill him for us while we lynched Vale

I also wanted to confirm Vale to a point too and catch any wolves who didnt put him in the FFA

Chagan

Pter wrote: »

Sorry to be the party pooper, but only QB and Nopeare are confirmed. None of the others are verified.

Xars revelation, which great if true, doesnt present us with much new info apart from Lord being good - and Xar and Lord could be working together as baddies.

It's possible, but I don't see how she could have been so confident of Kolido being Herman if she was not specifically told it.

tritium

The_Valeyard wrote: »

Where's my apologies?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5kx6-NzLpf0

quickbeam

quickbeam wrote: »

In theory one of, Lordy, Dottie and sKeith could be the Alpha. We have two dead evils from mafia teams (Andy & Sully) - if we were lucky it was one from each team and therefore any peeks after Sully's death were 100% accurate. But if they were both from the same team, the other team would still have a full quota and their Alpha would continue to remain un-peekable?

Or, did I miss where it was confirmed they were from separate teams?

Would Andy really out Sully as Moe. And dangle her as a 2 for 1 village kill to the other bad teams?

Deleted User

Deleted User wrote: »

Would Andy really out Sully as Moe. And dangle her as a 2 for 1 village kill to the other bad teams?

Most likely reducing his team down to 1 after 1 day

quickbeam

dottie_lottie wrote: »

except Xara didn't confirm I'm good, she confirmed I'm smithers

Yeah, was typing that before I read that Xara got extra power to actually know the role.

So, presume she knows the role of Lordy too?

I'm happy with a confirmed good list of:

QB
Nopeare
Xara
Dottie
Lordy

With a pretty sure good list of:
Vale (for now)
Trit
MrsF

Guffy

I'm out. Sick of the mods changing the rules mid game. Its the 3rd time its affected me for the negative. I have not asked to be mod killed so the badies will have to kill me. Not going to reveal my role.

Triceratops Ballet

I don't think I've been peeked before, so flattered!

Baggly

Chagan wrote: »

It's possible, but I don't see how she could have been so confident of Kolido being Herman if she was not specifically told it.

Yeah it would have to be quick editing.......24 mins between the lynch and her post.

Hmmmm im not as convinced of the theory as i once was, but still not dropping it yet.

The_Valeyard

dottie_lottie wrote: »

I don't think I've been peeked before, so flattered!

I'd say your a good peak alright

Baggly

The_Valeyard wrote: »

I'd say your a good peak alright

BOOM YOU JUST GOT VALED SON

Chagan

Pter wrote: »

Yeah it would have to be quick editing.......24 mins between the lynch and her post.

Hmmmm im not as convinced of the theory as i once was, but still not dropping it yet.

It's been long before that tbf. There has been a hint dropped here and there.

Lord TSC

Drawing quick attention to the notice above there's site wide Matinence between 5am and 9am tomorrow, and these things can sometimes stretch longer than expected, so don't rely on there being discussion tomorrow morning.

quickbeam

WerewolfGM wrote: »

All the mayhem really sobered Chief Wiggum up. He's now even more determined than ever to find the criminals and is going to start doing morning investigations in addition to his night investigations. He will also investigate more thoroughly and will learn the roles of all players except Nelson, Grampa, Mr. Burns and Krusty. These will show as unclear.

Okay, missed that first time around.

Triceratops Ballet

Pter wrote: »

Yeah it would have to be quick editing.......24 mins between the lynch and her post.

Hmmmm im not as convinced of the theory as i once was, but still not dropping it yet.

Pete, you're dsicrediting a lot of stuff, and remaining skeptical, which is healthy but do you have any alternative theories, or just a skeptical mind?

My votes for peeking are Aneurotic, Barney,

quickbeam

gufc21 wrote: »

I'm out. Sick of the mods changing the rules mid game. Its the 3rd time its affected me for the negative. I have not asked to be mod killed so the badies will have to kill me. Not going to reveal my role.

Aww, Guffy, it's hard being a mod. What you intended in your head isn't always worded perfectly in the OP. In my experience they (not just current mods, but all mods) tend to be as balanced as they can. Give them a break. Come play again.

Lord TSC

Tony isn't listed on that list of people who'd show as unclear, so can we say that's cause he's defo dead?

quickbeam

Lord TSC wrote: »

Tony isn't listed on that list of people who'd show as unclear, so can we say that's cause he's defo dead?

Good spot. Why would the Rich Alpha Mr Burns be included but Italian Alpha Tony not be?

Though it would mean Andy and Sully WERE on the same team, if Andy was Louie (as Tigger said) and Sully was Tony.

Chagan

Lord TSC wrote: »

Tony isn't listed on that list of people who'd show as unclear, so can we say that's cause he's defo dead?

It could mean that Andy (he was the only baddie dead at that stage iirc) was a member of the Italian mafia. That would mean Tony was vulnerable to peeks again.

Triceratops Ballet

I vote peek Mick and Barney

Baggly

dottie_lottie wrote: »

Pete, you're dsicrediting a lot of stuff, and remaining skeptical, which is healthy but do you have any alternative theories, or just a skeptical mind?

Thats a fair point.

Theory 1: There is an alpha hiding in the low posters. I have said this since day 0 and think we need to follow the plan Mick (IIRC) proposed to peek and lynch low posters.

Theory 2: Follow the FFA votes. Can we use the Wiggum reveal (again, ill be sceptical of it, but we would be silly to ignore it) to narrow down some suspects based on this handy post

Guffy

quickbeam wrote: »

Aww, Guffy, it's hard being a mod. What you intended in your head isn't always worded perfectly in the OP. In my experience they (not just current mods, but all mods) tend to be as balanced as they can. Give them a break. Come play again.

It was mentioned plenty of times in the thread both last night and tonight. It could have been corrected. It may not have been what they meant but thems the rules, its what we're playing by so role with them.

I dont want to detract from the evil hunt so wont be discussing it further. Good luck villys

Xaracatz

quickbeam wrote: »

Yeah, was typing that before I read that Xara got extra power to actually know the role.

So, presume she knows the role of Lordy too?

I'm happy with a confirmed good list of:

QB
Nopeare
Xara
Dottie
Lordy

With a pretty sure good list of:
Vale (for now)
Trit
MrsF

Yep - I didn't say the specific role as let's see if a baddie tries to claim it. But definitively Lordy is good - same as Dottie.

Lord TSC

I'm a little suspicious of gufc now tbh, in terms of this might be a handy excuse to go radio silent and hope people forget about him....

The_Valeyard

tritium wrote: »

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5kx6-NzLpf0

Second on my hit list.


You were so wrong. Unebelievablely wrong. It's rare I get to say it while not in the deadroom


So....

Baggly

Pter wrote: »

Thats a fair point.

Theory 1: There is an alpha hiding in the low posters. I have said this since day 0 and think we need to follow the plan Mick (IIRC) proposed to peek and lynch low posters.

Theory 2: Follow the FFA votes. Can we use the Wiggum reveal (again, ill be sceptical of it, but we would be silly to ignore it) to narrow down some suspects based on this handy post

Want to clarify on point 1 - i dont want to do this to the exclusion of an obvious target, should we ferret someone out.

The_Valeyard

dottie_lottie wrote: »

I vote peek Mick and Barney

Peek Mick.

dottie_lottie

dottie_lottie wrote: »

I vote peek Mick and Barney

reasons?

Triceratops Ballet

Deleted User wrote: »

reasons?

cos I wanna peek!